This paper presents an analysis of the evolution of flood policy in a city in the developing world. Jakarta was selected in order to analyse the role of colonialisation on water policy. Drawing data from historical sources and interviews of key informants, we mapped the history of flood-related investments made in the city for the past 400 years. Using analysis informed by historical institutionalism, we argue that Jakarta’s flood management institutions have been locked-in to infrastructural measures. Some major flood events were able to create critical junctures, resulting in the implementation of old policies and the instigation of flood research. However, they were not able to introduce institutional changes. The persistence of engineering-driven solutions to cope with flooding can be explained by the positive feedback mechanisms taking place after major floods. Infrastructure, albeit expensive, provides a fast relief to flooding, which is ideal to short political cycles. Scientific knowledge introduced by the colonial government plays an important role in sustaining this persistence. The current massive seawall proposal to alleviate increasing flood risks due to land subsidence and sea level rise exacerbates the path dependency of infrastructural measures.
AbeyasekereS (1989) Jakarta: A History.
Singapore:
Oxford University Press.
2.
AbidinHZAndreasHGumilarI, et al. (2011)
Land subsidence of Jakarta (Indonesia) and its relation with urban development. Natural Hazards59(3): 1753–1771.
3.
AdasM (1989) Machines as the Measure of Men: Science, Technology and Ideologies of Western Dominance.
Ithaca, NY:
Cornell University Press.
4.
ArgoTA (1999) Thirsty Downstream: The Provision of Clean Water in Jakarta.
Vancouver, Canada:
University of British Columbia.
5.
ArthurB (1994) Increasing Returns and Path Dependence in the Economy.
Ann Arbor:
University of Michigan Press.
BeinartWHughesL (2007) Environment and Empire.
Oxford:
Oxford University Press.
8.
BlanchetT (2015) Path Dependence and Change in the Governance of Organized Systems: The Case of Water Services in Three German Municipalities (1990–2010).
Berlin, Germany:
Free University of Berlin.
9.
BlusséL (1986) Strange Company: Chinese Settlers, Mestizo Women and the Dutch in VOC Batavia.
Dordrecht; Riverton, NJ:
Foris Publications.
10.
BoomgaardP (2005) The long goodbye? Trends in forest exploitation in the Indonesian Archipelago. In: BoomgaardP, Henley D and Osseweijer M (eds) Muddied Waters. Historical and Contemporary Perspectives on Management of Forests and Fisheries in Island Southeast Asia.
Leiden:
KITLV Press, pp. 211–234.
11.
BourchierDHadizV (2003) Indonesian Politics and Society: A Reader.
London:
Routledge Curzon.
12.
BPS (2015) Statistik Daerah Provinsi DKI Jakarta 2015.
Jakarta:
Badan Pusat Statistik Provinsi DKI Jakarta.
13.
BrinkmanJJHartmanM (2009) Jakarta flood hazard mapping framework. In: International Conference on Urban Flood Management, Paris, 25-27 November 2009, pp.1–9. Available at: http://edepot.wur.nl/140833 (accessed 1 August 2016).
14.
BrownRA (2006)
Indonesian corporations, cronyism, and corruption. Modern Asian Studies4: 953–992.
15.
BrugPH van der (1997)
Malaria in Batavia in the 18th century. Tropical Medicine and International Health2(9): 892–902.
16.
BuckleyRB (1893) Irrigation Works in India and Egypt.
London; New York:
Spon & Chamberlain.
17.
BunteMUfenA (eds) (2009) Democratization in Post-Suharto Indonesia.
London; New York:
Routledge.
18.
van BuurenAEllenGJWarnerJF (2016)
Path-dependency and policy learning in the Dutch delta: Toward more resilient flood risk management in the Netherlands?Ecology and Society21(4): 43.
19.
CaljouwMNasPJMPratiwo (2005)
Flooding in Jakarta: Towards a blue city with improved water management. Bijdragen Tot de Taal-, Land-en Volkenkunde (BKI)161(4): 454–484.
20.
CampbellJ (1997) Mechanisms of evolutionary change in economic governance: Interaction, interpretation and bricolage. In: MagnussonLOttossonJ (eds) Evolutionary Economics and Path Dependence.
Cheltenham:
Elgar, pp.10–32.
21.
CapocciaG (2016) Critical junctures. In: FioretosOFalletiTGSheingateA (eds) The Oxford Handbook of Historical Institutionalism.
Oxford:
Oxford University Press, pp.89–112.
22.
CapocciaGKelemenRD (2007)
The study of critical junctures: Theory, narrative and counterfactuals in historical institutionalism. World Politics59(3): 341–369.
23.
CareyPBR (1980) Aspects of Javanese history in the nineteenth century. In: AvelingH (ed) The Development of Indonesian Society: From the Coming of Islam to the Present Day.
New York:
St Martin Press, pp. 45–105.
24.
CastlesL (1989) Jakarta: The growing centre. In: HillH (ed) Unity and Diversity: Regional Economic Development in Indonesia.
Singapore:
Oxford University Press, pp.233–235.
25.
CohenMDMarchJGOlsenJP (1972)
A garbage can model of organizational choice. Administrative Science Quarterly17(1): 1–25.
26.
CollierD (2011)
Understanding process tracing. Political Science & Politics4(4): 823–830.
27.
CrouchH (1980) The trends to authoritarianism: The post-1945 period. In: AvelingH (ed) The Development of Indonesia’s Society: From the Coming of Islam to the Present Day.
New York:
St Martin’s Press, pp.166–120.
28.
DiMaggioPJPowellWW (1991) The New Institutionalism in Organizational Analysis.
Chicago, IL:
University of Chicago Press.
29.
DudalR (2005) Soils of Southeast Asia. In: GuptaA (ed) The Physical Geography of Southeast Asia.
Oxford:
Oxford University Press, p.103.
30.
FioretosOFalletiTGSheingateA (2016) Historical institutionalism in political science. In: Oxford Handbook of Historical Institutionalism. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 3–28.
31.
ForbesD (1990)
Jakarta towards 2005: Planning mechanisms and issues. Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies26(3): 111–120.
32.
FurnivallJS (1939) Netherlands India: A Study of Plural Economy.
Cambridge:
The University Press.
33.
GilmartinD (1994)
Scientific empire and imperial science: Colonialism and irrigation technology in the Indus Basin. The Journal of Asian Studies53(4): 1127–1149.
GunawanR (2010) Gagalnya Sistem Kanal: Pengendalian Banjir Jakarta Dari Masa ke Masa.
Jakarta:
Kompas.
36.
de HaanF (1935) Oud Batavia.
Bandung:
A.C.Nix.
37.
HadimadjaRK (2012) Ali Sadikin: Membenahi Jakarta Menjadi Kota Yang Manusiawi.
Jakarta:
Ufuk Press.
38.
van der HeidenCN (1990)
Town planning in the Dutch Indies. Planning Perspectives5(1): 63–84.
39.
HeukenA (1983) Historical Sites of Jakarta.
Jakarta:
Cipta Loka Karya.
40.
HugoGJ (1980) Population movements in Indonesia during the colonial period. In: FoxJJ (ed) Indonesia: The Making of a Culture.
Canberra:
Australia National University, pp. 95–136.
41.
JayapalM (1993) Old Jakarta.
Kuala Lumpur:
Oxford University Press.
42.
KanumoyosoB (2011) Beyond the City Wall: Society and Economic Development in the Ommelanden of Batavia, 1684–1740.
Leiden, The Netherlands:
Leiden University.
43.
KingdonJW (2014) Agendas, Alternatives, and Public Policies.
Harlow:
Pearson Education Limited.
44.
KooyMBakkerK (2008)
Splintered networks: The colonial and contemporary waters of Jakarta. Geoforum39(6): 1843–1858.
45.
KrauseF (2012)
Managing floods, managing people: A political ecology of watercourse regulation on the Kemijoki. Nordia Geographical Publications41(5): 57–68.
46.
KusnoA (2013) The post-colonial unconscious: Observing mega-imagistic urban projects in Asia. In: BharneV (ed) The Emerging Asian City: Concomitant Urbanities and Urbanisms.
Abingdon:
Routledge, pp. 168–178.
47.
LeclercJ (1993) Mirrors and the lighthouse. A search for meaning in the monuments and great works of Sukarno’s Jakarta, 1960–1966. In: NasPJM (ed) Urban Symbolism.
Leiden:
E.J. Brill, pp.38–58.
48.
LeggeJD (1968)
General Suharto’s new order. International Affairs (Royal Institute of International Affairs 1944–)44(1): 40–47.
49.
LeitnerHColvenESheppardE (2017) Ecological security for whom? The politics of flood alleviation and urban environmental justice in Jakarta, Indonesia. In: HeiseUNiemannMChristensenJ (eds) The Routledge Companion to the Environmental Humanities. London: Routledge, pp. 194–205.
50.
LeitnerHSheppardE (2017) From kampungs to condos? Contested accumulations through displacement in Jakarta. Environment and Planning AEconomy and Space 50(2): 437–456. DOI: 10.1177/0308518X17709279.
51.
LibecapGD (2010) Institutional Path Dependence in Climate Adaptation: Coman’s ‘Some Unsettled Problems of Irrigation’.
Santa Barbara, CA:
National Bureau of Economic Research.
MarcussenM (2000) Ideas and Elites: The Social Construction of Economic and Monetary Union.
Aalborg:
Aalborg University Press.
55.
MarshallGRAlexandraJ (2016)
Institutional path dependence and environmental water recovery in Australia’s Murray-Darling Basin. Water Alternatives9(3): 679–703.
56.
McLeodRH (2000)
Soeharto’s Indonesia: A better class of corruption. Agenda: A Journal of Policy Analysis and Reform7(2): 99–112.
57.
MeachamM (2009) Path Dependency of Infrastructure: Implications for the Sanitation System of Phnom Penh.
Stockholm, Sweden:
Stockholm University.
58.
MilonePD (1987)
Indische culture, and its relationship to urban life. Comparative Studies in Society and History9: 407–426.
59.
Ministry of Public Works (2011) ATLAS Pengamanan Pantai Jakarta, ATLAS Securing Jakarta’s Coastal Area. Jakarta: The Ministry of Public Works, Indonesia.
MurphyJ (2009) Environment and Imperialism: Why Colonialism Still Matters.
Leeds:
Sustainability Research Institute, University of Leeds.
64.
MustafaD (2013) Water Resource Management in a Vulnerable World: The Hydro-Hazardscapes of Climate Change.
London:
I.B. Tauris.
65.
NCICD (2013) Pengembangan Terpadu Pesisir Ibukota Negara (National Capital Integrated Coastal Development).
Jakarta:
The Coordinating Ministry of Economic Affairs. Available at: http://en.ncicd.com/ncicd/downloads/ (accessed 10 August 2016).
66.
NEDECO (1973) Master Plan for Flood Control and Drainage System of Jakarta.
Jakarta:
NEDECO.
67.
NiemeijerHE (forthcoming) The closure of the Bendungan; The colonial port city of Batavia/Jakarta and its primary hinterland in the seventeenth century.
68.
NL Agency (2012) Jakarta Coastal Development Strategy, End-of-Project Review Final Mission Report.
The Netherlands:
NL Agency, Ministry of Infrastructure and the Environment.
69.
NorthDC (1990) Institutions, Institutional Change and Economic Performance.
New York:
Cambridge University Press.
70.
OctaviantiTCharlesK (under review). Examining the political identity of Jakarta’s seawall through hegemonic articulations in discourses. Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning.
71.
Octavianti O and Charles K (2018) Disaster capitalism? Examining the politicisation of land subsidence crisis in pushing Jakarta’s seawall megaproject. Water Alternatives 11(2): 394–420.
72.
OstiG (2017)
The anti-flood detention basin projects in Northern Italy. New wine in old bottles?Water Alternatives10(2): 265–282.
Penning-RowsellECJohnsonC (2015)
The ebb and flow of power: British flood risk management and the politics of scale.Geoforum62: 131–142.
77.
PetersBGPierreJKingDS (2005)
The politics of path dependency: Political conflict in historical institutionalism. The Journal of Politics67(4): 1275–1300.
78.
PiersonP (2000)
Not just what, but when: Timing and sequence in political processes.Studies in American Political Development14(1): 72–92.
79.
PorterJDemerittD (2012)
Flood-risk management, mapping, and planning: The institutional politics of decision support in England. Environment and Planning A44: 2359–2378.
80.
PratiwoNasPJM (2005) Jakarta: Conflicting directions. In: NasPJM (ed) Directors of Urban Change in Asia.
London; New York:
Routledge, pp. 68–82.
81.
PU (2016) Normalisasi Kali Ciliwung Sudah Capai 47 Persen Rampung Akhir 2016. Available at: http://pu.go.id/main/view_pdf/10820 (accessed 1 February 2017).
82.
PutriPW (2014) Black Water – Grey Settlements. Domestic Wastewater Management and the Socio-Ecological Dynamics of Jakarta’s Kampungs. Leuven, Belgium: KU Leuven.
83.
PutriPWRahmantiAS (2010)
Jakarta waterscape: From structuring water to 21st century hybridnNature?Nakhara6: 59–74.
84.
ResinkGJ (1968) Indonesia’s History Between the Myths: Essays in Legal History and Historical Theory.
The Hague:
W. van Houve Publisher.
85.
RijkeJHerkSVan ZevenbergenC, et al. (2012)
Room for the river: Delivering integrated river basin management in the Netherlands. International Journal of River Basin Management10(4): 369–382.
SadoffCWHallJWGreyD, et al. (2015) Securing Water, Sustaining Growth: Report of the GWP/OECD Task Force on Water Security and Sustainable Growth. Oxford: University of Oxford.
88.
Schepers J (1926) De Primaire Kringen Ia En II, Benevens Het Stadsnet Van Batavia En Weltevreden. De Nauwkeurrig- heidswaterpassing Van Java. Topografische Dienst In Neder- lansch-Indie. Weltevreden Reproductiebedrifj Top.Dienst 1.
89.
ScottRW (1995) Institutions and Organisations.
Thousand Oaks, CA:
SAGE.
SidartaM (1996)
Jakarta waterfront city development. Journal Perencanaan Wilayah Dan Kota21: 38–45.
95.
SilverC (2008) Planning the Megacity: Jakarta in the Twentieth Century.
London; New York:
Routledge.
96.
SilverC (2014)
Spatial planning for sustainable development: An action planning approach for Jakarta. Jurnal Perencanaan Wilayah Dan Kota25(2): 115–125.
97.
SimanjuntakIFrantzeskakiNEnserinkB, et al. (2012)
Evaluating Jakarta’s flood defence governance: The impact of political and institutional reforms. Water Policy14(4): 561.
98.
SteinmoS (2008) What is historical institutionalism? In: Della PortaDKeatingM (eds) Approaches in the Social Sciences.
Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press, pp.150–178.
99.
StinchcombeAL (1968) Constructing Social Theories.
New York:
Harcourt, Brace and World.
100.
StinchcombeAL (1997)
On the virtues of the old institutionalism. Annual Review of Sociology23(1): 1–18.
101.
StreeckWThelenK (2005) Introduction: Institutional change in advanced political economies. In: StreeckWThelenK (eds) Beyond Continuity. Institutional Change in Advanced Political Economies.
Oxford:
Oxford University Press, pp.1–39.
Suharto P (1971) Precise leveling in Indonesia. Institute of Technology Bandung.
104.
SutherlandH (1979) The Making of a Bureaucratic Elite: The Colonial Transformation of the Javanese Priyayi.
Singapore:
Published for the Asian Studies Association of Australia by Heinemann Educational Books (Asia).
105.
Sutiyoso (2007) Megapolitan.
Jakarta:
Elex Media Computindo.
ValkenburgSV (1936)
Agricultural regions of Asia. Part IX – Java author. Economic Geography12(1): 27–44.
114.
VlekkeBHM (1943) Nusantara: A History of the East Indian Archipelago.
Cambridge, MA:
Harvard University Press.
115.
van VoorstR (2016)
Formal and informal flood governance in Jakarta, Indonesia.Habitat International52: 5–10.
116.
WarnerJFHoogestegerJHidalgoJP (2017)
Old wine in new bottles: The adaptive capacity of the hydraulic mission in Ecuador. Water Alternatives10(2): 322–340.
117.
WernersSEMatczakPFlachnerZ (2010)
Individuals matter: Exploring strategies of individuals to change the water policy for the Tisza River in Hungary. Ecology and Society15(2): 24.
