This study explores variation in people’s reactions to a punitive immigration law enforcement practice. Using a vignette-styled framing-effects experiment, we examined whether reactions to the practice depend, in part, on who receives its consequences. More than 500 undergraduates from a large Mid-Atlantic university read a brief vignette about an immigrant motorist who is stopped by a police officer for a broken taillight violation and then detained for failing to document his legal immigration status. We manipulated three characteristics of the motorist in the vignette, including his nationality (Mexico/Canada), occupation (factory worker/software engineer), and documentation status (documented/undocumented). When we framed the motorist as an unauthorized immigrant, the subjects were more likely to condone the officer’s intrusive actions. We also found that the subjects’ political orientation and immigrant threat perceptions were powerful predictors of their normative reactions to the vignette.
AlexanderCheryl S.BeckerHenry J.1978. “The Use of Vignettes in Survey Research.”Public Opinion Quarterly42(1):93–104.
2.
AschSolomon E.1952. Social Psychology. New York: Prentice-Hall.
3.
BartonRegina. 2003. “Examining Individual-level Voting Behavior on State Ballot Propositions.”Political Research Quarterly56:367–77.
4.
BartonReginaDillinghamGavinDunawayJohannaMillerBeth. 2007. “Anglo Voting on Nativist Ballot Initiatives: The Partisan Impact on Spatial Proximity to the U.S.-Mexico Border.”Social Science Quarterly88(3):882–97.
5.
BlumerHerbert. 1958. “Race Prejudice as a Sense of Group Position.”Pacific Sociological Review1:3–7.
6.
Bonilla-SilvaEduardo. 2003. Racism without Racists: Color-blind Racism and the Persistence of Racial Inequality in the United States. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.
BraderTedValentinoNicholas A.SuhayElizabeth. 2008. “What Triggers Public Opposition to Immigration? Anxiety, Group Cues, and Immigration Threat.”American Journal of Political Science52(4):959–78.
9.
ChandlerCharles R.TsaiYung-mei. 2001. “Social Factors Influencing Immigration Attitudes: An Analysis of Data from the General Social Survey.”The Social Science Journal38:177–88.
10.
ChavezJorge M.ProvineDoris M.2009. “Race and the Response of State Legislatures to Unauthorized Immigrants.”The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science623(1):78–92.
11.
ChavezLeo R.2008. The Latino Threat: Constructing Immigrants, Citizens, and the Nation. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
12.
CisnerosJ. David. 2008. “Contaminated Communities: The Metaphor of ‘Immigrant as Pollutant’ in Media Representations of Immigration.”Rhetoric & Public Affairs11(4):569–601.
13.
CitrinJackGreenDonald P.MusteChristopherWongCara1997. “Public Opinion toward Immigration Reform: The Role of Economic Motivations.”Journal of Politics59(3):858–81.
14.
CitrinJackLermanAmyMurakamiMichaelPearsonKathryn. 2007. “Testing Huntington: Is Hispanic Immigration a Threat to American Identity?”Perspectives on Politics5(1):31–48.
CoutinS. B.ChockP.1995. “Your Friend, the Illegal: Definition and Paradox in Newspaper Accounts of US Immigration Reform.”Identities: Global Studies in Culture and Power2(1/2):123–48.
17.
CowanG.MartinezL.MendiolaS.1997. “Predictors of Attitudes toward Illegal Latino Immigrants.”Hispanic Journal of Behavioral Sciences19(4):403–15.
18.
DixonTravis L.LinzDaniel. 2000. “Overrepresentation and Underrepresentation of African Americans and Latinos as Lawbreakers on Television News.”Journal of Communication50(2):131–54.
19.
DustmanChristianPrestonIan P.2007. “Racial and Economic Factors in Attitudes to Immigration.”The B.E. Journal of Economic Analysis & Policy7(1): Article 62.
EntmanRobert M.1993. “Framing: Toward Clarification of a Fractured Paradigm.”Journal of Communication43(4):51–58.
22.
EntmanRobert M.RojeckiAndrew. 2000. The Black Image in the White Mind: Media and Race in America. Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press.
23.
EspanshadeThomas J.CalhounCharles A.1993. “An Analysis of Public Opinion toward Undocumented Migration.”Population Research and Policy Review12:189–224.
24.
EssesVictoria M.DovidioJohn F.HodsonGordon. 2002. “Public Attitudes toward Immigration in the United States and Canada in Response to the September 11, 2001 ‘Attack on America.’”Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy2:69–85.
FinchJanet. 1987. “The Vignette Technique in Survey Research.”Sociology21(1):105–14.
27.
FloresLisa A.2003. “Constructing Rhetorical Borders: Peons, Illegal Aliens, and Competing Narratives of Immigration.”Critical Studies in Media Communication20(4):362–87.
28.
FrybergStephanie A.StephensNicole M.CovarrubiasRebeccaMarkusH. R.CarterE. D.LaiducG. A.SalidoA. J.2012. “How the Media Frames the Immigration Debate: The Critical Role of Location and Politics.”Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy12:96–112.
29.
GadarianShana Kushner2010. “The Politics of Threat: How Terrorism News Shapes Foreign Policy Attitudes.”The Journal of Politics72:469–83.
GilliamFranklin D.IyengarSheena. 2000. “Prime Suspects: The Influence of Local Television News on the Viewing Public.”American Journal of Political Science44:560–73.
33.
GoffmanErving. 1974. Frame Analysis: An Essay on the Organization of Experience. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
34.
GoldsmithP. R.RomeroM.Rubio-GoldsmithR.EscobedoM.KhouryL.2009. “Ethno-racial Profiling and State Violence in a Southwest Barrio.”Aztlán: A Journal of Chicano Studies34(1):93–123.
GonsalkoraleKaren.ShermanJeff W.KlauerKarl C.2009. “Aging and Prejudice: Diminished Regulation of Automatic Race Bias among Older Adults.”Journal of Experimental Psychology45:410–14.
37.
HainmuellerJensHopkinsDaniel J.2015. “The Hidden American Immigration Consensus: A Conjoint Analysis of Attitudes toward Immigrants.”American Journal of Political Science59(3):529–48.
HaubertJeannieFussellElizabeth. 2006. “Explaining Pro-immigrant Sentiment in the U.S.: Social Class, Cosmopolitanism, and Perceptions of Immigrants.”International Migration Review40:489–507.
40.
HenryP. J.SearsDavid O.2009. “The Crystallization of Contemporary Racial Prejudice across the Lifespan.”Political Psychology30:569–90.
41.
HitlanRobert T.CarrilloKimberlyZarateMichael A.AikmanShelley N.2007. “Attitudes toward Immigrant Groups and the September 11 Terrorist Attacks.”Peace and Conflict: Journal of Peace Psychology13(2):135–52.
42.
HoodM. V.MorrisI. L.1998. “Give Us Your Tired, Your Poor, . . . but Make Sure They Have a Green Card: The Effects of Documented and Undocumented Migrant Context on Anglo Opinion toward Immigration.”Political Behavior20:1–15.
43.
HughesRhidian. 1998. “Considering the Vignette Technique and Its Application to a Study of Drug Injecting and HIV Risk and Safer Behaviour.”Sociology of Health & Illness20(3):381–400.
44.
HuntingtonSamuel P.2004. “The Hispanic Challenge.”Foreign Policy (March/April):30–45.
45.
HurwitzJonPeffleyMark. 2005. “Playing the Race Card in the Post-Willie Horton Era: The Impact of Racialized Code Words on Support for Punitive Crime Policy.”Public Opinion Quarterly69(1):99–112.
46.
IyengarShanto. 1991. Is Anyone Responsible? How Television Frames Political Issues. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
KahnemanDanielTverskyAmos. 1984. “Choices, Values, and Frames.”American Psychologist39(4):341–50.
50.
KamCindy D.KinderDonald R.2007. “Terror and Ethnocentrism: Foundations of American Support for the War on Terrorism.”The Journal of Politics69(2):320–38.
51.
KimS.CarvalhoP. P.DavisA. G.MullinsA. M.2011. “The View of the Border: News Framing of the Definition, Causes, and Solutions to Illegal Immigration.”Mass Communication and Society14(3):292–314.
52.
KinderDavid R.SandersLynn M.1996. Divided by Color: Racial Politics and Democratic Ideals. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
53.
KingDesmond. 2000. Making Americans. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
54.
KnollBenjamin R.RedlawskDavid P.SanbornHoward. 2011. “Framing Labels and Immigration Policy Attitudes in the Iowa Caucuses: Trying to Out-Tancredo Tancredo.”Political Behavior33(3):433–54.
55.
KundaZ., 1999. Social Cognition: Making Sense of People. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
LaPiereRichard T.1934. “Attitudes vs Actions.”Social Forces13:230–37.
58.
LavrakasPaul J.2008. Encyclopedia of Survey Research Methods. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
59.
LeeYueh-TingOttatiVictor. 2002. “Attitudes toward U.S. Immigration Policy: The Roles of In-group–Out-group Bias, Economic Concern, and Obedience to Law.”The Journal of Social Psychology142(5) 617–34.
MalhortaNeilMargalitYotamHyunjung MoCecilia. 2013. “Economic Explanations for Opposition to Immigration: Distinguishing between Prevalence and Conditional Impact.”American Journal of Political Science57(2):391–410.
62.
ManevskaKaterinaAchterbergPeter. 2013. “Immigration and Perceived Ethnic Threat: Cultural Capital and Economic Explanations.”European Sociological Review29(3):437–49.
63.
ManeyGregWoehrleLynnCoyPatrick. 2005. “Harnessing and Challenging Hegemony: The U.S. Peace Movement after 9/11.”Sociological Perspectives48(3):357–81.
64.
MaydaAnna M.2006. “Who Is Against Immigration? A Cross-country Investigation of Individual Attitudes toward Immigrants.”Review of Economics and Statistics88(3):510–30.
65.
McLarenLauren M.2002. “Public Support for the European Union: Cost/Benefit Analysis or Perceived Cultural Threat?”The Journal of Politics64(2):551–66.
66.
McNeilBarbara J.PaukerS. G.SoxH. C.TverskyAmos. 1982. “On the Elicitation of Preferences for Alternative Therapies.”New England Journal of Medicine306:1259–62.
67.
MehanHugh. 1997. “The Discourse of the Illegal Immigration Debate: A Case Study in the Politics of Representation.”Discourse & Society8:249–70.
68.
MerollaJenniferRamakrishnanS. KarthickHaynesChris. 2013. “‘Illegal,’ ‘Undocumented,’ or ‘Unauthorized’: Equivalency Frames, Issue Frames, and Public Opinion on Immigration. Perspectives on Politics11:789–807.
69.
MeulemanBart. 2012. “Perceived Economic Threat and Anti-immigration Attitudes: Effects of Immigrant Group Size and Economic Conditions Revisited.”Cross-Cultural Analysis: Methods and Applications10:281–300.
70.
MooreKathleen M.2002. “‘United We Stand’: American Attitudes toward (Muslim) Immigration Post-September 11th.”The Muslim World92(1–2):39–57.
71.
NagelCaroline R.2002. “Geopolitics by Another Name: Immigration and the Politics of Assimilation.”Political Geography21(8):971–87.
72.
NewmanBenjamin J.HartmanTodd K.TaberCharles S.2012. “Foreign Language Exposure, Cultural Threat, and Opposition to Immigration.”Political Psychology33:635–37.
PanagopoulosCostas. 2006. “The Polls-trends. Arab and Muslim Americans and Islam in the Aftermath of 9/11”Public Opinion Quarterly70(4):608–24.
75.
PérezEfrén O.2010. “Explicit Evidence on the Import of Implicit Attitudes: The IAT and Immigration Policy Judgments.”Political Behavior32:517–45.
76.
PerrinAndrew J.2005. “National Threat and Political Culture: Authoritarianism, Antiauthoritarianism, and the September 11 Attacks.”Political Psychology26:167–94.
77.
Pew Research Center. 2006. No Consensus on Immigration Problem or Proposed Fixes. Washington, DC: Pew Research Center for the People and the Press.
78.
QuintonWendy J.CowanG.WatsonB. D.1996. “Personality and Attitudinal Predictors of Support of Proposition 187—California’s Anti-illegal Immigrant Initiative.”Journal of Applied Social Psychology26:2204–23.
79.
ReeseStephen D.GandyOscar H.Jr.GrantAugust E.2001. Framing Public Life: Perspectives on Media and Our Understanding of the Social World. Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum.
80.
RomeroMary. 2006. “Racial Profiling and Immigration Law Enforcement: Rounding Up of Usual Suspects in the Latino Community.”Critical Sociology32:449–75.
RossLeeNisbettRichard E.2011. The Person and the Situation: Perspectives of Social Psychology. London: McGraw-Hill.
83.
Santa AnaO. 1999. “‘Like an Animal I Was Treated’: Anti-immigrant Metaphor in US Public Discourse.”Discourse & Society10:191–224.
84.
Santa AnaO. 2002. Brown Tide Rising: Metaphors of Latinos in Contemporary. Austin, TX: University of Austin Press.
85.
SchemerChristian. 2012. “The Influence of News Media on Stereotypic Attitudes toward Immigrants in a Political Campaign.”Journal of Communication62:739–57.
86.
ScheveKenneth F.SlaughterMatthew J.2001. “Labor Market Competition and Individual Preferences over Immigration Policy.”Review of Economics and Statistics83(1):133–45.
87.
SchneiderSilke L.2008. “Anti-immigrant Attitudes in Europe: Outgroup Size and Perceived Ethnic Threat.”European Sociological Review24(1):53–67.
88.
SeldenDavid A.PaceJulie A.Nunn-GilmanNeidi. 2011. “Placing S.B. 1070 and Racial Profiling into Context, and What S.B. 1070 Reveals about the Legislative Process in Arizona.”Arizona State Law Journal43(1):523.
89.
SmithDanielTolbertCaroline. 2001. “The Initiative to Party: Partisanship and Ballot Initiatives in California.”Party Politics7:781–99.
90.
SnidermanPaul M.TheriaultSean M.2004. “The Structure of Political Argument and the Logic of Issue Framing.” Pp 133–65 in Studies in Public Opinion, edited by SarisW. E.SnidermanP. M.Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
TimberlakeJeffrey M.WilliamsRhys H.2012. “Stereotypes of U.S. Immigrants from Four Global Regions.”Social Science Quarterly93(4):867–90.
93.
TolberCarolineHeroRodney. 1996. “Race/Ethnicity and Direct Democracy: An Analysis of California’s Illegal Immigration Initiative.”Journal of Politics58:806–18.
94.
ValentinoNicholas A.BraderTedJardinaAshley E.2013. “Immigration Opposition among U.S. Whites: General Ethnocentrism or Media Priming of Attitudes about Latinos?”Political Psychology34:149–66.
95.
WilliamsR.2002. “From the ‘Beloved Community’ to ‘Family Values’: Religious Language, Symbolic Repertories, and Democratic Culture.” Pp. 247–65 in Social Movements: Identity, Culture, and the State, edited by WhittierN.MeyerD.RobnettB.New York: Oxford University Press.
96.
WilsonThomas C.2001. “Americans’ Views on Immigration Policy: Testing the Role of Threatened Group Interests.”Sociological Perspectives44:485–501.
97.
WoodsJoshua. 2011a. “The 9/11 Effect: Toward a Social Science of the Terrorist Threat.”The Social Science Journal48(1):1–21.
98.
WoodsJoshua. 2011b. “Framing Terror: An Experimental Framing Effects Study of the Perceived Threat of Terrorism.”Critical Studies on Terrorism4(2):199–217.
99.
WoodsJoshua. 2012. Freaking Out: A Decade of Living with Terrorism. Lincoln, NE: Potomac Books.
100.
WoodsJoshuaArthurDamien C.2014. “The Threat of Terrorism and the Changing Public Discourse on Immigration after September 11.”Sociological Spectrum44(5):421–41.
101.
WoodsJoshuaManningJasonMatzJacob. 2015. “The Impression Management Tactics of an Immigration Think Tank.”Sociological Focus48(4):354–72.
