Abstract
The extensive use of thin films in the manufacture of microelectronic devices and for protection against wear and corrosion has stimulated considerable interest in their mechanical properties. In this review the most widely used testing methods of free standing films and of films adherent to their substrates are described. Particular attention is given to problems and difficulties experienced with each of the techniques. Results obtained by these methods are discussed and critically examined.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
HOFFMAN
R. W.
: in ‘Thin films’ , (ed.
Wilsdorf
H. G. F.
), Chap. 4; 1964, Metals Park, OH, American Society for Metals.
2.
PLISKIN
W. A.
ZANIN
S. J.
: in ‘Handbook of thin film technology’ , (ed.
Maissel
L. I.
Glang
R.
), Chap. 11; 1970, New York, McGraw-Hill.
3.
OLIVER
W. C.
: MRS Bull ., Sept.—Oct . 1986 , 11 , 15 –19 .
4.
PHARR
G. M.
OLIVER
W. C.
: MRS Bull ., July 1992 , 17 ,28 –33 .
5.
GRODZINSKI
P.
: Plastics , 1953 , 18 , 312 –314 .
6.
FROHLICH
F.
GRAU
P.
GRELLMANN
W.
: Phys. Status Solidi (a ), 1977 , 42 , 79 –89 .
7.
NEWEY
D.
WILKINS
M. A.
POLLOCK
H. M.
: J. Phys. E , Sci. Instrum ., 1982 , 15 , 119 –122 .
8.
PETHICA
J. B.
HUTCHINGS
R.
OLIVER
W. C.
: Philos. Mag. A , 1983 , 48 , 593 –606 .
9.
LOUBET
J.
GEORGES
J. M.
MARCHESINI
D.
MEILLE
G.
: J. Tribology (Trans. ASME) , 1984 , 106 , 43 –48 .
10.
DOERNER
M. F.
Nix
w. D.
: J. Mater. Res ., 1986 , 1 , 601 –609 .
11.
OLIVER
W. C.
McHARGUE
C. J.
ZINKLE
S. J.
: Thin Solid Films , 1987 , 153 , 185 –196 .
12.
WU
T. W.
HWANG
C.
LO
J.
ALEXOPOULOS
P.
: Thin Solid Films , 1988 , 166 , 299 –308 .
13.
JOSLIN
D. L.
McHARGUE
C. J.
OLIVER
w. C.
: in ‘Structure—properties relationships in surface-modified ceramics’ , (ed.
McHargue
C. J.
et al.), 289-296; 1989, Dordrecht, Kluwer Academic Pub.
14.
MX
W. D.
: Metal!. Trans ., 1989 , 20A , 2217 –2245 .
15.
OLIVER
W. C.
PHARR
G. M.
: J. Mater. Res ., 1992 , 7 , 1564 –1583 .
16.
NISHIBORI
M.
KINOSITA
K.
: Jpn J. Appl. Phys ., 1972 , 11 , 758 .
17.
KINOSITA
K.
: Thin Solid Films , 1972 , 12 , 17 –28 .
18.
NISHIBORI
M.
KINOSITA
K.
: Thin Solid Films , 1978 , 48 , 325 –331 .
19.
BERKOVICH
E. S.
: Ind . Diamond Re
v ., 11, 129 –132 .
20.
TABOR
D.
: Proc. R. Soc ., 1948 , A192 , 247 –274 .
21.
TABOR
D.
: ‘The hardness of metals’ ; 1951 , Oxford , Clarendon Press .
22.
STILWELL
N. A.
TABOR
D.
: Proc. Phys. Soc. (Lond .), 1961 , 78 , 169 –179 .
23.
PHARR
G. M.
OLIVER
W. C.
BROTZEN
F. R.
: Mater. Res ., 1992 , 7 , 613 –617 .
24.
KING
R. B.
: Int. J. Solids Struct ., 1987 , 23 , 1657 –1664 .
25.
LAWN
B. R.
HOWES
V. R.
: J. Mater. Sc
i ., 1981 , 16, 2745 -2752.
26.
POLLOCK
H. M.
MAUGIS
D.
BARQUINS
M.
: in `Microindentation techniques in materials science and engin-eering', STP 889, (ed.
Blau
P. J.
Lawn
B. R.
), 47-71; 1985, Philadelphia, PA, American Society for Testing and Materials.
27.
BHATTACHARYA
A. K.
NIX
W. D.
: Int. J. Solids Struct ., 1988 , 24 , 881 –891 .
28.
LOUBET
J. L.
GEORGES
J. M.
MEILLE
G.
: in `Microindentation techniques in materials science and engin-eering', STP 889, (ed.
Blau
P. J.
Lawn
B. R.
), 72-89; 1985, Philadelphia, PA, American Society for Testing and Materials.
29.
LAURSEN
T. A.
mop
J. C.
: J. Mater. Res ., 1992 , 7 , 618 –626 .
30.
KINOSITA
K.
: Thin Solid Films , 1978 , 50 , 205 –210 .
31.
TAZAKI
M.
NISHIBORI
M.
KINOSITA
K.
: Thin Solid Films , 1978 , 51 , 13 –21 .
32.
OLIVER
W. C.
McHARGUE
C. J.
: Thin Solid Films , 1988 , 161 , 117 –122 .
33.
LEBOUVIER
P. D.
GILORMINI
P.
FELDER
E.
: J. Phys. D , Appl. Phys ., 1985 , 18 , 199 –210 .
34.
PETHICA
J. B.
OLIVER
w. C.
: Phys. Scr. Vol. T , 1987 , 19 , 61 –66 .
35.
PETHICA
J. B.
OLIVER
w. C.
: in ‘Thin films: Stresses and mechanical properties’ , (ed.
Bravman
J. C.
et al.), Mater. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc ., 1989 , 130 , 13 –23 .
36.
OLIVER
W. C.
PETHICA
J. B.
: US Pat . 4 848 141 , 1989 .
37.
ATKINS
A. G.
: Met. Sci ., 1982 , 16 , 127 –137 .
38.
ROSS
J. D. J.
POLLOCK
H. M.
PIVIN
J.-C.
TAICADOUM
J.
: Thin Solid Films , 1987 , 148 , 171 –180 .
39.
DOERNER
M. F.
GARDNER
D. S.
MX
W. D.
: J. Mater. Res ., 1986 , 1 , 845 –851 .
40.
BHATTACHARYA
A. K.
NIX
W. D.
: Int. J. Struct. Solids , 1988 , 24 , 1287 –1298 .
41.
PAGE
T. F.
OLIVER
W. C.
McHARGUE
C. J.
: J. Mater. Res ., 1992 , 7 , 450 –473 .
42.
PETHICA
J. B.
KOIDL
P.
, .1. GOBRECHT , and C. SCHULER: J. Vac. Technol ., 1985 , A3 , 2391 -2393.
43.
JOSLIN
D. L.
O'HERN
M. E.
McHARGUE
C. J.
CLAUSING
R. E.
OLIVER
w. c.
: in Proc. SPIE—Int. Soc. for Optical Engineering, Vol. 1050, (ed.
Campbell
R. L.
), 218-225; 1989, Bellingham, WA, Society of Photo-Optical Instrumentation Engineers.
44.
SINES
G.
CARLSON
R.
: ASTM Bull ., 1952 , 180 , 35 –37 .
45.
BLAIN
P. A.
: Met. Prog ., 1957 , 71 , (1 ), 99 –100 .
46.
KOKUBO
S.
: Sci . Rep. rohoku Imp. Uni
v ., 21, 256 –267 .
47.
Tsui
T. Y.
: MS thesis, Rice University, Houston, TX, 1992.
48.
GRIDNEVA
I. V.
, Yu. V. MILMAN , and V. I. TREHLOV: Phys. Status Solidi (a) , 1972 , 14 , 177 –182 .
49.
PHARR
G. M.
OLIVER
W. C.
COOK
R. F.
KIRCHNER
P. D.
KROLL
M. C.
DINGER
T. R.
CLARKE
D. R.
: J. Mater. Res ., 1992 , 7 , 961 –972 .
50.
STONE
D.
LaFONTAINE
W. R.
ALEXOPOULOS
P.
WU
T. W.
LI
C.-Y.
: J. Mater. Res ., 1988 , 3 , 141 –147 .
51.
PHARR
G. M.
OLIVER
W. C.
CLARKE
D. R.
: J. Electron. Mater ., 1990 , 19 , 881 –887 .
52.
PHARR
G. M.
OLIVER
W. C.
CLARKE
D. R.
: SCr . 1989 , 23 , 1949-1952 .
53.
PHARR
G. M.
OLIVER
W. C.
HARDING
D. S.
: J. Mater. Res ., 1991 , 6 , 1129 –1130 .
54.
CALLAHAN
D. L.
MORRIS
J. C.
: J. Mater. Res ., 1992 , 7 , 1614 –1617 .
55.
GILMAN
J. J.
: J. Mater. Res ., 1992 , 7 , 535 –538 .
56.
CAHN
R. W.
: Nature , 1992 , 357 , 645 –646 .
57.
VU
H. Y.
IMAM
M. A.
RATH
B. B.
: in
‘Proc. 5th in conf. on titanium’ , (ed.
Liitjering
G. L.
et al.), Vol. 3 , 1819 -1826; 1984 , Oberursel, Deutsche Gesellschaft fiir Metallkunde .
58.
YU
H. Y.
IMAM
M. A.
RATH
B. B.
: J. Mater. Sc
i ., 20, 636 –642 .
59.
BELL
T. J.
FIELD
J. S.
SWAIN
M. V.
: in ‘Thin films: Stresses and mechanical properties III’, (ed.
Nix
W. D.
et al.), Mater. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc ., 1992 , 239 , 331 –336 ,
60.
PHARR
G. M.
HARDING
D. S.
OLIVER
W. C.
: in Proc. NATO Advanced Study Institute on ‘Mechanical properties and deformation behavior of materials having ultra-fine micro-structures’, Praia do Porto Novo, Portugal, July 1992, (ed.
Nastasi
M.
et al.), 1-13.
61.
YOFFE
E. H.
: Philos. Mag ., 1982 , A46 , 617 –628 ,
62.
JOHNSON
R. L.
: ‘Contact mechanics’, Chap. 6; 1985, Cambridge University Press.
63.
LAWN
B. R.
EVANS
A. G.
MARSHALL
D. B.
: J. Am. Ceram. Soc ., 1980 , 63 , 574 –581 .
64.
COOK
R. F.
PHARR
G. M.
: J. Am. Ceram. Soc ., 1990 , 73 , 787 –817 .
65.
ZENG
K.
BREDER
K.
ROWCLIFFE
D. J.
: Acta Metall. Mater ., 1992 , 40 , 2595 –2600 .
66.
ZENG
K.
BREDER
K.
ROWCLIFFE
D. J.
: Acta Metal!. Mater ., 1992 , 40 , 2601 –2605 .
67.
HILL
R.
LEE
E. H.
TUPPER
S. J.
: Proc. R. Soc ., 1947 , A188 , 273 –289 .
68.
HILL
R.
: ‘The mathematical theory of plasticity’, Chap. 9; 1950, Oxford, Clarendon Press.
69.
SHAW
M. C.
: in ‘The science of hardness testing and its research applications’ , (ed.
Westbrook
J. H.
Conrad
H.
), 1-15; 1973, Metals Park, OH, American Society for Metals.
70.
SAMUELS
L. E.
: in `Microindentation techniques in materials science and engineering', STP 889, (ed.
Blau
P. J.
Lawn
B. R.
), 5-25; 1985, Philadelphia, PA, American Society for Testing and Materials.
71.
POLLOCK
H. M.
MAUGIS
D.
BARQUINS
M.
: in `Microindentation techniques in materials science and engineering', STP 889, (ed.
Blau
P. J.
Lawn
B. R.
), 47-71; 1985, Philadelphia PA, American Society for Testing and Materials.
72.
RAMAN
V.
BERR1CHE
R.
: J. Mater. Res ., 1992 , 7 , 627 –638 .
73.
LaFONTAINE
W. R.
, B. YOST, R. D. BLACK, and c.-v. 1.1 : J. Mater. Res ., 1990 , 5 , 2100 -2106.
74.
WU
T. W.
MOSHREF
M.
ALEXOPOULOS
P. S.
: Thin Solid Films , 1990 , 187 , 295 –307 .
75.
LI
C.-Y.
: in ‘Metallurgical treatises’ , (ed.
Tien
J. K.
Elliott
J. F.
), 469-485; 1981, Warrendale PA, Metallurgical Society of AIME.
76.
KORHONEN
M. A.
HANNULA
S.-P.
LI
C.-Y.
: in ‘Unified constitutive equations for creep and plasticity’ , (ed.
Miller
A. K.
), 89-137; 1987, London, Elsevier Applied Science.
77.
MAYO
M. J.
SIEGEL
R. W.
NARAYANASAMY
A.
a
W.
NIX:
J. Mater. Res ., 1990 , 5 , 1073 –1082 .
78.
MAYO
M. J.
NIX
W. D.
: in Proc. 8th Int. Conf. on ‘Strength of metals and alloys’, (ed.
Kettunen
P. 0.
et al.), 1415-1420; 1988 , Oxford , Pergamon Press.
79.
MAYO
M. J.
NIX
W. D.
: Acta Metal! ., 1988 , 36 , 2183 –2192 .
80.
MAYO
M. J.
SIEGEL
R. W.
LIAO
Y. X.
NIX
W. D.
: J. Mater. Res ., 1992 , 7 , 973 –979 .
81.
LUCAS
B. N.
OLIVER
W. C.
: in ‘Thin films: Stresses and mechanical properties III’, (ed.
Nix
W. D.
et al.), Mater. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc ., 1992 , 239 , 337 –341 .
82.
BAKER
S. P.
BARBEE
T. W.
NIX
W. D.
: in ‘Thin films: Stresses and mechanical properties III’, (ed.
Nix
W. D.
et al.), Mater. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc ., 1992 , 239 , 319 –324 .
83.
LAWLEY
A.
SCHUSTER
S.
: Rev. Sci. Instrum ., 1962 , 33 , 1178 –1180 .
84.
NEUGEBAUER
C. A.
: J. App!. Phys ., 1960 , 31 , 1096 –1101 .
85.
BLAKELY
J. M.
: J. App!. Phys ., 1964 , 35 , 1756 –1759 .
86.
HENNING
C. A. O.
BOSWELL
F. W.
CORBETT
J. M.
: Acta. Metal! ., 1975 , 23 , 177 –185 .
87.
Ya
M.
. FUKS, L. S. PALATNIK, A. I. IL'INSKI , and V. V. BELOZEROV: Soy. Phys. Solid State , 1967 , 9 , 588 –592 .
88.
ZILING
K. K.
POKROVSKIY
L. D.
, and Yu. PCHELKIN : Phys. Met. Metallogr ., 1970 , 29 , (5 ), 225 –227 .
89.
SPRINGER
R. W.
CATLETT
D. S.
: Thin Solid Films , 1978 , 54 , 197 –205 .
90.
D'ANTONIO
C.
HIRSCHHORN
J.
TARSHIS
L.
: Trans. AIME , 1963 , 227 , 1346 –1351 .
91.
MENTER
J. W.
PASHLEY
D. W.
: in ‘Structure and properties of thin films’ , (ed.
Neugebauer
C. A.
et al.), 111-150; 1960, New York, Wiley.
92.
PEDRAZA
A. J.
GODBOLE
M. J.
: SCr . Meta//. Mater ., 1990 , 24 , 1185 –1189 .
93.
GODBOLE
M. J.
PEDRAZA
A. J.
: SCr . Metal!. Mater ., 1990 , 24 , 1191 –1196 .
94.
BADACHHAPE
R. B.
, .1. L. MARGRAVE , and F. R. BROTZEN: Thin Solid Films , 1986 , 139 , L77—L78 .
95.
ROSENMAYER
C. T.
BROTZEN
F. R.
BRADY
D. P.
: Meas. Sci. Technol ., 1991 , 2 , 86 –87 .
96.
GRIFFIN
A. J.
, Jr, F. R. BROTZEN , and c. E DUNN: Thin Solid Films , 1992 , 220 , 265 –270 .
97.
YOSHI'
K.
TAGAKI
T.
UMENO
M.
KAWABE
IL
: J. Phys. E , Sci. Instrum ., 1983 , 16 , 127 –130 .
98.
ROSENMAYER
C. T.
BROTZEN
F. R.
GALE
R. J.
: in ‘Thin films: Stresses and mechanical properties’, (ed.
Bravman
J. C.
et al.), Mater. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc ., 1989 , 130 , 77 –86 .
99.
HOFFMAN
R. W.
: in ‘Physics of thin films’ , (ed.
Hass
G.
Thun
R. E.
), Vol. 3,211-273; 1966 , New York , Academic Press.
100.
BRENNER
S. S.
: J. App!. Phys ., 1957 , 28 , 1023 –1026 .
101.
D
. M. MARSH: J. Sci. Instrum ., 38, 229 –234 .
102.
KUHLMANN-WILSDORF
D.
RAGHAVAN
K. S.
: Rev. Sci. Instrum ., 1962 , 33 , 930 –933 .
103.
ODING
I. A.
ALEKSANYAN
I. T.
: Soy. Phys. Dokl ., 1964 , 8 , 818 –820 .
104.
KOSTYUK
V. G.
ZILING
K. K.
SEREBRYAKOV
A. V.
: Soy. Phys. Solid State , 1964 , 5 , 2241 –2245 .
105.
PALATNIK
L. S.
IL'INSKIE
A. I.
Soy. Phys. Usp ., 11, 564 –581 .
106.
HENNING
C. A. O.
BOSWELL
F. W.
CORBETT
J. M.
: J. Phys. E , Sci. Instrum ., 1972 , 5 , 1231 –1232 .
107.
ANDEEN
G. G.
HAGGERLING
C. W.
HOFFMAN
R. W.
: in Proc. 7th Int. Vacuum Cong. and 3rd Int. Conf. Solid Surfaces , Vienna , 1977 , Vol. 2 , 1769 –1772 .
108.
ANDEEN
C. G.
HOFFMAN
R. W.
: in ‘Probing polymer structures’ , (ed.
Koenig
J. L.
), Adv. Chem. Series No. 174, 25-33; 1979 , Washington, DC , American Chemical Society.
109.
LIU
L.
GRIFFIN
A. J.
, Jr, F. R. BROTZEN, and C. F. DuNN: Unpublished works.
110.
PASHLEY
D. W.
: Proc. R. Soc ., 1960 , A255 , 218 –231 .
111.
IL'INSKII
A. I.
PALATNIK
L. S.
Ye.LYAKH
G.
AN'
NGUEN TUAN
: Phys. Met. Metallogr ., 1975 , 39 , (1 ), 190 –192 .
112.
BEAMS
J. W.
BREAZEALE
J. B.
BART
W. L.
: Phys . Re
v ., 1955 , 100, 1657 -1661.
113.
VERDI
F. W.
TAVANE
R. L.
in ‘Properties of electrodeposits — their measurement and significance’, (ed.
Sard
R.
et al.), Chap. 12, 214-219; 1975, Princeton, NJ, The Electro-chemical Society.
114.
ALEKSANYAN
T.
TUMANOVA
L. A.
SHERMERGOR
T. D.
: Phys. Met. Metallogr ., 1972 , 34 , (3 ), 220 –221 .
115.
GRUNES
R. L.
, C. D'ANTONIO , and E K. KIES: J. App!. Phys ., 1965 , 36 , 2735 –2739 .
116.
PALATNIK
L. S.
IL'INSKII
A. I.
: Soy. Phys. Solid State , 1962 , 3 , 2053 –2057 .
117.
PALATNIK
L. S.
FEDOROV
G. V.
IL'INSKII
A. L.
: Phys. Met. Metallogr ., 1961 , 11 , (5 ), 160 –161 .
118.
VERBKINA
V. L.
ZILING
K. K.
POKROVSKIY
L. D.
: Phys. Met. Metallogr ., 1975 , 39 , (5 ), 168 –173 .
119.
IL'INSKII
A. I.
PALATNIK
L. S.
SAPELKIN
N. P.
: Soy. Phys. Solid State , 1974 , 15 , 2134 –2137 .
120.
TUMANOVA
L. A.
SHERMERGOR
T. D.
: Phys. Met. Metallogr ., 1972 , 34 , (4 ), 207 –209 .
121.
TUMANOVA
L. A.
SHERMERGOR
T. D.
: Phys. Met. Metallogr ., 1979 , 48 , (3 ), 172 –176 .
122.
ALEKSANYAN
I. T.
: Phys. Met. Metallogr., 1968 , 25 , (5) , 189 –190.
123.
EVANS
R. W.
WILSHIRE
a.
: ‘Creep of metals and alloys’, Chaps. 1 and 3; 1985, London, The Institute of Metals.
124.
BROTZEN
F. R.
ROSENMAYER
C. T.
COFER
C. G.
GALE
R. J.
: Vacuum , 1990 , 41 , 1287 –1290 .
125.
ZILING
K. K.
Yu
V.
. PCHELKIN: Zh. Prikl. Mekh. Tekh. Fiz. , 1970 , (3) , 442 –444.
126.
ATTARDO
M. J.
ROSENBERG
R.
:. 1. App!. Phys ., 41, 2381 –2386 .
127.
MUKHERJEE
A. K.
BIRD
J. E.
DORN
J. E.
: Trans. ASM , 1969 , 62 , 155 –179 .
128.
SEEGER
A.
: Philos. Mag ., 1955 , 46 , 1194 –1217 .
129.
THORNTON
P. R.
HIRSCH
P. B.
: Philos. Mag ., 1958 , 3 , 738 –761 .
130.
SOLONOVICH
I. I.
: Phys. Met. Metallogr., 1975 , 40 , (3) , 158 –163.
131.
BEAMS
J. W.
: in ‘The structure and properties of thin films’ , (ed.
Neugebauer
C. A.
etal.), 183-192; 1960, New York, Wiley.
132.
JACCODINE
R. J.
SCHLEGEL
W. A.
: J. App!. Phys ., 1966 , 37 , 2429 –2434 .
133.
CATLIN
A.
WALKER
W. P.
: J. App!. Phys ., 1960 , 31 , 2135 –2139 .
134.
LEIDHEISER
H.
, Jr and B. W. SLOOPE : J. App!. Phys ., 1970 , 41 , 402 –406 .
135.
Va
B.
. PINES and NGUEN SUAN TYAN' : Phys. Met. Metallogr ., 1965 , 19 , (6 ), 91 –97 .
136.
DEUBER
J. M.
It
G.
. LURIE : Plating , 1973 , 60 , 715 –719 .
137.
YANG
W. M. C.
TSAKALAKOS
T.
HILLIARD
J. E.
: J. App!. Phys ., 1977 , 48 , 876 –879 .
138.
GossErr
J. L.
: in ‘Properties of electrodeposits’ , (ed.
Sard
R.
et al.), 221-228; 1975, Princeton, NJ, The Electrochemical Society.
139.
GRIFFIN
A. J.
, Jr, F. R. BROTZEN , and C. F. DUNN: Thin Solid Films , 1987 , 150 , 237 –244 .
140.
DUDDERAR
T. D.
KOCH
R. B.
: in ‘Properties of electrodepos-its’ , (ed.
Sard
R.
et al.), 187-213; 1975, Princeton, NJ, The Electrochemical Society.
141.
RANTA-ESKOLA
A. J.
: Int. J. Mech. Sc! ., 1979 , 21 , 457 –465 .
142.
BROTZEN
F. R.
ROSENMAYER
C. T.
GALE
R. J.
: Thin Solid Films , 1988 , 166 , 291 –298 .
143.
SIMMONS
G.
WANG
H.
: ‘Single crystal elastic constants and calculated aggregate properties: a handbook’, 2nd ed; 1971, Cambridge, MA, The MIT Press.
144.
KRUKOVER
P. I.
BURAVIKHIN
V. A.
: Phys. Met. Metallogr., 1966, 22, (1), 1.56-159.
145.
JOVANOVIC
S.
smut
C. S.
J. App!. Phys ., 1961 , 32 , 121 –122 .
146.
SPINNER
S.
CLEEK
G. W.
: J. App!. Phys ., 1960 , 31 , 1407 –1410 .
147.
HILL
R.
: Philos. Mag ., 1950 , 41 , 1133 –1142 .
148.
GERARD
G.
PAPIRNO
R.
: Trans. ASM , 1957 , 49 , 132 –148 .
149.
PAPIRNO
R.
: J. App!. Phys ., 1961 , 32 , 1175 –1176 .
150.
BROWN
W. F.
, Jr and G. SACHS : Trans. ASME , 1948 , 70 , 241 –251 .
151.
BROWN
W. F.
, Jr and E C. momPsoN : Trans. ASME , 1949 , 71 , 575 –585 .
152.
TSAKALAKOS
T.
: Thin Solid Films , 1981 , 75 , 293 –305 .
153.
SMALL
M. K.
VLASSAK
J. J.
NIX
W. D.
: in ‘Thin films: Stresses and mechanical properties III’, (ed.
Nix
W. D.
et al.), Mater. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc ., 1992 , 239 , 257 –262 .
154.
SMALL
M. K.
NIX
W. D.
: J. Mater. Res ., 1992 ,7 , 1553 –1563 .
155.
VLASSAK
J. J.
NIX
W. D.
: J. Mater. Res ., 1992 ,7 , 3242 –3249 .
156.
WEISSMAN
G. E
: J. Test. Eval ., 1973 , 1 , 133 –138 .
157.
WEIHS
T. P.
HONG
S.
BRAVMAN
J. C.
NIX
W. D.
: J. Mater. Res ., 1988 , 3 , 931 –942 .
158.
SCHWEITZ
J.-A.
: MRS Bull ., 1992 , 17 , 34 –45 .
159.
LANDAU
L. D.
LIFSHITZ
E. M.
: ‘Theory of elasticity’, 3rd edn, Chap. 2; 1986 , Oxford , Pergamon Press.
160.
ERICSON
F.
and J.-A , SCHWEITZ : J. App!. Phys ., 1990 , 68 , 5840 –5844 .
161.
HONG
S.
WEIHS
T. P.
BRAVMAN
J. C.
NIX
W. D.
: J. Electron. Mater ., 1990 , 19 , 903 –909 .
162.
MULLEN
R. L.
MEHREGANY
M.
OMAR
M. P.
KO
W. H.
: in Proc. IEEE Conf. on `Microelectromechanical systems', Nara, Japan, 30 Jan.-2 Feb. 1991, 154-159; New York, Institute of Electrical and Electronic Engineers.
163.
PETERSEN
K. E.
GUARNIERE
c. R.
J. App!. Phys ., 1979 , 50 , 6761 –6766 .
164.
JOHANSSON
S.
ERICSON
F.
SCHWEITZ
J.-A.
: J. App!. Phys ., 1986 , 65 , 122 –128 .
165.
BAKER
S. P.
JANKOWSKI
A. E
HONG
S.
NIX
W. D.
: in ‘Thin films: Stresses and mechanical properties II’, (ed.
Doerner
M. F.
et al.), Mater. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc ., 1990 , 188 , 289 –294 .
166.
KINBARA
A.
BABA
S.
MATUDA
N.
: Thin Solid Films , 1986 , 141 , 229 –236 .
167.
KINBARA
A.
BABA
S.
MATUDA
N.
TAKAMISAWA
K.
: Thin Solid Films , 1986 , 84 , 205 –212 .
168.
UOZUMI
K.
HONDA
H.
KINBARA
A.
: Thin Solid Films , 1976 , 37 , L49—L51 .
169.
siNHA
A. K.
SHENG
T. T.
: Thin Solid Films , 1978 , 48 , 117 –126 .
170.
HERSHKOVITZ
M.
BLECH
I. A.
KOMEM
Y.
: Thin Solid Films , 1985 , 130 , 86 –93 .
171.
HIEBER
H.
SIMON
T.
: in 24th Annual Proc. IEEE, Internal Reliability Physics, San Diego, CA, 1986, 253-259.
172.
SW
C.-K.
GUPTA
D.
HO
P. S.
: in Proc. 2nd Int. Multilevel Interconnect Conf., 187-193; 1985, New York, Institute of Electrical and Electronic Engineers.
173.
TOWNSEND
P. H.
PLAS
H. A. VANDER
: in ‘Thin films: The relationship of structure to properties’, (ed.
Aita
C. R.
SreeHarsha
K. S.
), Mater. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc ., 1985 , 47 , 121 –126 .
174.
McINERNEY
E. J.
FLINN
P. A.
: in 20th Annual Proc. IEEE, Internal Reliability Physics, San Diego, CA, 1982, 264-267.
175.
SINHA
A. K,
LEVINSTEIN
H. J.
SMITH
T. E.
: J. App!. Phys ., 1978 , 49 , 2423 –2426 .
176.
FLINN
P. A.
GARDNER
D. S.
NIX
W. D.
: IEEE Trans. Electron Dev., 1987, ED-34, 689-699.
177.
FLINN
P. A.
: .1. Mater. Res ., 6, 1498 –1501 .
178.
HARDWICK
D. A.
: Thin Solid Films , 1987 , 154 , 109 –124 .
179.
GRIFFIN
A. J.
, Jr, F. R. BROTZEN , and C. F. DUNN: Scr. Metal! ., 1986 , 20 , 1271 –1272 .
180.
YANG
W. C.
HILLIARD
J. E.
: Unpublished results quoted in Ref. 181.
181.
BARAL
D.
. J. B. KETTERSON , and J. E. HILLIARD: J. App!. Phys ., 1985 , 57 , 1076 –1083 .
182.
coox
H. E.
HILLIARD
J. E.
: J. App!. Phys ., 1969 , 40 , 2191 –2198 .
183.
TSAKALAKOS
T.
HILLIARD
J. E.
: J. App!. Phys ., 1983 , 54 , 734 –737 .
184.
TESTARDI
L. R.
WILLENS
R. H.
KRAUSE
J. T.
McWHAN
D. B.
NAKAFIARA
S.
: J. App!. Phys ., 1981 , 52 , 510 –511 .
185.
HENEIN
G. E.
HILLIARD
J. E.
: J. App!. Phys ., 1983 , 54 , 728 –733 .
186.
JANKOWSKI
A.
TSAKALAKOS
T.
: J. App!. Phys ., 1985 , 57 , 1835 –1838 .
187.
BARAL
D.
HILLIARD
J. E.
KETTERSON
J. B.
MIYANO
K.
: J. App!. Phys ., 1982 , 53 , 3552 –3559 .
188.
BARAL
D.
KETTERSON
J. B.
HILLIARD
J. E.
: in Proc. NATO Advanced Study Institute on ‘Modulated structure materials’, Maleme-Chania, Greece, June 1983, (ed.
Tsakalakos
T.
), 465-473; 1983, Dordrecht, Martinus Nijhoff.
189.
BERRY
R. S.
PRITCHET
W. C.
: Thin Solid Films , 1976 , 33 , 19 –28 .
190.
SCHLESINGER
T. E.
CAMMARATA
R. C.
KIM
C.
QADRI
S. B.
EDELSTEIN
A. S.
: in ‘Thin films: Stresses and mechanical prop-erties II’, (ed.
Doerner
M. F.
et al.), Mater. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc ., 1990 , 188 , 295 –300 .
191.
CAMMARATA
R. C.
SCHLESINGER
T. E.
KIM.
C.
QADRI
S. B.
EDELSTEIN
A. S.
: Appl. Phys. Lett ., 1990 , 56 , 1862 –1864 .
192.
DUTCHER
J. R.
LEE
S.
KIM
J.
STEGEMAN
G. I.
FALCO
C. M.
: Phys. Rev. Lett ., 1990 , 65 , 1231 –1234 .
193.
DAVIS
B. M.
SEIDMAN
D. N.
MOREAU
A.
KETTERSON
J. B.
MATTSON
J.
GRIMSDITCH
M.
: Phys . Re
v ., 1991 , B43, 9304 -9307.
194.
CHOU
T. C.
NIEH
T. G.
TSUI
T. Y.
PHARR
G. M.
OLIVER
W. C.
: .1. Mater. Res ., 7, 2765 –2773 .
195.
CHOU
T. C.
NIEH
T. G.
McADAMS
S. D.
PHARR
G. M.
OLIVER
W. C.
: J. Mater. Res ., 1992 , 7 , 2774 –2784 .
196.
PHARR
G. M.
OLIVER
w. C.
: J. Mater. Res ., 1989 , 4 , 94 –101 .
197.
SARGENT
P. M.
: in `Microindentation techniques in materials science and engineering', STP 889, (ed.
Blau
P. J.
Lawn
B. R.
), 160-174; 1985, Philadelphia, PA, American Society for Testing and Materials.
198.
BURNETT
P. J.
PAGE
T. F.
: J. Mater. Sc
i ., 19, 845 –860 .
199.
BURNETT
P. J.
RICKERBY
D. S.
: Thin Solid Films , 1987 , 148 , 41 –50 ,
200.
BURNETT
P. J.
RICKERBY
D. S.
: Thin Solid Films , 1987 , 148 , 51 –65 .
201.
FABES
B. D.
OLIVER
W. C.
: in ‘Thin films: Stresses and mechanical properties II’ , (ed.
Doerner
M. F.
et al.), Mater Res. Soc. Symp. Proc ., 1990 , 188 , 127 –132 .
202.
FABES
B. D.
OLIVER
W. C.
McKEE
R. A.
WALKER
F. J.
: J. Mater. Res ., 1992 , 7 , 3056 –3064 .