This study investigated the impact of two widely used commercial programs designed to increase peer understanding and acceptance of elementary school-aged handicapped students. Second, fourth, and sixth graders from six rural school districts were used in the study. The Better Understanding of Disabled Youth (BUDY) program and the Lets Meet the New Kids on the Block (KOB) program were two treatments employed to determine whether positive gains in attitudes toward the disabled could be systematically attained. Furthermore, the two programs were compared to see if one was more effective in this regard. By employing an adaptation of the Acceptance Scale (Voeltz, 1981) as both a pre-test and post-test measure, changes in student attitudes were documented on a variety of survey items. While a variety of variables were tracked, the most meaningful differences occurred between students in different grade levels. It appeared that second grade children increased their acceptance toward their peers with disabilities more positively as a result of undergoing the KOB interventions, while the older intermediate level children increased their acceptance more positively as a result of completing the BUDY interventions. Implications of findings and recommendations for future research are discussed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Aiello,B. (1980). The Kids on the Block, Incorporated.Washington, D.C.: The Washington Building.
2.
Ballard,M., Gorman,L., Gottlieb,J., & Kaufman,M. (1977). Improving the social status of mainstreamed retarded children. Journal of Educational Psychology,69, 605-611.
3.
Burrello,L. C., Schrup,M. G., & Barnett,B. G. (1991). The Principal as the Special Education Instructional Leader. Unpublished manuscript, Indiana University, Department of Educational Leadership and Policy Studies, Bloomington, IN.
4.
Copper,C. A. (1988). What did you do in school today? A comparative rural and urban case study of students with low incidence capabilities. Rural Special Education Quarterly,9, 13-18.
5.
Cuban,L. (1990). Four stories about national goals for American education. Phi Delta Kappan,72, 264-271.
6.
Dahl,H. G., Horsman,K. R., & Arkell,R. N. (1978). Simulation of exceptionalities for elementary school students. Psychological Reports42, 573-574.
7.
Esposito,B. G., & Peach,W. J. (1983). Changing attitudes of preschool children toward handicapped persons. Exceptional Children,49, 361-363.
8.
Frisbee,K., Engels,J., & Swaim,S. (1982). Experience vs. program instruction in development of student attitudes and knowledge relative to the mainstreaming of the hearing impaired. National Association of Laboratory Schools Journal, Winter, 5-9.
9.
Gilfoyle,E., & Gliner,J. (1985). Attitudes toward handicapped children: Impact of an educational program. Physical and Occupational Therapy in Pediatrics,5, 27-41.
10.
Goodman,H., Gottlieb,J., & Harrison,R. (1972). Social acceptance of EMR's integrated into a nongraded elementary school. American Journal of Mental Deficiency,76, 412-417.
11.
Gottlieb,J. (1980). Improving attitudes toward retarded children by using group discussion. Exceptional Children,47, 105-111.
12.
Gottlieb,J., & Budoff,A. (1973). Social acceptability of retarded children in nongraded schools differing in architecture. American Journal of Mental Deficiency,78, 15-19.
13.
Gottlieb,J., Cohen,L., Goldstein,L. (1974). Social contact and personal adjustments as variables relating to attitudes toward educable mentally retarded children. Training School Bulletin,71, 136-148.
14.
Gronberg,G. (1983). Attitude responses of nonhandicapped elementary students to specific information and contact with the handicapped. Published doctoral dissertation, University of Northern Colorado, CO.
15.
Handlers,A., & Austin,K. (1980). Improving attitudes of high school students toward their handicapped peers. Exceptional Children,47, 228-229.
16.
Hazzard,A. (1981). Enhancing children's attitudes toward disabled peers using a multi-media curriculum. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 141 889).
17.
Helge,D.I. (1983). Increasing preservice curriculum accountability to rural handicapped populations. Teacher Education and Special Education,6, 137-142.
18.
Helge,D. I. (1984). The state of the art in rural special education. Exceptional Children,50, 294, 305.
19.
Higgs,R. (1975). Attitude formation-contact on information?Exceptional Children,4, 132-141.
20.
Howley,C. B. (1992). National and local economic structures: Conflicting views of rural education. Journal of Rural and Small Schools,5, 22-29.
21.
Iano,R., Ayers,D., Heller,H., McGettigan,J., & Walker,V. (1974). Sociometric states of retarded children in an integrated program. Exceptional Children,40, 267-271.
22.
Ibrahim,F., & Herr,E. (1982). Modification of attitudes toward disability, differential effect of two educational modes. Rehabilitation Counseling Bulletin,26, 29-36.
23.
Israelson,J. (1980). I'm special too: A classroom program promotes understanding and acceptance of handicaps. Teaching Exceptional Children,13, 35-37.
24.
Jaffe,J. (1966). Attitudes of adolescents toward mentally retarded. American Journal Mental Deficiency,70, 48-53.
25.
Jones,T. W., Sowell,V. M., Jones,J. K., & Butter,L. G. (1981). Changing children's perceptions of handicapped people. Exceptional Children,47, 365-368.
26.
Keppel,G. (1973). Design and analysis: A researcher's handbook.Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
27.
Kierscht,M.S., & Duttoux,M.A. (1980). Preparing the mainstream: Changing children's attitudes toward the disabled. School Psychology Review,9, 279-283.
28.
Lazar,A. L., Gensley,J. T., & Orpet,R. E. (1971). Changing attitudes of young mentally gifted children toward handicapped persons. Exceptional Children,37, 600-602.
29.
Leyser,Y., & Gottlieb,J. (1980). Improving the social status of rejected pupils. Exceptional Children,46, 459-461.
30.
Lombana,J. (1980). Fostering positive attitudes toward handicapped stuctents: A guidance challenge. The School Counselor,27, 176-182.
31.
Margo,B. (1983). Modifying attitudes toward physically handicapped children. Perceptual and Motor Skills,53, 1002-1008.
32.
McIntosh,D. K. & Raymond,G. I. (1988). Training special education teachers in rural areas: A viable model. Rural Special Education Quarterly,9, 2-5.
33.
Miller,M., Armstrong,S., & Hogan,M. (1981). Effects of teaching on elementary student's attitudes toward handicaps. Education and Training of the Mentally Retarded,16, 22-24.
34.
Panda,K., & Bartel,N. (1972). Teachers' perceptions of exceptional children. Journal of Special Education,6, 49-58.
35.
Rapier,J., Adelson,R., Carey,R., & Croke,K. (1972). Changes in children's attitudes toward the physically handicapped. Exceptional Children,39, 219-223.
36.
Reiff,H. D. & Anderson,P. L. (1989). Training needs of rural special educators in Louisiana. Research in Rural Education,6, 45-50.
37.
Roof,R. C. (1979). Investigating the reliability and validity of a measure of the attitudes of regular education children toward handicapped children. Unpublished Masters Thesis, University of Hawaii, HI.
38.
Rude,H. (1982). An investigation of selected elementary students' attitudes and knowledge about trainable mentally retarded children. Published doctoral dissertation, University of Northern Colorado, CO.
39.
Sasso,G. M. & Rude,H. A. (1987). Unprogrammed effects of training “high status” peers to interact with severely handicapped children. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis,20, 44-54.
40.
Scheffers,W.A. (1977). Sighted children learn about blindness. Journal of Visual Impairment and Blindness, 71, 258-261.
41.
Sheare,J. (1978). The impact of resource programs upon the self-concept and peer acceptance of learning disabled children. Psychology in the Schools,15, 406-412.
42.
Siperstein,G. N., & Bak,J. J. (1980). Improving children's attitudes toward blind peers. Journal of Visual Impairment and Blindness,74, 132-135.
43.
Siperstein,G.N., Bak,J.J., & Gottlieb,J. (1977). Effects of group discussion on children's attitudes toward handicapped peers. Journal of Educational Research,70, 131-134.
44.
Voeltz,L. (1980). Children's attitudes toward handicapped peers. American Journal of Mental Deficiency,84, 455-464.
45.
Voeltz,L. (1981). Acceptance Scale. University of Hawaii, Manoa, HI.
46.
Voeltz,L. (1982). Effects of structured interaction with severely handicapped peers on children's attitudes. American Journal of Mental Deficiency,86, 380-390.
47.
Wechsler,H., Suarez,A., & McFadden,M. (1975). Teachers' attitudes toward the education of physically handicapped children: Implications for implementation of Massachusetts Chapter 766. Journal of Education,157, 134-141.
48.
Weishahn,M. & Baker,C. (1980). BUDY: Better Understanding Disabled Youth. Ideal School Supply Company, Oak Lawn, IL.
49.
Westervelt,V. D., & McKinney,J. D. (1980). Effects of a film on nonhandicapped children's attitude toward handicapped children. Exceptional Children,46, 294-296.
50.
Wilson,E. D., & Alcorn,D. (1969). Disability simulation and development of attitudes toward the exceptional. Journal of Special Education,3, 303-307.
