Abstract
Category:
Sports; Midfoot/Forefoot; Trauma
Introduction/Purpose:
Acute medial collateral ligament (MCL) tears of the great toe metatarsophalangeal joint (MTPJ) are a rare occurrence. There is minimal literature existing regarding both operative and non-operative management of this pathology, also known as 'traumatic bunion' due to its low incidence. The closest analog is a traumatic ulnar collateral ligament (UCL) rupture in the hand (Skier's thumb). Suture anchor repair with an internal brace has proven to be an effective treatment for thumb UCL tears with rapid rehabilitation and early range of motion. This method has not yet been reported in literature for a weightbearing joint such as the hallux MTPJ. We present a case report for a professional surfer with traumatic great toe MCL avulsion with surgical technique allowing rapid return to sport.
Methods:
We present a case report of a novel technique for this rare traumatic MCL avulsion. Surgical management of the great toe MCL was performed utilizing a pre-loaded interference screw to fixate suture at the MCL origin with suture tape augmentation. A mid-axial medial approach was used with L-shaped capsular flap to expose the MCL. 3-0 braided suture was passed through the proximal avulsed MCL. A drill tunnel was prepared at the MCL origin, and the MCL was repaired to its anatomic origin with an interference screw technique for knotless technique. The interference screw was preloaded with suture tape. The suture tape from the interference screw was passed extra articular and the capsule was repaired. The sutuer tape was then inserted into the MCL insertion on the distal phalanx using a small interference screw and drill tunnel for a suture tape augmentation while the toe was held in neutral MTPJ position.
Results:
He was made weightbearing as tolerated in a CAM boot post-operatively. Immediate active great toe MTPJ motion was permitted. At 2 weeks post-op, sutures were removed, and he was allowed self-directed passive range of motion of the toe, with continued weightbearing as tolerated in the boot. All restrictions were lifted at 4 weeks for a return to play protocol and the patient resumed surfing immediately at that time. His last follow up appointment was at 3 months post-op, at which time he had resumed full activity, had no deformity recurrence, no pain, and his range of motion was symmetric to the contralateral foot. The patient was able to compete at full activity in a national tournament to continue the professional tour at 3 months post- operatively.
Conclusion:
This report demonstrates a novel surgical technique for the treatment of a rare traumatic MCL avulsion of the great toe (the 'traumatic bunion'). In this case of great toe MCL repair in a professional surfer, we utilized a knotless technique to repair the MCL to it's anatomic origin and also provide suture tape augmentation to allow rapid rehabilitation. This report demonstrates rapid return to sport, an excellent outcome, easy rehabilitation, and straightforward surgical technique. More research will be needed to demonstrate the success of this technique in a broader population.
