From Kansas to Oz: Seaside,Florida,and the Small Town in late-twentieth century American collective memory

Abstract

The New Urbanist town of Seaside, Florida, was envisioned by developer Robert Davis and planned by architects Andres Duany and Elisabeth Plater-Zyberk in the early 1980s with the goal of fostering community by simulating the design of historical American towns. By examining periodicals and other news items reporting on Seaside in its early decades, I demonstrate how Seaside's landscape not only mimicked small towns but evoked the collective memory of small-town America in the minds of its beholders. My study of collective memory through Seaside upholds notions of the historical small town as a “nation form” in the American imagination as put forth by scholars like Ryan Poll. I then interrogate the inclusiveness of this nation form, engaging with scholarship denouncing Seaside's call for a simpler time. Finally, by examining how Seaside's visitors harmonize Seaside's playful artificiality with the historic small-town ideal, I point towards the growing role of Hollywood in influencing the representation of the small town in American collective memory.

Keywords

Collective Memory New Urbanism Seaside Florida

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

20 Years After The Truman Show, Locals Share Memories of the Movie (2018) 30A Stories. 5 June. Available at: https://30a.com/truman-show-seaside-florida/ (accessed 6 April 2022)

News Sources.

Abrams

(2021) From SoHo to SoWal: Meet the Seaside residents who relocated from New York City. The Seaside Times. 25 February. Available at: https://seasidefl.com/news/new-york-city-seaside-relocating (accessed 25 March 2022.)

Andersen

(1991) Oldfangled New Towns. TIME. 20 May. Available at: http://content.time.com/time/subscriber/article/0,33009,972988,00.html (accessed 6 April 2022)

Andersen

(1991) Is seaside too good to be true? In: Mohney

Easterling

(eds) Seaside: Making a Town in America. New York: Princeton Architectural Press, 43–37.

Andersen

(2005) Design: Building a Down-Home Utopia. TIME. 18 April. Available at: http://content.time.com/time/subscriber/article/0,33009,1050544,00.html (accessed 6 April 2022)

Anderson

(1989) Their Town Two Designers Intent on Bringing Back Small-Town America are Taking Their Concept on the Road. But will it fly In New England?. The Boston Globe. April 2.

Boehm

Corey

(2014) America's Urban History. London: Taylor & Francis Group.

Brooke

(2005) Seaside. Singapore: Pelican Publishing Company.

10.

Buhasz

(1996) Seaside, Fla. Where tradition sparked a bright, new community. The Globe and the Mail. 6 January. (Online Factiva).

11.

Campbell

(1987) Seaside: A Fresh and Lovely Vision of Beaches Past. The Boston Globe. March 3.

12.

Carlton

(1989) Panhandle Prizes. Atlanta Journal and Constitution. 9 April. (Online Factiva).

13.

Coletti

(1992) Victims of success. Florida Trend. 1 July. (Online Factiva).

14.

Congress for the New Urbanism (2024) ‘The Charter of the New Urbanism’. Available at: https://www.cnu.org/who-we-are/charter-new-urbanism (Accessed March 2025)

15.

Corbett

(1994) THE REDNECK: Old South grace meets kitsch on the Florida Panhandle: Florida: Time travelling along back roads. The Vancouver Sun. December 10. (Online ProQuest).

16.

Crittenden

(1998) Front-porch challenge. The Globe and the Mail. 20 June (Online Factiva).

17.

Cunningham

(2005) A theme park built for one: The new urbanism vs. Disney design in “The Truman Show”. Critical Survey 17(1): 109–130.

18.

Davis (1989) Seaside Times. Spring. p. 2. Available at the Seaside Community Development Corporation.

19.

Davis (1996) Interview with Marietta Lovell, Seagrove Beach, Fla., July 13, 1996 quoted in Jackson, 2003.

20.

Dixon

(2021) Love Letters: Seaside Times readers share their favorite memories. The Seaside Times. 2 June. Available at: https://seasidefl.com/news/love-letters-seaside-times-readers-share-what-they-love (accessed: 6 April 2022)

21.

Dotson

(1990) ‘Profile: Planners reflecting earlier values in new town designs’. The American Family. NBC News 1 October. (Online Factiva).

22.

Duany

(1991) Interview by David Mohney. In: Mohney

Easterling

(eds) Seaside: Making a Town in America. New York: Princeton Architectural Press, 62–73.

23.

Duany

(1998) America the Ugly Searching for a Better Way to Live. Interview by Sawyer F. Nightline, ABC News, 1 August. (Online Factiva).

24.

Duany

Plater-Zyberk

(1991) A town plan for seaside. In: Mohney

Easterling

(eds) Seaside: Making a Town in America. New York: Princeton Architectural Press, 86.

25.

Dunlop

(1989) Coming of Age. Architectural Record 177. July. (Online ProQuest).

26.

Dunlop

(1995) Architecture: Alexander Gorlin. Architectural Digest 52 (12). December. (Online EBSCOhost).

27.

Ellis

(2002) The new urbanism: Critiques and rebuttals. Journal of Urban Design 7(3): 261–291.

28.

Ellis

(2019) Theoretical foundations. In: Talen

(eds) A Research Agenda for New Urbanism. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing, 8–19.

29.

Falconer Al-Hindi

Staddon

(1997) The hidden histories and geographies of neotraditional town planning: The case of seaside, Florida. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 15(3): 349–372.

30.

Grant

(2005) New urbanism(s) ascendant. In: In: Planning the Good Community: New Urbanism in Theory and Practice. Oxford: Taylor & Francis Group, 4–27.

31.

Guenther

(1985) Resort Developer Breaks Rules In Quest to Do Project ‘Right.’ Wall Street Journal. 30 October. (Online Factiva).

32.

Hirt

(2009) Premodern, modern, postmodern? Placing new urbanism into a historical perspective. Journal of Planning History 8(9): 248–273.

33.

History: Urban and Rural Areas (2022) The United States Census Bureau. Available at: https://www.census.gov/about/history/historical-censuses-and-surveys/census-programs-surveys/geography/urban-and-rural-areas.html#:∼:text=Statistics%20have%20been%20split%20into,use%20in%20defining%20urban%20areas (accessed 25 March 2025)

34.

Jackson

(2019) Cultural competency and racial inclusion. In: Talen

(eds) A Research Agenda for New Urbanism. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing, 81–107.

35.

Jackson

III (2003) Developing the panhandle: Seagrove beach, seaside, watercolor, and the Florida tourist tradition. In: Starnes

(eds) Southern Journeys: Tourism, History, and Culture in the Modern South. Tuscaloosa: University of Alabama Press, 66–87.

36.

Kay

(1989) The Return of a Native: The Front Porch. The New York Times. 8 June. (Online Factiva).

37.

Kelbaugh

(2015) The environmental paradox of the city, landscape urbanism, and new urbanism. Consilience: The Journal of Sustainable Development 13(1): 1–15.

38.

Krieger

(2019) The small town as an ideal: Puritan covenants to celebration, Florida. In: City on a Hill: Urban Idealism in America from the Puritans to the Present. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 69–87.

39.

Kunstler

(2018) Splendor at seaside: The Florida town still serves as a model for sustainable development. The American Conservative May/June 2018: 44–47.

40.

LaFrank

(1997) Seaside, Florida: “The New Town – The Old Ways.”. Perspectives in Vernacular Architecture 6: 111–121.

41.

Macy

(1996) The invention of nostalgia for everyday life: A critical analysis of seaside, Florida. Urban Issues: 435–438.

42.

Mohney

(1991) Preface and Acknowledgements. In: Mohney

Easterling

(eds) Seaside: Making a Town in America. New York: Princeton Architectural Press, 36–41.

43.

Mohney

Easterling

(1991) Seaside: Making a Town in America. New York: Princeton Architectural Press.

44.

Montgomery

(2013) Happy City: Transforming Our Lives Through Urban Design. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.

45.

Moore

(1998) New Urban Myths. The London Evening Standard. 24 November. (Online Factiva).

46.

Moore

(2013) What’s wrong with best practice? Questioning the typification of new urbanism. Urban Studies 50(11): 2371–2387.

47.

Ojdana

(2021a) From LA to 30A: Californians swap West Coast for Emerald Coast. The Seaside Times. 16 December. Available at: https://seasidefl.com/news/californians-swap-west-coast-for-emerald-coast.

48.

Ojdana

(2021b) Why My Family Moved from London to Seaside. The Seaside Times. 17 September. Available at: https://seasidefl.com/news/why-my-family-moved-from-london-to-seaside (accessed 25 March 2022.)

49.

Orvell

(2012) The Death and Life of Main Street: Small Towns in American Memory, Space, and Community. Chapel Hill: The University of North Carolina Press.

50.

Patton

(1991) In Seaside, Florida, the forward thing is to look backward. Smithsonian 12(10) January. Available at: (Online Gale Academic OneFile).

51.

Pelzman

(1990) In Seaside, A Florida Town with a Vision. The New York Times. January 7 (Online ProQuest Historical Newspapers).

52.

Plas

Lewis

(1996) Environmental factors and sense of community in a small town. American Journal of Community Psychlogy 24(1): 109–143.

53.

Plater-Zyberk

(1991) Interview with David Mohney. In: Mohney

Easterling

(eds) Seaside: Making a Town in America. New York: Princeton Architectural Press, 74–85.

54.

Poll

(2012) Main Street and Empire: The Fictional Small Town in the Age of Globalization. New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press.

55.

Reed

(1993) A Tale of Two Seasides. Vogue. 1 June. (Online ProQuest)

56.

Rogers

(2012) A New Urbanism Visionary Looks Back. VIE Magazine. Available at: http://viemagazine.com/article/a-new-urbanism-visionary-looks-back/ (accessed 6 April 2022)

57.

Saunders

(2005) The new urbanism and the communitarian trap: On social problems and the false hope of design. In: Sprawl and Suburbia: A Harvard Design Magazine Reader. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 21–26.

58.

Sawyer

McQueen

(1998) America the Ugly Searching for a Better Way to Live. Nightline, ABC News, 1 August. (Online Factiva).

59.

Seaside (2022b) Real Estate. Available at: https://seasidefl.com/properties (accessed 6 April 2022)

60.

Steuteville

(2001) Seaside at Twenty. Public Square. September. 1. Available at: https://www.cnu.org/publicsquare/seaside-twenty (accessed 13 December 2024)

61.

Steuteville

(2009) The New Urbanism: A better way to plan and build 21st Century communities. Public Square. June 10. Available at: https://www.cnu.org/publicsquare/new-urbanism-better-way-plan-and-build-21st-century-communities (accessed 18 November 2024).

62.

Talen

(2019) Why a new urbanist research agenda is needed. In: Talen

(eds) A Research Agenda for New Urbanism. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing, 1–7.

63.

The Seaside Style (2024) ‘Sweatshirts’. Available at: https://theseasidestyle.com/collections/unisex-sweatshirts (Accessed December 2024)

64.

The Seaside Times (2021) Why Addison Rae, Angela Lanter and more influencers flock to Seaside. 11 February. Available at: https://seasidefl.com/news/seaside-florida-influencers (accessed 6 April 2022)

65.

TIME (1990) Design: Best of the Decade. TIME. 1 January. Available at: http://content.time.com/time/subscriber/article/0,33009,969072,00.html (accessed 6 April 2022)

66.

U.S. Cities Factsheet (2024) Center for Sustainable Systems, University of Michigan. Pub. No. CSS09-06. https://css.umich.edu/sites/default/files/2024-10/U.S.%20Cities_CSS09-06.pdf (Accessed March 2025)

67.

Vogel

(1989) Design; Double Standards. New York Times Magazine. 30 April. (Online Gale AcademicOneFile).

68.

Wertsch

Roediger

(2008) Collective memory: Conceptual foundations and theoretical approaches. Memory 16(3): 318–326.

69.

Yenckel

(1991) Seaside Style: Picket-Fence Perfection on Florida's Gulf Coast. The New York Times. April 28. (Online ProQuest Historical Newspapers).