This case study explores potential educational tensions in historical empathy for learning about emotionally difficult topics through lessons that use dramatic feature films (movies). It investigates one case of historical empathy in the classroom by analyzing what a high-school teacher and her students do and talk about in class. The observed lesson was part of the teacher’s unit on World War II and the Holocaust in a World History course using the 2002 Academy Awardwinning film The Pianist. The conclusion interprets this case as an example of how the visual and emotional power of movies may lead some students to “overempathize “ and feel that they can “really” know what a historical perspective must have been like. The “caring” aspect of historical empathy has the potential to overrun historical context and override other educational goals like learning and applying content knowledge.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BartonK. C. & Levstik L. S. (2004). Teaching history for the common good. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
2.
BartovO. (1997). Spielberg’s Oskar: Hollywood tries evil. In LoshitzkyY. (Ed.), Spielberg’s Holocaust: Critical perspectives on Schindler’s List (pp. 41-60). Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
3.
BritzmanD. P. (1998). Lost subjects, contested objects: Toward a psychoanalytic inquiry of learning. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press.
4.
BrooksS. (2009). Historical empathy in the social studies classroom: A review of the literature. The Journal of Social Studies Research. 33(2), 213-234.
5.
DavisO. L.Jr., YeagerE. A., & FosterS. J. (Eds.). (2001). Historical empathy and perspective taking in the social studies. Oxford: Rowman and Littlefield Publishers, Inc.
6.
DonnellyM. B. (2006). Educating students about the Holocaust: A survey of teaching practices. Social Education, 70(1), 51-54.
7.
FallaceT. D. (2008). The emergence of Holocaust education in American schools. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
8.
GoldsteinP. (1995). Teaching Schindler’s List. Social Education, 59(6), 362-364.
9.
LevyS. A. (2010, May). Teacher educators’ constructions of Holocaust narratives. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Denver, CO.
10.
LoshitzkyY. (Ed.). (1997). Spielberg’s Holocaust: Critical perspectives on Schindler’s List. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
11.
MarcusA. S. (2005). “It is as it was”: Feature film in the history classroom. The Social Studies, 96(2), 61-67.
12.
MarcusA. S. (Ed.) (2007). Celluloid blackboard: Teaching history with film. Charlotte, NC: Information Age Publishing.
13.
MarcusA. S.MetzgerS. A., PaxtonR. J., & StoddardJ. D. (2010). Teaching history with film: Strategies for secondary social studies. New York: Routledge.
14.
MarcusA. S.PaxtonR. J., & MeyersonP. (2006). “The reality of it all”: History students read the movies. Theory and Research in Social Education, 34(3), 516-552.
15.
MetzgerS. A. (2007). Pedagogy and the historical feature film: Toward historical literacy. Film and History, 37(2), 67-75.
16.
MetzgerS. A. (2010). Maximizing the educational power of history movies in the classroom. The Social Studies, 101(3), 127-136.
17.
MetzgerS. A. & Suh Y. (2008). Significant or safe? Two cases of instructional uses of history feature films. Theory and Research in Social Education, 36(1), 88-109.
18.
NovickP. (1999). The Holocaust in American life. New York: Houghton Mifflin Company.
19.
Paxton, R. J., & Meyerson, P. (2002, April). From “Birth of a Nation” to “Pearl Harbor”: The influence of a movie’s perspective on students’ historical understandings. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, New Orleans, LA.
20.
RussellW. (2004). Teaching with film: A guide for social studies teachers. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 530820).
21.
RussellW. (2009). Teaching social issues with film. Charlotte, NC: Information Age Publishing.
22.
RussellW. (2012a). The reel history of the world: Teaching world history with major motion pictures. Social Education, 76(1), 22-28
23.
RussellW. (2012b). The art of teaching social studies with film. The Clearing House: A Journal of Educational Strategies, Issues, and Ideas, 85(4), 157-164.
24.
RussellW. (2012c). Teaching with film: A research study of secondary social studies teachers’ use of film. The Journal of Social Studies Education Research. 3(1).
25.
Scheiner-FisherC. & RussellW. (2012). Using historical films to promote gender equity in the history curriculum. The Social Studies, 103(6), 221-225.
26.
SchweberS. (2006). “Holocaust fatigue” in teaching today. Social Education, 70(1), 44-50.
27.
SeixasP. (1993). Popular film and young people’s understanding of the history of Native-American-White relations. The History Teacher, 26(3), 351-370.
28.
SeixasP. (1994). Confronting the moral frames of popular film: Young people respond to historical revisionism. American Journal of Education, 102(3), 261-285.
29.
StoddardJ. D. (2007). Attempting to understand the lives of others: Film as a tool for developing historical empathy. In MarcusA. S. (Ed.), Celluloid blackboard: Teaching history with film (pp. 187-214). Charlotte, NC: Information Age Publishing.
30.
StoddardJ. D. & Marcus A. S. (2006). The burden of historical representation: Race, freedom and “educational” Hollywood film. Film and History, 36(1), 26-35.
31.
VanSledrightB. A. (2011). The challenge of rethinking history education: On practices, theories, and policy. New York, NY: Routledge.
32.
WertschJ. V. (2002). Voices of collective remembering. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
33.
WineburgS. (2001). Historical thinking and other unnatural acts: Charting the future of teaching the past. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
34.
WineburgS.MosborgS. & PoratD. (2000). What can Forrest Gump tell us about students’ historical understanding?Social Education. 65(1), 55-58.
35.
WineburgS.MosborgS.PoratD. & DuncanA. (2007). Common belief and the cultural curriculum: An intergenerational study of historical consciousness. American Educational Research Journal, 44(1), 40-76.
36.
WillsJ. S. (1994). Popular culture, curriculum, and historical representation: The situation of Native Americans in American history and the perpetuation of popular stereotypes. Journal of Narrative and Life History, 4(4), 277-294.
