Subaltern? Illustrated: A Study of Ambedkar Cartoons

Abstract

Just like any other narrative form, cartoons too, by virtue of their storytelling ability, have problematized Dalit life history and delineated the trauma, tragedy and unflinching representational terms. Charting sociopolitical topics, cartoons are an example of popular culture influencing public opinion. With caricature, prose, topical content and a dash of humour, cartoons form a special category of news and a critical form of political journalism. When Elizabeth Edwards discusses the raw history and potential of photographs, she emphasizes their visual sovereignty, which is not only vital for the production of photography but also for the interpretation of images, and through them, the insertion of the human voice. Similarly, cartoons succeed in combining their visual sovereignty with their ethnographic potential because of their interpretive ingenuousness. As such, cartoons articulate lines of instability indiscernible under the garb of mythical solidarity of a myriad of political ideologies. Cartoonists construct publics and counter publics by problematizing the impact of sociopolitics on human beings through the construction of interpretative communities bound by visual perceptions. In other words, cartoons, particularly political cartoons, represent highly complex modern attempts to formulate visual identities under specific historical and political conditions that resonate with the readership. The present research article seeks to problematize Dalit representation in cartoons by non-Dalit illustrators against the work of a Dalit cartoonist to critically study the politics of representation, the discourse of powers and the dialectics of caste. The article seeks to study if and how Dalit agency is, respectively, illustrated or elided, how symbols and caricatures demonstrate the truth of Dalit life and the aesthetics of the Dalit experience. For the purpose of the study, the article especially focusses on the figure of Ambedkar, the iconic Dalit voice and the benevolent patriarch of Dalit ideology, and studies his representation in a series of political cartoons published between 1932 and 1956.

Keywords

Cartoons representation humour Ambedkar Unnamati Syama Sundar

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Agarwal

(2016). The rise of Dalit studies and its impact on the study of India: An interview with historian Ramnarayan Rawat. Perspectives on History. https://www.Historians.Org/,2016,www.historians.org/publications-and-directories/perspectives-on-history/summer-2016/the-rise-of-dalit-studies-and-its-impact-on-the-study-of-india-an-interview-with-historian-ramnarayan-rawat.

Berger

(2008). Ways of seeing. Penguin Books.

Bharati

S. R.

(2002). ‘Dalit’: A term asserting unity. Economic & Political Weekly, 37(42), 4339–4340.

Dangle

(1992). Poisoned bread: Translations from modern Marathi Dalit literature. Orient Longman.

Deleuze

, & Guattari

(1983). Anti-oedipus: Capitalism and schizophrenia. Penguin Classics.

Flanagan

(2002). The seduction of history: Trauma, re-memory, and the ethics of the real. Clio, 31(4), 387–402.

Forter

(2007). Freud, Faulkner, Caruth: Trauma and the politics of literary form. Narrative, 15(3), 259–285.

Giri

(2020). Perspectives on Indian Dalit literature: Critical responses. Booksclinic Publishing.

Gogulamanda

‘She Was Told’. Scroll.in, https://scroll.in/article/808905/how-40-poets-under-40-are-writing-india-of-the-1980s-and-1990s

10.

Kamra

(2003). The war of images: Mohammed Ali Jinnah and editorial cartoons in The Indian Nationalist Press, 1947. In ARIEL: A Review of International English Literature, 34(2–3).

11.

Khanduri

R. G.

(2014). Caricaturing culture in India: Cartoons and history in the modern world. Cambridge University Press.

12.

Massey

(1997). Downtrodden: The struggle of India’s Dalits for identity, solidarity and liberation. WCC Publications.

13.

Mokkil

(2019, 2 August). ‘No Laughing Matter’: Seriously damning lines. https://www.thehindubusinessline.com/blink/read/review-of-unnamati-syama-sundars-no-laughing-matter/article28794799.ece

14.

Navasky

V. S.

(2014). The art of controversy: Political cartoons and their enduring power. Knopf.

15.

Novetzke

(1993). TWICE DALIT: The poetry of Hira Bansode. Journal of South Asian Literature, 28(1/2), 279–95. http://www.jstor.org/stable/40873345. Accessed 6 June 2022.

16.

Patta

B R. R.

(2015). My Favourite Theologian: Arvind P. Nirmal. Movement Magazine. https://www.movement.org.uk/blog/my-favourite-theologian-arvind-p-nirmal. Accessed 13 April 2022.

17.

Pillai

(1933, 17 February). The towel, tar-brush and hammer. Hindustan Times. https://www.roundtableindia.co.in/the-cartoon-controversy-inside-the-mind-of-one-fanatic-dalit-ii/

18.

Pillai

(1936, 8 January). Medicine men in readiness. Hindustan Times (Image courtesy: Unnamati Syama Sundar (2019). No Laughing Matter: The Ambedkar Cartoons 1932–1956, p. 76).

19.

Pillai

(1942, 6 July). Temple entry is given to Harijans. Hindustan Times. https://huntthehaunted.com/ambedkar-in-cartoons-during-1930s-to-1950s/. Accessed on April 13, 2022.

20.

Pillai

K. S.

(1951). Open to Engagement. Shankar’s Weekly (Image courtesy: Unnamati Syama Sundar (2019). No Laughing Matter: The Ambedkar Cartoons 1932–1956, p. 323).

21.

Rao

(2009). Introduction (1st ed.). The caste question: Dalits and the politics of modern India (pp. 1–36). University of California Press. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.1525/j.ctt1pp88k.8

22.

Reddy

(2019, 3 October). Meet Syama Sundar, cartoonist whose work revolves around anti-caste themes. https://www.thenewsminute.com/article/meet-syama-sundar-cartoonist-whose-work-revolves-around-anti-caste-themes-109930

23.

Sundar

U. S.

(2019). No laughing matter: The Ambedkar cartoons, 1932–1956. Navayana Publishing.

24.

The Hindustan Times. (2022). Dalits denied temple entry in Andhra Pradesh’s Anatapur. https://www.hindustantimes.com/cities/others/dalits-denied-temple-entry-in-andhra-pradesh-s-anatapur-101642706192621.html

25.

Vasu. (1946, 19 June). By-passed. Pioneer (Unnamati Syama Sundar (2019). No Laughing Matter: The Ambedkar Cartoons 1932–1956, p. 138).

26.

Visser

(1997). Decolonizing trauma theory: Retrospect and prospects. Humanities, 4(2), 250–265. 10.3390/h4020250.