While a great deal of research has considered racial disparities in the justice system, there has been a lack of research on Asian populations. This research addresses this omission by conducting a comprehensive examination of policing of Asian victims and suspects. To accomplish this, this study uses NIBRS data to examine variation in arrest for Asian-involved incidents of violent crime. Results indicate that incidents involving Asian victims are more likely to result in arrest than other incidents, but that incidents involving Asian suspects are also especially likely to result in arrest, with the critical exception of instances that involve Black victimization. Taken together, results suggest that the consequence of the unique social position of Asian people in American racial hierarchies is a punishment system that is not uniformly positive or negative, but partially dependent on the role of Asian people in a criminal incident, as either victim or offender.
AddingtonLynn A.2006. “Using National Incident-based Reporting System Murder Data to Evaluate Clearance Predictors: A Research Note.” Homicide Studies10(2):140–52.
2.
AhujaSaritaChlalaRobert. 2013. Widening the Lens on Boys and Men of Color: California AAPI and AMEMSE Perspectives. San Francisco, CA: AAPIP.
3.
AnchetaAngelo N.2006. Race, Rights and the Asian American Experience. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
4.
BaluranDarwin A.2023. “Differential Racialization and Police Interactions among Young Adults of Asian Descent.” Sociology of Race and Ethnicity9(2):220–34.
5.
BediSheila A.2003. “The Constructed Identities of Asian and African Americans: A Story of Two Races and the Criminal Justice System.” Harvard Black Letter Law Journal19:181–99.
6.
BlackDonald. 1976. The Behavior of Law. Leeds, England: Emerald Group Publishing.
7.
Bonilla-SilvaEduardo. 2004. “From Bi-racial to Tri-racial: Towards a New System of Racial Stratification in the USA.” Ethnic and Racial Studies27(6):931–50.
8.
BrunsonRod K.WadeBrian A.2019. “Oh Hell No, We Don’t Talk to Police”: Insights on the Lack of Cooperation in Police Investigations of Urban Gun Violence.” Criminology and Public Policy18(3):623–48.
9.
ChamblissWilliam J.SeidmanRobert B.1971. Law, Order, and Power. Boston, MA: Addison-Wesley.
10.
DaviesElizabeth Jordie. 2022. “The Anti-Black Axis: Rethinking Racial Triangulation. Politics, Groups, and Identities.” Politics, Groups, and Identities10(3):475–80.
11.
DesmondMatthewEmirbayerMustafa. 2009. “What Is Racial Domination?” Du Bois Review: Social Science Research on Race6(2):335–55.
12.
DhananiLindsay Y.FranzBerkeley. 2020. “Unexpected Public Health Consequences of the COVID-19 Pandemic: A National Survey Examining Anti-Asian Attitudes in the USA.” International Journal of Public Health65:747–54.
13.
EichelbergerL.2007. “SARS and New York’s Chinatown: The Politics of Risk and Blame During an Epidemic of Fear.” Social Science & Medicine65:1285–95.
14.
FogliatoRiccardoXiangAliceLiptonZacharyNaginDanielChouldechovaAlexandra. 2021. “On the Validity of Arrest as a Proxy for Offense: Race and the Likelihood of Arrest for Violent Crimes.” Proceedings of the 2021 AAAI/ACM Conference on AI, Ethics, and Society, May 19–21, Virtual event.
15.
GeeHarvey. 2016. “Asian/Americans as Criminal Defendants: The End of the Model Minority Myth?” Pp. 31–48 in Asian/Americans, Education, and Crime: The Model Minority as Victim and Perpetrator, edited by BallD.HartlepN. D.Lanham, MD: Lexington Books.
16.
GordonLewis. 1997. Her Majesty’s Other Children: Sketches of Racism from a Neocolonial Age. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.
17.
GoverAngela R.HarperShannon B.LangtonLynn. 2020. “Anti-Asian Hate Crime during the COVID-19 Pandemic: Exploring the Reproduction of Inequality.” American Journal of Criminal Justice45(4):647–67.
18.
JeungRussellPopovicTaraLimRichardLinNelson. 2020. Anti-Chinese Rhetoric Employed by Perpetrators of Anti-Asian Hate. Stop AAPI Hate.
19.
JohnsonBrian D.BetsingerSara. 2009. “Punishing the “Model Minority”: Asian-American Criminal Sentencing Outcomes in Federal District Courts.” Criminology47(4):1045–90.
20.
KanYee W.PhillipsScott. 2003. “Race and the Death Penalty: Including Asian Americans and Exploring the Desocialization of Law.” Journal of Ethnicity in Criminal Justice1(1):63–92.
21.
KaoGrace. 2000. “Group Images and Possible Selves among Adolescents: Linking Stereotypes to Expectations by Race and Ethnicity.” Sociological Forum15:407–30.
22.
KawaiYuko. 2005. “Stereotyping Asian Americans: The Dialectic of the Model Minority and the Yellow Peril.” Howard Journal of Communications16(2):109–30.
23.
KimClaire Jean. 1999. “The Racial Triangulation of Asian Americans.” Politics & Society27(1):105–38.
24.
KimClaire Jean. 2018. “Are Asians the New Blacks? Affirmative Action, Anti-Blackness, and the ‘Sociometry’ of Race.” Du Bois Review: Social Science Research on Race15(2):217–44.
25.
KimClaire Jean. 2023. Asian Americans in an Anti-Black World. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
26.
KitanoHarry H.SueStanley. 1973. “The Model Minorities.”Journal of Social Issues29(2):1–9.
27.
KposowaAugustine J.TsunokaiGlenn T.2003. “Offending Patterns among Southeast Asians in the State of California.” Journal of Ethnicity in Criminal Justice1(1):93–113.
28.
LantzBrendan2022. “Why More Agencies and Researchers Should Embrace the Upcoming NIBRS Transition: Contributions and Promise of the NIBRS Data.” American Journal of Criminal Justice47(3):462–84.
29.
LantzBrendanWardCole. 2023. “Disproportionately Punished, yet Still Neglected: Variation in Official Police Responses to American Indian/Alaska Native Offending and Victimization.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency60(1):79–111.
30.
LantzBrendanWengerMarin R.2023. “Anti-Asian Xenophobia, Hate Crime Victimization, and Fear of Victimization During the COVID-19 Pandemic.” Journal of Interpersonal Violence38(1–2):1088–116.
31.
LantzBrendanWengerMarin R.CraigChloe J.2023a. “What If They Were White? The Differential Arrest Consequences of Victim Characteristics for Black and White Co-offenders.” Social Problems70(2):297–320.
32.
LantzBrendanWengerMarin R.MillsJack M.2023b. “Fear, Political Legitimization, and Racism: Examining Anti-Asian Xenophobia during the COVID-19 Pandemic.” Race and Justice13(1):80–104.
33.
LeeJennifer C.KyeSamuel. 2016. “Racialized Assimilation of Asian Americans.” Annual Review of Sociology42(1):253–73.
34.
LeeJennifer C.ZhouMin. 2015. The Asian American Achievement Paradox. Manhattan, NY: Russell Sage Foundation.
35.
LeeStacey J.1996. Unraveling the Model Minority Stereotype: Listening to Asian American Youth. New York: Teachers College Press.
36.
LongJ. ScottMustilloSarah A.2021. “Using Predictions and Marginal Effects to Compare Groups in Regression Models for Binary Outcomes.” Sociological Methods & Research50(3):1284–320.
37.
LopezGustavoRuizNeil G.PattenE.2017. Key Facts about Asian Americans. Washington, DC: Pew Research Group.
38.
MizeTrenton D.2019. “Best Practices for Estimating, Interpreting, and Presenting Nonlinear Interaction Effects.” Sociological Science6:81–117.
39.
PaintsilIsaac K. O.2022. “Does a Victim’s Race Influence a Violent Crime Arrest? A Test of the Victim Devaluation Thesis.” Crime & Delinquency70:3277–307.
40.
PegueroAnthony A.PoppAnn MarieShekarkharZahra. 2015. “Breaking Stereotypes and School Punishment: Family Socioeconomic Status, Test Scores, Academic and Sport Activities, Backlash, and Racial and Ethnic Discipline Disparities.” Journal of Ethnicity in Criminal Justice13(1):59–85.
41.
PetersenNick. 2017. “Neighbourhood Context and Unsolved Murders: The Social Ecology of Homicide Investigations.” Policing and Society27(4):372–92.
42.
PhelanJulie E.RudmanLaurie A.2010. “Reactions to Ethnic Deviance: The Role of Backlash in Racial Stereotype Maintenance.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology99(2):265.
43.
PizarroJesenia M.TerrillWilliamLoFasoCharles A.2020. “The Impact of Investigation Strategies and Tactics on Homicide Clearance.” Homicide Studies24(1):3–24.
44.
PykeKaren D.JohnsonDenise L.2003. “Asian American Women and Racialized Femininities: “Doing” Gender across Cultural Worlds.” Gender & Society17(1):33–53.
45.
QuinneyRichard. 1970. The Social Reality of Crime. Piscataway, NJ: Transaction Publishers.
46.
ReevesTerrance J.BennettClaudette E.2004. We the People: Asians in the United States, Census 2000 Special Report. Suitland, MD: Bureau of the Census.
47.
RegoecziWendy C.JarvisJohn. 2013. “Beyond the Social Production of Homicide Rates: Extending Social Disorganization Theory to Explain Case Outcomes.” Justice Quarterly30(6):983–1014.
48.
RegoecziWendy C.JarvisJohnRiedelMarc. 2008. “Clearing Murders: Is It about Time?” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency45(2):142–62.
49.
RiosVictor M.2011. Punished: Policing the Lives of Black and Latino Boys. New York: NYU Press.
50.
RobertsAki. 2023. “Solving Crime for America’s ‘Others’: Crime Clearance among Asian American Victims.” Race and Justice15:581–605.
51.
RobertsAkiLyonsChristopher J.2011. “Hispanic Victims and Homicide Clearance by Arrest.” Homicide Studies15(1):48–73.
52.
RubleThomas L.CohenRenaeRubleDiane N.1984. “Sex Stereotypes: Occupational Barriers for Women.” American Behavioral Scientist27(3):339–56.
53.
SampsonRobert J.LauritsenJanet L.1997. “Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Crime and Criminal Justice in the United States.” Crime and Justice21:311–74.
54.
SextonJared. 2010. “Proprieties of Coalition: Blacks, Asians, and the Politics of Policing.” Critical Sociology36(1):87–108.
55.
SteffensmeierDarrellDemuthStephen. 2001. “Ethnicity and Judges’ Sentencing Decisions: Hispanic-Black Comparisons.” Criminology39:145–78.
56.
TuanMia. 1998. Forever Foreigners or Honorary Whites? The Asian Ethnic Experience Today. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
57.
TurkAustin T.1969. Criminality and Legal Order. Chicago, IL: Rand McNally.
58.
UchidaAki. 1998. “The Orientalization of Asian Women in America.” Women’s Studies International Forum21(2):161–74.
59.
UlmerJeffrey T.BradleyMindy S.2018. “Punishment in Indian Country: Ironies of Federal Punishment of Native Americans.” Justice Quarterly35(5):751–81.
60.
UlmerJeffrey T.Painter-DavisNoahTinikLeigh. 2016. “Disproportional Imprisonment of Black and Hispanic Males: Sentencing Discretion, Processing Outcomes, and Policy Structures.” Justice Quarterly33(4):642–81.
61.
VelezMaria B.BrunsonRod K.2022. “Centering Race in the Study of Crime and Criminal Justice.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency60(1):3–13.
62.
WacquantLoic. 1997. “For an Analytic of Racial Domination.” Political Power and Social Theory11(1):221–34.
63.
WaltonJessicaTruongMandy. 2023. “A Review of the Model Minority Myth: Understanding the Social, Educational and Health Impacts.” Ethnic and Racial Studies46(3):391–419.
64.
WuEllen D.2014. The Color of Success: Asian Americans and the Origins of the Model Minority. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
65.
WuJawjeong. 2023. “Within-race Variations in Sentencing Outcomes: Nationality and Punishment among Asians in United States Federal Courts.” Punishment & Society25(2):449–70.
66.
YazdihaHajar. 2021. “Toward a Du Boisian Framework of Immigrant Incorporation: Racialized Contexts, Relational Identities, and Muslim American Collective Action.” Social Problems68:300–20.
67.
YenRhoda J.2000. “Racial Stereotyping of Asians and Asian Americans and Its Effect on Criminal Justice: A Reflection on the Wayne Lo Case.” Asian Law Journal7(1):1–28.
68.
ZuberiTukufuBonilla-SilvaEduardo. 2008. White Logic, White Methods: Racism and Methodology. Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield.
