William Matthew Flinders Petrie (1853–1942) was a legendary figure in the histories of archaeology and anthropology, recognised for his discipline-building efforts and his contributions to various intellectual paradigms including eugenics and anthropometry. Of lesser renown, however, is the donation of his own head to the collections of the Royal College of Surgeons of England in London. This paper sets that donation in the context of Petrie's lifelong investment in curating other people's heads and in building representative museological collections for teaching and research. The authors situate the curation of Petrie's head in the genealogy of his own scholarship and curatorial practice and, in so doing, initiate a conversation about the power of human remains to generate debate, critical reflection and reconsiderations of both historiography and future museum practice.
Institute of Archaeology Archive, UCL Special Collections
3.
Petrie to unknown: Letter from Flinders Petrie to unknown, 29 April 1937, UCL Petrie Correspondence, Box 1, 1900–1949, folder 6, Wheeler/Petrie 1934.
4.
Petrie to Verney Wheeler: Letter from Flinders Petrie to Tessa Verney Wheeler, 8 March 1935, UCL Petrie Correspondence, Box 1, 1900–1949, folder 6, Wheeler/Petrie 1934.
5.
Galton Papers, UCL Special Collections
6.
Petrie to Galton: Letter from Finders Petrie to Francis Galton, 12 February 1885, Galton Archive, Galton 297.
7.
Petrie Museum Archive (PMA)
8.
Daniel to Drower: Letter from Glyn Daniel to Margaret Drower, 1 March 1976, PMA 16/5/1 (1–3)
9.
Flower to Petrie: Letter from W. M. Flower to Flinders Petrie, 12 October 1889, PMA 16/5/1 (1–3)
10.
Hilda Petrie to unknown: Lady Hilda Petrie to unknown recipient, 29 November 1948, PMA 16/5/1 (1–3)
11.
Keith to Cave: Letter from Arthur Keith to A.J. Cave, 31 October 1944, PMA 16/2/2 & 16/8/1 (13)
12.
Keith to Thompson: Letter from Arthur Keith to WE Thompson, n.d., PMA 16/2/2 & 16/8/1 (13)
13.
Pearson to Petrie: Letter from Karl Pearson to Flinders Petrie, [Undated — 1895?], PMA 115/5/2
14.
Pearson to Petrie: Letter from Karl Pearson to Flinders Petrie, 17 June 1895, PMA 115/5/2
15.
Pearson to Petrie: Letter from Karl Pearson to Flinders Petrie, 12 August 1895, PMA 115/5/2
Thompson to Keith, Letter from WE Thompson to Arthur Keith, 9 October 1944, PMA 16/2/2 & 16/8/1 (13)
18.
Unknown to Provost of UCL: Letter from unknown source to the Provost of UCL, 23 February 1976, PMA 16/2/2 & 16/8/1 (13)
19.
Webb-Johnson to Hilda Petrie: Letter from Webb-Johnson to Lady Hilda Petrie, 2 Dec 1948, PMA 16/2/2 & 16/8/1 (13)
20.
Secondary sources
21.
AdamsE.2013. Shaping, collecting and displaying medicine and architecture: A comparison of the Hunterian and Soane museums. Journal of the History of Collections25: 59–75.
22.
AlbertiF. B. and AlbertiS. J. M. M.2006. The Hunterian Museum at the Royal College of Surgeons of England, London. Bulletin of the History of Medicine80: 571–573.
23.
AlbrightW. F.1942. Sir W.M. Flinders Petrie, 1853–1942. Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research87: 7–8.
24.
AppenzellerO.2002. An Ancient Eye. Archives of Neurology59: 480–481.
25.
AppenzellerO., StevensJ. M., KruszynskiR., and WalkerS.2001. Neurology in ancient faces. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery & Psychiatry70: 524–529.
26.
AppenzellerO., AmmM., and JonesH.2004. A brief exploration of neurological Art history. Journal of the History of the Neurosciences. 13: 345–350.
27.
BellJ. A.2012. Museums as relational entities: The politics and poetics of heritage. Reviews in Anthropology41: 70–92.
28.
BrooksM. M. and RumseyC.2006. The body in the museum. In: CassmanV., OdegaardN. and PowellJ. (eds.) Human Remains: Guide for Museums and Academic Institutions.Lanham: Altamira Press. Pp. 261–289.
29.
ChallisD.2013. The Archaeology of Race: The Eugenic Ideas of Francis Galton and Flinders Petrie. London: Bloomsbury.
30.
ChaplinS.1998. Appendix A: Report by Simon Chaplin. Senior Curator, Museums of The Royal College of Surgeons of England in The biography of a collection: The Sir Flinders Petrie Palestinian Collection and the role of university museums. Museum Management and Curatorship17: 391–394.
31.
ChaplinS.2009. John Hunter and the ‘museum oeconomy’, 1750–1800. Unpublished PhD thesis, Department of History, King's College London.
32.
Diaz-AndreuM.2007. A World History of Nineteenth-Century Archaeology. Nationalism, Colonialism and the Past. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
33.
DrowerM. S.1995. Flinders Petrie: A Life in Archaeology.Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.
34.
FawcettC. D. with LeeA.1902. A second study of the variation and correlation of the Human Skull with special reference to the Naqada Crania. Biometrika: 408–467.
35.
FfordeC.1992. The Royal College of Surgeons of England: A brief history of its collections and a catalogue of some current holdings. World Archaeological Bulletin6: 22–32.
36.
FilerJ.1997. If the face fits. A comparison of mummies and their accompanying portraits using computerised axial tomography. In: BierbrierM. (ed.) Portraits and Masks: Burial Customs in Roman Egypt.London: British Museum Press. Pp. 121–26.
37.
GreenDavid.1984. Veins of Resemblance: Photography and Eugenics. Oxford Art Journal7/2: 3–16.
38.
KennedyM.1997. She died 2,000 years ago. But Fatima has a smart new face. The Guardian, 26 June 1997, p. 9.
39.
KwintM.2012. Exhibiting the brain. In: KwintM. and WingateR. (eds.) 2012. Brains. The Mind as Matter. London: Wellcome Collection. Pp. 8–21.
40.
KwintM. and WingateR. (eds.) 2012. Brains. The Mind as Matter. London: Wellcome Collection.
41.
MarstineJ.2011. The contingent nature of the new museum ethics. In: MarstineJ. (ed.) The Routledge Companion to Museum Ethics. Redefining for the Twenty-First Century Museum. London: Routledge. Pp. 3–25.
42.
Manchester Guardian 1942. Obituary: Sir W. Flinders Petrie. Manchester Guardian, 30 July 1942, p. 3.
43.
MillerJ.2008. An Appraisal of the Skulls and Dentition of ancient Egyptians, highlighting the Pathology and Speculating on the Influence of Diet and Environment, BAR International Series 1794. Oxford: Archaeopress.
44.
MontserratD.1998. Unidentified human remains: Mummies and the erotics of biography. In: MontserratD. (ed.) Changing Bodies, Changing Meanings: Studies on the Human Body in Antiquity.London: Routledge. Pp. 162–197.
45.
MontserratD.2000. Akhenaten. History, Fantasy and Ancient EgyptLondon: Routledge.
46.
MurrayM. A.1942. William Matthew Flinders Petrie. Religions in the Light of Anthropology, Archaeology, History, Mysticism, Mythology, Philology, and Philosophy41: 21–24.
47.
PearsonE. S.1938. Karl Pearson. An appreciation of some aspects of his life and work. Part II. Biometrika XXIX: 161–200.
48.
PetrieW. M. F.1892. Ten Years Digging in Egypt, 1881–1891.London: Religious Tract Society.
49.
PetrieW. M. F.1894. Tell el Amarna. London: Methuen & Co.
50.
PetrieW. M. F.1896. Naqada and Ballas. London: Bernard Quartch.
51.
PetrieW. M. F.1902. The Use of Diagrams. Man2: 81–85.
52.
PetrieW. M. F.1906. Migrations. The Huxley Lecture of 1906. London: Anthropological Institute of Great Britain and Ireland.
53.
PetrieW. M. F.1932. Seventy Years in Archaeology.New York: Henry Holt & Co.
54.
PetrieW. M. F.2007. Extracts from the Petrie Journals, Selected and collated by Paul C. Roberts and Stephen Quirke. In: PictonJ., QuirkeS. and RobertsP. C. (eds.) Living Images. Egyptian Funerary Portraits in the Petrie Museum. Walnut Creek: Left Coast Press. Pp. 83–104.
55.
PorterT.M.2004. Karl Pearson. The Scientific Life in a Statistical Age.Princeton: Princeton University Press.
56.
RamseyJ. D.2004. Petrie and the intriguing idiosyncrasies of racism. Bulletin of the History of Archaeology14: 15–20.
RobertsP. C.2007. An archaeological context for British discoveries of mummy portraits in the Fayum. In: PictonJ., QuirkeS. and RobertsP.C. (eds.) Living Images. Egyptian Funerary Portraits in the Petrie Museum. Walnut Creek: Left Coast Press.
59.
SheppardK. L.2010. Flinders Petrie and eugenics at UCL. Bulletin of the History of Archaeology20: 16–29.
60.
SheppardK. L.2013. Afterword. In: ChallisD.The Archaeology of Race: The Eugenic Ideas of Francis Galton and Flinders Petrie. London: Bloomsbury. Pp. 223–232.
61.
SilbermanN. A.1999. Petrie's head: Eugenics and Near Eastern Archaeology. In: KehoeA. B. and EmmerichsM. B. (eds.) Assembling the Past: Studies in the Professionalization of Archaeology.Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press. Pp. 69–79.
StevensonA.2012. ‘We seem to be working in the same line’: A. H. L. F. Pitt-Rivers and W. M. F. Petrie. Bulletin of the History of Archaeology22: 4–13.
64.
ThomasN.2010. The museum as method. Museum Anthropology33(1): 6–10.
65.
TurnbullP.2007. British anatomists, phrenologists and the construction of the Aboriginal race, c.1790–1830. History Compass5: 26–50.
66.
UckoP. J.1998. The biography of a collection: The Sir Flinders Petrie Palestinian Collection and the role of university museums. Museum Management and Curatorship17: 351–399.
67.
UckoP. J., SparksR. T. and LaidlawS. (eds.) 2007. A Future for the Past: Petrie's Palestinian Collection.London: Institute of Archaeology.
