The Roles of iPLA2,TRPM8 and TRPA1 in Chemically Induced Cold Hypersensitivity

Abstract

Background:

The cooling agents menthol and icilin act as agonists at TRPM8 and TRPA1. In vitro, activation of TRPM8 by icilin and cold, but not menthol, is dependent on the activity of a sub-type of phospholipase A2, iPLA2. Lysophospholipids (e.g. LPC) produced by PLA2 activity can also activate TRPM8. The role of TRPA1 as a primary cold sensor in vitro is controversial, although there is evidence that TRPA1 plays a role in behavioural responses to noxious cold stimuli. In this study, we have investigated the roles of TRPM8 and TRPA1 and the influence of iPLA2 on noxious cold sensitivities in naïve animals and after local administration of menthol, icilin and LPC. The roles of the channels in cold sensitivity were investigated in mice lacking either TRPM8 (Trpm8^−/−) or TRPA1 (Trpa1^−/−).

Results:

Intraplantar administration of icilin evoked a dose-dependent increase in sensitivity to a 10°C stimulus that was inhibited by iPLA2 inhibition with BEL. In contrast the cold hypersensitivities elicited by intraplantar menthol and LPC were not inhibited by BEL treatment. BEL had no effect on basal cold sensitivity and mechanical hypersensitivities induced by the TRPV1 agonist, capsaicin, and the P2X3 agonist α,β-methylene ATP. Both Trpm8^−/− and Trpa1^−/− mice showed longer latencies for paw withdrawal from a 10°C stimulus than wild-type littermates. Cold hypersensitivities induced by either icilin or LPC were absent in Trpm8^−/− mice but were retained in Trpa1^−/− mice. In contrast, cold hypersensitivity evoked by menthol was present in Trpm8^−/− mice but was lost in Trpa1^−/− mice.

Conclusions:

The findings that iPLA2 inhibition blocked the development of cold hypersensitivity after administration of icilin but failed to affect menthol-induced hypersensitivity agree well with our earlier in vitro data showing a differential effect of iPLA2 inhibition on the agonist activities of these agents. The ability of LPC to induce cold hypersensitivity supports a role for iPLA2 in modulating TRPM8 activity in vivo. Studies on genetically modified mice demonstrated that the effects of icilin and LPC were mediated by TRPM8 and not TRPA1. In contrast, menthol-induced cold hypersensitivity was dependent on expression of TRPA1 and not TRPM8.

Background

TRPM8 expressed by a sub-population (∼10%) of primary afferent sensory neurons has a role in the detection and transmission of cold stimuli. This channel is activated by cool temperatures with a threshold for activation in the range 20–30°C. In addition, TRPM8 is activated by the cooling compounds icilin and menthol, which shift the threshold for thermal activation to higher temperatures [1 –3].

The activity of TRPM8 can also be modulated by other factors, such as the binding of phosphatidylinositol 4,5-bisphosphate (PIP2) and membrane depolarization [1 –5]. Our earlier studies also demonstrated that endogenous lysophospholipids (LPLs) generated by the calcium-independent form of the enzyme phospholipase A2 (iPLA2) regulated TRPM8 activity [6].

Another TRP channel, TRPA1, is expressed in about half of the sensory neurons that express TRPV1 and therefore is associated with nociceptive responses. Some publications have linked TRPA1 expression with the ability to sense cold pain, although the ability of TRPA1 to respond directly to cold temperatures is controversial [7 –9]. Not all studies found that TRPA1 could be activated by cold [10 –13], although some recent publications have provided support for a role in cold transduction in vitro [14 –17] and in vivo [15,18].

The cooling agent, icilin, activates both TRPM8 [2,19,20] and TRPA1 [21]. Systemic administration of icilin produces behaviours such as wet dog shakes and jumping in rodents that are absent in Trpm8^−/− mice [22,23]. Menthol also activates TRPM8 and TRPA1 at similar concentrations, although at higher concentrations it blocks the activity of rodent TRPA1 channels [24 –26]. Topical application of menthol to healthy human volunteers sensitizes the oral responses to innocuous cold temperatures and skin responses to noxious cold stimuli [27 –31].

There are conflicting data about the contribution of TRPM8 to cold withdrawal responses, with reports that Trpm8^−/− mice either have the same withdrawal latencies as wild type mice from a −1°C to 0°C cold plate [32,33] or show a reduced cold sensitivity [23]. Injection of icilin into the paw reduces cold plate paw withdrawal latency in wild type mice but not in Trpm8^−/− mice [32] consistent with a major role of TRPM8 in icilin-induced cold hypersensitivity. Whether icilin activation of TRPA1 can also induce cold hypersensitivity is unknown. The contributions of TRPM8 and TRPA1 to menthol-induced cold hypersensitivity are also unknown.

Earlier studies showed that the activity of TRPM8 was modulated by the activity of a sub-type of phospholipase A2, namely iPLA2 [6,34]. An iPLA2 inhibitor (bromenol lactone, BEL), abolished the response of TRPM8 to icilin, reduced the cold sensitivity of the channel and abolished the responses to cold stimuli in the majority of cold-sensitive dorsal root ganglion neurons. A reduction of iPLA2 expression with antisense oligonucleotides has also been shown to inhibit TRPM8 activity [34]. Furthermore lysophospholipids (e.g. LPC), which are the products of PLA2 activity, raised the temperature threshold for TRPM8 activation towards normal body temperature and so stimulated channel activity at experimental temperatures above 30°C [6].

In the current series of in vivo experiments in rats we have examined the effects of inhibiting iPLA2 on noxious cold responses in naïve animals and after intraplantar administration of icilin and menthol, and investigated the effects of local administration of LPC on noxious cold responses. We have also used genetically modified mice lacking either TRPM8 or TRPA1 to probe the contribution of these channels to the development of cold hypersensitivities evoked by these agents. Our data demonstrate that iPLA2 activity is required for icilin-induced cold hypersensitivity, which is mediated exclusively by TRPM8, and that LPC-induced increases in cold sensitivity depend on the presence of TRPM8. Menthol-induced cold sensitivity was not affected by iPLA2 inhibition and was still evident in TRPM8-deficient mice. The effect of menthol on cold-hypersensitivity was, however, absent in mice lacking TRPA1, indicating that activation of TRPA1 and not TRPM8 is responsible for the observed behavioural responses to noxious cold after administration of menthol.

Results

Measurement of cold sensitivity

Two methods were initially used to assess cold sensitivity using a temperature controlled metal plate. First, the time to the first behavioural response (paw lick/lift) in freely moving rats. Second, the time taken for lightly restrained rats to withdraw their paw from the cold plate.

The responses to varying cold stimuli were first investigated in untreated rats using a range of cold-plate temperatures from 0.5°C to 20°C (Figure 1A). The paw withdrawal latencies decreased with reduced cold-plate temperatures with a mid point at about 10°C. This temperature was used in subsequent experiments as it was suitable to show either an increase or a decrease in cold sensitivity. Similar results were obtained with freely moving and restrained animals, but one major advantage of using the held animals is that readings for both the left and right hind paws can be obtained; this is not easily achieved using freely moving animals. As shown in Figure 1B almost identical paw withdrawal latencies were obtained for the left and right paws. Because of this added advantage and the consistency of the data obtained, the restrained method was used in most of the studies.

Figure 1

Temperature dependence of withdrawal latencies. A Response time for rat hind-limb paw withdrawal (lick or lift) from a cold plate set at various temperatures for unrestrained, freely moving rats. B. Paw withdrawal latencies for left and right hind-imbs in lightly restrained rats. Note the similar results obtained with these two methods and the close correspondence between the values for left and right limbs in restrained animals. Data shows mean ± SEM for 9 rats.*** p < 0.001 vs. 20°C readings.

Effects of iPLA2 inhibition on cold sensitivity

Earlier in vitro experiments showed that iPLA2 inhibition abolished the responses of TRPM8 to icilin but not to menthol [6]. The effects of iPLA2 inhibition on icilin-induced cold hypersensitivity were therefore investigated to determine if this dependence on iPLA2 was present in vivo. Intra-plantar injection of icilin elicited a dose-related increase in cold sensitivity that was stable from 15 to 60 minutes following administration. At 6 μg and 60 μg there was a marked reduction in the paw withdrawal latency (Figure 2A). Doses above 60 μg were not used as they induced side effects, notably characteristic ‘wet dog shakes’ [35,36]. Prior administration of the selective iPLA2 inhibitor BEL (30–300 μg) had no effect on baseline cold sensitivity (data not shown) but inhibited the icilin-induced cold sensitivity significantly at 100 and 300 μg in a dose-dependent manner (Figure 2B).

Figure 2

Icilin-induced cold hypersensitivity is inhibited by the iPLA2 inhibitor, BEL. A. Ipsilateral paw withdrawal latencies in lightly restrained rats at various times after intra-plantar administration of 0.6, 6 or 60 μg icilin or vehicle alone. B. Prior administration of 30–300 μg BEL dose dependently inhibited the cold hypersensitivity induced by 60 μg icilin. Data show mean ± SEM for 6 rats/group. * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01, *** p < 0.001 vs vehicle. In B, † p < 0.05, †† p < 0.01 when compared with vehicle/icilin treated group.

A second set of experiments was performed in rats to investigate the effects of iPLA2 inhibition on menthol-induced cold hypersensitivity. Intra-plantar injection of menthol led to a dose-dependent cold hypersensitivity. Figure 3A illustrates the results of an experiment in freely moving rats where 25 mg menthol, which was the highest concentration that we could use, gave the maximal observed effect. Lower doses of menthol (10 mg and below) produced less consistent results. Menthol (2.5–25 mg) also evoked cold hypersensitivity in restrained animals although with this method a similar degree of hypersensitivity was noted for the 8.3 mg and 25 mg doses (Additional file 1). No wet dog shakes were evoked by menthol. In contrast to the effects on icilin-induced cold hypersensitivity, prior administration of BEL (30–300 μg) had no effect on the cold sensitivity induced by menthol (Figure 3B).

Figure 3

Menthol-induced cold hypersensitivity is not inhibited by BEL. A. Intraplantar administration of menthol (3–25 mg) induced a time- and dose-dependent reduction in ipsilateral paw withdrawal latency in freely-moving rats. B. Prior administration of BEL (30–300 μg) had no effect on the cold hypersensitivity evoked by 25 mg menthol. Data show mean ± SEM for 6 rats/group. * p < 0.05, *** p < 0.001 vs vehicle.

Effects of LPC on cold sensitivity

Lysophospholipids, such as LPC, sensitize TRPM8 in vitro and raise the thermal threshold towards body temperature [6]. We therefore investigated whether or not local administration of LPC would increase cold sensitivity in vivo. Intra-plantar injection of LPC (30–100 μg) resulted in an increased cold sensitivity as shown by a reduction in paw withdrawal latency (Figure 4A). A marked cold hypersensitivity was evident with 60 μg LPC but not with the 30 μg dose. The hypersensitivity produced by 100 μg LPC was less than at 60 μg. One possible explanation for this finding is that LPC exhibits a bell-shaped dose-response, but it is equally likely that poor solubility at higher concentrations is an issue. When tested in a hot-plate latency test using a 50°C stimuli no significant increase in heat sensitivity was seen following 60 μg LPC injection (Additional file 2).

Figure 4

LPC-induced cold hypersensitivity is not inhibited by BEL. A. Intraplantar administration of LPC evoked a dose-dependent cold hypersensitivity in lightly restrained rats. B. Prior administration of BEL (30–300 μg) did not inhibit the cold hypersensitivity evoked by 60 μg LPC. Data show mean ± SEM for 6 rats/group. ** p < 0.01, *** p < 0.001 vs vehicle.

Lysophospholipids are produced by the activity of PLA2 and so PLA2 inhibition would not be expected to affect any TRPM8-mediated behavioural effects of LPC. This was examined by pre-treating rats with an intra-plantar injection of BEL (30–100 μg) to inhibit iPLA2 prior to local administration of 60 μg LPC. BEL had no effect on the development of LPC-induced cold hyper-sensitivity as the paw withdrawal latencies were very similar in vehicle and BEL pre-treated groups (Figure 4B). No significant changes in the contralateral paw withdrawal latencies were noted in these experiments (data not shown).

Selectivity of the iPLA2 pathway

In order to gain information about the selectivity of the iPLA2 pathway for TRPM8 mediated events, we also examined the effects of BEL on hypersensitivities induced by a TRPV1 agonist, capsaicin, and a P2X3 agonist α,β-methylene ATP (α,βMeATP), in rats. Intraplantar injection of both agents induced a mechanical hypersensitivity measured by reduced paw withdrawal thresholds to mechanical pressure. Pre-treatment with intraplantar BEL (100 μg) had no effect on the development of mechanical hypersensitivities to either capsaicin or α,βMeATP (Additional file 3).

The effects of LPC and icilin on cold sensitivity in mice lacking TRPM8 or TRPA1

The role of TRPM8 in mediating LPC evoked cold hypersensitivity was investigated in mice, taking advantage of the availability of genetically modified animals lacking TRPM8. The paw withdrawal latency of Trpm8^−/− mice to a cold stimulus was longer than that in wild-type littermates (Figure 5A, B). Intraplantar injection of LPC in wild-type mice evoked a cold hyper-sensitivity as seen previously in rats. In contrast, LPC failed to induce cold hypersensitivity in Trpm8^−/− mice (Figure 5A). The effects of intraplantar injections of icilin were also evaluated in Trpm8^−/− mice and wild-type littermates. Icilin induced a cold hypersensitivity in wild-type mice but not in Trpm8^−/− mice (Figure 5B).

Figure 5

Cold hypersensitivities evoked by icilin and LPC are absent in Trpm8^−/− mice but retained in Trpa1^−/− mice. Effects of intraplantar administration of either 60 μg LPC (A) or 100 μg icilin (B) on cold withdrawal latencies in lightly restrained Trpm8^−/− and wild-type littermate mice. Neither compound had an effect on withdrawal latency for the injected (ipsilateral) paw in Trpm8^−/− mice. Both compounds reduced the ipsilateral paw withdrawal latencies in wild-type littermates, but had no effect on withdrawal latencies for the uninjected (contralateral) paw. Intraplantar LPC (C) or icilin (D) reduced paw withdrawal thresholds for ipsilateral paws in both Trpa1^−/− and wild-type littermate mice. Note that a greater cold hypersensitivity was seen in Trpa1^−/− than in wild-type mice. Data show mean ± SEM for 6 mice/group. * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01, *** p < 0.001 vs relevant predose values. † p < 0.05, †† p < 0.01 for contralateral-ipsilateral difference in wild-type mice.

As cold sensitivity in vivo is also influenced by another sensory neuron TRP channel, TRPA1, we also investigated the effects of LPC in mice lacking TRPA1. The basal cold threshold was higher in Trpa1^−/− mice than in wild-type littermates (Figure 5C, D) as has been shown previously for this line of genetically modified mice [15,18,37]. Nevertheless, intraplantar injection of LPC was able to induce cold hypersensitivity in both groups of mice illustrating that the effects of LPC are independent of TRPA1 (Figure 5C). Similarly icilin-induced cold hypersensitivity was retained in Trpa1^−/− mice. Icilin induced a modest cold hypersensitivity in wild-type mice but a marked reduction in withdrawal latency was noted in Trpa1^−/− mice indicating no loss of induced cold hypersensitivity (Figure 5D).

Menthol-induced cold hypersensitivity is dependent on TRPA1 but not TRPM8

The failure of BEL to inhibit menthol induced cold hypersensitivity was consistent with our in vitro data showing that BEL did not inhibit the agonist effects of menthol on TRPM8 [6]. As menthol can also activate TRPA1 [24 –26], we also examined if the observed behavioural effect of menthol could be mediated by TRPA1 and not by TRPM8. Menthol was administered by intraplantar injection in Trpm8^−/− and Trpa1^−/− mice and their respective wild-type littermates. Menthol evoked cold hypersensitivity in both wild-type and Trpm8^−/− mice (Figure 6A). In contrast, menthol induced cold hypersensitivity in wild-type (Trpa1^+/+) mice, but had no significant effects on cold thresholds in Trpa1^−/−mice (Figure 6B). The vehicles used in these experiments had no effect on the behavioural responses at any temperature. Both icilin and menthol do induce initial pain responses at room temperature (paw licking, biting and shaking) but these effects were short-lived (less than 10 minutes) and were not evident at the times used to assess the evoked responses to thermal stimuli.

Figure 6

Menthol-evoked cold hypersensitivity is absent in Trpa1^−/− mice but present in Trpm8^−/− mice. A. Intraplantar administration of 25 mg menthol evoked marked cold hypersensitivity in the ipsilateral paw of lightly restrained Trpm8^−/−mice. Note that a greater cold hypersensitivity was seen in Trpm8^−/−than in wild-type mice. B. Menthol evoked cold hypersensitivity in wild-type but not Trpa1^−/− mice. Data show mean ± SEM for 6 mice/group. * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01, *** p < 0.001 vs relevant predose values. † p < 0.05, †† p < 0.01, ††† p < 0.001 for contralateral-ipsilateral difference in wild-type mice.

Given the failure of menthol to elicit cold hypersensitivity in Trpa1^−/− in the cold plate assay, we also assessed the role of TRPA1 using an acetone evaporation method. Acetone administration evoked a significant behavioural response in Trpa1^+/+mice which was greatly diminished in Trpa1^−/− mice. Following intraplantar administration of menthol the acetone evoked paw responses were increased in wild-type Trpa1^+/+mice but not in Trpa1^−/− mice (Additional file 4).

Other TRPA1 agonists were also tested in the cold-plate assay to determine if cold hypersensitivity was a general feature of TRPA1 agonism. Both allyl isothiocyanate (AITC, 100 μg i.pl.) and cinnamaldehyde (50 μg i. pl.) induced a significant cold hypersensitivity in the injected paw of wild-type (Trpa1^+/+) mice but had no effect in Trpa1^−/− mice (Figure 7). No significant changes in cold evoked withdrawal latencies were noted in the contralateral paws (data not shown) of wild-type mice, which demonstrated that there were no systemic effects of locally administered AITC and cinnamaldehyde.

Figure 7

TRPA1 agonists AITC and cinnamaldehyde evoke cold hypersensitivity. Intraplantar injection of either AITC (100 μg) or cinnamaldehyde (50 μg) evoked marked cold hypersensitivity in the ipsilateral paw of lightly restrained wild-type mice but had no effect when administered to Trpa1^−/− mice. Data show mean ± SEM for 6 mice/group. *** p < 0.001 vs pre-dose latencies.

Discussion

The methods used to assess the behavioural changes to a cold stimulus vary widely in different laboratories. Methods described in the literature include observations of freely moving animals on a cold-plate or in a water bath, the latencies for tail or paw withdrawal from cold water using restrained animals and behavioural responses induced by acetone evaporation. Furthermore, the temperatures used differ considerably and are often overtly noxious. The use of freely moving animals on a cold-plate has limitations, particularly where mice are concerned as good responses are not readily obtained [38]. In addition it is difficult to evaluate the responses of each hind paw to the stimulus in freely moving animals. This precludes ready comparison of the effects of local administration of compounds into the ipsilateral (treated) and contralateral (untreated) limbs. Also, prolonged whole body exposure to cold in animals moving around on a cold plate may influence the behavioural response by stimulating higher brain centres rather than reporting peripheral transduction mechanisms. Such whole body exposure to cold can also cause the animals to become less mobile rather than evoking a measurable nociceptive response. In contrast, measurements of responses in lightly restrained animals allowed cold sensitivity to be evaluated in both paws in individual animals using a local cold stimulus. With the plate set at ambient temperatures (25–37°C), no paw withdrawals were observed with the 30 second cut-off used in these studies. In other experiments we noted that most animals did not withdraw their paws at ambient temperature during a 60 second observation period. It is therefore unlikely that simple mechanical sensitivity accounts for the paw withdrawal. In the traditional cold-plate assay, freely roaming rodents walk on the plate and do not usually have a single paw in constant contact with the cold-plate. Our method using lightly restrained animals provides continuous contact between the paw and the cold-plate, which results in shorter withdrawal threshold latencies and less variable responses.

Our finding of an increased latency for paw withdrawal from a 10°C cold plate in Trpm8^−/− mice supports a role for TRPM8 in the behavioural responses to cold. This result is consistent with the findings of one earlier study [23], but disagrees with results from two other laboratories [32,33]. One of the studies that did not show an increased latency in Trpm8^−/− mice [32] used a lower cold-plate temperature (−1°C) than in the current investigation. In the other study, Bautista et al. [33] did not observe a difference in cold-plate responses in freely moving Trpm8^−/− and wild-type mice over a range of temperatures (−10°C – 10°C) including the temperature (10°C) used in our studies. We can rule out the possibility that differences in mouse strains were responsible for the different results as the mice used in our experiments were from the same stock as those used by Bautista et al. [33]. Both published studies did, however, detect a reduced behavioural response in Trpm8^−/− mice in acetone-induced paw flinching assays consistent with a reduction in cold sensitivity [32,33]. The reason for the differences in cold-plate results between studies is unclear. It is possible that the less variable latencies that we observe with restrained mice with their paws in constant contact with the cold surface have allowed us to detect a reduced cold-sensitivity in the Trpm8^−/− mice. Such a cold-response deficit is consistent with the findings of Colburn et al [23] who showed a marked (threefold) increase in cold-plate response latencies in Trpm8^−/− mice.

The results of the in vivo studies with icilin and LPC agree well with our earlier in vitro studies [6] demonstrating that LPLs produced by iPLA2 play an important role in regulating the cold sensitivity of TRPM8. iPLA2 inhibition with BEL reduced the cold hypersensitivity induced by icilin, consistent with our in vitro findings that BEL inhibited TRPM8 responses to icilin. These results suggest that icilin activation of TRPM8 requires a product of iPLA2 activity perhaps acting as a cofactor that enables activation by icilin. Icilin acts as an agonist at both TRPM8 and TRPA1 channels. Our behavioural data with Trpm8^−/− and Trpa1^−/− mice show that icilin induction of cold hypersensitivity was dependent on the presence of TRPM8, in agreement with the findings of Dhaka et al. [32], and was not influenced by the presence or absence of TRPA1.

The finding that BEL treatment did not affect the baseline responses to the cold (10°C) stimulus indicates that tonic activity of iPLA2 does not contribute to the behavioural responses to noxious cold under normal circumstances. It is possible that the level of tonic iPLA2 activity is usually low and therefore no baseline modulation of TRPM8 activity occurs when the enzyme is inhibited. Such a conclusion would suggest that icilin stimulates iPLA2 activity either directly or indirectly.

The ability of LPC to induce cold hypersensitivity in vivo supports a role for iPLA2 in modulating TRPM8. The absence of any effect on the sensitivity to a noxious heat stimulus indicates that this is not due to general neuronal sensitization. The experiments with Trpm8^−/−mice showed that LPC-induced cold hypersensitivity was dependent on the presence of TRPM8 and was not due to an action of LPC on other targets. The lack of effect of iPLA2 inhibition by BEL on cold hypersensitivity induced by LPC was expected as LPC is the product of this enzyme. This result, together with the findings that BEL did not influence the mechanical hypersensitivities induced by intraplantar injection of capsaicin or the P2X3 agonist, α,βMeATP, show that BEL does not have non-specific effects on nociception in primary afferent neurons. The lack of effect of BEL on chemically evoked mechanical sensitivity indicates that the compound had no significant inhibitory actions on either activation of TRPV1 or P2X3 receptors by their respective agonists or the transduction and transmission of noxious mechanical stimuli.

Although there has been some debate concerning the role of TRPA1 in cold transduction [7], the behavioural data in our current study and in some other investigations on Trpa1^−/− mice [15,18,37] show that mice lacking TRPA1 have reduced behavioural responses to cold. Other investigators have failed to show reduced cold sensitivity in Trpa1^−/− mice [39]. Mechanisms, such as TRPM8 activation or cold inhibition of a potassium conductance [40,41] in sensory neurons, also contribute to cold responses. Cold sensation in vivo may depend on a number of mechanisms with varying contributions at different temperatures.

The finding from experiments in genetically modified mice that menthol-induced cold hypersensitivity was not obviously influenced by TRPM8 expression but was dependent on TRPA1 expression was initially surprising. The influence of TRPA1 on the development of menthol-induced cold hypersensitivity was therefore confirmed using a different method, measuring the behavioural responses to acetone evaporation. Menthol is a good TRPM8 agonist and so a TRPM8 mediated menthol-induced cold hypersensitivity would be expected in the Trpa1^−/− mice, similar to that seen for LPC. Menthol can, however, affect some other ion channels which may contribute an inhibitory component to its overall effect. For example, at higher concentrations menthol directly activates GABA_A receptors [42] and has an inhibitory effect on T-type Ca channel activity [43]. Both these actions could inhibit sensory neuron activation and firing. In the absence of an excitatory input from TRPA1 expressing neurons, an inhibitory effect of menthol via these other mechanisms may be sufficient to block the menthol-evoked excitatory input from cold-sensitive TRPM8 neurons. The concentrations of menthol that activate TRPM8 and TRPA1 in vitro are very similar [24,25] and it is unlikely that menthol would selectively activate TRPA1 in vivo. High concentrations of menthol can inhibit TRPA1 in vitro [24 –26]. However, the highest concentration of menthol that we could use (25 mg) evoked cold hypersensitivity in wild-type rats and mice and Trpa1^−/− mice, so it is unlikely that we achieved inhibitory concentrations of the compound in vivo.

LPC and icilin induced a greater cold hypersensitivity in Trpa1^−/− than in the WT mice. It is possible that the presence of TRPA1 could in some way reduce the hypersensitivity induced by these agonists, although there have been no reports of a tonic analgesic effect mediated by TRPA1. Another possibility is that the stimulation of a TRPM8-linked pathway by agonists is enhanced in the absence of TRPA1. We also found that menthol induced a greater cold hypersensitivity in Trpm8^−/− mice than in WT mice. Activation of TRPM8 has been shown to induce centrally-mediated analgesic effects [44] and it is possible that the absence of a component of TRPM8 mediated analgesia contributes to the larger induced cold hypersensitivity. However, the elevated baseline latencies seen with both Trpm8^−/− and Trpa1^−/−mice may provide a common and simpler explanation as there is a greater range for reductions in paw withdrawal latencies in the gene deficient mice.

While TRPA1 may or may not act as a direct sensor of noxious cold temperature in vitro [8,9,15,16], the evidence from the studies reported here and elsewhere [15,45] indicates that in vivo TRPA1 does influence the behavioural responses to noxious cold. Our data also reinforce the need for caution in the interpretation of data obtained using menthol as an agonist in vivo as the effects of this agent can be due to an action on TRPA1 rather than TRPM8.

Methods

Animals

All animal studies were performed according to the UK Home Office Animal Procedures Act (1986) after in-house ethical review.

Adult male Wistar rats, weighing approximately 180–200 g were purchased from Harlan (Bicester, Oxon, U. K.). TRPA1-null mice and wild-type littermates were bred from heterozygotic mice kindly provided by Drs. Kelvin Kwan (Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA) and David Corey (Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA) [18]. TRPM8-null mice and wild-type littermates were bred from heterozygotic mice kindly provided by Dr. David Julius (University of California, San Francisco, California) [33].

Drug administration

Injections (25 μl) were made subcutaneously into the plantar surface of one of the hind paws using a 50 μl luer-syringe (Hamilton, Reno, NV) fitted with a 26-gauge by 3/8 inch intradermal needle. Icilin (Biomol International) was dissolved in DMSO and diluted to 50% in saline. Menthol and 1-palmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (LPC, Sigma, Poole) were dissolved in saline and bromoenol lactone (BEL, Sigma) was made up in DMSO. The vehicle for capsaicin (Sigma) was 10% DMSO in saline and α,β-methylene ATP (α,βMeATP, Sigma) was dissolved in saline. A stock solution of AITC was made up in 50%ethanol/10% Tween 80/saline which was then diluted serially 100-fold in saline to obtain the final concentration. Cinnamaldehyde was diluted in 0.5% Tween 80 in saline.

Injections of vehicle solutions had no effect at room temperature. Intraplantar injections of icilin, menthol, allyl isothiocyanate and cinnamaldehyde evoked some initial pain responses (paw licking and shaking) but these effects were short lived (less than 10 minutes) and were not apparent at times when responses to thermal or mechanical stimuli were tested. A few rats exhibited characteristic ‘wet dog’ shakes after administration of icilin but these animals were not used in the studies reported here.

Behavioural tests, temperature sensitivity

Cold sensitivity was assessed with a cold-plate using two different methods. Firstly, animals were placed onto the cold-plate within a perspex enclosure and the first sign of ipsilateral paw lift or lick was recorded as the paw withdrawal latency. A maximum cut-off paw withdrawal latency of 120 seconds was used to prevent possible tissue damage and unnecessary cold-induced trauma to the animal. In the second method the animals were lightly restrained and each hind paw in turn placed onto the surface of the cold-plate. The end point was taken as the withdrawal of the paw and recorded as the withdrawal latency for the ipsilateral and the contralateral paw. A maximum cut-off of 30 seconds was used for each paw. Experiments were performed using a cold-plate equipped with a Peltier and water cooled via a flow-cooler (Techne FC-200) and circulator (Techne C-85A) (Mechanical workshop, Novartis Institutes for Biomedical Research) or latterly using a commercially available cold-plate (Ugo Basile, Milan). The cold-plates were set according to pre-determined calibration data using a surface temperature probe to correlate set temperature to actual surface temperature over a wide temperature range (−5°C to 26°C). The cold plate was allowed to stabilize for 5 minutes prior to testing at each temperature.

Using both methods the paw withdrawal latencies were determined at a range of temperatures (0.5° to 20° C). For all subsequent studies the cold-plate was set at 10°C. Dose responses to icilin, LPC and BEL were obtained and doses selected for use in future studies. In iPLA2 inhibitor studies predose readings were taken prior to drug administration. BEL was then administered 1 hour before induction of cold hypersensitivity with icilin or LPC and subsequent post-dose readings were taken after 15 minutes.

In one set of experiments we also assessed cold sensitivity using acetone evaporation based on a previously published method [46]. Animals were placed into wire grid bottom cages allowing access to the underside of their paws and habituated to this environment prior to the start of the experiment. Acetone (0.05 ml) was applied to the centre of the plantar hind-paw using a micropipette and the animal's response monitored for 40 seconds. Responses to acetone were graded using the following four point scale: 0 = no response, 1 = quick withdrawal, flick or stamp of the hind-paw, 2 = prolonged withdrawal or repeated (>2) flicking of the hind-paw, 3 = repeated flicking of the paw with licking directed at the affected limb. Acetone was applied alternately three times to each hind-paw and the responses recorded. Cumulative scores were generated for each hind-paw by adding the 3 scores for each paw, the minimum score being 0 (no response to any trial) and the maximum possible score being 9 (repeated flicking and paw licking in all trials). The effect of menthol was assessed at a single time point, 15 minutes after intra-plantar injection of 25 mg menthol. This time point was chosen on the basis of the time course of cold-plate hypersensitivity seen in wild-type mice.

Heat sensitivity was assessed by measuring the time for paw withdrawal in lightly restrained rats using a calibrated hot-plate (Ugo Basile, Milan) at 50°C. A maximum, cut-off paw withdrawal latency of 15 seconds was used to prevent possible tissue damage and unnecessary trauma to the rats.

Behavioural tests, mechanical sensitivity

Mechanical sensitivity was assessed in lightly restrained rats by measuring paw withdrawal thresholds to an increasing mechanical force applied to the dorsal surface of the rat paw using an Analgesymeter (Ugo-Basile, Milan). The analgesymeter employed a wedge shaped probe (area 1.75 mm2). Cut-off was set at 250 grams and the end point was taken as withdrawal of the hind paw. Data are expressed as withdrawal thresholds in grams. Paw withdrawal thresholds were determined in the hind paws of both ipsilateral and contralateral hind limbs.

Predose readings were taken prior to drug administration BEL was then administered 1 hour before induction of mechanical hypersensitivity by the injection of capsaicin (1 nmole in 10% DMSO in saline) or α,βMeATP (1 μmole in saline). Post-dose readings were taken after 30 minutes.

Statistical analysis

Statistical analysis was carried out on raw data using repeated measures of ANOVA followed by post-hoc analysis using Tukey's HSD test (p < 0.05 was set as the level of statistical significance).

Footnotes

Notes

Acknowledgements

This study was supported by a grant from the MRC (G0500847). DA holds a London Law Trust/KCL medal fellowship. We thank Drs. Kelvin Kwan and David Corey for provision of Trpa1^−/+ mice and Dr. David Julius for Trpm8^−/+ mice.

SB conceived the study, performed the mouse genotyping and drafted the manuscript. CG and NS designed and performed the in vivo behavioural studies; CG also helped draft the manuscript. DA participated in the study design and helped to draft the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

References

Peier

Moqrich

Hergarden

Reeve

Andersson

Story

Earley

Dragoni

McIntyre

Bevan

Patapoutian

: A TRP channel that senses cold stimuli and menthol. Cell 2002, 108:705–715.

McKemy

Neuhausser

Julius

: Identification of a cold receptor reveals a general role for TRP channels in thermosensation. Nature 2002, 416:52–58.

Voets

Droogmans

Wissenbach

Janssens

Flockerzi

Nilius

: The principle of temperature-dependent gating in cold- and heat-sensitive TRP channels. Nature 2004, 430:748–754.

Liu

Qin

: Functional control of cold- and menthol-sensitive TRPM8 ion channels by phosphatidylinositol 4,5-bisphosphate. J Neurosci 2005, 25:1674–1681.

Rohacs

Lopes

Michailidis

Logothetis

: PI(4,5)P2 regulates the activation and desensitization of TRPM8 channels through the TRP domain. Nat Neurosci 2005, 8:626–634.

Andersson

Nash

Bevan

: Modulation of the cold-activated channel TRPM8 by lysophospholipids and polyunsaturated fatty acids. J Neurosci 2007, 27:3347–3355.

McKemy

: How cold is it? TRPM8 and TRPA1 in the molecular logic of cold sensation. Mol Pain 2005, 1:16.

Caspani

Heppenstall

: TRPA1 and Cold Transduction: An Unresolved Issue?. J Gen Physiol 2009, 133:245–249.

Kwan

Corey

: Burning Cold: Involvement of TRPA1 in Noxious Cold Sensation. J Gen Physiol 2009, 133:251–256.

10.

Jordt

Bautista

Chuang

McKemy

Zygmunt

Hogestatt

Meng

Julius

: Mustard oils and cannabinoids excite sensory nerve fibres through the TRP channel ANKTM1. Nature 2004, 427:260–265.

11.

Munns

Alqatari

Koltzenburg

: Many cold sensitive peripheral neurons of the mouse do not express TRPM8 or TRPA1. Cell Calcium 2007, 41(4):331–42.

12.

Nagata

Duggan

Kumar

Garcia-Anoveros

: Nociceptor and hair cell transducer properties of TRPA1, a channel for pain and hearing. J Neurosci 2005, 25:4052–4061.

13.

Reid

: ThermoTRP channels and cold sensing: What are they really up to?. Pflugers Arch 2005, 451:250–263.

14.

Klionsky

Tamir

Gao

Wang

Immke

Nishimura

Gavva

: Species-specific pharmacology of Trichloro(sulfanyl)ethyl benzamides as transient receptor potential ankyrin 1 (TRPA1) antagonists. Mol Pain 2007, 3:39.

15.

Karashima

Talavera

Everaerts

Janssens

Kwan

Vennekens

Nilius

Voets

: TRPA1 acts as a cold sensor in vitro and in vivo. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 2009, 106:1273–1278.

16.

Sawada

Hosokawa

Hori

Matsumura

Kobayashi

: Cold sensitivity of recombinant TRPA1 channels. Brain Res 2007, 1160:39–46.

17.

Fajardo

Meseguer

Belmonte

Viana

: TRPA1 channels mediate cold temperature sensing in mammalian vagal sensory neurons: Pharmacological and genetic evidence. J Neurosci 2008, 28:7863–7875.

18.

Kwan

Allchorne

Vollrath

Christensen

Zhang

Woolf

Corey

: TRPA1 contributes to cold, mechanical, and chemical nociception but is not essential for hair-cell transduction. Neuron 2006, 50:277–289.

19.

Andersson

Chase

Bevan

: TRPM8 activation by menthol, icilin, and cold is differentially modulated by intracellular pH. J Neurosci 2004, 24:5364–5369.

20.

Chuang

Neuhausser

Julius

: The super-cooling agent icilin reveals a mechanism of coincidence detection by a temperature-sensitive TRP channel. Neuron 2004, 43:859–869.

21.

Story

Peier

Reeve

Eid

Mosbacher

Hricik

Earley

Hergarden

Andersson

Hwang

: ANKTM1, a TRP-like channel expressed in nociceptive neurons, is activated by cold temperatures. Cell 2003, 112:819–829.

22.

Wei

Seid

: AG-3-5: A chemical producing sensations of cold. J Pharm Pharmacol 1983, 35:110–112.

23.

Colburn

Lubin

Stone

Jr Wang

Lawrence

D'Andrea

Brandt

Liu

Flores

Qin

: Attenuated cold sensitivity in TRPM8 null mice. Neuron 2007, 54:379–386.

24.

Xiao

Dubin

Bursulaya

Viswanath

Jegla

Patapoutian

: Identification of transmembrane domain 5 as a critical molecular determinant of menthol sensitivity in mammalian TRPA1 channels. J Neurosci 2008, 28:9640–9651.

25.

Karashima

Damann

Prenen

Talavera

Segal

Voets

Nilius

: Bimodal action of menthol on the transient receptor potential channel TRPA1. J Neurosci 2007, 27:9874–9884.

26.

Macpherson

Hwang

Miyamoto

Dubin

Patapoutian

Story

: More than cool: Promiscuous relationships of menthol and other sensory compounds. Mol Cell Neurosci 2006, 32(4):335–43.

27.

Namer

Seifert

Handwerker

Maihofner

: TRPA1 and TRPM8 activation in humans: Effects of cinnamaldehyde and menthol. Neuroreport 2005, 16:955–959.

28.

Wasner

Naleschinski

Binder

Schattschneider

McLachlan

Baron

: The effect of menthol on cold allodynia in patients with neuropathic pain. Pain Med 2008, 9:354–358.

29.

Seifert

Maihofner

: Representation of cold allodynia in the human brain–a functional MRI study. Neuroimage 2007, 35:1168–1180.

30.

Hatem

Attal

Willer

Bouhassira

: Psychophysical study of the effects of topical application of menthol in healthy volunteers. Pain 2006, 122:190–196.

31.

Wasner

Schattschneider

Binder

Baron

: Topical menthol–a human model for cold pain by activation and sensitization of C nociceptors. Brain 2004, 127:1159–1171.

32.

Dhaka

Murray

Mathur

Earley

Petrus

Patapoutian

: TRPM8 is required for cold sensation in mice. Neuron 2007, 54:371–378.

33.

Bautista

Siemens

Glazer

Tsuruda

Basbaum

Stucky

Jordt

Julius

: The menthol receptor TRPM8 is the principal detector of environmental cold. Nature 2007, 448:204–208.

34.

Vanden

Abeele F

Zholos

Bidaux

Shuba

Thebault

Beck

Flourakis

Panchin

Skryma

Prevarskaya

: Ca²⁺-independent phospholipase A2-dependent gating of TRPM8 by lysophospholipids. J Biol Chem 2006, 281:40174–40182.

35.

Wei

: Chemical stimulants of shaking behaviour. J Pharm Pharmacol 1976, 28:722–723.

36.

Werkheiser

Rawls

Cowan

: Mu and kappa opioid receptor agonists antagonize icilin-induced wet-dog shaking in rats. Eur J Pharmacol 2006, 547:101–105.

37.

Andersson

Gentry

Moss

Bevan

: Clioquinol and pyrithione activate TRPA1 by increasing intracellular Zn2+. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 2009, 106:8374–8379.

38.

Petrus

Peier

Bandell

Hwang

Huynh

Olney

Jegla

Patapoutian

: A role of TRPA1 in mechanical hyperalgesia is revealed by pharmacological inhibition. Mol Pain 2007, 3:40.

39.

Bautista

Jordt

Nikai

Tsuruda

Read

Poblete

Yamoah

Basbaum

Julius

: TRPA1 mediates the inflammatory actions of environmental irritants and proalgesic agents. Cell 2006, 124:1269–1282.

40.

Viana

de la Pena

Belmonte

: Specificity of cold thermotransduction is determined by differential ionic channel expression. Nat Neurosci 2002, 5:254–260.

41.

Madrid

de la Pena

Donovan-Rodriguez

Belmonte

Viana

: Variable threshold of trigeminal cold-thermosensitive neurons is determined by a balance between TRPM8 and Kv1 potassium channels. J Neurosci 2009, 29:3120–3131.

42.

Zhang

Jiang

Gong

Fei

Xiong

: A-type GABA receptor as a central target of TRPM8 agonist menthol. PLoS ONE 2008, 3:e3386.

43.

Swandulla

Carbone

Schafer

Lux

: Effect of menthol on two types of Ca currents in cultured sensory neurons of vertebrates. Pflugers Arch 1987, 409:52–59.

44.

Proudfoot

Garry

Cottrell

Rosie

Anderson

Robertson

Fleetwood-Walker

Mitchell

: Analgesia mediated by the TRPM8 cold receptor in chronic neuropathic pain. Curr Biol 2006, 16:1591–1605.

45.

Katsura

Obata

Mizushima

Yamanaka

Kobayashi

Dai

Fukuoka

Tokunaga

Sakagami

Noguchi

: Antisense knock down of TRPA1, but not TRPM8, alleviates cold hyperalgesia after spinal nerve ligation in rats. Exp Neurol 2006, 200:112–123.

46.

Flatters

Bennett

: Ethosuximide reverses paclitaxel- and vincristine-induced painful peripheral neuropathy. Pain 2004, 109:150–161.