Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

Researchers who assume that Universal Grammar (UG) plays a role in second language (L2) acquisition are still debating whether L2 learners have access to UG in its entirety (the Full Access hypothesis; e.g. Schwartz and Sprouse, 1994; 1996; White, 1989; 2003) or only to those aspects of UG that are instantiated in their first language (L1) grammar (the No Parameter Resetting hypothesis; e.g. Hawkins and Chan, 1997). The Full Access hypothesis predicts that parameter resetting will be possible where the L1 and L2 differ in parameter values, whereas the No Parameter Resetting hypothesis predicts that parameter resetting will not be possible. These hypotheses are tested in a study examining whether English-speaking learners of Afrikaans can reset the Split-IP parameter (SIP) (Thráinsson, 1996) and the V2 parameter from their L1 ([-SIP], [-V2]) to their L2 ([+SIP], [+V2]) values. 15 advanced English learners of Afrikaans and 10 native speakers of Afrikaans completed three tasks: a sentence manipulation task, a grammaticality judgement task and a truth-value judgement task. Results suggest that the interlanguage grammars of the L2 learners are [+SIP] and [+V2] (unlike the L1), providing evidence for the Full Access hypothesis.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alexiadou, A. and Anagnostopoulou, E. 1997: Postverbal subjects. Ms. Tilburg and MIT .

Ayoun, D. 1999: Verb movement in French L2 acquisition . Language and Cognition 2, 103-125 .

Bobaljik, J.D. 1995: Morphosyntax: the syntax of verbal inflection. Unpublished PhD dissertation, MIT, Cambridge, MA.

Bobaljik, J. D. and Jonas, D. 1996: Subject positions and the roles of TP . Linguistic Inquiry 27. 195-236 .

Bobaljik, J. D. and Thráinsson, H. 1998: Two heads aren’t always better than one . Syntax 1, 37-71 .

Chomsky, N. 1995: The minimalist program. MIT Press .

Clahsen, H. and Muysken, P. 1986: The availability of universal grammar to adult and child learners: a study of the acquisition of German word order . Second Language Research 2, 93-119 .

Clahsen, H. and Muysken, P. 1989: The UG paradox in L2 acquisition . Second Language Research 5, 1-29 .

Crain, S. and Thornton, R. 1998: Investigations in universal grammar: a guide to experiments on the acquisition of syntax. MIT Press .

10.

Dekydtspotter, L. , Sprouse, R. A. and Thyre, R. 1999: The interpretation of quantification at a distance in English-French interlanguage: domain specificity and second-language acquisition . Language Acquisition 8, 265-320 .

11.

Diesing, M. 1997: Yiddish VP order and the typology of object movement in Germanic . Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 15, 369-427 .

12.

Donaldson, B. C. 1993: A grammar of Afrikaans, Mouton de Gruyter .

13.

Duffield, N. and White, L. 1999: Assessing L2 knowledge of Spanish clitic placement: converging methodologies . Second Language Research 15, 133-160 .

14.

Du Plessis, J. , Solin, D. , Travis, L. and White, L. 1987: UG or not UG, that is the question: a reply to Clahsen and Muysken . Second Language Research 3, 56-75 .

15.

Grimshaw, J. and Rosen, S. T. 1990: Knowledge and obedience: the developmental status of the binding theory . Linguistic Inquiry 21, 187-222 .

16.

Hawkins, R. and Yuet-hung Chan, C. 1997: The partial availability of universal grammar in second language acquisition: the ‘failed functional features hypothesis’ . Second Language Research 13, 187-226 .

17.

Hawkins, R. , Towell, R. and Bazergui, N. 1993: Universal grammar and the acquisition of French verb movement by native speakers of English . Second Language Research 9, 189-233 .

18.

Iatridou, S. 1990: About Agr(P) . Linguistic Inquiry 21, 551-577 .

19.

Mahajan, A. 1990: The A/A? distinction and movement theory. Unpublished PhD dissertation, MIT, Cambridge, MA.

20.

Perlmutter, D. and Postal, P. 1984: The 1-Advancement exclusiveness law. In Perlmutten D. and Rosen, C. , editors, Studies in Relational Grammar 2. University of Chicago Press , 81-125.

21.

Pollock, J.-Y. 1989: Verb movement, universal grammar, and the structure of IP . Linguistic Inquiry 20, 365-424 .

22.

Rizzi, L. 1990: Relativized Minimality? MIT Press .

23.

Robertson, D. and Sorace, A. 1999: Losing the V2 constraint. In Klein. E. and Martohardjono, G. , editors, The development of second language grammars: a generative approach. John Benjamins , 317-361.

24.

Schwartz, B. D. and Sprouse, R. A. 1994: Word order and nominative case in nonnative language acquisition: a longitudinal study of (L1 Turkish) German interlanguage. In Hoekstra, T. and Schwartz, B. D. , editors, Language acquisition studies in generative grammar. John Benjamins , 317-368.

25.

Schwartz, B. D. and Sprouse, R. A. 1996: L2 cognitive states and the full transfer/full access model . Second Language Research 12, 40-72 .

26.

Shwartz, B. D. and Vikner, S. 1989: All verb second clauses are CPs . Working Papers in Scandinavian Syntax 43, 27-49 .

27.

Shwartz, B. D. and Vikner, S. 1996: The verb always leaves IP in V2 clauses. In Belletti, A. and Rizzi, L. , editors, Parameters and functional heads: essays in comparative syntax. Oxford University Press , 11-62.

28.

Smith, N. and Tsimpli, I.-M. 1995: The mind of a savant: language learning abd modularity. Blackwell .

29.

Thráinsson, H. 1996: On the (non-)universality of functional categories. In Werner, A. , Epstein, S. D. , Thráinsson, H. and Zwart, C. J.-W. , editors, Minimal ideas. John Benjamins , 253-281.

30.

Thráinsson, H. 2001: Object shift and scrambling. In Baltin, M. and Collins, C. editors, The handbook of contemporary syntactic theory. Blackwell 148-202.

31.

Travis, L. 1984: Parameters and effects of word order variation. Unpublished PhD dissertation, MIT, Cambridge, MA.

32.

Travis, L. 1986: Parameters of word order and V2 phenomena . Paper presented at the Princeton Workshop on Comparative Syntax, Princeton, March 1986. (Subsequently published as Travis 1991.)

33.

Travis, L. 1991: Parameters of phrase structure and verb-second phenomena. In Freidin, R. , editor, Principles and parameters in comparative grammar. MIT Press , 339-364.

34.

Tsimpli, I.-M. and Smith, N. 1991: Second language learning: evidence from a polyglot savant . UCL Working Papers in Linguistics 3, 171-184 .

35.

Vainikka, A. and Young-Scholten, M. 1994: Direct access to X'-theory: evidence from Korean and Turkish adults learning German. In Hoekstra, T. and Schwartz, B. D. , editors, Language acquisition studies in generative grammar. John Benjamins , 265-316.

36.

Vainikka, A. and Young-Scholten, M. 1996: Gradual development of L2 phrase structure . Second Language Research 12, 7-39 .

37.

White, L. 1989: Universal grammar and second language acquisition. John Benjamins .

38.

White, L. 1991: Adverb placement in second language acquisition: some effects of positive and negative evidence in the classroom . Second Language Research 7, 133-161 .

39.

White, L. 1996: Clitics in L2 French. In Clahsen, H. , editor, Generative perspectives on language acquisition. John Benjamins , 335-368.

40.

White, L. 2003: Second language acquisition and universal grammar. Cambridge University Press .

41.

Yuan, B. 2001: The status of thematic verbs in the second language acquisition of Chinese: against inevitability of thematic-verb-raising in second language acquisition . Second Language Research 17, 248-272 .

42.

Zwart, C. J.-W. 1991: Clitics in Dutch: evidence for the position of Infl . Groninger Arbeiten zur Germanistischen Linguistik 33, 71-92 .

Investigating the acquisition of the Split-IP parameter and the V2 parameter in second language Afrikaans

Abstract

Get full access to this article

References