Problematizing K-12 “Best Practices” in the gulf cooperation council region

Abstract

Emerging from the discourse of business in the 1960s, the concept of “best practices” has gained increasing status in education but has rarely been problematized. This essay aims to problematize the use of K-12 best practices in the Gulf Cooperation Council Region (GCC) since nowhere is the importing of best practices more evident than in the GCC region. Using Foucault’s notion of problematization as the theoretical framework, this essay provides an understanding of how best practices have emerged as a solution to educational change, how these practices are legitimized, and how the use of best practices has evolved into challenges for those relying on best practices to bring about educational change. The discussion centres on five central challenges: (1) educational transfer and profit-making, (2) a false universalism, (3) leapfrogging, (4) language and discourse, and (5) the fidelity of implementation. The essay concludes by addressing the issue of using problematizing as a tool for transformative or reconstructive possibilities.

Keywords

best practices problematizing educational borrowing Foucault Gulf Cooperation Council

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abou-El-Kheir

(2017) Qatar’s K-12 education reform—a review of the policy decisions and a look to the future. OSF Preprints. DOI: 10.17605/OSF.IO/9U8CA.

Adair

(1999) Indigenisation of psychology: the concept and its practical implementation. Applied Psychology: An International Review 48(4): 403–418.

Aydarova

(2017) Discursive Contestations and Pluriversal Futures: A Decolonial Analysis of Educational Policies in the United Arab Emirates. Education Policy Analysis Archives. DOI: 10.14507/epaa.25.3063.

Akkary

(2014) Facing the challenges of educational reform in the Arab world. Journal of Educational Change 15(2): 179–202.

Altbach

Knight

(2007) The internationalization of higher education: motivations and realities. Journal of Studies in International Education 11(3/4): 290–305.

Al-Tikriti

(2010) Negligent mnemocide and the shattering of Iraqi collective memory. In: Baker

Ismael

(eds), Cultural Cleansing in Iraq (93-115). Pluto.

Bacchi

(2016) Problematizations in health policy: questioning how “problems” are constituted in policies. Sage Open 6(2). DOI: 10.1177/2158244016653986.

Batra

(2018) Imperatives of comparative and international education: some reflections from the South. In: Wiseman

(ed), Annual Review of Comparative and International Education 2017 International Perspectives on Education and Society. Emerald Publishing Limited, pp. 75–83. DOI: 10.1108/S1479-367920180000034008.

Bennett

(1997) Understanding ripple effects: the cross-national adoption of policy instruments for bureaucratic accountability. Governance 10(3): 213–233.

10.

Bennett

(2015) Towards an epistemological monoculture: mechanisms of epistemicide in European research publication. In: Plo

Pérez-Llantada

(eds), English as an Academic and Research Language: Debates and Discourses. De Gruyter Mouton, pp. 9–36.

11.

Bernstein

Van der Ven

(2017) Best practices in global governance. Review of International Studies 43(3): 534–556. DOI: 10.1017/S0260210516000425.

12.

Bauer

Kenton

(2005) Toward technology integration in the schools: why it isn’t happening. Journal of technology and teacher education 13(4): 519–546.

13.

Borch

(2016) Foucault, Crime and Power: Problematisations of Crime in the Twentieth Century. Routledge.

14.

BrewerAugustine

DJCH

Zellman

Ryan

, et al. (2007) Education for a New Era: Design and Implementation of K-12 Education Reform in Qatar. RAND-Qatar Policy Institute.

15.

Cameron

(2001) Globalization and the teaching of communication skills. In: Block

Cameron

(eds), Globalization and Language Teaching. Routledge, pp. 67–72.

16.

Chandler

(2007) Semiotics: The Basics. 2nd edition. Routledge.

17.

Chee Mok

(2006) Shedding light on the East Asian learner paradox: reconstructing student-centredness in a Shanghai classroom. Asia Pacific Journal of Education 26(2): 131–142. DOI: 10.1080/02188790600932087.

18.

Cho

(1998) Rethinking Curriculum Implementation: Paradigms, Models, and Teachers' Work. San Diego, CA: Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, pp. 13–17.

19.

Crespy

Vanheuverzwijn

(2019) What “Brussels” means by structural reforms: empty signifier or constructive ambiguity? Comparative European Politics 17(1): 92–111.

20.

Dimmock

Walker

(2000) Developing comparative and international and management: a cross-cultural model. School Leadership and Management 20(2): 143–160.

21.

Dolowitz

Marsh

(2000) Learning from abroad: the role of policy transfer in contemporary policy making. Governance 13(1): 5–24.

22.

Dusenbury

Brannigan

Falco

, et al. (2003) A review of research on fidelity of implementation: implications for drug abuse prevention in school settings. Health Education Research 18(2): 37–256.

23.

Ellili-Cherif

Romanowski

Nasser

(2011) All that glitters is not gold: challenges of teacher and school leader licensing system in a GCC country. International Journal of Educational Development 32(3): 471–481.

24.

Fang

Gopinathan

(2009) Teachers and teaching in eastern and western schools: a critical review of cross-cultural comparative studies. In: Saha

Dworkin

(eds), International Handbook of Research on Teachers and Teaching. Springer, pp. 557–572.

25.

Foucault

(1994) Polemics, politics, and problematizations. In: Rabinow

(ed), Ethics, Subjectivity and Truth. The New Press, pp. 111–119.

26.

Foucault

Burchell

(2008) The birth of biopolitics: Lectures at the Collège de France, 1978–1979. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

27.

Foucault

Lawrence

(1988) Politics, philosophy, culture: interviews and other writings, 1977-1984. MLN 104(4): 255–567. DOI: 10.2307/2905276.

28.

Gee

(2004) Discourse analysis: what makes it critical? In: Rogers

(ed), An Introduction to Critical Discourse Analysis in Education. Lawrence Erlbaum, pp. 19–50.

29.

Gray

O’Regan

Wallace

(2018) Education and the discourse of global neoliberalism. Language and Intercultural Communication 18(5): 471–477. DOI: 10.1080/14708477.2018.1501842.

30.

Greening

(2017) Teachers – the Experts Driving Social Mobility (Speech). https://www.gov.uk/government/speeches/justine-greening-teachers-theexperts-driving-social-mobility.

31.

Gronemeyer

(1992) Helping. In: Sachs

(ed), The Development Dictionary: A Guide to Knowledge as Power. Zed Books, pp. 55–73.

32.

Hall

Loucks

(1978) Innovation Configurations: Analyzing the Adaptations of Innovations. Austin: University of Texas, Research and Development Center for Teacher Education.

33.

Hannon

(2008) Should educational leadership focus on 'best practice' or 'next practice. Journal of Educational Change 9: 77–81.

34.

Hartog

House

Hanges

, et al. (1999) amp; other Globe Country InvestigatorsCulture specific and cross-culturally generalizable implicit leadership theories: are attributes of charismatic/transformational leadership universally endorsed? The Leadership Quarterly 10(2): 219–238.

35.

Hastings

(2019) Neoliberalism and education. In: Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Education. Oxford University Press. DOI: 10.1093/acrefore/9780190264093.013.404.

36.

Hofstede

(1993) Cultural constraints in management theories. Academy of Management Executive 7(1): 81–94.

37.

Holden

(2009) Exporting public–private partnerships in healthcare: export strategy and policy transfer. Policy Studies 30(3): 313–332.

38.

Hollway

(2001) The psycho-social subject in “evidence-based practice. Journal of Social Work Practice 15(1): 9–22. DOI: 10.1080/02650530120041975.

39.

House

Hanges

Ruiz-Quintanilla

, et al. (1999) Cultural influences on leadership and organization: project GLOBE. In: W Mobley Gessner

Arnold

(eds), Advances in Global Leadership. Greenwich: JAI Press, pp. 171–233.

40.

ICEF Monitor (2015) Australian Education Exports Reach AUS$18 Billion in 2014/15. IICF Monitor. https://monitor.icef.com/2015/08/australian-education-exports-reach-aus18-billion-in-201415/

41.

Istance

Paniagua

(2019) Learning to Leapfrog: Innovative Pedagogies to Transform Education. Center for Universal Education at The Brookings Institution.

42.

Jarrar

Zairi

(2000) Best practice transfer for future competitiveness: a study of best practices. Total Quality Management 11(4–6): 734–740. DOI: 10.1080/09544120050008147.

43.

Kandel

(1961) Comparative education and underdeveloped countries: a new dimension. Comparative Education Review 4(3): 130–135.

44.

Kirk

(2013) Comparative education and the arabian gulf. In: Wiseman

Anderson

(eds), Annual Review of Comparative and International Education. Emerald Group Publishing, pp. 175–189.

45.

Laclau

Mouffe

(1985) Hegemony and Socialist Strategy. Verso.

46.

Lampert

(2010) Learning teaching in, from, and for practice: what do we mean? Journal of Teacher Education 61(1–2): 21–34.

47.

Lopdrup-Hjorth

(2013) Let's Go outside. The Value of Co-creation. Copenhagen Business School.

48.

Majone

(1989) Evidence, Argument and Persuasion in the Policy Process. Yale University Press.

49.

Maschler

Schiffrin

(2015) Discourse markers: language, meaning, and context. In: Tannen

Hamilton

Schiffrinc

(eds), The Handbook of Discourse Analysis, pp. 189–221.

50.

Maslen

(2012) Education as an Export Is Worth Billions. University World News. https://www.universityworldnews.com/post.php?story=20121128163603470

51.

McFarlane

(2019) Coloring outside the Lines: Deconstructing Talent Best Practices to Find what Really Works. https://www.trishmcfarlane.com/2019/07/08/coloring-outside-the-lines-deconstructing-talent-best-practices-to-find-what-really-works/

52.

McKenna

(2006) The World's Newest Profession: Management Consulting in the Twentieth Century. Cambridge University Press.

53.

Merino

(2014) Foucault for dummies. Arts and Opinion 13(3). http://www.artsandopinion.com/2014_v13_n3/merino-1.htm

54.

Mohamed

Morris

(2019) Buying, selling and outsourcing educational reform: the global education industry and 'policy borrowing' in the gulf. Compare: A Journal of Comparative and International Education 51(2): 181–201.

55.

Morgan

(2018) The spectacle of global tests in the Arabian Gulf: a comparison of Qatar and the United Arab Emirates. Comparative Education 54(3): 285–308. DOI: 10.1080/03050068.2017.1348018.

56.

Neumann

Meadows

(2011) Problematizing notions of decontextualized “best practice. Curriculum and Teaching Dialogue 13(1/2): 93–107.

57.

Noah

Eckstein

(1969) Towards a Science of Comparative Education. Macmillan.

58.

Ochs

Phillips

(2004) Processes of educational borrowing in historical context. In: Phillips

Ochs

(eds), Educational Policy Borrowing: Historical Perspectives. Oxford: Symposium Books.

59.

O'Donnell

(2008) Defining, conceptualizing, and measuring fidelity of implementation and its relationship to outcomes in k–12 curriculum intervention research. Review of Educational Research 78(1): 33–84.

60.

O'Malley

(2019) Education Exports Worth Almost £20 Billion to the UK. University World News. https://www.universityworldnews.com/post.php?story=20190131121139224

61.

Orchard

Winch

(2015) What training do teachers need? Why theory is necessary to good teaching. Impact 22: 1–43.

62.

Perry

Tor

(2008) Understanding educational transfer: theoretical perspectives and conceptual frameworks. Prospects 38(4): 509–526.

63.

Phillips

Ochs

(2004) Researching policy borrowing: some methodological challenges in comparative education. British Educational Research Journal 30(6): 773–777.

64.

Pickup

(2017) Problematization as activism: disrupting the neoliberal education project through the work of thought. Philosophical Studies in Education 48: 85–95.

65.

Portnoi

(2016) Policy Borrowing and Reform in Education. Palgrave Macmillan. DOI: 10.1057/978-1-137-53024-0_6.

66.

Powell

JJW

(2014) University roots and branches between ‘glocalization' and ‘mondialisation': Qatar's (inter)national universities. In: Wiseman

Alromi

Alshumrani

(eds), Education for a Knowledge Society in Arabian Gulf Countries. Emerald Group, pp. 253–276.

67.

Raffe

(2011) Policy Borrowing or Policy Learning? How (Not) to Improve Education Systems. CES Briefing, Vol 57.

68.

Romanowski

(2013) The Qatar national professional standards for school leaders: a critical discourse analysis using Habermas’ theory of knowledge constitutive interests. International Journal of Leadership in Education 17(2): 174–199.

69.

Romanowski

Alkhateeb

Nasser

(2018) Policy borrowing in the gulf cooperation Council countries: cultural scripts and epistemological conflicts. International Journal of Educational Development 60: 19–24.

70.

Romanowski

(2020) Education transferring and decentralized reforms: Qatar’s decentralized and recentralized education system. Prospects DOI: 10.1007/s11125-020-09478-x.

71.

Rose

(1991) Comparing forms of comparative analysis. Political Studies 39: 6–462.

72.

Ruby

(2020) The mobility of education policy in the 21st century: lessons from other fields. FIRE: Forum for International Research in Education 6(3): 83–93. DOI: 10.32865/fire202063187.

73.

Sellami

Sawalhi

Romanowski

, et al. (2019) Definitions of educational leadership – arab educators’ perspectives. International Journal of Leadership in Education. DOI: 10.1080/13603124.2019.1690701.

74.

Silova

(2012) Contested meanings of educational borrowing. In: Steiner-Khamsi

Waldow

(eds), World Yearbook of Education 2012: Policy Borrowing and Lending in Education. Routledge, pp. 229–245.

75.

Spring

(2015) Economization of Education: Human Capital, Global Corporations, Skills-Based Schooling. Routledge.

76.

Steiner-Khamsi

(2004) The Global Politics of Educational Borrowing and Lending. Teachers College Press.

77.

Steiner-Khamsi

(2013) What is wrong with the ‘what-went-right’ approach in educational policy? European Educational Research Journal 12(1): 20–33. DOI: 10.2304/eerj.2013.12.1.20.

78.

Stevenson

Stigler

(1992) The Learning Gap: Why Our Schools Are Failing and what We Can Learn from Japanese and Chinese Education.

79.

SwanNewell

Robertson

(2000) The diffusion, design and social shaping of production management information systems. . Europe. Information Technology and People 13(1): 27–45.

80.

TakayamaSriprakash

Connell

(2016) Toward a postcolonial comparative and international education. Comparative Education Review 61: 1–24.

81.

Thompson

(2021) Educating from a socioculturally situated perspective: minds in society. In: D Thompson

Coffey

(eds), Promoting Educational Success through Culturally Situated Instruction (Pp1-18). Rowman & Littlefield.

82.

Tooley

(2001) The Global Education Industry: Lessons from Private Education in Developing Countries. Affairs Institute of EconomicIEA.

83.

Torfing

(1999) New Theories of Discourse: Laclau, Mouffe and Zizek. Oxford: Blackwell.

84.

Verger

Steiner-Khamsi

Lubienski

(2017) The emerging global education industry: analysing market-making in education through market sociology. Globalisation, Societies and Education 15(3): 325–340. DOI: 10.1080/14767724.2017.1330141.

85.

Volante

Klinger

(2022) PISA, global reference societies, and policy borrowing: the promises and pitfalls of ‘academic resilience. Policy Futures in Education. DOI: 10.1177/14782103211069002.

86.

Webb

(2014) Policy problematization. International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education 27(3): 364–376. DOI: 10.1080/09518398.2012.762480.

87.

Winthrop

McGivney

(2017) Can We Leapfrog? the Potential of Education Innovations to Rapidly Accelerate Progress. Skills for a Changing World. Center for Universal Education at the Brookings Institution.

88.

Wiseman

Pilton

Courtney Lowe

(2010) International educational governance models and national policy convergence. In: Karin Amos

(ed), International Perspectives on Education and Society. Emerald Group Publishing Limited, pp. 3–18. DOI: 10.1108/S1479-3679(2010)0000012004.

89.

Yang

(2008) Overview of Best Practices in Taiji. Champaign, IL: Center for Taiji Studies. https://qigonginstitute.org/upload/tinymce-editor/docs/Best_Taiji_Practices_Aug_08.pdf

90.

Yazdi

(2013) Review of centralization and decentralization approaches to curriculum development in Iran. International Journal of Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences 3(4): 97–115.

91.

You

(2020) The ‘new Orientalism’: education policy borrowing and representations of East Asia. Compare: A Journal of Comparative and International Education 50(5): 1–22.