Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

Using a case study approach, we examine displaceability in the geographical landscape of the Occupied Palestinian Territories (OPT). We examine incidents in four Palestinian localities in the Susiya region. Similar to other regions in the OPT, the Palestinians in Susiya are affected by legal and geographical processes, both formal (such as land expropriations and declarations of “state lands”) and informal, which include the seizure of agricultural land, harassment, and violent displacement of Palestinians by Jewish settlers, resulting in creeping Judaization. The present article examines informal processes that took place under the cover of the Second Intifada (2000–2005). We demonstrate how, despite its legal obligation to protect Palestinians’ land rights and security, Israel facilitates Jewish encroachment on their land and homes and illuminate the often-understudied aspect of the Palestinians’ agentic resistance. These processes became more pronounced over time. This is particularly true now, following the outbreak of the war on Gaza (2023), when soldiers and armed settlers intensified the intimidation of Palestinian communities with the aim of removing Palestinian residents from the area. Hence the relevance and topicality of this study.

Keywords

displaceability settler colonialism Susiya OPT Israel-Palestine

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Albeck

(2002) The use of lands in Judea and Samaria for Jewish settlement – legal aspects and the reality test. In: Shvut

(ed) Going up the Mountain – the Renewed Jewish Settlement in Judea and Samaria. Jerusalem: Beit El Library, Vol. 221.

Amira

(2021) The slow violence of Israeli settler-colonialism and the political ecology of ethnic cleansing in the West Bank. Settler Colonial Studies 11: 512–532.

Azoulay

(2009) Constitutive Violence, 1947–1950: Visual Genealogy of a Regime and Turning Disaster into “A Disaster from Their Point of View”. Resling.

Ben Shemesh

(1953) Land Laws in the State of Israel. Masada.

Bird Rose

(1991) Hidden Histories: Black Stories from Victoria River Downs, Humbert River and Wave Hill Stations. Aboriginal Studies Press.

Bisharat

(1994) Land, law and legitimacy in Israel and the Occupied Territories. American University Law Review 43: 467–561.

Blandy

Sibley

(2010) Law, boundaries and the production of space. Social & Legal Studies 19(3): 275–284.

Blomley

(2003) Law, property and the geography of violence: the frontier, the survey, and the grid. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 93: 121–141.

Braverman

(2008) “The tree is the enemy soldier”: a sociolegal making of war landscapes in the Occupied West Bank. Law & Society Review 42(3): 449–482.

10.

Braverman

(2009) Uprooting identities: the regulation of olive trees in the Occupied West Bank. PoLAR: Political and Legal Anthropology Review 32(2): 237–264.

11.

Braverman

Blomley

Delaney

Kedar

(2014) Expanding the spaces of law. In: Braverman

Blomley

Delaney

et al. (eds) The Expanding Spaces of Law: A Timely Legal Geography. Stanford University Press, 1–29.

12.

Breaking the Silence (n.d.) Soldiers’ testimonies from the Southern Hebron hills. Available at: https://www.breakingthesilence.org.il/wp-content/uploads/2011/07/Soldiers_Testimonies_from_the_South_Hebron_Hills_2000_2008_Eng.pdf (accessed 20 March 2024).

13.

Bronner

(Taayush NGO and unpublished) (n.d.) Uprooting Palestinians from the South Hebron Hills Area.

14.

B’Tselem (2008) Accessed denied: Israeli measures to deny Palestinians access to land around settlements. Summary, September 2008. Available at: https://www.btselem.org/hebrew/publications/summaries/200809_access_denied (accessed 13 November 2021).

15.

B’Tselem (2010) By hook and by crook: Israeli settlement policy in the West Bank. Summary, July 2010. Available at: https://www.btselem.org/publications/summaries/201007_by_hook_and_by_crook (accessed 13 November 2021).

16.

B’Tselem (2012) Under the guise of legality: declarations of state land in the West Bank. Summary, March 2012. Available at: https://www.btselem.org/publications/summaries/201203_under_the_guise_of_legality (accessed 13 November 2021).

17.

B’Tselem (2013) Acting the landlord: Israel’s policy in Area C, the West Bank. Report Summary, June 2013. Available at: https://www.btselem.org/publications/summaries/201306_acting_the_landlord (accessed 13 November 2021).

18.

B’Tselem (2024) Forcible transfer of isolated Palestinian communities and families in area C under cover of Gaza fighting. Summary, October 2024. Available at: https://www.btselem.org/settler_violence/20231019_forcible_transfer_of_isolated_communities_and_families_in_area_c_under_the_cover_of_gaza_fighting (accessed at 2 April 2025).

19.

Central Bureau of Statistics (2023) Localities in Israel – locality files. Available at: https://www.cbs.gov.il/he/publications/Pages/2019/%D7%99%D7%99%D7%A9%D7%95%D7%91%D7%99%D7%9D-%D7%91%D7%99%D7%A9%D7%A8%D7%90%D7%9C.aspx#losExcelos (accessed 13 May 2025).

20.

Christian Peacemaker Team (2007) Susiya village – fifth demolition looming. Report, July 7. Available at: https://www.operazionecolomba.it/susiya_report.pdf?phpMyAdmin=2YiVz8KHFWA0WE8JARiVaFRtFc5 (accessed 13 November 2021).

21.

Davidov

Reichman

(2010) Prolonged armed conflict and diminished deference to the military: lessons from Israel. Law & Social Inquiry 35(4): 919–956.

22.

Delaney

(2004) Tracing displacements: or evictions in the nomosphere. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 22(6): 847–860.

23.

Dotan

(1999a) Judicial rhetoric, government lawyers, and human rights: the case of the Israeli High Court of Justice during the Intifada. Law & Society Review 33(2): 319–363.

24.

Dotan

(1999b) Do the “haves” still come out ahead? Resource inequalities in ideological courts: the case of the Israeli High Court of Justice. Law & Society Review 33(4): 1059–1080.

25.

Faingulernt

(2018) In the Desert – A Documentary Diptych. Ruth Diskin Films.

26.

Falah

(2005) Peace, deception and justification for territorial claims: the case of Israel. In: Flint

(ed) The Geography of War and Peace. from Death Camps to Diplomats. Oxford University Press, 297–320.

27.

Fanon

(1967) Black Skin, White Masks. Grove Press.

28.

Forman

(2009) A tale of two regions: diffusion of the Israeli ‘50 Percent Rule’ from the Galilee to the Occupied West Bank. Law & Social Inquiry 34: 671–711.

29.

Galanter

(1974) Why the ‘haves’ come out ahead: speculations on the limits of legal change. Law & Society Review 9(1): 95–160.

30.

Gazit

(2015) State-sponsored vigilantism: Jewish settlers’ violence in the Occupied Palestinian Territories. Sociology 49(3): 438–454.

31.

Gazit

(2019) Jewish vigilantism in the West Bank. In: Bjørgo

Mareš

(eds) Vigilantism Against Migrants and Minorities. Routledge, 43–54.

32.

Gazit

(2020) Military (non-)policing in the Occupied Territories. Israel Studies Review 35(2): 77–100.

33.

Ghanim

(2012) Not really apartheid: on the dynamics between settler-colonialism and military occupation. The Public Space 6: 95–112.

34.

Ghanim

(2014) On indigeneity, ghosts and the shadows of ruins. In: Seter

(ed) Childhood and Exile in Israel/Palestine. Tel Aviv University Press, 17–24.

35.

Ghanim

(2017) Transforming Al-Quds into urshalim: erasure and opposition in a situation of emergent settler colonialism. Theory and Criticism 48: 151–174.

36.

Gould

Barclay

(2012) Mind the gap: the place of gap studies in sociolegal scholarship. Annual Review of Law and Social Science 8(1): 323–335.

37.

Hanafi

(2009) Spacio-cide: colonial politics, invisibility and rezoning in Palestinian territory. Contemporary Arab Affairs 2(1): 106–121.

38.

Hanafi

(2013) Explaining spacio-cide in the Palestinian territory: colonization, separation, and state of exception. Current Sociology 61: 190–205.

39.

Hass

Harel

(2001) Suspected: the company commander decided to evacuate Palestinians without authorization. Haaretz.

40.

Huisman

(2018) Non-enforcement as a technique of governance – the case of rental housing in the Netherlands. European Journal of Cultural and Political Sociology 6(3): 172–200.

41.

Israeli-Palestinian Interim Agreement on the West Bank and the Gaza Strip (Oslo II), Government of Israel - Palestine Liberation Organization , Sept. 28, 1995.

42.

Jafri

(2017) Ongoing colonial violence in settler states. Lateral 6(1).

43.

Joronen

(2017) Spaces of waiting: politics of precarious recognition in the Occupied West Bank. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 35(6): 994–1011.

44.

Karish-Hazoni

(2016) The widow of the terrorist attack victim remarries: “If you want revenge, this is the way”. Makor Rishon.

45.

Kedar

(1998) Majority time, minority time: land, nation, and the law of diverse possession in Israel. Tel Aviv University Law Review 21(3): 665–746.

46.

Kedar

(2001) The legal transformation of ethnic geography: israeli law and the Palestinian landholder 1948–1967. NYU Journal of International Law and Politics 33(4): 923–1000.

47.

Kedar

Amara

Yiftachel

(2018) Emptied Lands: A Legal Geography of Bedouins Rights in the Negev. Stanford University Press.

48.

Kretzmer

(2002) The Occupation of Justice: The Supreme Court of Israel and the Occupied Territories. SUNY Press.

49.

Kritzer

Silbey

(2003) In Litigation: Do the “Haves” Still Come out Ahead? Stanford Law and Politics.

50.

Levine-Schnur

(2017) Private property and public power in the Occupied West Bank. European Property Law Journal 6(2): 122–141.

51.

Manderson

(2005) Interstices: new work on legal spaces. Law Text Culture 9: 1–10. https://ro.uow.edu.au/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1092&context=ltc

52.

Maoz

(2020) Living Law: Police and Sovereignty in an Occupation Regime. Van Leer Institute and Hakibbutz Hameuchad.

53.

Miller

(2018) The use of case studies in law and social science research. Annual Review of Law and Social Science 14: 381–396.

54.

Mishirqi-Assad

Kedar

(2022) Power, law and place in the shadow of the occupation: a legal-geographical examination of the transformation of the Susya area (Shafa Yatta شفا يطّا) 1967 to 1998. Haifa Law Review 16(1): 177–245.

55.

Moncada

(2017) Varieties of vigilantism: conceptual discord, meaning and strategies. Global Crime 18(4): 402–423.

56.

Navot

(2013) Israeli settlers’ agriculture as a means of land takeover in the West Bank. Available at: https://f35bf8a1-b11c-4b7a-ba04-05c1ffae0108.filesusr.com/ugd/cdb1a7_370bb4f21ceb47adb3ac7556c02b8972.pdf (accessed 19 March 2024).

57.

Pappé

(2016) The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine. Oneworld.

58.

Peace Now (n.d.) Ancient Susiya synagogue. Available at: https://peacenow.org.il/en/settlements/settlement230-en (accessed 20 March 2024).

59.

Report of the Committee to Examine the Status of Building in Judea and Samaria (2012) (Levy Report).

60.

Rosenfeld

(2004) Confronting the Occupation: Work, Education, and Political Activism of Palestinian Families in a Refugee Camp. Stanford University Press.

61.

Sabbagh-Khouri

(2018) Settler colonialism, the indigenous perspective and sociology of knowledge production. Theory & Criticism 50: 391–418.

62.

Salazar Hughes

(2020) Unbounded territoriality: territorial control, settler colonialism, and Israel/Palestine. Settler Colonial Studies 10(2): 216–233.

63.

Sandberg

(2018) Summary Report of the Professional Team for Formulating an Outline for Regulating Construction in the Judaea and Samaria area. Available at: https://www.gov.il/BlobFolder/reports/report_11/he/report_11.pdf (accessed 19 March 2024).

64.

Sasson

(2005) (Interim) Report Concerning Unauthorized Outposts.

65.

Sfard

(2018) The Wall and the Gate: Israel, Palestine, and the Legal Battle for Human Rights. Metropolitan Books.

66.

Shalhoub-Kevorkian

(2016b) The occupation of the senses: the prosthetic and aesthetic of state terror. British Journal of Criminology 57(6): 1279–1300.

67.

Shalhoub-Kevorkian

David

(2016) Is the violence of Tag Mehir a state crime? British Journal of Criminology 56(5): 835–856.

68.

Shalhoub–Kevorkian

(2015) Security, Theology, Surveillance and the Politics of Fear. Cambridge University Press.

69.

Shalhoub–Kevorkian

(2016a) At the limits of the human: reading postraciality from Palestine. Ethnic and Racial Studies 39(13): 2252–2260.

70.

Shamir

(1990) Landmark cases and the reproduction of legitimacy: the case of Israel’s High Court of Justice. Law & Society Review 24(3): 781–806.

71.

Shragai

(2001) Har-Sinai wrote to the Commander of Central Command that his life was in danger. Haaretz.

72.

State Comptroller (2005) Annual Report 56b for the Year 2005. Available at: https://www.mevaker.gov.il/(X(1)S(3ujirddiwct2wt235tqucdyh))/he/Reports/Pages/570.aspx?entity=&entity=&AspxAutoDetectCookieSupport=1 (accessed 13 November 2021).

73.

Tzfadia

(2013) Informality as control: the legal geography of colonization of the West Bank. In: Chiodelli

De Carli

Falletti

et al. (eds) Cities to Be Tamed? Spatial Investigations Across the Urban South. Cambridge Scholars, 192–214.

74.

Tzfadia

(2017) Informal outposts in the West Bank: normality in gray space. In: Allegra

Handel

Maggor

(eds) Normalizing Occupation: The Politics of Everyday Life in the West Bank Settlements. Indiana University Press, 92–111.

75.

Tzfadia

Yiftachel

(2022) Displaceability. Mafteah 17: 152–153.

76.

Veracini

(2010) Settler Colonialism: A Theoretical Overview. Palgrave Macmillan.

77.

Veracini

(2011) Introducing: settler colonial studies. Settler Colonial Studies 1(1): 1–12.

78.

Veracini

(2013) The other shift: settler colonialism, Israel, and the occupation. Journal of Palestine Studies 42(2): 26–42.

79.

Weisburd

(1988) Vigilantism as community social control: developing a quantitative criminological model. Journal of Quantitative Criminology 4(2): 137–153.

80.

Wolfe

(2006) Settler colonialism and the elimination of the native. Journal of Genocide Research 8(4): 387–409.

81.

Yesh Din (2014) The lawless zone: the transfer of policing and security to the civilian security coordinators in the settlements and outposts. Available at: https://www.yesh-din.org/en/the-lawless-zone-the-transfer-of-policing-and-security-to-the-civilian-security-coordinators-in-the-settlements-and-outposts/ (accessed 19 March 2024).

82.

Yesh Din (2016) From occupation to annexation: the silent adoption of the Levy Report on retroactive authorization of illegal construction in the West Bank. Available at: https://www.yesh-din.org/en/from-occupation-to-annexation-the-silent-adoption-of-the-levy-report-on-retroactive-authorization-of-illegal-construction-in-the-west-bank/ (accessed 13 November 2021).

83.

Yiftachel

(2006) Ethnocracy: Land and Identity Politics in Israel/Palestine. University of Pennsylvania Press.

84.

Yiftachel

(2009) Critical theory and ‘gray space’: mobilization of the colonized. City 13(2): 246–263.

85.

Yiftachel

(2013) Critical theory and ‘gray space’: the Bedouins in the Beersheba area. In: Meir

Karplus

(eds) The Production of Bedouin Space in the Negev. Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, 227–253.

86.

Yiftachel

(2020) From displacement to displaceability: a southeastern perspective on the new metropolis. City 24(1–2): 151–165.

87.

Yoav

(1999a) Judicial rhetoric, government lawyers and human rights: the case of the Israeli High Court of Justice during the Intifada. Law and Society Review 33(2): 319.

88.

Yoav

(1999b) Do the “haves” still come out ahead? Resource inequalities in ideological courts: the case of the Israeli High Court of Justice. Law and Society 33: 1059.

89.

Yoaz

(2004) Court: Palestinian homes in Southern Hebron Hills can stay. Haaretz, Available at: https://web.archive.org/web/20070525104810/http:/www.taayush.org/new/20040908-haae.htm (accessed 19 March 2024).

90.

Zamir

(1985) State Lands in Judea and Samaria – Legal Review. Jerusalem Institute for the Study of Israel.

91.

Zreik

(2016) When does a settler become a native? (with apologies to Mamdani). Constellations 23(3): 351–364.

92.

Abd al-Qadr v. Military Appeals Committee, HCJ 5439/09 (2012) (Abd al-Qadr).

93.

Abu Sabha v. Minister of Defense, HCJ 2143/11 (2014) (Tawamin).

94.

Adnan Nawaj’A v. Minister of Defense, HCJ 5825/10 (2014) (Susiya 2010).

95.

Ahmad Muhammad Mahmoud v. Commander of IDF Troops, HCJ 656/11 (2011).

96.

Ali Shritikh v. Civil Administration of the Judea and Samaria area, HCJ 7530/01 (2007) (Susiya 2001).

97.

Amana – Gush Emunim’s Settlement Movement v. IDF Troops Commander in the Judea and Samaria area, HCJ 548/04 (2004).

98.

Commander of IDF Troops v. Military Appeals Committee, HCJ 9296/08 (2011).

99.

Coptic Mutran v. Minister of Police, HCJ 109/70 (1971).

100.

Ismail Awad v. Minister of Defense, HCJ 7838/10 (Awad 2010).

101.

Ismail Awad v. Minister of Defense, HCJ 3373/14 (2016) (Awad 2014).

102.

Jamil Hushiya v. Minister of Defense, HCJ 1315/12 (2014) (Atariyya and Umm al-Arayes).

103.

Jihad Nawajah v. Commander of the IDF in the West Bank, HCJ 8117/23 (2024).

104.

Military Prosecutor v. Jihad Youssef Ismail Najar (Military Court of Appeals (Judea and Samaria area)) 1001/07 (2007).

105.

Moshe Deutsch v. Commander of IDF Troops, HCJ 9690/07 (2009).

106.

Moshe Deutsch v. Head of the Civil Administration (Military Board of Appeals) 2/08 (2010) (Deutsch).

107.

Moshe Deutsch v. Minister of Defense, HCJ 6392/12 (2013).

108.

Moshe Deutsch v. Talal Hushniya, Tel Aviv Civic Case 39372-02-11 (2012).

109.

Rashed Marar Head of the Yanun Village Council v. Commander of IDF Troops in Judea and Samaria, HCJ 9593/04 (2006) (Marar Case).

110.

Susiya Village Council v. Minister of Defense, HCJ 1420/14 (2023).

111.

Tal Construction and Investments Karney Shomron v. Minister of Defense, HCJ 10302/07 (2008) (Tal).

112.

Talal Hushiya v. Minister of Defense, HCJ 6675/06 (2009) (Wad Swed).

Settler vigilantism and place remaking in the Occupied Palestinian Territories: A legal geography of displaceability in Susiya

Abstract

Keywords

Get full access to this article

References