The purpose of this review is to summarize the most relevant recent literature on patient safety practices focused on fatigue and sleepiness of clinicians related to hours of service.
Methods
We conducted a rapid response review, which required strategic adjustments to expedite the review process. These adjustments included being as specific as possible about the questions, limiting the number of databases searched, modifying search strategies to focus on finding the most valuable studies, and restricting the search to studies published recently (i.e. since 2013) that are in English. We used an artificial intelligence (AI) feature of DistillerSR (AI Classifier Manager) as a second reviewer at the title and abstract screening stage.
Results
Interventions have focused primarily on work schedules, including limiting the number of hours worked in a shift or total over a week, and ensuring adequate time for recovery between shifts. Few studies have addressed fatigue risk management interventions beyond scheduling, but interventions have included lighting, breaks, and scheduled napping. Evidence for the impact of these interventions on patient outcomes is mixed.
Conclusions
The inconsistent findings from this body of research make it difficult to determine the most appropriate evidence-based policies for mitigating the risk of patient harm from clinician fatigue and sleepiness due to long work hours. More research is needed to determine how to mitigate the risks of patient harm from clinician fatigue and sleepiness due to long work hours.
GoelN. Neurobehavioral effects and biomarkers of sleep loss in healthy adults. Curr Neurol Neurosci Rep2017; 17: 89.
2.
PhilibertI. Sleep loss and performance in residents and nonphysicians: a meta-analytic examination. Sleep2005; 28: 1392–1402.
3.
TrockelMTMenonNKRoweSG, et al.Assessment of physician sleep and wellness, burnout, and clinically significant medical errors. JAMA Netw Open2020; 3: e2028111.
4.
KhubchandaniJPriceJH. Short sleep duration in working American adults, 2010-2018. J Community Health2020; 45: 219–227.
5.
CaldwellJACaldwellJLThompsonLA,et al.Fatigue and its management in the workplace. Neurosci Biobehav Rev2019; 96: 272–289.
6.
LermanSEEskinEFlowerDJ, et al.Fatigue risk management in the workplace. J Occup Environ Med2012; 54: 231–258.
7.
GurubhagavatulaIBargerLKBarnesCM, et al.Guiding principles for determining work shift duration and addressing the effects of work shift duration on performance, safety, and health: guidance from the American academy of sleep medicine and the sleep research society. J Clin Sleep Med2021; 17: 2283–2306.
8.
SprajcerMThomasMJWSargentC, et al.How effective are fatigue risk management systems (FRMS)? A review. Accid Anal Prev2022; 165: 106398.
9.
RosenMKilcullenMPZhangA, et al.Fatigue and Sleepiness of Clinicians Due to Hours of Service. Rapid Response. (Prepared by the Johns Hopkins University Evidence-based Practice Center under Contract No. 75Q80120D00003). AHRQ Publication No. 23(24)-EHC019-14. Rockville, MD: Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, 2024. DOI: https://doi.org/10.23970/AHRQEPC_MHS4FATIGUE.
10.
Di MuzioMDionisiSDi SimoneE, et al.Can nurses’ shift work jeopardize the patient safety? A systematic review. Eur Rev Med Pharmacol Sci2019; 23: 4507–4519.
11.
ParkerRSParkerP. The impact of sleep deprivation in military surgical teams: a systematic review. J R Army Med Corps2017; 163: 158–163.
12.
Smith-MillerCAShaw-KokotJCurroB,et al.An integrative review: fatigue among nurses in acute care settings. J Nurs Adm2014; 44: 487–494.
13.
StecNArjeDMoodyAR, et al.A systematic review of fatigue in radiology: is it a problem?AJR Am J Roentgenol2018; 210: 799–806.
14.
LeroyerERomieuVMediouniZ, et al.Extended-duration hospital shifts, medical errors and patient mortality. Br J Hosp Med (Lond)2014; 75: 96–101.
GatesMWingertAFeatherstoneR, et al.Impact of fatigue and insufficient sleep on physician and patient outcomes: a systematic review. BMJ Open2018; 8: e021967.
17.
BolsterLRourkeL. The effect of restricting residents’ duty hours on patient safety, resident well-being, and resident education. An Updated Systematic Review. J Grad Med Educ2015; 7: 349–363.
18.
BaeSH. Relationships between comprehensive characteristics of nurse work schedules and adverse patient outcomes: a systematic literature review. J Clin Nurs2021; 30: 2202–2221.
19.
SephienAReljicTJordanJ, et al.Resident duty hours and resident and patient outcomes: systematic review and meta-analysis. Med Educ2023; 57: 221–232.
20.
WeaverMDSullivanJPLandriganCP,et al.Systematic review of the impact of physician work schedules on patient safety with meta-analyses of mortality risk. Jt Comm J Qual Patient Saf2023; 49: 634–647.
21.
HarrisJDStaheliGLeClereL, et al.What effects have resident work-hour changes had on education, quality of life, and safety? A systematic review. Clin Orthop Relat Res2015; 473: 1600–1608.
22.
WeaverALStutzmanSESupnetC,et al.Sleep quality, but not quantity, is associated with self-perceived minor error rates among emergency department nurses. Int Emerg Nurs2016; 25: 48–52.
23.
IversonAStanberryLGarberichR, et al.Impact of sleep deprivation on the outcomes of percutaneous coronary intervention. Catheter Cardiovasc Interv2018; 92: 1118–1125.
24.
AbdallaRNAnsariSAHurleyMC, et al.Correlation of call burden and sleep deprivation with physician burnout, driving crashes, and medical errors among US neurointerventionalists. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol2022; 43: 1286–1291.
25.
QuanSFLandriganCPBargerLK, et al.Impact of sleep deficiency on surgical performance: a prospective assessment. J Clin Sleep Med2023; 19: 673–683.
26.
KalmbachDAArnedtJTSongPX, et al.Sleep disturbance and short sleep as risk factors for depression and perceived medical errors in first-year residents. Sleep2017; 40: zsw073.
27.
BaeSH. Presence of nurse mandatory overtime regulations and nurse and patient outcomes. Nurs Econ2013; 31: 59–68. 89; quiz 69.
28.
DensonJLMcCartyMFangY, et al.Increased mortality rates during resident handoff (Hales, 2015) periods and the effect of ACGME duty hour regulations. Am J Med2015; 128: 994–1000.
29.
WestleyJAPetersonJFortD, et al.Impact of nurse's worked hours on medication administration near-miss error alerts. Chronobiol Int2020; 37: 1373–1376.
30.
OuyangDChenJHKrishnanG, et al.Patient outcomes when housestaff exceed 80 hours per week. Am J Med2016; 129: 993–9.e1.
31.
BargerLKWeaverMDSullivanJP, et al.Impact of work schedules of senior resident physicians on patient and resident physician safety: nationwide, prospective cohort study. BMJ Med2023; 2: e000320.
32.
SalgadoSMKatzJTPelletierSR, et al.Impact of extended duty hours on perceptions of care and objective patient outcomes. J Patient Safety2022; 18: e938–e946.
33.
DesaiSVFeldmanLBrownL, et al.Effect of the 2011 vs 2003 duty hour regulation-compliant models on sleep duration, trainee education, and continuity of patient care among internal medicine house staff: a randomized trial. JAMA Intern Med2013; 173: 649–655.
34.
WenTAttenelloFJCenSY, et al.Impact of the 2003 ACGME resident duty hour reform on hospital-acquired conditions: a national retrospective analysis. J Grad Med Educ2017; 9: 215–221.
35.
RajaramRChungJWJonesAT, et al.Association of the 2011 ACGME resident duty hour reform with general surgery patient outcomes and with resident examination performance. Jama2014; 312: 2374–2384.
36.
WeaverMDLandriganCPSullivanJP, et al.National improvements in resident physician-reported patient safety after limiting first-year resident physicians’ extended duration work shifts: a pooled analysis of prospective cohort studies. BMJ Qual Saf2023; 32: 81–89.
37.
LandriganCPRahmanSASullivanJP, et al.Effect on patient safety of a resident physician schedule without 24-hour shifts. N Engl J Med2020; 382: 2514–2523.
38.
RahmanSASullivanJPBargerLK, et al.Extended work shifts and neurobehavioral performance in resident-physicians. Pediatrics2021; 147: e2020009936.
39.
MirmehdiIO'NealCMMoonD, et al.The interventional arm of the flexibility in duty-hour requirements for surgical trainees trial: first-year data show superior quality in-training initiative outcomes. J Surg Educ2016; 73: e131–e1e5.
40.
BilimoriaKYChungJWHedgesLV, et al.National cluster-randomized trial of duty-hour flexibility in surgical training. N Engl J Med2016; 374: 713–727.
41.
SilberJHBelliniLMSheaJA, et al.Patient safety outcomes under flexible and standard resident duty-hour rules. N Engl J Med2019; 380: 905–914.
42.
ShekellePGWachterRMPronovostPJ, et al.Making health care safer II: an updated critical analysis of the evidence for patient safety practices. Evid Rep Technol Assess (Full Rep)2013: 1–945.
43.
Fleming 2ndMAEtchillEWMarshKM, et al.A dual-institutional study on first-year practice outcomes of pediatric surgeons who trained in the era of work hour restrictions. Pediatr Surg Int2022; 38: 277–283.
44.
KelzRRNiknamBASellersMM, et al.Duty hour reform and the outcomes of patients treated by new surgeons. Ann Surg2020; 271: 599–605.
45.
JenaABFaridMBlumenthalD,et al.Association of residency work hour reform with long term quality and costs of care of US physicians: observational study. Br Med J2019; 366: l4134.
46.
JenaABSchoemakerLBhattacharyaJ. Exposing physicians to reduced residency work hours did not adversely affect patient outcomes after residency. Health Aff (Millwood)2014; 33: 1832–1840.
47.
FishbeinDNambiarSMcKenzieK, et al.Objective measures of workload in healthcare: a narrative review. Int J Health Care Qual Assur2020; 33: 1–7.
48.
HalesSLesher-TrevinoAFordN, et al.Reporting guidelines for implementation and operational research. Bull W H O2015; 94: 58.
49.
SmithJDLiDHRaffertyMR. The implementation research logic model: a method for planning, executing, reporting, and synthesizing implementation projects. Implement Sci2020; 15: 1–2.
