Humanitarian border: Reprise. Anti-human trafficking discourses and security practices at the southern Italian border

Abstract

The article analyses the friction between anti-human trafficking discourse and border practices in the context of EU migration management: the narrative of protecting migrants from human traffickers, evoked by law enforcement actors, merges with a discourse criminalizing migration, discerning between the migrant as a passive victim – the asylum seeker –the “economic migrant” and the ruthless smuggler. Practices and procedures at the border aim primarily at classifying migrants within these categories, in fact identifying potentially dangerous subjects for the country of arrival. The case study is the Southern European border in Sicily, and the operations enacted by law enforcement actors and EU agencies within the hotspot facilities. Moving from the ethnographic fieldwork I conducted on this context since 2016, witnessing disembarkations and border procedures and getting access to the hotspot structures of Lampedusa and Pozzallo in 2021, the article analyses the transformation of the border apparatus and of contemporary governance of mobility. What delineates is a revival of the humanitarian border, where anti-human trafficking discourses are evoked to legitimize exclusionary border procedures and practices.

Keywords

Humanitarian border smuggling human trafficking border practices southern European border

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Agier

(2011) Managing the Undesirables: Refugee Camps and Humanitarian Government. Cambridge: Polity Press.

Akkerman

(2018) Militarization of European border security. In: The Emergence of EU Defense Research Policy. Springer, 337–355.

Alpes

Spire

(2013) Dealing with law in migration control: the powers of street-level bureaucrats at French consulates. Social & Legal Studies: 23(2): 261–274.

Amit

Ved

(2000) Constructing the Field: Ethnographic Fieldwork in the Contemporary World. London; New York: Routledge.

Anderlini

Jacopo

(2018) Cura e controllo al confine: scritturazioni e pratiche del sapere medico negli hotspot. Mondi Migranti (2): 61–80. DOI: 10.3280/MM2018-002004.

Anderlini

Jacopo

(2020) Border Troubles: Medical Expertise in the Hotspots. In: Ambrosini

Maurizio

Cinalli

Manlio

Jacobson

David

(eds). Migration, Borders and Citizenship: Between Policy and Public Spheres. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 141–161.

Anderlini

Jacopo

(2022) Fitful circulations: unauthorized movements in the Sicilian transit zone. International Migration. DOI: 10.1111/imig.12996.

Anderson

(2014) Trafficking. In: Fiddian-Qasmiyeh

Loescher

Long

, et al. (eds) The Oxford Handbook of Refugee and Forced Migration Studies. Oxford University Press, DOI: 10.1093/oxfordhb/9780199652433.013.0009.

Andersson

(2016) Europe’s failed ‘fight’ against irregular migration: ethnographic notes on a counterproductive industry. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 42(7): 1–21.

10.

Aradau

(2004) The perverse politics of four-letter words: risk and pity in the securitisation of human trafficking. Millennium 33(2): 251–277.

11.

ARCI Porco Rosso Phone

Sicilia

(2021) From Sea to prison. The criminalization of boat drivers in Italy. Palermo. https://fromseatoprison.files.wordpress.com/2021/10/from-sea-to-prison_arci-porco-rosso-and-alarm-phone_october-2021.pdf

12.

Arendt

(1958) The Human Condition. Chicago: The University Chicago Press.

13.

Balibar

(2009) Europe as borderland. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 27(2): 190–215.

14.

Bhagat

(2022) Trafficking borders. Political Geography 95: 102598.

15.

Bialasiewicz

(2012) Off-shoring and out-sourcing the borders of EUrope: Libya and EU border work in the Mediterranean. Geopolitics 17: 102. https://dare.uva.nl/search?identifier=81ec97f1-470f-47e9-bf6e-863cbde082bf

16.

Bigo

(2001) Internal and external security (ies): the Möbius ribbon. In: Identities, Borders, Orders. University of Minnesota Press, 91–116. https://kclpure.kcl.ac.uk/portal/en/publications/internal-and-external-securityies-the-m%C3%B6bius-ribbon.

17.

Bigo

(2002) Security and immigration: toward a critique of the governmentality of unease. Alternatives: Global, Local, Political 27(1S): S63.

18.

Bigo

(2014) The (in)securitization practices of the three universes of EU border control: military/Navy – border guards/police – database analysts. Security Dialogue 45(3): 209–225.

19.

Boswell

(2011) The Political Uses of Expert Knowledge: Immigration Policy and Social Research. First paperback edition. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press.

20.

Brachet

(2018) Manufacturing smugglers: from irregular to clandestine mobility in the Sahara. The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 676(1): 16–35.

21.

Brunet-Jailly

Eed

(2007) Borderlands: Comparing Border Security in North America and Europe. Ottawa, ON: University of Ottawa Press.

22.

Ceyhan

Tsoukala

(2002) The securitization of migration in western societies: ambivalent discourses and policies. Alternatives 27(1_suppl): 21–39.

23.

Chebel d’Appollonia

(2012) Frontiers of Fear: Immigration and Insecurity in the United States and Europe. Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell Univ. Press.

24.

Chouliaraki

Fairclough

(2007) Discourse in Late Modernity: Rethinking Critical Discourse Analysis. Edinburgh: Edinburgh Univ. Press. Transferred to digital printing.

25.

Coleman

Von Hellermann

(2011). (eds) Multi-sited Ethnography: Problems and Possibilities in the Translocation of Research Methods. New York: Routledge.

26.

Crawley

Skleparis

(2018) Refugees, migrants, neither, both: categorical fetishism and the politics of bounding in Europe’s ‘migration crisis. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 44(1): 48–64.

27.

El-Enany

(2013) The EU asylum, immigration and border control regimes: including and excluding the deserving migrant. European Journal of Social Security 15: 171.

28.

Ellermann

(2006) Street-level democracy: how immigration bureaucrats manage public opposition. West European Politics 29(2): 293–309.

29.

EUNAVFOR MED (2017) Profiles of vulnerable people and smugglers/traffickers. EUNAVFOR MED. https://www.slideshare.net/lucarinaldi/manuale-operativo-operazione-sophia

30.

European Commission , 2021, “A renewed EU action plan against migrant smuggling (2021-2025)”.

31.

Europol (2016) Migrant Smuggling in the EU. Luxembourg: Europol Public Information.

32.

Europol (2022) European Migrant Smuggling Centre - 6th Annual Report. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union.

33.

Fairclough

(2003) Analysing Discourse: Textual Analysis for Social Research. London; New York: Routledge.

34.

Fassin

(2007) Humanitarianism: a nongovernmental government. In: Nongovernmental Politics. New York: Zone Books, 149–160.

35.

Fassin

(2012) Humanitarian Reason: A Moral History of the Present Times. Berkeley: University of California Press.

36.

Freedman

(2016) Engendering security at the borders of Europe: women migrants and the mediterranean ‘crisis. Journal of Refugee Studies 29(4): 568–582.

37.

Friese

(2012) Border economies. Lampedusa and the nascent migration industry. Shima: The International Journal of Research into Island Cultures 6(2): 66–84.

38.

Frontex Risk Analysis Network (2023) Risk Analysis for 2023/2024 (Warsaw).

39.

Garelli

Tazzioli

(2018) The humanitarian war against migrant smugglers at sea. Antipode 50(3): 685–703.

40.

Gazzotti

(2021) The ‘war on smugglers’ and the expansion of the border apparatus. In: The Routledge Handbook of Smuggling. Routledge.

41.

Giliberti

Queirolo Palmas

(2021) The hole, the corridor and the landings: reframing Lampedusa through the COVID-19 emergency. Ethnic and Racial Studies 45(9): 1760–1781.

42.

Guild

(2009) Security and Migration in the 21st Century. Polity. https://books.google.com/books?hl=it&lr=&id=-hOkAcr06tQC&oi=fnd&pg=PR1&dq=guild+security+and+migration&ots=-YGTcY4Snj&sig=kqV8_KkD13e3m4SKDG6QgloVTas

43.

Gunatilleke

(1994) International response to trafficking in migrants and the safeguarding of migrant rights. International Migration 32(4): 593–603.

44.

Herbert

(2000) For ethnography. Progress in Human Geography 24(4): 550–568.

45.

Hess

(2012) De-naturalising transit migration. Theory and methods of an ethnographic regime analysis. Population, Space and Place 18(4): 428–440.

46.

Hess

Kasparek

(2017) Under control? Or border (as) conflict: reflections on the European border regime. Social Inclusion 5(3): 58.

47.

Huysmans

(2006) The Politics of Insecurity: Fear, Migration, and Asylum in the EU. London; New York: Routledge.

48.

Jeandesboz

Pallister-Wilkins

(2016) Crisis, routine, consolidation: the politics of the mediterranean migration crisis. Mediterranean Politics 21(2): 316–320.

49.

Jordan

Stråth

Triandafyllidou

(2003) Contextualising immigration policy implementation in Europe. Journal of ethnic and migration studies 29(2): 195–224.

50.

Jubany

(2011) Constructing truths in a culture of disbelief Understanding asylum screening from within. International Sociology 26(1): 74–94.

51.

Kallius

Monterescu

Rajaram

(2016) Immobilizing mobility: border ethnography, illiberal democracy, and the politics of the ‘refugee crisis’ in Hungary. American Ethnologist 43(1): 25–37.

52.

Kleemans

(2014) “Theoretical perspectives on organized crime” In: The Oxford Handbook of Organized Crime 32–52.

53.

Kotiswaran

(2017) Revisiting the Law and Governance of Trafficking, Forced Labor and Modern Slavery. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/revisiting-the-law-and-governance-of-trafficking-forced-labor-and-modern-slavery/5459710DEF4EEA62401D963666D13533

54.

Laclau

Mouffe

(1985) Hegemony and Socialist Strategy: Towards a Radical Democratic Politics. London: Verso.

55.

Léonard

(2010) EU border security and migration into the European Union: FRONTEX and securitisation through practices. European Security 19(2): 231–254.

56.

Liempt

I van

Sersli

(2013) State responses and migrant experiences with human smuggling: a reality check. Antipode 45(4): 1029–1046.

57.

Lipsky

(1980) Street-level Bureaucracy: Dilemmas of the Individual in Public Service. Russell Sage Foundation.

58.

Lutterbeck

(2005) Blurring the dividing line: the convergence of internal and external security in western Europe. European Security 14(2): 231–253.

59.

Lutterbeck

(2006) Policing migration in the mediterranean. Mediterranean politics 11(1): 59–82.

60.

Maillet

Mountz

Williams

(2017) Researching migration and enforcement in obscured places: practical, ethical and methodological challenges to fieldwork. Social & Cultural Geography 18(7): 927–950.

61.

Mainwaring

DeBono

(2021) Criminalizing solidarity: search and rescue in a neo-colonial sea. Environment and Planning C: Politics and Space 39(5): 1030–1048.

62.

Malkki

(1996) Speechless emissaries: refugees, humanitarianism, and dehistoricization. Cultural Anthropology 11(3): 377–404.

63.

Marcus

(1995) Ethnography in/of the world system: the emergence of multi-sited ethnography. Annual Review of Anthropology 24(1): 95–117.

64.

Mbembe

(2003) Necropolitics. Public Culture 15(1): 11–40.

65.

Miller

Baumeister

(2013) Managing Migration: is border control fundamental to anti-trafficking and anti- smuggling interventions? Anti-Trafficking Review 1(2): 15–32.

66.

Molland

(2013) Tandem ethnography: on researching ‘trafficking’ and ‘anti-trafficking. Ethnography 14(3): 300–323.

67.

Mountz

(2011) The enforcement archipelago: detention, haunting, and asylum on islands. Political Geography 30(3): 118–128.

68.

Mutua

(2001) Savages, victims, and saviors: the metaphor of human rights. Social Science Research Network, Rochester, NY. https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=1525547

69.

Neal

(2009) Securitization and risk at the EU border: the origins of FRONTEX. JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies 47(2): 333–356.

70.

Neocleous

(2013) Air power as police power. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 31(4): 578–593.

71.

O’Reilly

(2005) Ethnographic Methods. London: Routledge.

72.

Pallister-Wilkins

(2015) The humanitarian politics of European border policing: Frontex and border police in evros. International Political Sociology 9(1): 53–69.

73.

Pallister-Wilkins P (2017) Humanitarian rescue/sovereign capture and the policing of possible responses to violent borders. Global Policy 8: 19–24.

74.

Queirolo Palmas

(2020) Back to the Sicilian landing site: exploring a borderland through a refugee gaze. Journal of Contemporary Ethnography 8(6): 853–880.

75.

Raineri

(2021) Migrant smuggling and the social organisation of cross-border mobility. In: The Routledge Handbook of Smuggling. Routledge.

76.

Sandy

(2012) International politics, anti-trafficking measures and sex work in Cambodia. In: Labour Migration and Human Trafficking in Southeast Asia. Routledge.

77.

Shah

(2017) Ethnography? Participant observation, a potentially revolutionary praxis. HAU: Journal of Ethnographic Theory 7(1): 45–59.

78.

Stambøl

(2019) The rise of crimefare Europe: fighting migrant smuggling in west Africa. European Foreign Affairs Review 24(Issue 3): 287–307.

79.

Stierl

(2017) A fleet of mediterranean border humanitarians. Antipode. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/anti.12320/abstract

80.

Ticktin

(2011) Casualties of Care: Immigration and the Politics of Humanitarianism in France. Berkeley: University of California Press.

81.

Tsianos

Hess

Karakayali

(2009) Transnational migration. Theory and method of an ethnographic analysis of border regimes. Sussex Centre for Migration Research Working Paper 55 https://www.academia.edu/download/31178322/sussespaper.pdf

82.

Tummers

Bekkers

(2014) Policy implementation, street-level bureaucracy, and the importance of discretion. Public Management Review 16(4): 527–547.

83.

Tyszler

(2019) From controlling mobilities to control over women’s bodies: gendered effects of EU border externalization in Morocco. Comparative Migration Studies 7(1): 25.

84.

Van Dijk

(2011) Discourse Studies: A Multidisciplinary Introduction. 2nd edition. London. https://sk.sagepub.com/books/discourse-studies-2e

85.

Vaughan-Williams

(2015) Europe’s Border Crisis: Biopolitical Security and beyond. 1st edition. Oxford, United Kingdom: Oxford University Press.

86.

Wakisaka

(2021) Beyond street-level bureaucracy: the organisational culture of migration policy-making and administrative elites. International Migration. 60: 150–163. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/imig.12919

87.

Walters

(2011) Foucault and frontiers: notes on the birth of the humanitarian border. In: Governmentality: Current Issues and Future Challenges. Routledge, 138–164. https://www.academia.edu/download/25286013/FoucaultandFrontiers.pdf

88.

Williams

(2016) The safety/security nexus and the humanitarianisation of border enforcement. The Geographical Journal 182(1): 27–37.

89.

Yanow

(1993) The communication of policy meanings: implementation as interpretation and text. Policy Sciences 26(1): 41–61.

90.

Yea

(2021) Towards critical geographies of anti-human trafficking: producing and precluding victimhood through discourses, practices and institutions. Progress in Human Geography 45(3): 513–530.

91.

Zaiotti

(2011) Cultures of Border Control: Schengen and the Evolution of European Frontiers. Chicago; London: University of Chicago Press.

92.

Zampagni

(2016) Unpacking the schengen visa regime. A study on bureaucrats and discretion in an Italian consulate. Journal of borderlands studies 31(2): 251–266.