Autoclave study of zirconium alloys with and without hydride rim

Abstract

Autoclave corrosion experiments were conducted on a number of zirconium alloys in different heat treatment conditions. The alloys tested in the present work were Zircaloy-4, ZIRLO® (ZIRLO is a registered trademark of Westinghouse Electric Company LLC in the USA and may be registered in other countries throughout the world. All rights reserved. Unauthorised use is strictly prohibited.) and two variants of ZIRLO with significantly lower Sn levels, referred to here as A-0·6Sn and A-0·0Sn. Typical corrosion kinetics with a change from pre- to post-initial transition was observed with ZIRLO and Zircaloy-4 displaying the shortest time to the initial transition after 120-140 days of autoclave exposure, followed by A-0·6Sn materials after 140-260 days. A-0·0Sn materials showed no sign of transition even after 360 days although one sample tested to 540 days had gone through transition. Material in the stress relieved condition generally experienced initial transition earlier than the same alloy in the recrystallised condition. Pretransition samples had a universally black oxide layer, which eventually developed grey patches when transition occurred. Practically, all non-hydrogen charged alloys showed a strong trend towards cubic oxide growth rates. Cathodic hydrogen charging was conducted to simulate end of life condition of cladding tubes, forming a hydride rich rim region at the outer surface of the cladding tubes. Hydrogen charged materials generally experienced accelerated corrosion of different degrees with the exception of recrystallised A-0·0Sn and partially recrystallised A-0·6Sn showing no sign of acceleration. It therefore seems that increasing tin levels has a negative impact on autoclave corrosion behaviour for materials with and without a hydride rich rim. In developing advanced alloys for use in cladding, this effect has been balanced against the benefits that Sn is known to provide in-reactor, including robustness in corrosion behaviour and reduced irradiation growth. It was noted that most materials with a hydride rich rim exhibit parabolic corrosion kinetics with decreased initial weight gain but increased overall weight gain.

Keywords

Zirconium alloys Nuclear cladding Zirconium alloy corrosion Autoclave testing Zirconium hydride Zircaloy-4 ZIRLO

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Arima

Miyata

Inagaki

and Idemitsu

: ‘Oxidation properties of Zr–Nb alloys at 500-600°C under low oxygen potentials’, Corros. Sci. 2005 47 (2) 435–446.

Arima

Moriyama

Gaja

Furuya

Idemitsu

and Inagaki

: ‘Oxidation kinetics of Zircaloy-2 between 450°C and 600°C in oxidizing atmosphere’, J. Nucl. Mater. 1998 257 (1) 67–77.

Bryner

J. S.

: ‘The cyclic nature of corrosion of Zircaloy-4 in 633 K water’, J. Nucl. Mater. 1979 82 (1) 84–101.

Cox

: ‘Comments on “aqueous corrosion of the Zircaloys at low temperatures”’, J. Nucl. Mater. 1969 30 (3) 351–352.

Cox

: ‘Some thoughts on the mechanisms of in-reactor corrosion of zirconium alloys’, J. Nucl. Mater. 2005 336 (2-3) 331–368.

Griggs

Maffei

H. P.

and Shannon

D. W.

: ‘Multiple rate transitions in the aqueous corrosion of zircaloy’, J. Electrochem. Soc. 1962 109 (8) 665–668.

Hauffe

: ‘Oxidation of metals’; 1965

New York

Plenum Press, Inc.

Kass

: ‘The development of the zircaloys’ Proc. ANS Winter Meet. on ‘Corrosion of zirconium alloys’; 1964

New York

ASTM International.

Kass

: ‘Aqueous corrosion of the zircaloys at low temperatures’, J. Nucl. Mater. 1969 29 (3) 315–321.

10.

Kiselev

A. A.

Myshkin

V. A.

Kozhevnikov

A. V.

Korolev

S. L.

and Shorina

E. G.

: ‘Corrosion of reactor materials’; 1962

Vienna

IAEA.

11.

Lustman

and Kerze

JR : ‘The metallurgy of zirconium’776; 1955

New York

McGraw-Hill.

12.

Motta

A. T.

Silva

M. J. G. D.

Yilmazbayhan

Comstock

R. J.

Cai

and Lai

: ‘Micostructural characterisation of oxides formed on model Zr alloys using synchrotron radiation’ Proc. 15th Int. Symp. on ‘Zirconium in the nuclear industry’, Sunriver, OR, USA, June 2007, ASTM International486–506.

13.

Sabol

G. P.

and Dalgaard

S. B.

: ‘The origin of the cubic rate law in zirconium alloy oxidation’, J. Electrochem. Soc. 1975 122 (2) 316–317.

14.

Bossis

Pêcheur

Hanifi

Thomazet

and Blat

: ‘Comparison of the high burn-up corrosion on M5 and low tin Zircaloy-4’ Proc. 14th Int. Symp. on ‘Zirconium in the nuclear industry’, Stockholm, Sweden, June 2004, ASTM International494–525.

15.

Bouvier

Godlewski

and Lucazeau

: ‘A Raman study of the nanocrystallite size effect on the pressure–temperature phase diagram of zirconia grown by zirconium-based alloys oxidation’, J. Nucl. Mater. 2002 300 (2-3) 118–126.

16.

Garde

A. M.

: ‘Enhancement of aqueous corrosion of Zircaloy-4 due to hydride precipitation at the metal–oxide interface’ Proc. 9th Int. Symp. on ‘Zirconium in the nuclear industry’, Kobe, Japan, November 1990, ASTM International566–592.

17.

Godlewski

: ‘How the tetragonal zirconia is stabilized in the oxide scale that is formed on a zirconium alloy corroded at 400°C in steam’ Proc. 10th Int. Symp. on ‘Zirconium in the nuclear industry’, Baltimore, MD, USA, June 1993, ASTM International663–683.

18.

Peters

H. R.

: ‘Improved characterization of aqueous corrosion kinetics of Zircaloy-4’ Proc. 6th Int. Symp. on ‘Zirconium in the nuclear industry’, Vancouver, BC, Canada, June–July 1982, ASTM International507–519.

19.

Yilmazbayhan

Motta

A. T.

Comstock

R. J.

Sabol

G. P.

Lai

and Cai

: ‘Structure of zirconium alloy oxides formed in pure water studied with synchrotron radiation and optical microscopy: relation to corrosion rate’, J. Nucl. Mater. 2004 324 (1) 6–22.

20.

Preuss

Frankel

Lozano-Perez

Hudson

Polatidis

Wei

English

Storer

Chong

B. K.

Fitzpatrick

Wang

Smith

Grosvenor

Smith

Sykes

Cottis

Lyon

Hallstadius

Comstock

R. J.

Ambard

and Blat-Yrieix

: ‘Studies regarding corrosion mechanisms in zirconium alloys’, J. ASTM Intl, Vol. 8, No. 9, doi: 10:1520/JAI103246, 2011 649–681.

21.

Blat-Yrieix

Ambard

Foct

Miquet

Beguin

and Cayet

: ‘Toward a better understanding of dimensional changes in Zircaloy-4: what is the impact induced by hydrides and oxide layer?’, J. ASTM Int. 2008 5 (9) 16.

22.

Busser

Desquines

Fouquet

Baietto

M. C.

and Mardon

J. P.

: ‘Modelling of corrosion induced stresses during Zircaloy-4 oxidation in air’, Mater. Sci. Forum 2008 595-598 419–427.

23.

Roy

and Burgess

: ‘A study of the stresses generated in zirconia films during the oxidation of zirconium alloys’, Oxid. Met. 1970 2 (3) 235–261.

24.

Cox

: ‘Are zirconium corrosion films a form of partially stablized zirconia?’ AECL-9382, Atomic Energy of Canada Ltd, Chalk River, Ont., Canada 1987.

25.

Godlewski

Bouvier

Lucazeau

and Fayette

: ‘Stress distribution measured by Raman spectroscopy in zirconia films formed by oxidation of Zr-based alloys’ Proc. 12th Int. Symp. on ‘Zirconium in the nuclear industry’, Toronto, Ont., Canada, June 1998, ASTM International877–899.

26.

Schwartz

C. M.

Vaughan

D. A.

and Cocks

G. G.

: ‘Report BMI-793 December 17, 1952’ in ‘The metallurgy of zirconium’, (ed. Lustman

.), 562; 1955

New York

McGraw-Hill.

27.

Heuer

A. H.

and Rühle

: ‘Overview no. 45: on the nucleation of the martensitic transformation in zirconia (ZrO₂)’, Acta Metall. 1985 33 (12), 2101-2112.

28.

Ploc

R. A.

and Newcomb

S. B.

: ‘Microscopy of oxidation 3’ Proc. 3rd Int. Conf. on ‘Microscopy of oxidation’, Cambridge, UK, September 1996, Institute of Materials, Minerals and Mining475–487.

29.

Cox

Kritsky

V. G.

Lemaignan

Polley

Ritchie

I. G.

Ruhmann

Shishov

V. N.

Bibilashvili

Y. K.

and Nikulina

A. V.

: ‘Waterside corrosion of zirconium alloys in nuclear power plants’ TECDOC-996, IAEA, Vienna, Austria 1998.

30.

Clayton

J. C.

: ‘Out-of-pile nickel alloy-induced accelerated hydriding of zircaloy fasteners’ Proc. 6th Int. Symp. on ‘Zirconium in the nuclear industry’, Vancouver, BC, Canada, June–July 1982, ASTM International572–591.

31.

Garde

A. M.

Smith

G. P.

and Pirek

R. C.

: ‘In-PWR irradiation performance of dilute tin–zirconium advanced alloys’ Proc. 13th Int. Symp. on ‘Zirconium in the nuclear industry’, Annecy, France, June 2001, ASTM International490–506.

32.

Kammenzind

B. F.

Franklin

D. G.

Duffin

W. J.

and Peters

H. R.

: ‘Hydrogen pickup and redistribution in alpha-annealed Zircaloy-4’ Proc. 11th Int. Symp. on ‘Zirconium in the nuclear industry’, Garmisch-Partenkirchen, Germany, September 1995, ASTM International338–370.

33.

Kearns

J. J.

: ‘Terminal solubility and partitioning of hydrogen in the alpha phase of zirconium, Zircaloy-2 and Zircaloy-4’, J. Nucl. Mater. 1967 22 (3) 292–303.

34.

Mcminn

Darby

E. C.

and Schofield

J. S.

: ‘The terminal solid solubility of hydrogen in zirconium alloys’ Proc. 12th Int. Symp. on ‘Zirconium in the nuclear industry’, Toronto, Ont., Canada, June 1998, ASTM International173–196.

35.

Kammenzind

B. F.

Berquist

B. M.

Bajaj

Kreyns

P. H.

and Franklin

D. G.

: ‘The long range migration of hydrogen through zircaloy in response to tensile and compressive stress gradients’ Proc. 12th Int. Symp. on ‘Zirconium in the nuclear industry’, Toronto, Ont., Canada, June 1998, ASTM International196–233.

36.

Blat

and Noel

: ‘Detrimental role of hydrogen on the corrosion rate of zirconium alloys’ Proc. 11th Int. Symp. on ‘Zirconium in the nuclear industry’, Garmisch-Partenkirchen, Germany, September 1995, ASTM International319–337.

37.

Cox

: ‘Observation of a second transition point during the oxidation of zirconium alloys’ Corrosion 18 (1) 33–36.

38.

Khatamian

: ‘Role of hydrides on the oxidation and deuterium pickup of Zr–2·5Nb in D₂O at 573 K’, J. Alloys Compd 2005 404-406 297–302.

39.

Kido

: ‘A study on enhanced uniform corrosion of Zircaloy-4 cladding during high burnup operation in PWRs’ Proc. 6th Int. Symp. on ‘Environmental degradation of materials in nuclear power systems – water reactors’, San Diego, CA, USA, August 1993, The Minerals, Metals & Materials Society449–456.

40.

Blat

Legras

Noel

and Amanrich

: ‘Contribution to a better understanding of the detrimental role of hydrogen on the corrosion rate of Zircaloy-4 cladding materials’ Proc. 12th Int. Symp. on ‘Zirconium in the nuclear industry’, Toronto, Ont., Canada, June 1998, ASTM International563–592.

41.

Carpenter

G. J. C.

: ‘The dilatational misfit of zirconium hydrides precipitated in zirconium’, J. Nucl. Mater. 1973 48 (3) 264–266.

42.

Daum

R. S.

Chu

Y. S.

and Motta

A. T.

: ‘Identification and quantification of hydride phases in Zircaloy-4 cladding using synchrotron X-ray diffraction’, J. Nucl. Mater. 2009 392 (3) 453–463.

43.

Santisteban

J. R.

Vicente-Alvarez

M. A.

Vizcaíno

Banchik

A. D.

and Almer

J. D.

: ‘Hydride precipitation and stresses in Zircaloy-4 observed by synchrotron X-ray diffraction’, Acta Mater. 2010 58 (20), 6609-6618.

44.

Kim

Y. S.

Woo

H. K.

K. S.

and Kwun

S. I.

: ‘The cause for enhanced corrosion of zirconium alloys by hydrides’ Proc. 13th Int. Symp. on ‘Zirconium in the nuclear industry’, Annecy, France, June 2001, ASTM International274–295.

45.

Seibold

and Garzarolli

: ‘Influence of composition and condition on in-PWR behavior of Zr–Sn–Nb–FeCrV alloys’ Proc. 13th Int. Symp. on ‘Zirconium in the nuclear industry’, Annecy, France, June 2001, ASTM International743–757.

46.

Garde

A. M.

Pati

S. R.

Krammen

M. A.

Smith

G. P.

and Endter

R. K.

: ‘Corrosion behavior of Zircaloy-4 cladding with varying tin content in high-temperature pressurized water reactors’ Proc. 10th Int. Symp.: ‘Zirconium in the nuclear industry’, (ed. Garde

A. M. B. E. R.

), 760–778; 1994

Philadelphia, PA

ASTM.

47.

Yueh

H. K.

Kesterson

R. L.

Comstock

R. J.

Shah

H. H.

Colburn

D. J.

Dahlback

and Hallstadius

: ‘Improved ZIRLO^TM cladding performance through chemistry and process modifications’ Proc. 14th Int. Symp.: ‘Zirconium in the nuclear industry’, (ed. Rudling

P. K. B.

), 330–346; 2005

Philadelphia, PA

ASTM.

48.

Kesterson

R. L.

Yueh

Shah

Foster

Colburn

Hallstadius

and Arana

: ‘Cladding optimization for enhanced performance margins’ Proc. TopFuel 2006 Conf., Salamanca, Spain, October 2006, ENS67.

49.

Sabol

G. P.

Kilp

G. R.

Balfour

M. G.

and Roberts

: ‘Development of a cladding alloy for high burnup’ ASTM STP 1023227–244; 1989

Philadelphia, PA

ASTM.

50.

Chabretou

Hoffmann

Trapp-Pritsching

Garner

Barberis

Rebeyrolle

and Vermoyal

: ‘Ultra low tin quaternary alloys PWR performance – impact of tin content on corrosion resistance, irradiation growth, and mechanical properties’, J. ASTM Int. 2011 8, (5).

51.

Wei

Frankel

Govender

Blat

Ambard

Comstock

R. J.

Hallstadius

Lyon

Cottis

and Preuss

: ‘Synthesis of a hydride rich rim on zirconium alloys: a cathodic hydrogen charging method’ Corros. Sci. to be published.

52.

Cheng

Gilmore

P. M.

and Klepfer

H. H.

: ‘PWR zircaloy fuel cladding corrosion performance, mechanisms and modeling’ Proc. 11th Int. Symp. on ‘Zirconium in the nuclear industry’, Garmisch-Partenkirchen, Germany, September 1995, ASTM International137–160.

53.

Barberis

: ‘Zirconia powders and zircaloy oxide films: tetragonal phase evolution during 400°C autoclave tests’, J. Nucl. Mater. 1995 226 (1-2) 34–43.

54.

Beie

H.-J.

Mitwalsky

Garzarolli

Ruhmann

and Sell

H.-J.

: ‘Examinations of the corrosion mechanism of zirconium alloys’ Proc. 10th Int. Symp. on ‘Zirconium in the nuclear industry’, Baltimore, MD, USA, June 1993, ASTM International615–643.

55.

Harada

Kimpara

and Abe

: ‘Effect of alloying elements on uniform corrosion resistance of zirconium-based alloy in 360°C water and 400°C steam’ Proc. 9th Int. Symp. on ‘Zirconium in the nuclear industry’, Kobe, Japan, November 1990, ASTM International368–390.

56.

Mardon

J. P.

Charquet

and Senevat

: ‘Optimization of PWR behavior of stress-relieved Zircaloy-4 cladding tubes by improving the manufacturing and inspection process’ Proc. 10th Int. Symp. on ‘Zirconium in the nuclear industry’, Baltimore, MD, USA, June 1993, ASTM International328–347.

57.

Takeda

and Anada

: ‘Mechanism of corrosion rate degradation due to tin’ Proc. 12th Int. Symp. on ‘Zirconium in the nuclear industry’, Toronto, Ont., Canada, June 1998, ASTM International592–608.

58.

Chen

I. W.

and Penner-Hahn

J. E.

: ‘Effect of dopants on zirconia stabilization – an X-ray absorption study. II: tetravalent dopants’, J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 1994 77 (5), 1281-1288.

59.

Kim

D.-J.

Jang

J.-W.

and Lee

H.-L.

: ‘Effect of tetravalent dopants on Raman spectra of tetragonal zirconia’, J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 1997 80 (6), 1453-1461.

60.

Cox

and Pemsler

J. P.

: ‘Diffusion of oxygen in growing zirconia films’, J. Nucl. Mater. 1968 28 (1) 73–78.

61.

Cox

and Roy

: Electrochem. Technol. 1966 4 121.

62.

Ploc

R. A.

: ‘Transmission electron microscopy of thin (<2000 Å) thermally formed ZrO₂ films’, J. Nucl. Mater. 1968 28 (1) 48–60.

63.

Ploc

R. A.

: ‘A transmission electron diffraction study of ZrO₂ on α-Zr (0001)’, J. Nucl. Mater. 1982 110 (1) 59–64.

64.

Ploc

R. A.

: ‘Electron diffraction from ZrO₂ on αZr(1010)’, J. Nucl. Mater. 1983 115 (1) 110–117.

65.

Ploc

R. A.

: ‘Electron diffraction analysis of ZrO₂ on αZr(1120)’, J. Nucl. Mater. 1983 113 (1) 75–80.

66.

Yilmazbayhan

Breval

Motta

A. T.

and Comstock

R. J.

: ‘Transmission electron microscopy examination of oxide layers formed on Zr alloys’, J. Nucl. Mater. 2006 349 (3) 265–281.

67.

Cox

: in ‘Advances in corrosion science and technology’, (ed. Fontana

M. G.

.), 173; 1976

New York

Plenum.

68.

Donaldson

A. T.

and Evans

H. E.

: ‘Oxidation-induced creep in Zircaloy-2. Parts I–III’ RD/T/N4855, 4952 and 4976, Central Electricity Generating Board, Berkeley Nuclear LabsUK Reports, Berkeley, UK 1980.

69.

Lozano-Perez

Jenkins

M. L.

English

Smith

G. D. W.

Sykes

J. M.

and Grovenor

C. R. M.

: ‘Porosity in oxides on zirconium fuel cladding alloys, and its importance in controlling oxidation rates’, Scr. Mater. 2010 62 (8) 564–567.

70.

Park

J.-Y.

Choi

B.-K.

Yoo

S. J.

and Jeong

Y. H.

: ‘Corrosion and oxide properties of HANA alloys’ Proc. 15th Int. Symp. on ‘Zirconium in the nuclear industry’, Sunriver, OR, USA, June 2007, ASTM International471–485.

71.

Bossis

Verhaeghe

Doriot

Gilbon

Charbretou

Dalmais

Mardon

J.-P.

Blat

and Miquet

: ‘In PWR comprehensive study of high burn-up corrosion and growth behavior of M5 and recrystallized low-tin Zircaloy-4’ Proc. 15th Int. Symp. on ‘Zirconium in the nuclear industry’, Sunriver, OR, USA, June 2007, ASTM International430–456.

72.

Takagawa

Ishimoto

Etoh

Kubo

Ogata

and Kubota

: ‘The correlation between microstructures and in-BWR corrosion behavior of highly irradiated Zr-based alloys’ Proc. 14th Int. Symp. on ‘Zirconium in the nuclear industry’, Stockholm, Sweden, June 2004, ASTM International386–403.

73.

Sell

H.-J.

Trapp-Pritsching

and Garzarolli

: ‘Effect of alloying elements and impurities on in-BWR corrosion of zirconium alloys’ Proc. 14th Int. Symp. on ‘Zirconium in the nuclear industry’, Stockholm, Sweden, June 2004, ASTM International404–417.

74.

Dahlbäck

Limbäck

Hallstadius

Barberis

Bunel

Simonot

Andersson

Askeljung

Flygare

Lehtinen

and Massih

A. R.

: ‘The effect of beta-quenching in final dimension on the irradiation growth of tubes and channels’ Proc. 14th Int. Symp. on ‘Zirconium in the nuclear industry’, Stockholm, Sweden, June 2004, ASTM International276–304.

75.

Arborelius

Dahlbäck

Hallstadius

Jourdain

Andersson

Lisdat

Hahn

and Toscano

E. H.

: ‘The effect of duplex cladding outer component tin content on corrosion, hydrogen pick-up, and hydride distribution at very high burnup’ Proc. 14th Int. Symp. on ‘Zirconium in the nuclear industry’, Stockholm, Sweden, June 2004, ASTM International526–546.

76.

Garzarolli

Ruhmann

and Swam

L. V.

: ‘Alternative Zr alloys with irradiation resistant precipitates for high burnup BWR application’ Proc. 13th Int. Symp. on ‘Zirconium in the nuclear industry’, Annecy, France, June 2001, ASTM International119–134.

77.

Etoh

Shimada

Yasuda

Ikeda

Adamson

R. B.

Chen

J.-S. F.

Ishii

and Take

: ‘Development of new zirconium alloys for a BWR’ Proc. 11th Int. Symp. on ‘Zirconium in the nuclear industry’, Garmisch-Partenkirchen, Germany, September 1995, ASTM International825–849.

78.

Kim

Young S.

Rheem

K. S.

and Min

D. K.

: ‘Phenomenological study of in-reactor corrosion of Zircaloy-4 in pressurized water reactors’ Proc. 10th Int. Symp. on ‘Zirconium in the nuclear industry’, Baltimore, MD, USA, June 1993, ASTM International745–759.

79.

Garzarolli

Schumann

and Steinberg

: ‘Corrosion optimized zircaloy for boiling water reactor (BWR) fuel elements’ Proc. 10th Int. Symp. on ‘Zirconium in the nuclear industry’, Baltimore, MD, USA, June 1993, ASTM International709–723.