The train derailment in East Palestine, Ohio resulted in extensive air and water pollution to communities near and far. Many news reports detailed the burning of vinyl chloride that posed serious threats to air quality and health risks to nearby residents. At the same time, East Palestine and surrounding communities suffer the limited economic opportunities that have accompanied deindustrialization and globalization. As a consequence, one might consider this a case of environmental injustice. To analyze the train derailment, we employ critical environmental justice studies, which broadens and deepens traditional approaches to analyzing disparate environmental outcomes and experiences. We set out to make a few key contributions to the literature: to call attention to the non-monolithic nature of whiteness and in so doing call for an increased concentration on solidarity and movement building across communities harmed by environmental injustices, to highlight intersectionality in intraspecies and interspecies terms, to recast the train derailment as a case of state-sanctioned violence that must be viewed in the context of environmental injustices across the region's history, and to illuminate East Palestine's community-centric, collaborative spaces of care.
AlexanderM (2010) The New Jim Crow. New York: The New Press.
2.
AllisonM (2023) Executive session and rail safety hearing. U.S. Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation April 22.
3.
AlvarezCHShtobDATheisNG (2024) Analyzing the military’s role in producing air toxics disparities in the United States: A critical environmental justice approach. Social Problems71(3): 636–661.
4.
AndrewsE (2024) 1 year after the toxic train derailment, is East Palestine safe? Depends on whom you ask. Grist.
5.
AnnevelinkMPJAMeestersJAJHendriksAJ (2016) Environmental contamination due to shale gas development. Science of The Total Environment550: 431–438.
6.
WeissH (2023) ‘It’s worrisome to not have data.’ an expert questions whether air is safe after train derailment. TIME.
7.
BellSEYorkR (2010) Community economic identity: The coal industry and ideology construction in West Virginia. Rural Sociology75(1): 111–143.
8.
BogardusKBorstE (2023) EPA promised clarity, transparency after Ohio train derailment. but some air monitors didn’t work. E&E News.
9.
BoudetHBugdenDZanoccoC, et al. (2016) The effect of industry activities on public support for ‘fracking. Environmental Politics25(4): 593–612.
10.
BrunoR (1999) Steelworker Alley: How Class Works in Youngstown. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
11.
BullardRD (1990) Dumping in Dixie. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
12.
CamaT (2021) Ohio senate hopefuls look to out-trump each other on climate. E&E News.
13.
CareyT (2022) Northeast Ohio politicians react to President Biden’s State of the Union address. Wkyc.Com, 1 March. https://www.wkyc.com/article/news/politics/northeast-ohio-politicians-react-president-biden-state-of-the-union-address/95-79dee535-1a55-4c8d-9f5f-e626aae2f92c
14.
CarolanM (2020) The rural problem: Justice in the countryside. Rural Sociology85(1): 22–56.
15.
CatteE (2018) What You Are Getting Wrong About Appalachia. Cleveland, OH: Belt Publishing.
16.
CheckerM (2005) Polluted Promises: Environmental racism and the search for justice in a southern town. New York: NYU Press.
17.
ClelandD (2023) Connect to congress: Progress continues but struggles remain in East Palestine months post-train derailment. WTOV 9, December 8.
18.
CoelhoPB, Fitzgerald G, Isaacson K, et al. (2024) Environmental and private property contamination following the Norfolk southern chemical spill and chemical fires in Ohio. Environmental Science: Water Research & Technology10(11): 3007–3023.
19.
CohenL (2023) East Palestine train derailment: Officials share information about dead fish and contamination in waterways amid reports of sick pets. CBS News. Retrieved August 23, 2024.
20.
ColeLWFosterSR (2001) From the Ground Up. New York: NYU Press.
21.
CollardR-CDempseyJ (2017a) Capitalist natures in five orientations. Capitalism Nature Socialism28(1): 78–97.
22.
CollardR-CDempseyJ (2017b) Politics of devaluation. Dialogues in Human Geography7(3): 314–318.
23.
CollerPRodriguezJ (2023) Money trail from Norfolk Southern leads to area politicians. Fox 8 Cleveland WJW, 27 March. https://fox8.com/news/money-trail-from-norfolk-southern-leads-to-area-politicians/
24.
Committee on Energy and Commerce. (2023) Chairs Rodgers and Johnson announce hearing on EPA’s PM2.5 proposal. House Committee on Energy and Commerce.
25.
CramerKJ (2016) The Politics of Resentment. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
26.
CrenshawK (1991) Mapping the margins: Intersectionality, identity politics, and violence against women of color. Stanford Law Review43(6): 1241–1299.
27.
Cunningham-CookM (2023) After Norfolk southern support, Dewine says no disaster in East Palestine. The Lever, February 23.
28.
De La GarzaARebeccaK (2024) East Palestine, one year after train derailment. TIME.
29.
DomhoffGW (2021) Who Rules America?: The Corporate Rich, White Nationalist Republicans, and Inclusionary Democrats in the 2020s. New York, NY: Routledge.
30.
DowneyL (1998) Environmental injustice: Is race or income a better predictor?Social Science Quarterly79(4): 766–778.
31.
DucreKA (2012) A Place We Call Home. Syracuse. NY: Syracuse University Press.
32.
ElverdS (2024) Consortium Analyzes Data, Encourages Public Participation in EP Derailment Studies. Salemnews.net.
33.
EstesN (2019) Our History is the Future. London: Verso.
34.
FisherMP, Mayer A, Vollet K, et al. (2018) Psychosocial implications of unconventional natural gas development: Quality of life in Ohio’s guernsey and noble counties. Journal of Environmental Psychology55: 90–98.
35.
FlesherJ (2023) Aches, rashes and fear: trauma remains after Ohio derailment. AP News, March 11.
36.
FoxJ (1999) Mountaintop removal in West Virginia. Organization & Environment12(2): 163–183.
37.
FrazierR (2024) Scientist questions EPA’s handling of East Palestine cleanup: “They should have tested correctly. The Allegheny Front, 26 January. https://www.alleghenyfront.org/east-palestine-epa-cleanup-criticism-science/
38.
FunkJ (2024) Judge approves $600 million settlement for residents near fiery Ohio derailment. AP News, September 25.
39.
GaventaJ (1982) Power and Powerlessness: Quiescence and Rebellion in an Appalachian Valley. Urbana. IL: University of Illinois Press.
40.
GayDABlaydesKSchauerJJ, et al. (2024) Widespread impacts to precipitation of the East Palestine Ohio train accident. Environmental Research Letters19: 074022.
41.
Gilio-WhitakerD (2019) As Long as Grass Grows. Boston, MA: Beacon Press.
42.
GoldbergDT (2002) The Racial State. Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishing.
43.
GrahamC (2022) “U.S. Rep. Bill Johnson stresses need for U.S. energy independence in Cadiz visit. Theintelligencer.Net.
44.
GrantJ (2023) Questions about the testing and cleanup of streams after the train derailment. The Allegheny Front.
45.
GrantJ (2024) Judge approves $600 million settlement for Ohio derailment but not everyone is satisfied. The Allegheny Front, September 27.
46.
GreenbergP (2017) Disproportionality and resource-based environmental inequality: An analysis of neighborhood proximity to coal impoundments in Appalachia. Rural Sociology82(1): 149–178.
47.
GreenbergP (2018) Coal waste, socioeconomic change, and environmental inequality in Appalachia: Implications for a just transition in coal country. Society & Natural Resources31(9): 995–1011.
48.
GrimleyN (2023) North Lima woman finds chickens dead tuesday, questions chemical release from train. WKBN, February 7.
49.
GrovesER (1965) Local folks were a little indignant over federal hearing on Mahoning River pollution. Farm and Dairy, 24 February.
50.
GuernseyPJKeelerKJuliusJ‘ (2021) How the Lummi nation revealed the limits of Species and habitats as conservation values in the endangered Species act: Healing as indigenous conservation. Ethics, Policy & Environment24(3): 266–282.
51.
HarrisonJL (2019) From the Inside Out: The Fight for Environmental Justice Within Government Agencies. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
52.
HarrisonJL (2023) Environmental justice and the state. Environment and Planning E: Nature and Space6(4): 2740–2760.
53.
HartiganJ (2003) Who are these White people?: ‘Redneck,’ ‘Hillbillies,’ and ‘White Trash’ as Marked Racial Subject. Pp. 95-112 in White Out, edited by A.W. Doan and E. Bonilla-Silva. Routledge.
54.
HaynesE (2024) R21-UKY East Palestine train derailment health tracking study. National Institute of Health.
55.
HenryMS (2019) Extractive fictions and postextraction futurisms. Environmental Humanities11(2): 402–426.
56.
Hill CollinsP (2019) Intersectionality as Critical Social Theory. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
57.
HolsoppleK (2024) A Pennsylvania resident impacted by the Norfolk Southern derailment pushes for answers. The Allegheny Front.
58.
HooksGSmithCL (2004) The treadmill of destruction: National sacrifice areas and native Americans. American Sociological Review69(4): 558–575.
59.
HuangK-MEtienneX (2021) Impact of Marcellus and Utica shale exploitation on Ohio, Pennsylvania, and West Virginia regional economies: A synthetic control analysis. Papers in Regional Science100(6): 1449–1480.
60.
IpsenALequieuAM (2025) From rationalized exploitation to supra sacrifice zones: Tracing sacrifice zones as a keyword of environmental sociology. Environmental Sociology11(3): 351–362.
61.
IsenbergN (2017) White Trash. London: Penguin Books.
62.
JacksonDZ (2023) Why does white East Palestine, Ohio get apologies, but none for Black Cancer Alley? The Root, March 23.
63.
JacquetJB, Junod AN, Bugden D, et al. (2018) A decade of Marcellus shale: Impacts to people, policy, and culture from 2008 to 2018 in the greater Mid-Atlantic region of the United States. The Extractive Industries and Society5(4): 596–609.
64.
JerolmackC (2021) Up to Heaven and Down to Hell: Fracking, Freedom, and Community in an American Town. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
KuletzV (1998) The Tainted Desert. New York: Routledge.
67.
KurtzHE (2009) Acknowledging the racial state: An agenda for environmental justice research. Antipode41(4): 684–704.
68.
LaddAE (ed.) (2018) Fractured Communities: Risk, Impacts, and Protest Against Hydraulic Fracking in U.S. Shale Regions. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
69.
LandrieuMRyanT (2024) “Biden’s LNG Decision Will Make It Harder to Reach Our Climate Goals.” The Hill, February 8.
70.
LernerS (2010) Sacrifice Zones. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
71.
LewinPG (2019) “Coal is not just a job, it’s a way of life”: The cultural politics of coal production in central Appalachia. Social Problems66(1): 51–68.
72.
LievanosR (2015) Race, deprivation, and immigrant isolation: The spatial demography of air-toxic clusters in the continental United States. Social Science Research54: 50–67.
73.
LievanosRGreenbergPWishartR (2018) In the shadow of production: Coal waste accumulation and environmental inequality formation in eastern Kentucky. Social Science Research71: 37–55.
74.
LinkonSLRussoJ (2002) Steeltown U.S.A: Work and Memory in Youngstown. Lawrence, KS: University Press of Kansas.
75.
LobaoL (1996) A sociology of the periphery versus a peripheral sociology: Rural sociology and the dimension of space. Rural Sociology61(1): 77–102.
MaxourisCReillyL (2023) “Ohio’s Governor Wants Norfolk Southern to Pay for Toxic Derailment’s Long-Term Impacts, Including Lowered Home Values and Potential Health Issues.” CNN.
78.
McCallL (2005) The complexity of intersectionality. Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society30(3): 1771–1800.
79.
McKaneRG, Satcher LA, Houston SL et al. (2018) Race, class, and space: An intersectional approach to environmental justice in New York city. Environmental Sociology4(1): 79–92.
80.
McKaneRGGreinerPTPellowD. (2024) Mutual aid as a praxis for critical environmental justice: Lessons from WEB DuBois, critical theoretical perspectives, and mobilising collective care in disasters. Antipode56(2): 581–602.
81.
MellonS (2023) As Six-Month Anniversary of Derailment Nears, East Palestine Residents Press Officials, Fight Burnout. Pittsburgh, PA: Pittsburgh Union Progress.
82.
MichaelsD (2023) East Palestine residents should be skeptical of cleanup efforts. TIME.
83.
MohaiPSahaR (2006) Reassessing racial and socioeconomic disparities in environmental justice research. Demography43: 383–399.
84.
MonnatSMBrownDL (2017) More than a rural revolt: Landscapes of despair and the 2016 presidential election. Journal of Rural Studies55: 227–236.
85.
MorrowD (2023) Why elites Don’t give a damn about Ohio. Newsweek. Retrieved August 21, 2024.
86.
NarcisseDA (2017) Beyond treading water: Bringing water justice to America’s urban poor. Race, Gender & Class24(1–2): 27–64.
87.
NewitzAWrayM (1997) White Trash: Race and Class in America. New York, NY: Routledge.
88.
O'BrienD (2021) Utica shale pumped up promises to valley landowners. Business Journal Daily.
89.
Office of Public Affairs. (2024) United States reaches over $310 Million settlement with Norfolk southern to address harms caused by East Palestine train derailment. United States Department of Justice Retrieved October 6, 2024.
90.
Ohio Department of Natural Resources. (2023) Update on east Palestine train derailment impact to wildlife. ODNR Emergency Management Agency. Retrieved August 23, 2024.
PartridgeMWeinsteinA (2012) Ohio shale coalition report appears to have overestimated Ohio shale job creation by about 400%. Ohio State University.
93.
PellowDN (2000) Environmental inequality formation: Toward a theory of environmental injustice. American Behavioral Scientist43(4): 581–601.
94.
PellowDN (2016) Environmental justice and rural studies: A critical conversation and invitation to collaboration. Journal of Rural Studies47: 381–386.
95.
PellowDN (2018) What is Critical Environmental Justice?New York: Polity.
96.
PellowDNBrulleRJ (2005) Power, Justice, and the Environment. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
97.
PerkinsTE (2022) Evolution of a Movement: Four Decades of California Environmental Justice Activism. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
98.
PulidoL (2017) Geographies of race and ethnicity II. Progress in Human Geography41(4): 524–533.
99.
PulidoLKohlECottonN-M (2016) State regulation and environmental justice: The need for strategy reassessment. Capitalism Nature Socialism27(2): 12–31.
100.
RiceJLLongJLevendaA (2022) Against climate apartheid: Confronting the persistent legacies of expendability for climate justice. Environment and Planning E: Nature and Space5(2): 625–645.
101.
RimK-T (2017) Reproductive toxic chemicals at work and efforts to protect workers' health: A literature review. Safety and Health at Work8(2): 143–150.
RoyAAAdamsPJRobinsonAL (2014) Air pollutant emissions from the development, production, and processing of Marcellus shale natural gas. Journal of the Air & Waste Management Association64(1): 19–37.
104.
RubinkamM (2023) Shesll agrees to pay $10 million for air pollution at massive new Pennsylvania petrochemical plant. AP News.
105.
RuckartPZBoveFJMasliaM (2013) Evaluation of exposure to contaminated drinking water and specific birth defects and childhood cancers at Marine Corps Base Camp Lejeune, North Carolina: A case-control study. Environmental Health: A Global Access Science Source12: 104.
106.
RulliM (2023) Lawmakers: I Pray ‘our Families Haven’t Been Poisoned ‘Black Plume of Burning Chemicals.’ The Columbus Dispatch, March 24.
107.
RulliMJoyceD (2024) East Palestine on our minds. Tribune Chronicle, September 4.
108.
SchlosbergDRickardsLPearseR, et al. (2025) Critical environmental justice in contemporary scholarship and movements: consensus and plurality of the discourse. Environmental Politics34(3): 399–420.
109.
SchultzRSkoumalRJBrudzinskiMR, et al. (2020) Hydraulic fracturing-induced seismicity. Reviews of Geophysics58(3): e2019RG000695.
SirotaDRockJBurnsR, et al. (2023) “Rail Companies Blocked Safety Rules Before Ohio Derailment.” The Lever.
112.
StankorbS (2023) “East Palestine Isn’t Suffering From One Disaster, But Many.” The New Republic, May 1.
113.
SunW (2023) The devastating health consequences of the Ohio derailment: A closer Look at the effects of vinyl chloride spill. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health20(6): 5032.
VanceJD (2023a) Senator Vance’s written testimony on the disaster in East Palestine.
118.
VanceJD (2023b) Now the time to expand utica shale usage. Marietta Times, Augsust 26.
119.
VanceJDRyanT (2022) Vance/Ryan debate. Cleveland, Ohio: Fox 8 News Cleveland.
120.
WebberT (2023) East palestine residents live in limbo months after fiery train derailment. PBS News. Retrieved September 18, 2024.
121.
WestraSGoldbergMSLabrècheF, et al. (2023) The association between the incidence of postmenopausal breast cancer and occupational exposure to selected organic solvents, Montreal, Canada, 2008–2011. American Journal of Industrial Medicine66(11): 911–927.
122.
WhittenburgA (2021) A dozen images made in or near Youngstown, Ohio, that show why people need both jobs and fish. Journal of Working-Class Studies6(2): 115–137.
123.
WrayM (2006) Not Quite White. 2006. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
124.
ZuckermanJ (2024) Did a Gas Lobbyist write an Ohio Senator’s speech about a pipeline resolution? Cleveland.com, April 26.
