Ongoing controversy debates whether public schools should implement critical pedagogy—curricula centering on the perspectives of marginalized peoples. Despite much contention, students (particularly racially marginalized students) enrolled in courses that employ critical pedagogy demonstrate more school engagement, higher grade point averages (GPAs), and more civic engagement than students who do not. Building on previous reviews, this article briefly summarizes the history and controversy of critical pedagogy, evaluates the scientific evidence surrounding it, and offers suggestions on how to make the most of critical pedagogy in academic curricula.
AdamsG.BiernatM.BranscombeN. R.CrandallC. S.WrightsmanL. S. (2008). Beyond prejudice: Toward a sociocultural psychology of racism and oppression. In AdamsG.BiernatM.BranscombeN. R.CrandallC. S.WrightsmanL. S. (Eds.), Commemorating Brown: The social psychology of racism and discrimination (pp. 215–246). Washington, DC: APA Books.
2.
AltschulI.OysermanD.BybeeD. (2006). Racial-ethnic identity in mid-adolescence: Content and change as predictors of academic achievement. Child Development, 77, 1155–1169.
3.
AldanaA.ByrdC. M. (2015). School ethnic-racial socialization: Learning about race and ethnicity among African American students. Urban Review, 47, 563–576.
4.
AmosY. T. (2016). Wanted and used: Latina bilingual education teachers at public schools. Equity & Excellence in Education, 49(1), 41–56.
5.
BañalesJ.HoffmanA. J.Rivas-DrakeD.JagersR. J. (2020). The development of ethnic-racial identity process and its relation to civic beliefs among Latinx and Black American adolescents. Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 49, 2495–2508. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10964-020-01254-6
6.
BanksJ. A. (1999). An introduction to multicultural education (2nd ed.). Boston, MA: Allyn & Bacon.
Bonilla-SilvaE. (2006). Racism without racists: Color-blind racism and the persistence of racial inequality in the United States. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.
9.
BradyL. M.GermanoA. L.FrybergS. A. (2017). Leveraging cultural differences to promote education equality. Current Opinion in Psychology, 18, 79–83.
10.
BrownK. D.BrownA. L. (2011). Teaching K-8 students about race: African Americans, racism, and the struggle for social justice in the US. Multicultural Education, 19(1), 9–13.
11.
BuchananL. B. (2015). “We make it controversial”: Elementary preservice teachers’ beliefs about race. Teacher Education Quarterly, 42(1), 3–26.
12.
CabreraN. L.ChangR. S. (2019). Stats, social justice, and the limits of interest convergence: The story of Tuscon Unified School District’s Mexican American Studies litigation [Education, Law, and the Courts: Communities in the Struggle for Equality and Equity in Public Education]. Association of Mexican American Educators Journal, 13.
13.
CabreraN. L.MilemJ. F.JaquetteO.MarxR. W. (2014). Missing the (student achievement) forest for all the (political) trees: Empiricism and the Mexican American studies controversy in Tucson. American Educational Research Journal, 51, 1084–1118.
14.
CammarotaJ. (2007). A social justice approach to achievement: Guiding Latina/o students toward educational attainment with a challenging, socially relevant curriculum. Equity and Excellence in Education, 40, 87–96.
15.
Carver-ThomasD. (2018). Diversifying the teaching profession: How to recruit and retain teachers of color. Learning Policy Institute.
16.
CastagnoA. E. (2014). Educated in whiteness: Good intentions and diversity in schools. University of Minnesota Press.
17.
ChavousT. M.BernatD. H.Schmeelk-ConeK.CaldwellC. H.Kohn-WoodL.ZimmermanM. A. (2003). Racial identity and academic attainment among African American adolescents. Child Development, 74(4), 1076–1090. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-8624.00593
18.
CherngH. Y. S.DavisL. A. (2019). Multicultural matters: An investigation of key assumptions of multicultural education reform in teacher education. Journal of Teacher Education, 70(3), 219–236.
19.
CivitilloS.JuangL. P.SchachnerM. K. (2018). Challenging beliefs about cultural diversity in education: A synthesis and critical review of trainings with pre-service teachers. Educational Research Review, 24, 67–83.
20.
CoffeyH. (2010). “They taught me”: The benefits of early community-based field experiences in teacher education. Teaching and Teacher Education, 26(2), 335–342.
21.
CohenG. L.GarciaJ.ApfelN.MasterA. (2006). Reducing the racial achievement gap: A social-psychological intervention. Science, 313, 1307–1310.
22.
CorkinD. M. S.EkmekciA.FisherA. (2020). Integrating culture, art, geometry, and coding to enhance computer science motivation among underrepresented minoritized high school students. The Urban Review, 52, 950–969.
23.
DeeT. S.PennerE. K. (2017). The causal effects of cultural relevance: Evidence from an ethnic studies curriculum. American Educational Research Journal, 54, 127–166. http://dx.doi.org/10.3102/0002831216677002
24.
de los RíosC.V.LópezJ.MorrellE. (2015). Toward a critical pedagogy of race: Ethnic studies and literacies of power in high school classrooms. Race and Social Problems, 7(1), 84–96. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12552-014-9142-1
25.
Del ToroJ.WangM.-T. (2020). School cultural socialization and academic performance: Examining ethnic-racial identity development as a mediator among African American adolescents. Child Development. https://doi.org/10.1111/cdev.13467
26.
DiemerM. A.LiC. H. (2011). Critical consciousness development and political participation among marginalized youth. Child Development, 82, 1815–1833.
27.
DodgeK. A. (2011). Context matters in child and family policy. Child Development, 82, 433–442.
28.
DuboisW. E. B. (1935). Black reconstruction in America 1860-1880. Harcourt, Brace, and Company.
29.
Duncan-AndradeJ. M. R.MorrellE. (2008). The art of critical pedagogy: Possibilities from moving theory to practice in urban schools. Peter Lang.
30.
DupreeC. H. (in press). Experts are people, too: How attitudes and cognition impact experts’ progress toward racial equality. Psychological Inquiry.
31.
EgaliteA. J.KisidaB. (2018). The effects of teacher match on students’ academic perceptions and attitudes. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 40(1), 59–81.
32.
EigenbergH. M.ParkS. M. (2016). Marginalization and invisibility of women of color: A content analysis of race and gender in introductory criminal justice and criminology texts. Race & Justice, 6(3), 257–279.
FreireP. (1970). Pedagogy of the oppressed. Continuum.
36.
FrybergS.A.StephensN.M. (2010). When the world is colorblind, American Indians are invisible: A diversity science approach. Psychological Inquiry, 21, 115–119.
37.
GershensonS.HartC. M.HymanJ.LindsayC.PapageorgeN. W. (2018). The long-run impacts of same-race teachers (No. w25254). National Bureau of Economic Research.
38.
GinwrightS. (2000). Identity for sale: The limits of racial reform in urban schools. The Urban Review, 32, 87–104.
39.
GistC. D.BiancoM.LynnM. (2019). Examining Grow Your Own programs across the teacher development continuum: Mining research on teachers of color and nontraditional educator pipelines. Journal of Teacher Education, 70(1), 13–25.
40.
GivensJ. R. (2021). Fugitive pedagogy: Carter G. Woodson and the art of Black teaching. Harvard University Press.
41.
GlasfordD. E.JohnstonB. (2018). Respect the technique: Status-based respect increases minority group social cohesion with majority groups, while also increasing minority collective action tendencies. The Journal of Social Psychology, 158(2), 201–214.
42.
GodfreyE. B.SantosC. E.BursonE. (2019). For better or worse? System justifying beliefs in sixth grade predict trajectories of self-esteem and behavior across early adolescence. Child Development, 90, 180–195.
43.
HazariZ.SonnertG.SadlerP.ShanahanM. (2010). Connecting high school physics experiences, outcome expectations, physics identity, and physics career choice: A gender study. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 47, 978–1003.
44.
HeberleA. E.RapaL. J.FaragoF. (2020). Critical consciousness in children and adolescents: A systematic review, critical assessment, and recommendations for future research. Psychological Bulletin, 146(6), 525–551.
45.
HeiligJ. V.BrownK. D.BrownA. L. (2012). The illusion of inclusion: A critical race theory textual analysis of race and standards. Harvard Educational Review, 82, 43–424.
46.
HineD. C. (1992). The Black studies movement: Afrocentric traditionalist-feminist paradigms for the next stage. The Black Scholar, 22, 11–18.
47.
hooksB. (2014). Teaching to transgress. Routledge.
48.
HopeE. C.SkoogA. B.JagersR. J. (2015). “It’ll never be the white kids, it’ll always be us”: Black high school students’ evolving critical analysis of racial discrimination and inequity in schools. Journal of Adolescent Research, 30, 83–112.
49.
HorneT. (2010). Findings by the state superintendent of public instruction of violation by Tucson Unified School District pursuant to A.R.S.§15-112(B). Phoenix: State of Arizona Department of Education.
50.
HorowitzE.SorensenN.YoderN.OysermanD. (2018). Teachers can do it: Scalable identity-based motivation intervention in the classroom. Contemporary Educational Psychology, 54, 12–28.
51.
HughesJ. M.BiglerR. S.LevyS. R. (2007). Consequences of learning about historical racism among European American and African American children. Child Development, 78(6), 1689–1705.
52.
IJzermanH.LewisN. A.JrPrzybylskiA. K.WeinsteinN.DeBruineL.RitchieS.VazireS.ForscherP. S.MoreyR.IvoryJ. D.AnvariF. (2020). Use caution when applying behavioural science to policy. Nature Human Behaviour, 4(11), 1092–1094.
53.
JonesJ. M. (2016). The colorblind racial approach: Does race really matter? In NevilleH. A.GallardoM. E.SueD. W. (Eds.), The myth of racial color blindness: Manifestations, dynamics, and impact (pp. 39–52). American Psychological Association.
54.
JostJ. T. (2019). A quarter century of system justification theory: Questions, answers, criticisms, and societal applications. British Journal of Social Psychology. https://doi.org/10.1111/bjso.12297
55.
KeenanH. B. (2019). Selective memory: California mission history and the problem of historical violence in elementary school textbooks. Teachers College Record, 121(8), 1–28.
56.
KeenanH. B. (2020). The Trans Educators Network: A reflection on community organizing and knowledge production. Teaching Education, 31(1), 84–97.
57.
KhanB.RobbinsC.OkrentA. (2020). The state of U.S. science and engineering 2020. National Science Foundation.
58.
KingJ. E.SwartzE. E. (2016). The Afrocentric praxis of teaching for freedom: Connecting culture to learning. Taylor & Francis.
59.
KiskerE. E.LipkaJ.AdamsB. L.RickardA.Andrew-IhrkeD.YanezE. E.MillardA. (2012). The potential of a culturally based supplemental mathematics curriculum to improve the mathematics performance of Alaska Native and other students. Journal for Research in Mathematics Education, 43(1), 75–113.
60.
KohliR. (2018). Behind school doors: The impact of hostile racial climates on urban teachers of color. Urban Education, 53(3), 307–333.
61.
KohliR. (2019). Lessons for teacher education: The role of critical professional development in teacher of color retention. Journal of Teacher Education, 70(1), 39–50.
LajimodiereD. K. (2019). Stringing rosaries: The history, unforgivable, and the healing of Northern Plains American Indian boarding school survivors. North Dakota State University Press.
64.
Ladson-BillingsG. (1995). Toward a theory of culturally relevant pedagogy. American Educational Research Journal, 32, 465–491.
65.
Ladson-BillingsG. (2006). From the achievement gap to the education debt: Understanding achievement in U.S. schools. Educational Researcher, 35, 3–12.
66.
LedgerwoodA.PickettC.NavarroD.RemediosJ. D.LewisN. A.Jr. (in press). The unbearable limitations of solo science: Team science as a path for more rigorous and relevant research. Behavioral and Brain Sciences.
67.
LewisN. A.Jr. (in press). Can we achieve “equality” when we have different understandings of its meaning? How contexts and identities shape the pursuit of egalitarian goals. Psychological Inquiry.
68.
LewisN. A.Jr. (2021). What counts as good science? How the battle for methodological legitimacy affects public psychology. American Psychologist.
69.
LiuK. (2015). Critical reflection as a framework for transformative learning in teacher education. Educational Review, 67, 135–157.
70.
LuterD.MitchellA.TaylorH. (2017). Critical consciousness and schooling: The impact of the community as a classroom program on academic indicators. Education Sciences, 7, Article 25.
71.
McDonaldM.TysonK.BraykoK.BowmanM.DelportJ.ShimomuraF. (2011). Innovation and impact in teacher education: Community-based organizations as field placements for preservice teachers. Teachers College Record, 113(8), 1668–1700.
72.
McLeanK. C.SyedM. (2015). Personal, master, and alternative narratives: An integrative framework for understanding identity development in context. Human Development, 58(6), 318–349.
73.
MillerP. M.BrownT.HopsonR. (2011). Centering Love, Hope, and Trust in the Community: Transformative Urban Leadership Informed by Paulo Freire. Urban Education, 46(5), 1078–1099. https://doi.org/10.1177/0042085910395951
74.
Miller-CottoD.LewisN. A.Jr. (in press). Am I a “math person”?How classroom cultures shape math identity among Black and Latinx students.
75.
MistryR. S.BrownC. S.ChowK. A.CollinsG. S. (2012). Increasing the complexity of young adolescents’ beliefs about poverty and inequality: Results of an 8th grade social studies curriculum intervention. Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 41(6), 704–716.
76.
CarlosMuñoz. (2007). Youth, identity, power: the Chicano movement. Verso.
77.
National Center for Education Statistics (NCES). (2019). U.S. Department of Education. Institute of Education Sciences.
78.
NelsenM. (2020). Educating for empowerment: Race, socialization, and reimagining civic education [Unpublished dissertation]. Northwestern University.
79.
NelsenM. (2021). Cultivating youth engagement: Race & the behavioral effects of critical pedagogy. Political Behavior, 43, 1–34.
80.
O’BrienL. T.MarsD. E.EcclestonC. (2011). System-justifying ideologies and academic outcomes among first-year Latino college students. Cultural Diversity and Ethnic Minority Psychology, 17(4), 406–414.
81.
OwensL. M.EnnisC. D. (2005). The ethic of care in teaching: An overview of supportive literature. Quest, 57(4), 392–425.
82.
OysermanD.LewisN. A.Jr. (2017). Seeing the destination AND the path: Using identity-based motivation to understand and reduce racial disparities in academic achievement. Social Issues and Policy Review, 11(1), 159–194.
83.
PahlkeE.BiglerR. S.MartinC. L. (2014). Can fostering children’s ability to challenge sexism improve critical analysis, internalization, and enactment of inclusive, egalitarian peer relationships?Journal of Social Issues, 70(1), 115–133.
84.
PahlkeE.BiglerR. S.SuizzoM. A. (2012). Relations between colorblind socialization and children’s racial bias: Evidence from European American mothers and their preschool children. Child Development, 83(4), 1164–1179.
85.
PerryS. P.Skinner-DorkenooA. L.AbaiedJ. L.WatersS. F. (in press). Applying the evidence we have: Support for having race conversations in White U.S. families. Perspectives on Psychological Science.
86.
RichmondG. (2017). The power of community partnership in the preparation of teachers. Journal of Teacher Education, 68(1), 6–8.
87.
RiordanC. (1990). Girls and boys in school: Together or separate?Teachers College Press.
88.
Rivas-DrakeD.SeatonE.MarkstromC.QuintanaS.SyedM.LeeR. M.SchwartzS. J.Umaña-TaylorA. J.FrenchS.YipT. (2014). Ethnic and racial identity in adolescence: Implications for psychosocial, academic, and health outcomes. Child Development, 85, 40–57.
89.
SampsonD.Garrison-WadeD. F. (2011). Cultural vibrancy: Exploring the preferences of African American children toward culturally relevant and non-culturally relevant lessons. The Urban Review, 43, 279–309.
90.
Sánchez TapiaI.KrajcikJ.ReiserB. (2017). “We do not know what is the real story anymore”: Curricular contextualization principles that support indigenous students in understanding natural selection. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 55, 348–376. https://doi.org/10.1002/tea.21422
91.
San PedroT. (2018). Abby as Ally: An argument for culturally disruptive pedagogy. American Educational Research Jounal, 55, 1193–1232.
92.
SaricM.StehB. (2017). Critical reflection in the professional development of teachers: Challenges and possibilities. CEPS Journal, 7(3), 67–85.
93.
SeiderS.GravesD. (2020). Schooling for critical consciousness. Harvard Education Press.
94.
SeidlB.FriendG. (2002). Leaving authority at the door: Equal-status community-based experiences and the preparation of teachers for diverse classrooms. Teaching and Teacher Education, 18(4), 421–433.
95.
SleeterC. E. (2011). The academic and social value of ethnic studies: A research review. Washington, DC: National Education Association.
96.
SleeterC. E. (2016) Multicultural programming New Mexico. Expert witnessreport to MALDEF prepared for Martinez v. New Mexico, D-101-CV-2014-00793.
97.
SleeterC. E.ZavalaM. (2020). Transformative ethnic studies in schools: Curriculum, pedagogy, and research. Teachers College Press.
98.
TaieS.GoldringR. (2020). Characteristics of public and private elementary and secondary school teachers in the United States: Results from the 2017-18 national teacher and principal survey first look (NCES 2020-142). National Center for Education Statistics.
99.
VillegasA. M.IrvineJ. J. (2010). Diversifying the teaching force: An examination of major arguments. The Urban Review, 42(3), 175–192.
100.
WeismanE. M.HansenL. E. (2008). Student teaching in urban and suburban schools: Perspectives of Latino preservice teachers. Urban Education, 43(6), 653–670.
101.
WhiteI.LorenziF.O’Higgins NormanJ. (2018). Fighting words as revolutionary pedagogy: a Freirean reading of young people’s experiences of a socially-engaged creative writing centre. Pastoral Care in Education, 36, 271–285. https://doi.org/10.1080/02643944.2018.1527389
102.
WhiteE. S.MistryR. S.ChowK. A. (2013). How do teachers talk about economic inequality? The complexity of teaching at a socioeconomically integrated elementary school. Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy, 13(1), 370–394.
103.
WigganG. (2008). From opposition to engagement: Lessons from high achieving African American students. The Urban Review, 40(4), 317–349.
104.
WilsonT. D.DamianiM.SheltonN. (2002). Improving the academic performance of college students with brief attributional interventions. In AronsonJ. (Ed.), Improving academic achievement: Impact of psychological factors on education (pp. 91–110). Academic Press.
105.
WoodsonC. G. (2011). The mis-education of the negro. Oshun Publishing Company.
ZeichnerK.BowmanM.GuillenL.NapolitanK. (2016). Engaging and working in solidarity with local communities in preparing the teachers of their children. Journal of Teacher Education, 67(4), 277–290.
