Aid micropolitics: Everyday southern resistance to racialized and geographical assumptions of expertise

Abstract

Aid partnerships between global north and global south institutions are critiqued for maintaining colonial knowledge politics and restricting the participation of southern development experts. This paper draws on lifework interviews with senior civil servants within the Antigua and Barbuda government to explore how southern development experts subvert the development hierarchies that permeate partnership micropolitics. The paper first reveals how southern development experts draw on their experiences and normative discourses of ‘local knowledge’ to dismantle assumptions that whiteness and ‘westerness’ symbolise expertise in partnerships. Second, southern development experts engage in small-scale acts of everyday resistance to assert their expertise and decentre the authority and knowledge of foreign consultants. Everyday resistance allows this paper to reveal southern experts’ personal agency and subtle forms of resistance, which Foucauldian analyses of power and ‘spectacular’ theories of resistance are unequipped to recognise. I suggest that the racialised and geographic hierarchies, which structure power and privilege in the micro-level encounters between donors and beneficiaries are not as entrenched as we may think.

Keywords

Everyday resistance partnerships knowledge politics Antigua aid micropolitics lifework interviews

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aagaard

Trykker

(2020) The road to partnerships in practice. Development Policy Review 38: 266–282.

Amin

(1972) Neocolonialism in West Africa. Harmondsworth: Penguin.

Ancker

Rechel

(2015) Donors are not interested in reality. Central Asian Survey 34(4): 516–530.

Baaz

M E

(2005) The Paternalism of Partnership: A Postcolonial Reading of Identity in Development Aid. London: Zed Books.

Baaz

Lilja

Vinthagen

(2017) Researching Resistance and Social Change. Vol. 1. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.

Bhabha

(1994) The postcolonial and the postmodern. The Location of Culture 171: 197.

Bonilla

(2015) Non-Sovereign Futures. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Boudewijn

I A

(2020) Negotiating belonging and place. Human Geography 13(1): 40–48.

Bourbeau

Ryan

(2018) Resilience, resistance, infrapolitics and enmeshment. European Journal of International Relations 24(1): 221–239.

10.

Bradley

(2017) Whose agenda? In: Mougeot

(ed.) Putting Knowledge to Work: Collaborating, Influencing and Learning for International Development. Ottawa, ON: IDRC, pp. 37–70.

11.

Bron

West

(2000) Time for stories. Journal of Contemporary Sociology 37(2): 157–169.

12.

Cambers

(2009) Caribbean beach changes and climate change adaptation. Aquatic Ecosystem Health & Management 12(2): 168–176.

13.

Carolini

(2020) Go South, young planner, go South! Journal of Planning Education and Research 40(1): 10–15.

14.

Carr

McWha

MacLachlan

, et al. (2010) International–local remuneration differences across six countries. International Journal of Psychology Journal International de Psychologie 45(5): 321–340.

15.

Chua

(2012) Pragmatic resistance, law, and social movements in authoritarian states. Law & Society Review 46(4): 713–748.

16.

Cohen

Hjalmarson

(2020) Quiet struggles. International Journal of Comparative Sociology 61(2–3): 141–158.

17.

Cohen

William

(eds) (2009) What Works in Development? Washington DC: Brookings Institution Press.

18.

Colburn

(2016) Everyday Forms of Peasant Resistance. Milton Park, Abingdon: Routledge.

19.

Collyer

(2018) Global patterns in the publishing of academic knowledge. Current Sociology 66(1): 56–73.

20.

Connell

(2007) Southern Theory. Cambridge: Polity.

21.

Crewe

Harrison

(1998) Whose Development? London: Zed Books.

22.

Crush

(1995) Power of Development. Milton Park, Abingdon: Routledge

23.

Dotson

(2008) In Search of Tanzania. The Southern Journal of Philosophy 46(S1): 52–64.

24.

Eade

(2007) Capacity building. Development in Practice 17(4–5): 630–639.

25.

Easterly

(2008) Reinventing Foreign Aid. Vol. 1. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.

26.

Elbers W. 2012: The partnership paradox: Principles and practice in North-South NGO relations. Ipskamp B.V.

27.

Elliott

(2005) Using Narrative in Social Research. London: Sage Publications.

28.

Escobar

(1995) Encountering Development. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

29.

Esson

Noxolo

Baxter

, et al. (2017) The 2017 RGS‐IBG chair's theme: Decolonising geographical knowledges, or reproducing coloniality? Area 49(3): 384–388.

30.

Eyben

(2010) Hiding relations. The European Journal of Development Research 22(3): 382–397.

31.

Fechter

(ed.) (2012) The personal and the professional in aid work. Third World Q 33(8): 1387–1404.

32.

Ferguson

(1994) The anti-Politics Machine. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.

33.

Flyvbjerg

(2006) Five misunderstandings about case-study research. Qualitative Inquiry 12(2): 219–245.

34.

Fröhlich

Jacobsson

(2019) Performing resistance: Liminality, infrapolitics, and spatial contestation in contemporary Russia. Antipode 51(4): 1146–1165.

35.

Goitom

(2019) Legitimate knowledge. Social Epistemology 33(3): 193–204.

36.

Goldman

(2005) Imperial Nature. London: Yale University Press.

37.

Gore-Francis

(2016) Antigua and Barbuda: SIDS 2014 Prepatory Progress Report.

38.

Goulet

(1980) Development experts. World Development 8(7–8): 481–489.

39.

Government of Antigua and Barbuda (2011), Population and Housing Census. Available at: https://statistics.gov.ag/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/2011-Antigua-and-Barbuda-Population-and-Housing-Census-A-Demographic-Profile.pdf (accessed 20 April 2020).

40.

Grosfoguel

(2011) Decolonizing post-colonial studies and paradigms of political-economy. Transmodernity: Journal of Peripheral Cultural Production of the Luso-Hispanic World 1(1): 1–38.

41.

Gulrajani

(2011) Transcending the great foreign aid debate. Third World Quarterly 32(2): 199–216.

42.

Gupta

(2001) Everyday resistance or routine repression? The Journal of Peasant Studies 29(1): 89–108.

43.

Hatch

Cunliffe

(1997) Organization Theory. Oxford: Oxford university press.

44.

Hatton

Schroeder

(2007) Partnership Theory and Practice Canadian Journal of Development Studies 28: 157–162.

45.

Heathershaw

(2016) Who are the ‘international community?’ Journal of Intervention and Statebuilding 10(1): 77–96.

46.

Hellman

Forell

(2015) Who is rebuilding Aceh? Development in Practice 25(1): 58–70.

47.

Hollander

Einwohner

(2004) Conceptualizing resistance. Sociological Forum 19(4): 533–554.

48.

Howitt

Suchet-Pearson

(2006) Rethinking the building blocks. Geografiska Annaler: Series B, Human Geography 88(3): 323–335.

49.

Hyden

(2008) After the Paris declaration. Development Policy Review 26(3): 259–274.

50.

Impey

Overton

(2014) Developing partnerships. Community Development Journal 49(1): 111–128.

51.

Jaffe

(2014) Toward an anthropology of the Caribbean state. Small Axe: A Caribbean Journal of Criticism 18(1): 173–180.

52.

Jenkins

(2017) Women anti-mining activists’ narratives of everyday resistance in the Andes. Gender, Place & Culture 24(10): 1441–1459.

53.

Johansson

Vinthagen

(2016) Dimensions of everyday resistance. Critical Sociology 42(3): 417–435.

54.

Kamruzzaman

(2017) Understanding the role of national development experts in development ethnography. Development Policy Review 35(1): 39–63.

55.

Ketola

(2016) Understanding NGO strategies to engage with donor-funded development projects. The European Journal of Development Research 28(3): 479–494.

56.

Koch

(2020) The local consultant will not be credible. Social Epistemology 34(5): 478–489.

57.

Kothari

(ed.) (2019) A Radical History of Development Studies. London: Zed Books Ltd.

58.

Kothari

(2005) Authority and expertise. Antipode 37(3): 425–446.

59.

Kothari

(2006) An agenda for thinking about ‘race’ in development. Progress in Development Studies 6(1): 9–23.

60.

Kothari

Minogue

(2002) Critical perspectives on development. In: Kothari U and Minogue M (eds) Development Theory and Practice. Basingstoke: Palgrave, pp.1–15.

61.

Kumi

Kamruzzaman

(2021) Understanding the motivations and roles of national development experts in Ghana: ‘We do all the donkey work and they take the glory’. Third World Quarterly 42(6): 1–19.

62.

(2021) Unanticipated transformations of infrapolitics. The Journal of Peasant Studies : 1–20.

63.

Lewis

(2008) Using life histories in social policy research. Journal of Social Policy 37(4): 559–578.

64.

Lister

(2000) Power in partnership? Journal of International Development 12(2): 227–239.

65.

McCabe

Ciuk

Gilbert

(2020) There is a crack in everything. Human Relations 73(7): 953–980.

66.

McCammon

Chaudhuri

Hewitt

, et al. (2008) Becoming full citizens” 113. American Journal of Sociology 113(4): 1104–1147.

67.

Mackay

Spencer

(2017) The future of Caribbean tourism. Worldwide Hospitality and Tourism Themes 9(1): 44–59.

68.

Mannell

(2014) Adopting, manipulating, transforming. Health & Place 30: 4–12.

69.

Mawdsley

Townsend

Porter

(2005) Trust, accountability, and face-to-face interaction in North–South NGO relations. Development in Practice 15(1): 77–82.

70.

McWha I. (2011). What’s in a name?: Job categorisation, relationship building, and work motivation in aid organisations: a thesis presented in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Psychology at Massey University, Albany, New Zealand (Doctoral dissertation, Massey University).

71.

Mosse

(2013) The anthropology of international development. Annual Review of Anthropology 42(1): 227–246.

72.

Mosse D. “Global Governance and the Ethnography of International Aid.” In The Aid Effect, edited by D. Mosse, and D. Lewis, 1–28. London: Pluto Press, 2005.

73.

Mosse

Lewis

(2005) The Aid Effect. London: Pluto Press.

74.

Mowles

Stacey

Griffin

(2008) What contribution can insights from the complexity sciences make to the theory and practice of development management? Journal of International Development 20(6): 804–820.

75.

Müller

M-M

(2013) Postcolonial bureaucracies. Postcolonial Studies 16(2): 233–242.

76.

Musgrave

M K

Wong

(2016) Towards a more nuanced theory of elite capture in development projects. Journal of Sustainable Development 9(3): 87.

77.

Ngugi wa Thiong’o (1985, April/June). The language of African literature. New Left Review, pp. 109–27

78.

OCHA (2020) Antigua and Barbuda: Country Profile. Available at: www.humanitarianresponse.info/sites/www.humanitarianresponse.info/files/documents/files/corrected_july_2020_antigua_and_barbuda_country_profile_power_point_inforgraphic_pdf.pdf (accessed 18 June 2021).

79.

OECD (1996) Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development: Shaping the 21st Century. Paris: OECD.

80.

Pailey

(2020) De‐centring the ‘white gaze’ of development. Development and Change 51(3): 729–745.

81.

Peters

(2016) Participation denied. Human Organization 75(4): 315–325.

82.

Pile

Keith

(eds) (1997) Geographies of Resistance. Hove: Psychology Press.

83.

Pugh

(2013) Speaking without voice. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 103(5): 1266–1281.

84.

Pugh

(2017) Postcolonial development, (non) sovereignty and affect. Antipode 49(4): 867–882.

85.

Riessman

(2000) Stigma and everyday resistance practices. Gender & Society 14(1): 111–135.

86.

Roth

(2019) Linguistic Capital and inequality in aid relations. Sociological Research Online 24(1): 38–54.

87.

Rottenburg

(2009) Far-Fetched facts . (A. Brown and T. Lampert, Trans). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

88.

Schech

Mundkur

Skelton

, et al. (2015) New spaces of development partnership. Progress in Development Studies 15(4): 358–370.

89.

Scott, J. ‘The infra-politics of subordinate groups’ in The Post-Development reader. Rahnema, Majid, editor with Victoria Bawtree. London: Zed books, 1997, pp. 180–199.

90.

Scott

(1985) Weapons of the Weak. London: Yale University Press.

91.

Sharma

Gupta

(2006) Introduction. In: Sharma

Gupta

(eds) The Anthropology of the State: A Reader. Oxford: Blackwell, pp 1–17.

92.

Sjöstedt

(2013) Aid effectiveness and the Paris declaration. Public Administration and Development 33(2): 143–155.

93.

Spivak

(2003) Can the subaltern speak? Die Philosophin 14(27): 42–58.

94.

Sundberg

(2019) Donors dealing with ‘aid effectiveness’ inconsistencies. Journal of Eastern African Studies 13(3): 445–464.

95.

Thompson

(1988) The Voice of the Past. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

96.

Townsend

Porter

Mawdsley

(2004) Creating spaces of resistance. Antipode 36(5): 871–889.

97.

Vaditya

(2018) Social domination and epistemic marginalisation. Social Epistemology 32(4): 272–285.

98.

Watson

Watson-Franke

(1985) Interpreting Life Histories. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers Univ Press.

99.

Watts

(2001) Development ethnographies. Ethnography 2(2): 283–300.

100.

White

(2002) Thinking race, thinking development. Third World Quarterly 23(3): 407–419.

101.

Whitfield

(ed.) (2009) The Politics of Aid. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

102.

Winter

(2014) Beyond eurocentrism? International Journal of Heritage Studies 20(2): 123–137.

103.

Wood

(2013) Architects and Contractors: Political Economy Analysis of Policy Research in Pakistan. Islamabad: Sustainable Development Policy Institute.

104.

Woolcock

Szreter

Rao

(2011) How and why does history matter for development policy? Journal of Development Studies 47(1): 70–96.

105.

World Bank (n.d) GDP Growth Available at: https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.MKTP.KD.ZG?end=2020&locations=AG&start=1978&view=chart (accessed 8 June 2021).

106.

Yarrow

(2011) Development beyond Politics. Berlin: Springer.