Pan-Jewish Solidarity and the Jewish Significance of Modern Israel: The 1958 “Who Is a Jew?” Affair Revisited

Abstract

The focus of this article is the 1958 “Who is a Jew?” controversy and David Ben-Gurion’s inquiry into Jewishness leading intellectuals from Israel and the Diaspora regarding how to register a child born to a non-Jewish mother in the Israeli identity card. The article’s main claim is that this correspondence must be understood not only as reflecting a continuous struggle between diaspora and Israeli Jews or between Jews of various religious persuasions, but rather as reflecting a built-in tension between pan-Jewish solidarity and Israeli Jewish sovereignty. This built-in tension seems to prevail today as well, and thus our analysis of the 1958 event may enable a more complex understanding of the continuous and seemingly unresolved tensions within today’s Jewish world.

Keywords

Israel religion and state David Ben-Gurion diaspora nationalism diaspora-homeland relations

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ben-Rafael

(2002). Jewish identities–Fifty intellectuals answer Ben-Gurion . Leiden and Boston, MA: Brill.

Don-Yehiya

(2002). Religion, nationality, and politics: The crisis over ‘who is a Jew’, 1958. In Bar-on

Zameret

(Eds.), On both sides of the bridge: Religion and state in the early years of Israel (pp. 88–143). Jerusalem: Yad Izhak Ben-Zvi Press. [Hebrew]

Eilam

(2000). Judaism as status quo . Tel Aviv: Am Oved.

Goldman

(2018). David Ben-Gurion asks 51 Jewish scholars: ‘Who is a Jew?’. Tablet . Retrieved from https://www.tabletmag.com/jewish-arts-and-culture/275873/david-ben-gurion-who-is-a-jew

Kedar

(2009). Mamlakhtiyut, David Ben-Gurion’s civic thought . Jerusalem: The Ben-Gurion Research Institute Press and Yad Ben-Zvi Press. [Hebrew]

Kedar

(2013). Ben-Gurion’s view of the place of Judaism in Israel. Journal of Israeli History , 32(2), 157–174.

Leibowitz

(1995). Judaism, human values, and the Jewish state . Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Litvin

Heoning

S. B.

(1965). Jewish Identity: Modern responsa and opinions on the registration of children of mixed marriages, David Ben-Gurion’s query to leaders of world Jewry, a documentary compilation . New York, NY: Philipp Feldheim. [republished in a second edition in 2013].

Shiff

(2011). Abba Hillel Silver and David Ben-Gurion, a diaspora leader challenges the revered status of the founding father. Studies in Ethnicity and Nationalism , 10(3), 391–421.

10.

Silver

A. H.

(1958). What is a Jew? The answer to the Maccabees (Abba Hillel Silver Archives, Microfilm edition, Series IV Folder 1018, Sermon No. 939).

11.

Zameret

(1999). Judaism in Israel: Ben-Gurion’s private beliefs and public policy. Israel Studies , 4(2), 64–89.