The aim of this study was to compare the fracture load of different joints made by conventional brazing, tungston inert gas (TIG) and laser welding.
Materials and methods
Six standardized joining configurations of spring hard quality orthodontic wire were investigated: end-to-end, round, cross, 3 mm length, 9 mm length and 6.5 mm to orthodontic band. The joints were made by five different methods: brazing with universal silver solder, two TIG and two laser welding devices. The fracture loads were measured with a universal testing machine (Zwick 005). Data were analysed with the Mann–Whitney–Wilcoxon and Kruskal–Wallis tests. The significance level was set at P<0.05).
Results
In all cases brazed joints were ruptured at a low level of fracture load (186–407 N). Significant differences between brazing and TIG or laser welding (P<0.05) were found. The highest mean fracture loads were observed for laser welding (826 N). No differences between the various TIG or laser welding devices were demonstrated, although it was not possible to join an orthodontic wire to an orthodontic band using TIG welding.
Conclusion
For orthodontic purposes laser and TIG welding are solder free alternatives. TIG welding and laser welding showed similar results. The laser technique is an expensive, but sophisticated and simple method.
ChavesM, VermilyeaSG, PapazoglouE, BrantleyWAEffects of three soldering techniques on the strength of high-palladium alloy solder joints. J Prosthet Dent1998; 79: 677–84.
2.
DuaR, NandlalBA comparative evaluation of the tensile strength of silver soldered joints of stainless steel and cobalt chromium orthodontic wires with band material – an in vitro study. J Indian Soc Pedod Prev Dent2004; 22: 13–16.
3.
GawlikJA, MathieuGP, HondrumSThe effects of tack welding and increasing surface area on the tensile strength of silver electric and flame soldered stainless steel joints. Pediatr Dent1996; 18: 215–18.
4.
GulkerIA, MartiniRT, ZinnerID, PannoFVA comparison of hydrogen/oxygen and natural gas/oxygen torch soldering techniques. Int J Prosthodont1994; 7: 258–63.
5.
HeidemannJ, WittE, FeegM, HeidemannJ, WittE, FeegMOrthodontic soldering techniques: aspects of quality assurance in the dental laboratory. J Orofac Orthop2002; 63: 325–38.
6.
Anselm WiskottHW, DoumasT, ScherrerSS. Mechanical and structural characteristics of commercially pure grade 2 Ti welds and solder joints. J Mater Sci Mater Med2001; 12: 719–25.
7.
JelmertO, HansteenIL, LangardSCytogenetic studies of stainless steel welders using the tungsten inert gas and metal inert gas methods for welding. Mutat Res1995; 342: 77–85.
8.
McCartneyJW, DoudRPassive adaptation of the prosthesis-implant interface by soldering gold cylinders to the framework casting. J Prosthet Dent1993; 70: 17–20.
9.
MockersO, DerozeD, CampsJCytotoxicity of orthodontic bands, brackets and archwires in vitro. Dent Mater2002; 18: 311–17.
10.
OdaY, OkabeTEffect of corrosion on the strength of soldered titanium and Ti–6Al–4V alloy. Dent Mater1996; 12: 167–72.
SestiniS, NotarantonioL, CerboniB, AlessandriniC, FimianiM, NannelliP, PelagalliA, GiorgettiR.In vitro toxicity evaluation of silver soldering, electrical resistance, and laser welding of orthodontic wires. Eur J Orthod2006; 28: 567–72.
13.
SolmiR, MartiniD, ZanariniM, IsazaPenco S, RimondiniL, CarinciP, BoreaG, RuggeriA.Interactions of fibroblasts with soldered and laser-welded joints. Biomaterials2004; 25: 735–40.
14.
YanXJ, YangDZCorrosion resistance of a laser spot-welded joint of NiTi wire in simulated human body fluids. J Biomed Mater Res A2006; 77: 97–102.
15.
YokotaK, MinamiT, MichitsujiH, FujioT, YamadaSOccupational dermatitis from soldering flux. Ind Health2004; 42: 383–84.
16.
ZupancicR, LegatA, FundukNTensile strength and corrosion resistance of brazed and laser-welded cobalt-chromium alloy joints. J Prosthet Dent2006; 96: 273–82.
17.
BabaN, WatanabeI, LiuJ, AtsutaMMechanical strength of laser-welded cobalt-chromium alloy. J Biomed Mater Res B Appl Biomater2004; 69: 121–24.
18.
BabaN, WatanabeIPenetration depth into dental casting alloys by Nd:YAG laser. J Biomed Mater Res B Appl Biomater2005; 72: 64–68.
19.
BergE, WagnereWC, DavikG, DootzERMechanical properties of laser-welded cast and wrought titanium. J Prosthet Dent1995; 74: 250–57.
20.
BertrandC, le PetitcorpsY, AlbingreL, DupuisVOptimization of operator and physical parameters for laser welding of dental materials. Br Dent J2004; 196: 413–18.
21.
ChaiT, ChouCKMechanical properties of laser-welded cast titanium joints under different conditions. J Prosthet Dent1998; 79: 477–83.
TambascoJ, AnthonyT, SandvenOLaser welding in the dental laboratory: an alternative to soldering. J Dent Technol1996; 13: 23–31.
24.
TaylorJC, HondrumSO, PrasadA, BrodersenCAEffects of joint configuration for the arc welding of cast Ti–6Al–4V alloy rods in argon. J Prosthet Dent1998; 79: 291–97.
25.
UysalH, KurtogluC, GurbuzR, TutuncuNStructure and mechanical properties of Cresco-Ti laser-welded joints and stress analyses using finite element models of fixed distal extension and fixed partial prosthetic designs. J Prosthet Dent2005; 93: 235–44.
26.
VerstryngeA, van HumbeeckJ, WillemsG.In-vitro evaluation of the material characteristics of stainless steel and beta-titanium orthodontic wires. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop2006; 130: 460–70.
27.
WangRR, ChangCTThermal modeling of laser welding for titanium dental restorations. J Prosthet Dent1998; 79: 335–41.
28.
HuangHH, LinMC, LinCC, LinSC, HsuCC, ChenFL, LeeSY, HungCCEffects of welding pulse energy and fluoride ion on the cracking susceptibility and fatigue behavior of Nd:YAG laser-welded cast titanium joints. Dent Mater J2006; 25: 632–40.
29.
IwasakiK, OhkawaS, RoscaID, UoM, AkasakaT, WatariFDistortion of laser welded titanium plates. Dent Mater J2004; 23: 593–99.
WatanabeI, BabaN, ChangJ, ChiuYNd:YAG laser penetration into cast titanium and gold alloy with different surface preparations. J Oral Rehabil2006; 33: 443–46.
32.
WatanabeI, TophamDSLaser welding of cast titanium and dental alloys using argon shielding. J Prosthodont2006; 15: 102–07.
33.
WatanabeI, TophamDSTensile strength and elongation of laser-welded Ti and Ti–6Al–7Nb. J Biomed Mater Res B Appl Biomater2004; 71: 46–51.
34.
YamagishiT, ItoM, FujimuraYMechanical properties of laser welds of titanium in dentistry by pulsed Nd:YAG laser apparatus. J Prosthet Dent1993; 70: 264–73.
35.
SrimaneepongV, YoneyamaT, KobayashiE, DoiH, HanawaTMechanical strength and microstructure of laser-welded Ti–6Al–7Nb alloy castings. Dent Mater J2005; 24: 541–49.
36.
WatanabeI, LiuJ, AtsutaM, OkabeTEffect of welding method on joint strength of laser-welded gold alloy. Am J Dent2003; 16: 231–34.
37.
WatanabeI, LiuJ, AtsutaMEffects of heat treatments on mechanical strength of laser-welded equi-atomic AuCu–6 at%Ga alloy. J Dent Res2001; 80: 1813–17.
38.
WatanabeI, LiuJ, BabaN, AtsutaM, OkabeTOptimizing mechanical properties of laser-welded gold alloy through heat treatment. Dent Mater2004; 20: 630–34.
39.
RochaR, PinheiroAL, VillaverdeABFlexural strength of pure Ti, Ni–Cr and Co–Cr alloys submitted to Nd:YAG laser or TIG welding. Braz Dent J2006; 17: 20–23.
