Model-based condition monitoring of a HVAC cooling coil sub-system in a real building

Abstract

A comparison of the performance of two fault detection and diagnosis methods applied to a cooling coil subsystem in an air-handling unit installed in a real building is presented. Both methods employ a first principles based reference model of the target system. One scheme carries out diagnosis using expert rules and the other recursively re-estimates selected parameters of the system model that correspond to particular faults. The procedures and information required to configure the schemes for condition monitoring are discussed. The results of testing the methods on an HVAC cooling coil subsystem in a commercial office building in the UK over an entire cooling season are reported. Both methods were able to both detect faults and provide some diagnosis. The expert rule method, however, appears to be more robust. Issues associated with the con” guration and implementation of both methods are discussed in terms of performance and cost.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

ASHRAE . Fault detection and diagnosis for HVAC systems. ASHRAE Technical Data Bulletin. 1996; 12(12).

UK Building Regulations . Document L2: conservation of fuel and power in buildings other than dwellings. 2002.

Hyvarinen, J . Building optimisation and fault diagnosis source book. Technical Research Centre of Finland, 1996.

Dexter A , Pakenen J eds. Demonstrating automated fault detection and diagnosis in real buildings. Espoo. VTT Building Technology, 2001. VTT Symposium 217.

Benouarets M , Dexter AL , Fargus RS , Haves P , Salsbury TI , Wright JA . Model-based approaches to fault detection and diagnosis in air-conditioning systems. Proceedings of System Simulation in Buildings' 94. Liege, Belgium, 1994.

Buswell RA , Wright JA , Salsbury TI , Haves P . Fault detection and diagnosis using recursive parameter estimation in non-linear systems. Proceedings of System Simulation in Buildings 2002. Le `ige, Belgium, 2002.

Salsbury TI. Fault detection and diagnosis in HVAC systems using analytical models. Loughborough University. PhD Thesis, 1996.

Buswell RA , Haves P , Salsbury, TI . A model based approach to the commissioning of HVAC systems. Proceedings of CLIMA 2000, Brussels, 1997.

Holmes MJ . The simulation of heating and cooling coils for performance analysis. Proceedings of the First International Conference on System Simulation in Buildings. Liege, Belgium, 1982.

10.

Salsbury TI , Haves P , Wright JA . A fault detection and diagnosis method based on first principles models and expert rules. Proceeding of Tsinghua HVAC-95. Beijing, PRC, 1995.

11.

Box MJ . A new method of constrained optimisation and a comparison with other methods. The Computer Journal. 1965; 8-8.

12.

Fortescue TR , Kershenbaum LS , Ydstie BE . Implementation of self-tuning regulators with variable forgetting. Automatica 1981; 17: 831-831.