Objectives: To compare the clinical effectiveness of an intensive three-month training programme with a less intensive programme on females suffering from chronic neck/shoulder pain.
Study design: A prospective observer-blinded clinical trial including 12-month pretreatment follow-up.
Setting: Patients were referred to the Departments of Rheumatology and Physical Medicine at Hvidovre Hospital by their general practitioners. Training was undertaken at a satellite clinic for physiotherapy of Hvidovre Hospital.
Subjects: Female patients aged 18–65 years suffering from chronic neck/shoulder pain for a minimum of six months.
Intervention: Patients were examined by a physician in order to exclude serious diseases. They were then randomized to either an intensive neck/shoulder training programme or a programme of lesser intensity but of similar duration.
Main outcome measures: Scales measuring pain and activities of daily living (ADL) were used, and strength and endurance measurements of the cervical and shoulder muscles were carried out at baseline and completion of the study. Follow-up measurements were carried out by postal questionnaire at 6 and 12 months after inclusion, and included pain, ADL and treatment satisfaction measurements.
Results: Seventy-seven patients were included in the trial, of whom 27 (69%) completed the intensive programme and 25 (61%) the lighter programme. Forty-one (>80%) completed the follow-up questionnaires. The patients in the two groups did not differ with regard to age, pain, ADL scores and physical measurements prior to training. Patients in both groups that completed the trial demonstrated statistically significant improvements in nearly all of the outcome measurements at completion. ADL scores maintained statistical significance at 12 months in both groups, but pain scores were only significantly improved in the intensive group at 12 months follow-up. There was no statistically significant difference between groups regarding pain or ADL, but overall 50% of all patients showed improvement.
Conclusions: The type of low-tech dynamic training used in either of our two programmes resulted in both subjective and objective improvements in patients suffering from chronic neck/shoulder pain, but there were no statistically significant differences in outcome between the two approaches. The subjective improvements were maintained throughout the follow-up period.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Bredkjær SR. Sundhed og sygelighed i Danmark: Rygbesvær og andre lidelser i bevægeapparatet hos danskerne. Report by the Danish Institute for Clinical Epidemiology, Copenhagen, 1989.
2.
Bovin G , Schrader H , Sand T . Neck pain in the general population . Spine1994; 19: 1307–1309 .
3.
Maekela M , Heliovaara M , Sievers K , Impivaara O , Knekt P , Aromaa A . Prevalence, determinants and consequences of chronic neck pain in Finland . Am J Epidemiol1991; 134: 1356–1367 .
4.
Tola S , Riihimaeki H , Videman T , Viikari-Juntura E , Haenninen K . Neck and shoulder symptoms among men in machine operating, dynamic physical work and sedentary work . Scand J Work Environ Health1988; 14: 299–305 .
5.
Dyrssen T , Svendenkrans M , Paasikivi J . Muskelträning vid besvär i nacke och skuldror; effektiv behandling för att minska smärtan (Muscle training for neck and shoulder problems: an effective treatment for pain relief) . Läkartidningen1989; 86: 2116–2120 .
6.
Jordan A . Neck painProceedings of the Danish Rheumatological Society. Astra, Denmark: Fossum Tryk , 1993: 44–54.
7.
Rosonoff HL , Fishbain DA , Goldsberg M , Santana R , Rosomoff RS . Physical findings in patients with chronic intractable benign pain of the neck and/or back . Pain1989; 37: 279–287 .
8.
Estlander AM , Mellin G , Vanharanta H , Hupli M . Effects and follow-up of a multimodel treatment program including physical training for low back pain patients . Scand J Rehabil Med1991; 23: 97–102 .
9.
Frost H , Klaber Moffett JA , Moser JS , Fairbank JCT . Randomised controlled trial for evaluation of fitness programme for patients with low back pain . BMJ1995; 310: 151–154 .
10.
Manniche C , Hesselsøe, Bentzen L , Christensen I , Lundberg E . Intensive muscle training for chronic low back pain . The Lancet1988; ii: 1473–1476 .
11.
Jensen MP , Karoly P , Braver S . The measurement of clinical pain intensity: A comparison of six methods . Pain1986; 27: 117–126 .
12.
Manniche C , Asmussen K , Lauritsen B , Vinterberg H , Kreiner S , Jordan A . Low back pain rating scale: validation of a tool for assessment of low back pain . Pain1994; 57: 317–326 .
13.
Jordan A. Functional assessment of the cervical spine and interventions in chronic neck pain patients. PhD thesis, University of Copenhagen, 1996.
14.
Silverman JL , Rodriquez AA , Agre JC . Quantitative cervical flexor strength in healthy subjects and in subjects with mechanical neck pain . Arch Phys Med Rehabil1992; 72: 679–681 .
15.
Jordan A , Mehlsen J . Cervicobrachial syndrome and neck muscle function: Effects of rehabilitation . J Musculoskeletal Pain1993; 1: 283–288 .
16.
Manniche C. Assessment and exercise in low back pain. With special reference to the management of pain and disability following first-time lumbar disc surgery. Doctoral thesis, Lægeforeningens forlag, Copenhagen, 1995.
17.
Spitzer WO , LeBlanc FE , Dupuis M eds. Scientific approach to the assessment and management of activity-related spinal disorders . Spine1987; 12: S1–S59 .
18.
Bigos S , Bowyer O , Braen G et al. Acute low back problems in adults. Clinical practice guidelines No. 14. AHCPR Publication No. 95-0642. Rockville, MD: Agency for Health Care Policy and Research, Public Health Service, US Department of Health and Human Services . December 1994.
19.
Hansen TM , Bendix T , Bünger C et al. Lændesmerter. Copenhagen: Danish Society for Internal Medicine , 1995: 16–28.
20.
Highland TR , Dreisinger TE , Vie LL , Russel GS . Changes of isometric strength and range of motion of the isolated cervical spine after eight weeks of clinical rehabilitation . Spine1992; 17: 77–82 .
21.
Manniche C , Jordan A . Exercise therapy . Editorial. Spine1995; 20: 1221–1222 .
22.
Fordyce WE , Brockway JA , Bergman JA , Spengler D . Acute back pain: A control group comparison of behavioural vs traditional management methods . J Behav Med1986; 9: 127–140 .
23.
Mayer TG , Gatchel RJ , Mayer H , Kishino ND , Keeley J , Mooney V . A prospective two-year study of functional restoration in industrial low-back injury. An objective assessment procedure . JAMA1987; 258: 1763–1767 .
