Comparing China’s Claims and Policies in the East and South China Seas: Implications for Regional Security

Abstract

What is the long-term impact of China’s territorial and maritime security policy in East Asia on regional security? To address this question, we compared China’s claims and actual policies related to the East China Sea and South China Sea and explored the motivations behind Beijing’s position and behaviour in the two disputes. More specifically, we examined a few interrelated issues: (a) similarities and differences in China’s claims in these two disputes from historical and legal perspectives, (b) China’s strategic and security calculations and its changing tactics in handing these two disputes in the past few years and (c) the major factors affecting China’s behaviour in the two disputes. Our conclusion is that China is unlikely to make any major concessions in the near future, and that regional security in East Asia will remain fraught with many uncertainties for a fairly long period of time.

Keywords

East China Sea dispute South China Sea dispute Chinese maritime security policy East Asian security

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Buszynski, L.

(2010). Rising tensions in the South China Sea: Prospects for a resolution of the issue. Security Challenges, 6(2), 85–104, 101–102. Retrieved 11 November 2015, from http://www.regionalsecurity.org.au/Resources/Documents/vol6no2Buszynski.pdf

China Daily . (2014, December 7). China’s position paper on South China Sea. China Daily. Retrieved 2 June 2016, from http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/china/2014-12/07/content_19037946.htm

Desker, B.

(2015, November 3). South China Sea tensions: Unlikely to lead to war. RSIS Commentaries. Retrieved 11 November 2015, from http://www.rsis.edu.sg/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/CO15233.pdf

Dzurek, D.J.

(1996). The Spratly Islands dispute: Who’s on first? IBRU Maritime Briefing, 2 (1), 16–17.

Gao, Z., & Jia, B. (2013, January). The nine-dash line in the South China Sea: History, status, and implications. American Society of International Law, 107 (1), 98–124.

Glaser, B.S.

(2014, December 16). Beijing determined to advance sovereignty claims in South China Sea. The Interpreter. Retrieved 11 November 2015, from http://www.lowyinterpreter.org/post/2014/12/16/Beijing-determined-advance-sovereignty-claims-South-China-Sea.aspx

Glaser, B.S., & Szalwinski, A. (2013, August 9). Major country diplomacy with Chinese characteristics. China Brief, 13(16), 9–12. Retrieved 11 November 2015, from http://www.jamestown.org/programs/chinabrief/single/?tx_ttnews%5Btt_news%5D=41253&cHash=0a8feca702f07ed9446305974da9d0d3#.Vu5K_uRf0_w

Hagström, L.

(2015). The Sino-Japanese battle for soft power: Pitfalls and promises. Global Affairs, 1(2), 131–132, 129–137. doi:10.1080/23340460.2015.990798

Han, P.

(Ed.). (2008, June 18). China, Japan reach principled consensus on East China Sea issue. Xinhua News. Retrieved 11 November 2015, from http://news.xinhuanet.com/english/2008-06/18/content_8394206.htm

10.

Holmes, J.R.

(2012, December 14). A competitive turn: How increased Chinese maritime actions complicate U.S. partnerships. East and South China Seas Bulletin, 7, 1–6. Retrieved 10 October 2015, from http://www.cnas.org/content/bulletin-7-competitive-turn-how-increased-chinese-maritime-actions-complicate-us

11.

Huang, J.

(2013, November 22). Southeast Asian perspective: China and international law/norms. National Commentaries. Retrieved 10 October 2015, from http://www.theasanforum.org/southeast-asia-perspective/

12.

International Court of Justice. (1969, February 20). North Sea continental shelf cases: Judgment of 20 February 1969, pp. 4–57. Retrieved 10 October 2015, from http://www.icj-cij.org/docket/index.php?sum=295&code=cs2&p1=3&p2=3&case=52&k=cc&p3=5

13.

International Crisis Group. (2013, April 8). Dangerous waters: China–Japan relations on the rocks (Crisis Group Asia Report No. 245, pp. 1–63). Retrieved 10 October 2015, from http://www.crisisgroup.org/~/media/Files/asia/north-east-asia/245-dangerous-waters-china-japan-relations-on-the-rocks.pdf

14.

International Crisis Group. (2014, July 24). Old scores and new grudges: Evolving Sino-Japanese tensions (Crisis Group Asia Report, 258, pp. 1–52). Retrieved 10 October 2015, from http://www.crisisgroup.org/~/media/Files/asia/north-east-asia/258-old-scores-and-grudges-evolving-sino-japanese-tensions.pdf

15.

Jakobson, L.

(2014, December 11). China’s unpredictable maritime security actors (Lowy Institute for International Policy Report). Retrieved 10 October 2015, from http://www.lowyinstitute.org/files/chinas-unpredictable-maritime-security-actors_3.pdf

16.

Japan Times . (2015, March 14). Japan, China eye May talks on maritime crisis management mechanism. Retrieved 10 March 2016, from http://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2015/03/14/national/japan-china-eye-may-talks-on-maritime-crisis-management-mechanism/#.VuviQNJAWlV

17.

Jia, X.

(2013). Zhongguo fachu haiyang weiquan zui qiangyin [China expresses strong voices to safeguard its maritime rights]. Fazhi Yu Jingji, (9), 21.

18.

Jin, Y.

(2012). Zhongguo nanhai duanxuxian de xingzhi ji xian nei shuiyu de falv diwei [The nature of the Chinese dotted line in the South China Sea and the legal status of the waters within the line]. Zhongguo faxue [China law studies], 6(6), 38–50.

19.

Johnson, A.I.

(2013). How new and assertive is China’s new assertiveness? International Security, 37(4, Spring), 7–48.

20.

Kaplan, R.

(2011, August 15). The South China Sea is the future of conflict. Foreign Policy. Retrieved 2 June 2016, from http://foreignpolicy.com/2011/08/15/the-south-china-sea-is-the-future-of-conflict/

21.

Lee, L.T., & Chen, S. (2009). China and joint development in the South China Sea: An energy security perspective. In

Bateman &

Emmers (Eds), Security and international politics in the South China Sea: Towards a cooperative management (pp. 155–171). New York: Routledge.

22.

Li, M.

(2015). The people’s liberation army and China’s smart power quandary in Southeast Asia. Journal of Strategic Studies, 38(3), 359–382. doi:10.1080/01402390.2014.1002910

23.

Li, X., & Zhang, Y. (2015, October 27). US warned over patrol by warship. China Daily. Retrieved 2 June 2016, from http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/world/2015-10/27/content_22300929.htm

24.

Manicom, J.

(2013, September 12). China’s energy development in the East China Sea. China Brief, 13(18), 6–9. Retrieved 2 June 2016, from http://www.jamestown.org/programs/chinabrief/single/?tx_ttnews%5Btt_news%5D=41349#.Vu1wq-Rf0_w

25.

Manicom, J.

(2014). Bridging troubled waters: China, Japan, and maritime order in the East China Sea. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.

26.

Martinson, R.D.

(2014a, November 21). The militarization of China’s coast guard. The Diplomat. Retrieved 2 June 2016, from http://thediplomat.com/2014/11/the-militarization-of-chinas-coast-guard/

27.

Martinson, R.D.

(2014b, December 18). Chinese maritime activism: Strategy or vagary? A new study questions the conventional wisdom of a coordinated national strategy. The Diplomat. Retrieved 2 June 2016, from http://thediplomat.com/2014/12/chinese-maritime-activism-strategy-or-vagary/

28.

McDevitt, M.

(2015, January 12). Beijing leaves little room for compromise in South China Sea. The Interpreter. Retrieved 10 October 2015, from http://www.lowyinterpreter.org/post/2015/01/12/Beijing-leaves-little-room-for-compromise-in-South-China-Sea.aspx

29.

Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Japan. (2015, August 6). Japan’s legal position on the development of natural resources in the East China Sea. Retrieved 21 February, 2016, from http://www.mofa.go.jp/a_o/c_m1/page3e_000358.html

30.

New York Times . (2015, February 5). Japan says China aimed military radar at ship. Retrieved 2 June 2016, from http://www.nytimes.com/2013/02/06/world/asia/japan-china-islands-dispute.html?_r=0

31.

PRC Ministry of Foreign Affairs. (2012). Foreign ministry spokesperson Hong Lei’s regular press conference on 29 February 2012. Retrieved 2 June 2016, from http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/mfa_eng/xwfw_665399/s2510_665401/2511_665403/t910855.shtml

32.

PRC Ministry of Foreign Affairs. (2014, August 9). Wang Yi: Handle the South China Sea issue through the ‘dual-track’ approach. Retrieved 10 October 2015, from http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/mfa_eng/zxxx_662805/t1181523.shtml

33.

PRC State Council Information Office. (2012, September). Diaoyu Dao, an inherent territory of China. Retrieved 10 October 2015, from http://www.scio.gov.cn/zfbps/gfbps/Document/1435334/1435334.htm

34.

Reilly, J.

(2013, March). A wave to worry about? Public opinion, foreign policy and China’s anti-Japan protests. Journal of Contemporary China, 23(86), 197–215. doi:10.1080/10670564.2013.832519

35.

Sun, U.

(2014, April 25). Backgrounder: The US role in the Diaoyu Islands dispute. China Daily. Retrieved 2 June 2016, from http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/world/2014-04/25/content_17465180.htm

36.

Swaine, M.

(2013, April). Chinese views regarding the Senkaku/Diaoyu Islands dispute. China Leadership Monitor, 41. Retrieved 2 June 2016, from http://media.hoover.org/sites/default/files/documents/CLM41MS.pdf

37.

Taylor, F.

(2011). China’s strategy in the South China Sea. Contemporary Southeast Asia, 33(3), 305. Retrieved 2 June 2016, from http://taylorfravel.com/documents/research/fravel.2011.CSA.china.strategy.scs.pdf

38.

Taylor, F.

(2012, November 1). China’s island strategy: ‘Redefine the status quo’. The Diplomat. Retrieved 24 July 2015, from http://thediplomat.com/2012/11/chinas-island-strategy-redefine-the-status-quo/

39.

United Nations. (2010, July 8). Indonesia, communication submitted to UN CLCS, 480/POL-703/VII/10, New York. Retrieved 22 September 2015, from http://www.un.org/Depts/los/clcs_new/submissions_files/mysvnm33_09/idn_2010re_mys_vnm_e.pdf

40.

United Nations. (2011, May 3). Malaysia and Vietnam, joint submission to UN CLCS: Commission on the limits of the continental shelf (CLCS), outer limits of the continental shelf beyond 200 nautical miles from the baselines. Retrieved 22 September 2015, from http://www.un.org/Depts/los/clcs_new/submissions_files/submission_mysvnm_33_2009.htm

41.

Wain, B.

(2008, January/February). Manila’s bungle in the South China Sea. Far Eastern Economic Review, 171(1), 45–48. Retrieved 22 September 2015, from http://www.viet-studies.info/kinhte/Manila_South_China_Sea.htm

42.

Wen, X.

(2012, April 8). Meifang zaidu baolu ‘hunshuimoyu’qitu [The US exposed its intention of ‘fishing in the muddy water’]. Renmin ribao [People’s Daily]. Retrieved 2 June 2016, from http://paper.people.com.cn/rmrb/html/2012-08/04/nw.D110000renmrb_20120804_1-03.html

43.

Xinhua News . (2014, November 7). China, Japan reach four-point agreement on ties. Retrieved 12 March 2016, from http://news.xinhuanet.com/english/china/2014-11/07/c_133772952.htm

44.

Xinhua News . (2015, April 9). Foreign Ministry: Strongly opposed to using the US–Japan alliance to harm the interest of a third party. Retrieved 10 March 2016, from http://news.xinhuanet.com/world/2015-04/09/c_1114920615.htm

45.

Xue, L.

(2014, August 11). Zhongguo yinggai zai huanhe Nanhai zhengduanshang yousuozuowei [China should do something to alleviate tension in the South China Sea]. Jinrong shibao [Financial Times Chinese version]. Retrieved 2 June 2016, from http://www.ftchinese.com/story/001057663?full=y

46.

Xu, J., & Ma, L. (2015, June 30). Nanhai wenti cheng ‘yidai yilu’ guanjian zhanlue hezuo jidai jiaqiang [The South China Sea disputes is the key for the ‘One Belt One Road’: Strategic cooperation needs to be strengthened]. Renmin wang [People’s Daily Online]. Retrieved 10 October 2015, from http://scitech.people.com.cn/n/2015/0630/c1007-27228962.html

47.

Yahuda, M.

(2013). China’s new assertiveness in the South China Sea. Journal of Contemporary China, 22(81), 446–459. Retrieved 10 March 2015, from http://myweb.rollins.edu/tlairson/china/chiassertsea.pdf

48.

You, J.

(2013, October). Deciphering Beijing’s maritime security policy and strategy in managing sovereignty disputes in the China Seas. S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies, Singapore. Retrieved 2 June 2016, from http://www.rsis.edu.sg/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/PB131001_Deciphering_Beijing_Martime_Security_Policy.pdf

49.

Yu, Z.

(2012). Donghai weiquan—Zhongri donghai Diaoyudao zhizheng [Rights protection in the East China Sea: Struggle for the Diaoyu Island, p. 5]. Shanghai: Wenhui.

50.

Yu, Z.

(2014, August 22). Wanshan woguo haiyang weiquan guanli tizhishi zai bixing [Imperative to improve the system of China’s maritime law enforcement]. Zhongguo haiyang bao [China Ocean News]. Retrieved 2 June 2016, from http://epaper.oceanol.com/shtml/zghyb/20140822/18180.shtml

51.

Zhai, X.

(2014, January 20). Shelving the Diaoyu Islands dispute: A tacit consensus and the Abe Cabinet’s policy change. China Institute of International Studies. Retrieved 2 June 2016, from http://www.ciis.org.cn/english/2014-01/20/content_6623684_2.htm

52.

Zhang, J.

(2013). Huangyandao moshi yu Zhongguo Haiyang quanwei zhengce de zhuanxiang [Scarborough Shoal model and the change of Chinese maritime rights protection policies]. Dongnanya yanjiu [Southeast Asian Studies], 4, 25–32.

53.

Zhang, J.

(2014). Dui Nanhai duanxuxian de renshi yu Zhongguo de zhanlue xuanze [The strategic understanding of the nine-dashed line and China’s choices]. Guoji zhengzhi yanjiu [International Political Studies], 2(2), 45–60.

54.

Zhang, X.

(2011, January). Why the 2008 Sino-Japanese consensus on the East China Sea has stalled: Good faith and reciprocity considerations in interim measures pending a maritime boundary delimitation. Ocean Development and International Law, 42(1–2), 53–65. doi:10.1080/00908320.2011.542105

55.

Zhang, Y., Yu, Z., & Dong, X. (2006). Zhongri Donghai guanxia haiyu huafen Zhengyi de fali fenxi [The legal analysis on the Sino-Japanese disputes over East China Sea delimitation]. Haiyang kaifa yu guanli [Ocean Development and Management], (1), 18–20.

56.

Zou, K.

(1999). The Chinese traditional maritime boundary line in the South China Sea and its legal consequences for the resolution of the dispute over the Spratly Islands. The International Journal of Marine and Coastal Law, 14 (1), 27–56.

57.

Zou, K.

(2001). Historic rights in international law and in China’s Practice. Ocean Development and International Law, 32(2), 149–168. doi:10.1080/00908320151100280

58.

Zou, K.

(2012). China’s U-shaped line in the South China Sea revisited. Ocean Development & International Law, 43(1), 23–24, 18–34. doi:10.1080/00908320.2012.647483