Instruments for assessing the burden of informal caregiving for stroke patients in clinical practice: a comparison of CSI,CRA,SCQ and self-rated burden

Abstract

Objective: To compare the feasibility, convergent and clinical validity of three commonly used burden scales: Caregiver Strain Index (CSI), Caregiver Reaction Assessment (CRA) and Sense of Competence Questionnaire (SCQ), with a self-developed single question on self-rated burden (SRB).

Subjects: Stroke patients receiving support from an informal caregiver (n=148) and their caregivers were followed up to six months after stroke.

Intervention: Feasibility was assessed with several measures of missing values. Convergent validity was assessed on the basis of the correlation patterns between the burden scales, and clinical validity through evaluation of expected associations between levels of burden and explanatory patients' and caregivers' characteristics.

Results: Missing values were less often observed on CSI and SRB than SCQ and CRA. Significant correlation coefficients (p<0.05) could be demonstrated between all burden scales, except for one subscale of CRA. Evidence for clinical validity was strongest for CSI and SRB, based on associations between higher burden scores and patients' disability, and patients' and caregivers' poor level of health-related quality of life (all p<0.05).

Conclusions: A concise and simple measure would facilitate early detection of caregivers at risk in clinical practice and research. CSI and SRB are more feasible and at least as valid instruments for assessment of caregiver burden in stroke than the longer and more complex SCQ and CRA. SRB could be used for quick screening of caregivers at risk. CSI is indicated for further diagnosis of the burden of informal caregivers.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Han B , Haley WE . Family caregiving for patients with stroke: review and analysis. Stroke 1999; 30: 1478–1485.

Scholte op Reimer WJM , de Haan RJ , Pijnenborg JMA , Limburg M , van den Bos GAM . Assessment of burden in partners of stroke patients with the Sense of Competence Questionnaire. Stroke 1998; 29: 373–379.

Dennis M , O'Rourke S , Lewis S , Sharpe M , Warlow C . A quantitative study of the emotional outcome of people caring for stroke survivors. Stroke 1998; 29: 1867–1872.

Mant J , Carter J , Wade DT , Winner S . Family support for stroke: a randomised controlled trial. Lancet 2000; 356: 808–813.

Dewey HM , Thrift AG , Mihalopoulos C et al. Informal care for stroke survivors: Results from the North East Melbourne Stroke Incidence Study (NEMESIS). Stroke 2002; 33: 1028–1033.

Anderson CS , Linto J , Stewart-Wynne EG . A population-based assessment of the impact and burden of caregiving for long-term stroke survivors. Stroke 1995; 26: 843–849.

Thommessen B , Wyller TB , Bautz-Holter E , Laake K . Acute phase predictors of subsequent psychosocial burden in carers of elderly stroke patients. Cerebrovasc Dis 2001; 11: 201–206.

Schulz R , Beach SR . Caregiving as a risk factor for mortality: the caregiver health effects study. JAMA 1999; 282: 2215–2219.

Glass TA , Matchar DB , Belyea M , Feussner JR . Impact of social support on outcome in first stroke. Stroke 1993; 24: 64–70.

10.

Evans RL , Connis RT , Bishop DS , Hendricks RD , Haselkorn JK . Stroke: a family dilemma. Disabil Rehabil 1994; 16: 110–118.

11.

Anderson C , Rubenach S , Mhurchu CN , Clark M , Spencer C , Winsor A . Home or hospital for stroke rehabilitation? Results of a randomized controlled trial I: Health outcomes at 6 months. Stroke 2000; 31: 1024–1031.

12.

Beech R , Rudd AG , Tilling K , Wolfe CDA . Economic consequences of early inpatient discharge to community-based rehabilitation for stroke in an Inner-London teaching hospital. Stroke 1999; 30: 729–735.

13.

Robinson BC . Validation of a Caregiver Strain Index. J Gerontol 1983; 38: 344–348.

14.

Low JTS , Payne S , Roderick P . The impact of stroke on informal carers: a literature review. Soc Sci Med 1999; 49: 711–725.

15.

Montgomery RJV , Gonyea JG , Hooyman NR . Caregiving and the experience of subjective and objective burden. Family Relat 1985; 43: 19–26.

16.

Dorman PJ , Slattery J , Farrell B , Dennis M , Sandercock P . A randomised comparison of the EuroQol and Short Dorm-36 after stroke. BMJ 1997; 315: 461-461.

17.

Iglesias C , Torgenson D . Does length of questionnaire matter? A randomised trial of response rates to a mailed quationnaire. J Health Serv Res Policy 2000; 5: 219–221.

18.

Eaker S , Bergstrom R , Bergstrom A , Adami HO , Nyren O . Response rate to mailed epidemiologic questionnaires: a population-based randomized trial of variations in design and mailing routines. Am J Epidemiol 1998; 147: 74–82.

19.

Bugge C , Alexander H , Hagen S . Stroke patients' informal caregivers: Patient, caregiver, and service factors that affect caregiver strain. Stroke 1999; 20: 1517–1523.

20.

Given CW , Given B , Stommel M , Collins C , King S , Franklin S . The caregiver reaction assessment (CRA) for caregivers to persons with chronic physical and mental impairment. Res Nurs Health 1992; 15: 271–283.

21.

Vernooij-Dassen MJFJ , Persoon JMG , Felling AJA . Predictors of sense of competence in caregivers of demented persons. Soc Sci Med 1996; 43: 41–49.

22.

Huijsman R , Klazinga NS , Scholte op Reimer WJM et al. Beroerte, beroering en borging in de keten: Results of the EDISSE evaluation of three regional experiments with stroke services. Report [in Dutch] on behalf of ZON-MW, Den Haag, NL.

23.

Van den Heuvel ET , de Witte LP , Schure LM , Sanderman R , Meyboom-de Jong B . Risk factors for burn-out in caregivers of stroke patients, and possibilities for intervention. Clin Rehabil 2001; 15: 669–677.

24.

Wilkinson PR , Wolfe CDA , Warburton FG et al. A long-term follow-up of stroke patients. Stroke 1997; 28: 507–512.

25.

Rudd AG , Wolfe CDA , Tilling K , Beech R . Randomised controlled trial to evaluate early discharge scheme for patients with stroke. BMJ 1997; 315: 1039–1044.

26.

Gunnell D , Coast J , Richards SH , Peters TJ , Pounsford JC , Darlow M . How great a burden does early discharge to hospital-at-home impose on carers? A randomized controlled trial. Age Ageing 2000; 29: 137–142.

27.

Nijboer C , Triemstra M , Tempelaar R , Sanderman R , van den Bos GAM . Determinants of caregiving experiences and mental health of partners of cancer patients. Cancer 1999; 86: 577–588.

28.

Nijboer C , Triemstra M , Tempelaar R , Sanderman R , van den Bos GAM . Measuring both negative and positive reactions to giving care to cancer patients: psychometric qualities of the Caregiver Reaction Assessment (CRA). Soc Sci Med 1999; 48: 1259–1269.

29.

Scholte op Reimer WJM , de Haan RJ , Rijnders PT , Limburg M , van den Bos GAM . The burden of caregiving in partners of long-term stroke survivors. Stroke 1998; 29: 1605–1611.

30.

Hermans E , Anten HWM , Diederiks JPM , Pjhilipsen H . Use of care by home-dwelling stroke patients during three years following hospital discharge. Scand J Caring Sci 1998; 12: 186–190.

31.

Fayers PM , Sprangers MAG . Understanding self-rated health. Lancet 2002; 359: 187–188.

32.

Easterlin RA . Does economic growth improve the human lot? Some experimental evidence, in: David, PA , Reder MW eds. Nations and households in economic growth – essays in honor of Moses Abramovitz. London: Academic Press, 1974: 89–125.

33.

Veenhoven, R . Advances in understanding happiness, Rev Québécoise Psychol 1997; 18: 29–79.

34.

Essink-Bot ML , Krabbe PFM , Bonsel GJ , Aaronson NK . An empirical comparison of four generic health measures: the Nottingham Health Profile, the Medical Outcome Study 36-Item Short-Form Health Survey, the COOP/WONCA charts, and the EuroQol instrument. Med Care 1997; 35: 522–537.

35.

Kesselring A , Krulik T , Bichsel M , Minder C , Beck JC , Stuck AE . Emotional and physical demands on caregivers in home care to the elderly in Switzerland and their relationship to nursing home admission. Eur J Public Health 2001; 11: 267–273.

36.

King RB , Carlson CE , Shade-Zeldow Y , Bares KK , Roth EJ , Heinemann AW . Transition to home care after stroke: Depression, physical health, and adaptive processes in support persons. Res Nurs Health 2001; 24: 307–323.

37.

Mahoney FI , Barthel DW . Functional evaluation: the Barthel Index. Md State Med J 1965; 14: 61–65.

38.

The EuroQol Group . EuroQol – a new facility for the measurement of health-related quality of life. Health Policy 1999; 16: 199–208 (see also www.euroqol.org).

39.

Dolan P . Modelling valuations for EuroQol health states. Med Care 1997; 35: 1095–1108.

40.

Kind P , Hardman G , Macran S . UK population norms for EQ-5D. Discussion paper 172. Centre for Health Economics, The University of York, York, 1999.

41.

Cohen J . Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences, second edition. Hillsdale, New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 1988: 19–74.

42.

Rankin J . Cerebral vascular accidents in patients over the age of 60. Scott Med J 1957; 2: 200–215.

43.

Wilkinson PR , Wolfe CDA , Warburton FG et al. A long-term follow-up of stroke patients. Stroke 1997; 28: 507–512.

44.

Brugge C , Alexander H , Hagen S . Stroke patients' informal caregivers: Patient, caregiver, and service factors that affect caregiver strain. Stroke 1999; 20: 1517–1523.

45.

Sneeuw KCA , Aaronson NK , de Haan RJ , Limburg M . Assessing quality of life after stroke: The value and limitations of proxy ratings. Stroke 1997; 28: 1541–1549.