The ‘brother layer problem’: Routine killing,biotechnology and the pursuit of ‘ethical sustainability’ in industrial poultry

Abstract

The global poultry industry culls approximately seven billion day-old male layer chicks annually. Superfluous to both egg and meat, male ‘brother’ layers constitute a momentous problem, simultaneously economical and ethical, to the poultry industry. In this article, we scrutinize present and proposed alternatives to routine killing involving multiple biotechnological innovations, including novel methods for fetus sexing, genome editing technologies and re-sexing. We utilize a political ecological perspective that views attempts to solve the ‘brother layer problem’ as discursive and techno-scientific ‘fixes’ to problems of the capitalist poultry industry's own making and to rising demands for ethics and environmental-friendly animal agriculture. This context opens new avenues for profit-making by and for an expanding matrix of actors we view as an evolving ‘economy of repair’ that is built in part by public resources. Further, these fixes constitute an ostensible ‘ethical sustainability’ meant to signal both animal welfare and environmental improvements, which seem to work towards stabilizing agro-industry, thereby foreclosing alternatives to agro-industrial intensification.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

AAT (2021) Italy introduces the ban of chick killing as third European country. Agri Advanced Technologie (AAT). Available at: https://www.agri-at.com/en/press/19-press-releases-in-ovo/200-italy-introduces-the-ban-of-chick-killing (accessed 16 January 2022).

Animal Equality (2021) Stop the massacre of male chicks. Available at: https://animalequality.org/action/ban-chick-culling (accessed 3 January 2022).

Arcari

Probyn-Rapsey

Singer

(2020) Where species don’t meet: Invisibilized animals, urban nature and city limits. Environment and Planning E: Nature and Space 4(3): 940–965.

Bakker

(2010) The limits of ‘neoliberal natures’: Debating green neoliberalism. Progress in Human Geography 34(6): 715–735.

Besky

Blanchette

(2019) How Nature Works: Rethinking Labor on a Troubled Planet. Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press.

Bjørkdahl

Syse

KVL

(2021) Welfare washing: Disseminating disinformation in meat marketing. Society & Animals 2021: 1–19.

Boyd W (2001) Making meat: Science, technology, and American Poultry Production. Technology and Culture 42(4): 631–664.

Boyd

Prudham

Schurman

(2001) Industrial dynamics and the problem of nature. Society & Natural Resources 14(7): 555–570.

Brockotter

(2020) Novel techniques make culling male layers obsolete. Poultry World. Available at: https://www.poultryworld.net/Eggs/Articles/2020/4/Novel-techniques-make-culling-male-layers-obsolete-575007E/ (accessed 18 December 2021).

10.

Bruijnis

Blok

Stassen

, et al. (2015) Moral “lock-in” in responsible innovation: The ethical and social aspects of killing day-old chicks and its alternatives. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 28(5): 939–960.

11.

Brundtland

(1987) Our common future—call for action. Environmental Conservation 14(4): 291–294.

12.

Busse

Kernecker

Zscheischler

, et al. (2019) Ethical concerns in poultry production: A German consumer survey about dual purpose chickens. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 32(5): 905–925.

13.

Carton

Jönsson

Bustos

(2017) Revisiting the “Subsumption of Nature”: Resource Use in Times of Environmental Change. Society & Natural Resources 30(7): 789–796.

14.

Chakraboty

(2018) An economic trauma: Capitalism says food waste is OK Street Roots. Available at: https://www.streetroots.org/news/2018/06/01/economic-trauma-capitalism-says-food-waste-ok (accessed 5 January 2022).

15.

Clapp

Ruder

S-L

(2020) Precision technologies for agriculture: Digital farming, gene-edited crops, and the politics of sustainability. Global Environmental Politics 20(3): 49–69.

16.

Cooper

(2017) Open up and say “baa”: Examining the stomachs of ruminant livestock and the real subsumption of nature. Society & Natural Resources 30(7): 812–828.

17.

Corbyn

(2021) Is it possible to change a chicken’s sex before it hatches?. The Guardian . Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/food/2021/jan/31/good-vibrations-sound-waves-eggs-ethical-slaughter-male-chicks (accessed 21 December 2021).

18.

Cremer

(2021) How CRISPR can create more ethical eggs. Alliance for Science. Available at: https://allianceforscience.cornell.edu/blog/2021/03/how-crispr-can-create-more-ethical-eggs/ (accessed 18 December 2021).

19.

Dahm

Pistorius

(2021) Germany, France call on EU countries to also ban culling of male chicks Euractiv.com. Available at: https://www.euractiv.com/section/agriculture-food/news/germany-france-call-on-eu-countries-to-also-ban-culling-of-male-chicks/ (accessed 3 January 2022).

20.

Danovich

(2021) Why the US egg industry is still killing 300 million chicks a year. Vox. Available at: https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/22374193/eggs-chickens-animal-welfare-culling (accessed 21 December 2021).

21.

de Haas

Oliemans

van Gerwen

(2021) The need for an alternative to culling day-old male layer chicks: A survey on awareness, alternatives, and the willingness to pay for alternatives in a selected population of Dutch citizens. Frontiers in Veterinary Science 8: 662197.

22.

Doughman

(2021) Gene edited mice could be key to ending male chick culls. WattPoultry.com. Available at: https://www.wattagnet.com/blogs/51-poultry-tech-trends/post/44179-gene-edited-mice-could-be-key-to-ending-male-chick-culls (accessed 21 December 2021).

23.

Douglas

Maciulyte

Zohren

, et al. (2021) CRISPR-Cas9 effectors facilitate generation of single-sex litters and sex-specific phenotypes. Nature Communications 12(1): 1–10.

24.

DW (2021) Germany bans male chick culling from 2022. Deutsche Welle (DW). Available at: https://p.dw.com/p/3thD2 (accessed 3 January 2022).

25.

EC (2021) Questions and Answers: Commission’s response to the European Citizens’ Initiative on “End the Cage Age”. European Commission (EC). Available at: https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/qanda_21_3298 (accessed 21 December 2021).

26.

EggXYt (2019) eggXYt at The Alltech Ideas Conference. Available at: https://vimeo.com/309308441 (accessed 17 January 2022).

27.

Eggxyt (2021) Count your chickens before they hatch. Available at: https://www.eggxyt.com/ (accessed 18 February 2022).

28.

Ekers

Prudham

(2017) The metabolism of socioecological fixes: Capital switching, spatial fixes, and the production of nature. Annals of the American Association of Geographers 107(6): 1370–1388.

29.

Emel

Neo

(2015) Political Ecologies of Meat. London: Routledge.

30.

Fairhead

Leach

Scoones

(2012) Green grabbing: A new appropriation of nature? Journal of Peasant Studies 39(2): 237–261.

31.

FAO (2021) Meat Market Review: Emerging trends and outlook, December 2021. Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) Rome.

32.

Ferreira

(2017) Critical sustainability studies: A holistic and visionary conception of socio-ecological conscientization. Journal of Sustainability Education 13: 1–22.

33.

FFAR (2021) Egg-Tech Prize. USA: Foundation for Food and Agricultural Research (FFAR). Available at: https://foundationfar.org/programs/egg-tech-prize/ (accessed 8 January 2022).

34.

FindLight (2019) In Ovo Spectroscopy for Chicken Egg Sex Determination. Blog of lasers, optics, optomechanics, light detection systems, and other photonics. FindLight.net. Available at: https://www.findlight.net/blog/2019/11/26/in-ovo-spectroscopy-for-chicken-egg-sex-determination/ (accessed 3 January 2022).

35.

Frewer

Kleter

Brennan

, et al. (2013) Genetically modified animals from life-science, socio-economic and ethical perspectives: Examining issues in an EU policy context. New Biotechnology 30(5): 447–460.

36.

Gander

(2015) Shortage of chick sexers in the UK, despite £40,000 salary. The Independent . Available at: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/shortage-of-chick-sexers-in-the-uk-despite-ps40-000-salary-10086063.html (accessed 21 December 2021).

37.

Gautron

Réhault-Godbert

Van de Braak

, et al. (2021) What are the challenges facing the table egg industry in the next decades and what can be done to address them? Animal 15(1): 100282.

38.

Ghosh

(2021) Gene edited sex selection may spare animal suffering. BBC . Available at: https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-59505112 (accessed 6 January 2022).

39.

Giersberg

Kemper

(2018) Rearing male layer chickens: A German perspective. Agriculture 8(11): 176.

40.

Gjerris

(2015) Willed blindness: A discussion of our moral shortcomings in relation to animals. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 28(3): 517–532.

41.

Gómez-Baggethun

Naredo

(2015) In search of lost time: The rise and fall of limits to growth in international sustainability policy. Sustainability Science 10(3): 385–395.

42.

Gorvett

(2021) The genetic mistakes that could shape our species. BBC . Available at: https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20210412-the-genetic-mistakes-that-could-shape-our-species (accessed 8 January 2022).

43.

Gremmen

Bruijnis

Blok

, et al. (2018) A public survey on handling male chicks in the Dutch egg sector. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 31(1): 93–107.

44.

Grow

(2020) 2020 Grow-NY $1,000,000 Winner: Soos Technology. grow-ny.com. Available at: https://www.grow-ny.com/2020-winners/ (accessed 21 December 2021).

45.

Guthman

(2019) Wilted: Pathogens, Chemicals, and the Fragile Future of the Strawberry Industry. Oakland: University of California Press.

46.

Harris

(2019) Finding the value in processing spent laying hens. The Poultry Site . Available at: https://www.thepoultrysite.com/articles/finding-the-value-in-processing-spent-laying-hens (accessed 11 February 2022).

47.

Hein

(2018) Egg sexing close to market. Poultry World . Available at: https://www.poultryworld.net/Eggs/Articles/2018/6/Egg-sexing-close-to-market-301797E/ (accessed 10 January 2022).

48.

Holloway

(2007) Subjecting cows to robots: Farming technologies and the making of animal subjects. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 25(6): 1041–1060.

49.

Huff

(2021) Frictitious commodities: Virtuality, virtue and value in the carbon economy of repair. Environment and Planning E: Nature and Space 0(0): 1–26.

50.

Johnson

(2021) Is there a genetic solution for preventing male chicks?. WattPoultry.com. Available at: https://www.wattagnet.com/articles/43894-is-there-a-genetic-solution-for-preventing-male-chicks (accessed 21 December 2021).

51.

Kaleta

Redmann

(2008) Approaches to determine the sex prior to and after incubation of chicken eggs and of day-old chicks. World’s Poultry Science Journal 64(3): 391–399.

52.

Kirksey E and Chao S (2022) Who Benefits from Multispecies Justice? In: The Promise of Multispecies Justice. Oakland: Duke University Press.

53.

Klein

Grossmann

(2008) Primary sex ratio in fertilized chicken eggs (gallus gallus domesticus) depends on reproductive age and selection. Journal of Experimental Zoology Part A: Ecological Genetics and Physiology 309(1): 35–46.

54.

Kloppenburg

(2005) First the Seed: The Political Economy of Plant Biotechnology. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.

55.

Krautwald-Junghanns

Cramer

Fischer

, et al. (2018) Current approaches to avoid the culling of day-old male chicks in the layer industry, with special reference to spectroscopic methods. Poultry Science 97(3): 749–757.

56.

le Blond

(2018) World’s first no-kill eggs go on sale in Berlin. The Guardian . Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2018/dec/22/worlds-first-no-kill-eggs-go-on-sale-in-berlin (accessed 3 January 2022).

57.

Leary

(2019) Keywords: The New Language of Capitalism. London: Haymarket Books.

58.

Makov

Shepon

Krones

, et al. (2020) Social and environmental analysis of food waste abatement via the peer-to-peer sharing economy. Nature Communications 11(1): 1–8.

59.

Mann

Dickinson

(1978) Obstacles to the development of a capitalist agriculture. The Journal of Peasant Studies 5(4): 466–481.

60.

McKenna

(2016) By 2020, Male Chicks May Avoid Death By Grinder. National Geographic . Available at: https://www.nationalgeographic.com/culture/article/by-2020--male-chicks-could-avoid-death-by-grinder (accessed 3 January 2022).

61.

Merchant

(1980) The death of nature: Women, ecology, and the scientific revolution.

62.

Morgen

(2021) How Companies Are Turning Trash Into Products (And Profits). Forbes.com.

63.

Mottet

Tempio

(2017) Global poultry production: Current state and future outlook and challenges. World’s Poultry Science Journal 73(2): 245–256.

64.

Neo

Emel

(2017) Geographies of Meat: Politics, Economy and Culture. Abingdon: Routledge.

65.

NR Soos Technologies (2022) Playing God or helping nature? Medium.com. Available at: https://medium.com/@sdannyvi_17115?p=cc7307f74873 (accessed 18 December 2021).

66.

Ouma

Premchander

(2022) Labour, Efficiency, Critique: writing the plantation into the technological present-future. Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space 54(2): 413–421.

67.

Patel

(2012) Stuffed and Starved: The Hidden Battle for the World Food System – Revised and Updated. London: Melville House.

68.

Patel

Moore

(2017) A History of the World in Seven Cheap Things. Oakland: University of California Press.

69.

PETA (2019) Egg-Laying Hens: Mothers, Not Machines. People for the Ethical treatment of Animals (PETA) Australia. Available at: https://www.peta.org.au/issues/egg-laying-hens-mothers-not-machines/ (accessed 15 March 2022).

70.

Physics World (2016) Laser spectroscopy determines sex of a chicken egg. Available at: https://physicsworld.com/a/laser-spectroscopy-determines-sex-of-a-chicken-egg/ (accessed 3 January 2022).

71.

Plantegg (2020) In-Ovo Gender determination. Available at: https://www.plantegg.de/en (accessed 6 January 2022).

72.

Reid

(2019) Germany hopes new technology will stop the slaughter of male chicks. CNBC.com. Available at: https://www.cnbc.com/2019/05/30/chick-culling-germany-makes-tech-to-stop-slaughter-of-male-chicks.html (accessed 3 January 2022).

73.

Reisman

(2021) Sanitizing agri-food tech: COVID-19 and the politics of expectation. The Journal of Peasant Studies 48(5): 910–933.

74.

Respeggt (2021) Let’s end chick culling together. respeggt-group.com. Available at: https://www.respeggt-group.com/ (accessed 3 January 2022).

75.

Robbins

(2019) Political ecology: A critical introduction. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons.

76.

Rose

Cachelin

(2018) Critical sustainability: Incorporating critical theories into contested sustainabilities. Journal of Environmental Studies and Sciences 8(4): 518–525.

77.

Rosenbruch

(1997) [The sensitivity of chicken embryos in incubated eggs][article in German]. ALTEX-Alternatives to Animal Experimentation 14(3): 111–113.

78.

Ruiz

(2019) Cyborg chickens or hens in the future. WattPoultry.com. Available at: https://www.wattagnet.com/blogs/25-latin-america-poultry-at-a-glance/post/36842-cyborg-chickens-or-hens-in-the-future (accessed 11 February 2022).

79.

Seleggt (2018) Frequently asked questions about the SELEGGT process. Seleggt.com. Available at: https://www.seleggt.com/ (accessed 3 January 2022).

80.

Seleggt (2019) Every year, around 300 million male chicks of the egg-laying breeds are killed in the EU alone because they do not lay eggs and it is uneconomical to fatten them. SELEGGT GmbH. Available at: https://www.seleggt.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/11/SELEGGT_u_respeggt_FAQs_E.pdf (accessed 3 January 2022).

81.

Sexton

Garnett

Lorimer

(2019) Framing the future of food: The contested promises of alternative proteins. Environment and Planning E: Nature and Space 2(1): 47–72.

82.

Smith

Sinclair

(2004) Sex determination: Insights from the chicken. Bioessays 26(2): 120–132.

83.

Striffler

(2005) Chicken: The Dangerous Transformation of America’s Favorite Food. New Haven: Yale University Press.

84.

The Humane League (2021) The truth about chick culling: one of the egg industry’s hidden secrets. Available at: https://thehumaneleague.org/article/chick-culling (accessed 3 January 2022).

85.

Thompson

(2021) French technology detects egg embryo sex to save killing male chicks. Connexionfrance.com. Available at: https://www.connexionfrance.com/French-news/French-technology-detects-egg-embryo-sex-to-save-killing-male-chicks (accessed 18 January 2022).

86.

van de Braak

(2021) The brother males. Hendrix Genetics. Available at: https://layinghens.hendrix-genetics.com/en/news/Growing-the-brother-males-instead-of-culling-them-as-day_old_chicks/ (accessed 3 January 2022).

87.

van de Braak

(2022) What are the challenges facing the table egg industry in the next decades and what can be done to address them? Hendrix Genetics. Available at: https://www.hendrix-isa.com/en/news/what-are-challenges-facing-table-egg-industry-next-decades-and-what-can-be-done-address-them/ (accessed 17 January 2022).

88.

Wadiwel

(2016) Chicken harvesting machine: Animal labor, resistance, and the time of production. The South Atlantic Quarterly 117:(3): 527–549.

89.

Wallace

(2016) Big Farms Make Big Flu: Dispatches on Influenza, Agribusiness, and the Nature of Science. New York: Monthly Review Press.

90.

Watson

(2021) eggXYt strategy: Israeli startup launches bid to disrupt the egg industry. Foodnavigator-usa.com. Available at: https://www.foodnavigator-usa.com/Article/2021/01/08/eggXYt-strategy-Israeli-startup-launches-bid-to-disrupt-the-egg-industry (accessed 18 January 2022).

91.

Watts

(2004) Are hogs like chickens? Enclosure and mechanization in two ‘white meat’filieres. Geographies of Commodity Chains. London: Routledge, 51–74.

92.

Weis

(2010) The accelerating biophysical contradictions of industrial capitalist agriculture. Journal of Agrarian Change 10(3): 315–341.

93.

Weis

(2013) The Ecological Hoofprint: The Global Burden of Industrial Livestock. London: Bloomsbury Publishing.

94.

Winders

Ransom

(2019) Global Meat: Social and Environmental Consequences of the Expanding Meat Industry. Cambridge: MIT Press.

95.

Yildiz

(2021) Global Poultry Industry and Trends. FeedandAdditive.com. Available at: https://www.feedandadditive.com/global-poultry-industry-and-trends/ (accessed 17 December 2021).