Uranium was discovered 200 years ago. Its radioactive character was first demonstrated in 1896 and two years later radium was extracted from uranium minerals. In 1911 studies with alpha rays from radioactive decay led to the unexpected discovery of the atomic nucleus. Exposure of beryllium to alpha rays yielded neutrons, first detected in 1932. Starting in 1934, neutron irradiation of uranium produced radioactive substances erroneously attributed to transuranium elements but with confusing properties. Painstaking experiments by chemists left no doubt on 17 December 1938 that barium was produced by these irradiations: the neutrons had split some uranium nuclei. The physics of the fission process was understood two weeks later; after a few months, neutron multiplication was found to be probable. This review deals with the eminent scientists involved, their successes, errors and disappointments, and the unexpected insights which occurred on the paths and detours of scientific research. It is, therefore, instructive also to discuss how fission was not discovered. The momentous discovery must be considered inevitable; the great tragedy was that Germany started World War II just at the time when the possibility of nuclear chain reactions and bombs became known. The consequences and anxieties that remain after 50 years of nuclear fission demand that mankind act with reason and conscience to maintain peace.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
KlaprothM. H., Chemische Untersuchung des Uranits, einer neuentdeckten metallischen Substanz. Crell Chem. Ann. 1789II, 387. Klaproth's uranite was the oxide; the metal was first prepared in1841.
2.
MendeleevD., Lieb. Ann. Suppl. 8, 178 (1872). He assigned the atomic weight 240 instead of 120, as had been assumed before (Gmelin's Handbook of Inorganic Chemistry).
3.
GeigerH. and MarsdenE., On a diffuse reflection of the alpha particles. Proc. Roy. Soc., LondonA82, 495 (1909).
4.
RutherfordE., The scattering of the alpha and beta rays and the structure of the atom. Proc. Manchester Lit. Phil. Soc. IV. 55, 18 (1911)
5.
GeigerH., The large scattering of the alpha particles, Proc. Manchester Lit. Phil. Soc IV55, 20 (1911).
6.
GeigerH. and MarsdenE., Die Zerstreuungsgesetze der Alphastrahlen bei grossen Ablenkungswinkeln. Sitz. Ber. Akad. Wiss. Wien, Math.-Nat. Kl. Abt. lla, 121, 2361 (1912).
7.
ThomsonJ. J.(Nobel Prize 1906), at the Second Solvay Conference in Brussels, October 1913. The only reference to the atomic nucleus was made by Rutherford himself. See Mehra, JiThe Solvay Conferences on Physics, Reidel, Dordrecht/Boston (1975), p. 75.
8.
RutherfordE., Collisions of alpha particles with light atoms. IV. An anomalous effect in nitrogen. Philos. Mag. 37. 581 (1919).
9.
FleischmannR., Zur Entdeckungsgeschichte der künstlichen Kern-Gamma-Strahlung. Naturwiss. 38, 465 (1951).
10.
Mitteil, aus d. Max-Planck-Gesellschaft1/1957, p. 12. Hahn gave this talk on 17 Dec. 1956, when a memorial tablet was unveiled at what is now called the ‘Otto Hahn Bau’ of the Free University of Berlin. The text reads: ‘In this building, the former Kaiser-Wilhelm-Institut für Chemie, Otto Hahn and Fritz Strassmann discovered uranium fission in December 1938….’
11.
LemmerichJ., Die Geschichte der Entdeckung der Kernspaltung. Catalogue of the exhibition, tuBerlin, Universitätsbibliothek, Berlin (1988).
12.
HahnD.(Ed.), Mein Leben, Otto Hahn, Extended new edition. Piper, Munich (1986).
13.
MeitnerL., Wege und Irrwege zur Kernenergie. Naturwiss. Rundschau16, 167 (1963).
14.
GamowG. and HoutermansF. G., Zur Quantenmechanik des radioaktiven Kerns. Z. Physik52, 496 (1928).
15.
AlvarezL. W., Adventures of a Physicist. Basic Books, New York (1987), p. 75.
16.
KrafftF., Im Schatten der Sensation: Leben und Wirken von Fritz Strassmann. Verlag Chemie, Weinheim (1981), pp. 218 and 225. According to G. Herrmann, each 6-cm-long brass tube contained a sealed glass tube with beryllium powder and about 100 mg of radium sulfate or radon gas (G. Hermann, Vor fünf Jahrzehnten: Von den ‘Transuranen zur Kernspaltung. Angew. Chem. 102, 469, 1990).51
17.
NoddackI., Über das Element 93. Angew. Chemie47, 653 (1934). The idea was not so revolutionary as is often mentioned. Hahn and Strassmann protested against a priority claim by Mrs Noddack, stating ‘that the possibility of a decay of heavy atoms into smaller fragments has been discussed earlier by many others, too, without experimental consequences being drawn’ (Naturwiss. 27, 213, 1939). In 1932, for example, W, Bothe, when discussing dual radioactive decay, mentioned the assumption that a heavy radioactive nucleus might ‘break apart into two complex nuclei’ (H. Geiger and K. Scheel, ed., Handb. d. Physik XXII/1, Springer, Berlin 1933, p. 207).
18.
PromiesW.(Ed.), G. C. Lichtenberg: Schriften und Briefe, vol. 1. Hanser, Munich (1968), p. 518. Lichtenberg (1742–1799) was professor of experimental physics at Göttingen.
19.
BadashL., HodesE. and TiddensA., Nuclear fission: Reaction to the discovery in 1939. Proc. Am. Phil. Soc. 130, 196 (1986).
20.
HeisenbergW., Der Teil und das Ganze. Piper, Munich (1969), p. 217.
21.
BohrN., Neutron capture and nuclear constitution. Nature137, 344 (1936).
22.
Remark inHoutermansF. G., Zur Frage der Auslösung von Kern-Kettenreaktionen. Mitt. aus d. Laboratorium Manfred v. Ardenne1941, p. 115.
23.
British Patents 440, 023 and 630, 726.
24.
WeartS. R. and SzilardG. Weiss (Ed): Leo Szilard: His Version of the Facts, mitPress, Cambridge, Mass./London (1978), p. 17.
25.
CrawfordE., HeilbronJ. L. and UllrichR.: The Nobel Population 1901–1937. University of California, Berkeley (1987).
26.
In 1972, the remnants of a natural prehistoric reactor were discovered at Oklo in the Gabon Republic. Uranium ore with typically 0.4% was found; 0.72% is normal. It is concluded that the missing 235U was fissioned 1800 million years ago when the deposit went critical with water as a moderator.
27.
At that time the relative abundance of235U was about 3.5%, as in present technical reactors (because the half-life of 235U is shorter than that of 238U). Other data support this assumption. See first publication in English: R. Naudet, The Oklo Nuclear Reactor, Interdisciplinary Science Reviews, 1, 72 (1976). See also G. A. Cowan, Sci. Am. 235, 36 (1976); M. Maurette, Ann. Rev. Nucl. Sci. 26, 319 (1976); and J. M. Irvine, and R. Humphreys, Progr. Part. Nucl. Phys. 17, 59 (1986).
28.
FlüggeS., Kann der Energieinhalt der Atomkerne technisch nutzbar gemacht werden?Naturwiss. 27, 402 (1939).
29.
HahnO., Nobel lecture1946(reprinted in reference 11).
30.
GowingM., The lesson of quantum theory, inde BoerJ., DalE. and UlfbeckO.(Eds), The Niels Bohr Centenary Symposium. North-Holland, Amsterdam (1986), p. 343.
31.
KernerC., Lise, Atomphysikerin. Beiz, Weinheim/Basel (1986), p. 107.
32.
See for example, BernsteinJ., Prophet der Energie: Hans Bethe, Hirzel, Stuttgart (1988), p. 137.
33.
JaspersK., Die Atombombe und die Zukunft des Menschen. Munich (1958); new edition, Piper, Munich(1982) pp. 263 and 475.
34.
Ibid., p. 489.
35.
WeartSee S. R., Nuclear Fear: A History of Images. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass./London (1988).
36.
At the end of his1946Nobel lecture (see reference 26).
37.
StrassmannF., Kernspaltung. Privately printed, Mainz (1978), p. 19.
38.
Ibid., p. 34. Also reference 28, p. 123.
39.
Last paragraph of the Mainau Statement of 15 July1955. This statement was initiated by Hahn and signed by 51 Nobel prize winners. Facsimile reproduction byHahnD.inOtto Hahn: Begründer des Atomzeitalters. List, Munich(1979), p. 250.
40.
HahnD.(Ed.), Otto Hahn, Erlebnisse und Erkenntnisse. Düsseldorf/Vienna (1975).
41.
KrafftF., MeitnerLise: Her life and times – On the centenary of the great scientist's birth. Angew. Chemie Internat. Ed. 17826 (1978).
42.
BrixP., Die folgenreiche Entdeckung der Uranspaltung – und wie es dazu kam. Naturwiss. Rundschau42, 1 (1989): Physikalische Blätter45, 2 (1989). Both publications are practically identical; they include four pages of Hahn's pocket diary (11–24 Dec 1938) as facsimile reproduction.
43.
GraetzerH. G. and AndersonD. L., The Discovery of Nuclear Fission: a Documentary History. Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York (1971).
44.
WohlfarthH., 40 Jahre Kernspaltung: Eine Einführung in die Originalliteratur. Wiss. Buchgesellschaft, Darmstadt (1979).
45.
HerrmannG., Discovery and confirmation of fission. Nucl. Phys. A502, 141c, 1989.
46.
Additional general references (in English):
47.
StarkeK., The detours leading to the discovery of nuclear fission. J. Chem. Educ. 56, 771 (1979).
48.
SheaW. R.(ed.). Otto Hahn and the Rise of Nuclear Physics. Reidel, Dordrecht (1983).
49.
AmaldiE., From the discovery of the neutron to the discovery of nuclear fission. Phys. Rep. 3, 1, 1984.
50.
RhodesR., The Making of the Atomic Bomb. Simon and Schuster, New York (1986).
51.
PeierlsR., Reflections on the discovery of fission. Nature342, 852 (1989).
52.
HermannA., 200 years with uranium. Nucl. Eur. 9–10, 9 (1989).
53.
SimeR. L., Lise Meitner and the discovery of fission. J. Chem. Educ. 66, 373 (1989).
54.
SegrèE. G., The discovery of nuclear fission. Physics Today, July1989, p. 38.
55.
HerrmannG., Fifty years ago: From transuranic elements to nuclear fission. Angew. Chemie Internat. Ed., translation of the paper quoted in reference 15.
56.
SimeR. L., Lise Meitner's escape from Germany. Am. J. Phys. 58(3), 262 (1990).
