Despite the fact that many low-wage, violation-ridden industries are disproportionately occupied by immigrants, labor standards and immigration reform have largely been treated as separate pieces of an otherwise interrelated puzzle. Not only is this view misguided, but this paper argues that strengthening labor standards enforcement would ensure that standards are upheld for all workers, immigrant and others. In addition, labor standards enforcement is instrumental to the erosion of sub-standard conditions in certain sectors, often referred to as the “secondary” labor market, that are associated with advanced market economies. Ensuring labor standards are upheld diminishes the incentive for employers to undercut wages by exploiting vulnerable workers, many of whom are immigrants. As this paper argues, strengthening enforcement must include not only “vertical” mechanisms, including strategic enforcement and penalizing and criminalizing egregious and repeated labor violators, but also “lateral” mechanisms, such as co-enforcement by workers and through worker and community organizations. The article illustrates the role of co-enforcement in labor standards through two case studies.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AFL-CIO (American Federation of Labor and Congress of Industrial Organizations). 2015. Death on the Job: The Toll of Neglect: A National and State-by-State Profile of Worker Safety and Health in the United States, 24th ed. https://aflcio.org/sites/default/files/2017-03/DOTJ2015Finalnobug.pdf.
AmengualMatthew, and FineJanice2016. “Co-Enforcing Labor Standards: The Unique Contributions of State and Worker Organizations in Argentina and the United States.”Regulation and Governance.
4.
AnuradhaJoshi, and MooreMick“Institutionalized Coproduction: Unorthodox Public Service Delivery in Challenging Environments.”The Journal of Development Studies40(4): 31–49.
5.
AppelbaumEileenBoschGerhardGautiéJérômeMasonGeoffMayhewKenSalverdaWiemerSchmittJohn, and Westergaard-NielsenNiels2010. “Introduction and Overview.” In Low-Wage Work in the Wealthy World, edited by GautiéJérôme, and SchmittJohn, 1–32. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
BergerSuzanne, and PioreMichael J.1980. Dualism and Discontinuity in Industrial Societies.New York: Cambridge University Press.
11.
BernhardtAnnetteMcGrathSiobhan, and DeFillipisJames2008. “The State of Worker Protections in the United States: Unregulated Work in New York City.”International Labour Review147(2/3): 135–62.
12.
BernhardtAnnetteMilkmanRuthTheodoreNikHeckathornDouglasAuerMirabaiDeFilippisJamesGonzalezAna LuzNarroVictorPerelshteynJasonPolsonDiana, and SpillerMichael2009. Broken Laws, Unprotected Workers: Violations of Employment and Labor Laws in America's Cities.Chicago, New York, and Los Angeles: Center for Urban Economic Development, National Employment Law Project, and UCLA Institute for Research on Labor and Employment.https://nelp.3cdn.net/e470538bfa5a7e7a46_2um6br7o3.pdf.
13.
BernhardtAnnetteSpillerMichael W., and TheodoreNik2013. “Employers Gone Rogue: Explaining Industry Variation in Violations of Workplace Laws.”Industrial and Labor Relations Review66(4): 808–32. https://doi.org/10.1177/001979391306600404.
14.
BoboKimberly A.2009. Wage Theft in America: Why Millions of Working Americans are Not Getting Paid — and What We Can Do About It.New York: New Press.
15.
BovairdTony2007. “Beyond Engagement and Participation: User and Community Co-Production of Public Services.”Public Administration Review67(5): 846–60. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6210.2007.00773.x.
16.
California Department of Industrial Relations, Labor, and Workforce Development. 2013. “A Report on the State of the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement Under Labor Commissioner Julie A. Su.”Sacramento, CA: California Department of Industrial Relations, Labor, and Workforce Development Agency.https://nelp.3cdn.net/e470538bfa5a7e7a46_2um6br7o3.pdf.
CBO (US Congressional Budget Office). 2010. “The Role of Immigrants in the U.S. Labor Market: An Update.”Washington, DC: CBO.https://www.cbo.gov/publication/17452.
DoeringerPeter B., and PioreMichael J.1971. Internal Labor Markets and Manpower Analysis.Lexington, MA: D.C. Heath and Company.
21.
DOL/DHS (US Department of Labor/US Department of Homeland Security). 2011. “Revised Memorandum of Understanding between the Departments of Homeland Security and Labor Concerning Enforcement Activities at Worksites.”Washington, DC: DOL/DHS.https://www.dol.gov/asp/media/reports/DHS-DOL-MOU.pdf.
FineJanice2006. Worker Centers: Organizing Communities at the Edge of the Dream.Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
28.
FineJanice2013. “Solving the Problem from Hell: Tripartism as a Strategy for Addressing Labour Standards Non-Compliance in the United States.”Osgoode Hall Law Journal (4): 813–43.
FineJanice2017. Enforcing Labor Standards in Partnership with Civil Society: Can Co-enforcement Succeed Where the State Alone Has Failed?Politics & Society (Spring).
31.
FineJanice, and GordonJennifer2010. “Strengthening Labor Standards Enforcement through Partnerships with Workers' Organizations.”Politics & Society38(4): 552–85. https://doi.org/10.1177/0032329210381240.
32.
Future Flow Working Group. 2008. “The W-Visa, A Workable Compromise in a Difficult Situation.”
33.
GautiéJérôme, and SchmittJohn, eds. 2010. Low-Wage Work in the Wealthy World.New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
34.
GleesonShannon2010. “Labor Rights for All? The Role of Undocumented Immigrant Status for Worker Claims Making.”Law & Social Inquiry35(3): 561–602. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1747-4469.2010.01196.x.
35.
GordonJennifer2005. Suburban Sweatshops: The Fight for Immigrant Rights.Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.https://doi.org/10.4159/9780674037823.
36.
GordonJennifer2014. “Holding the Line on Workplace Standards.” In What Works for Worker: Public Policies and Innovative Strategies for Low-Wage Workers, edited by LuceStephanieLuffJenniferMcCartinJoseph Anthony, and MilkmanRuth, 134–62. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
LaferGordon2004. “What is ‘skill’? Training for Discipline in the Low-Wage Labour Market.” In The Skills That Matter, edited by WarhurstChrisKeepEwart, and GrugulisIrena, 109–27. New York: Palgrace MacMillan.
39.
LuceStephanieLuffJenniferMcCartinJoseph Anthony, and MilkmanRuth2014. What Works for Workers?: Public Policies and Innovative Strategies for Low-Wage Workers.New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
MasonGeoff, and SalverdaWiemer2010. “Low Pay, Working Conditions, and Living Standards.” In Low-Wage Work in the Wealthy World, edited by JérômeGautié, and SchmittJohn, 35–90. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
42.
MasseyDouglas S.1988. “Economic Development and International Migration in Comparative Perspective.”Population and Development Review14(3): 383–413. https://doi.org/10.2307/1972195.
43.
Massey, Douglas S., Jorge Durand, and Nolan J. Malone. 2002. Beyond Smoke and Mirrors: Mexican Immigration in an Era of Economic Integration.New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
44.
MilkmanRuth2008. “Putting Wages Back into Competitions: Deunionization and Degradation in Place-Bound Industries.” In The Gloves Off Economy: Workplace Standards at the Bottom of America's Labor Market, edited by BernhardtAnnetteBousheyHeatherDresserLaura, and TillyChris, 65–90. Champaign, IL: Labor and Employment Relations Association.
45.
MoffittSusan L.2012. Making Policy Public: Participatory Bureaucracy in American Democracy.New York: Cambridge University Press.
PortesAlejandro, and RumbautRubén G.2006. Immigrant America: A Portrait, 4th ed. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
51.
RolfDavid2016. The Fight for Fifteen: The Right Wage for a Working America.New York: The New Press.
52.
RosenblumJonathan2017. Immigrant Workers, Faith Activists, and the Revival of the Labor Movement.Boston: Beacon Press.
53.
SchmittJohnWallerMargyFremstadShawn, and ZippererBen2008. “Unions and Upward Mobility for Low-Wage Workers.”Working USA: The Journal of Labor and Society11(3): 337–48. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1743-4580.2008.00209.x.
StoneKatherine V.W.2013. “The Decline of the Standard Contract of Employment in the United States: A Socio-Regulatory Perspective.” In Rethinking Workplace Regulation: Beyond the Standard Contract of Employment, edited by StoneKatherine V.W., and ArthursHarry, 58–78. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
57.
SuJulie2015. “Enforcing Labor Laws: Wage Theft, the Myth of Neutrality and Agency Transformation.” David E. Feller Memorial Lecture, Berkeley, California, April 14.
58.
SuJulie2016. “Strategic Labor Law Enforcement through Community Partnerships with the Labor Commissioner's Office.”
59.
ThomasJohn Clayton2012. Citizen, Customer, Partner: Engaging the Public in Public Management.New York: Routledge.
60.
WaldingerRoger1996. Still the Promised City? New Immigrants and African-Americans in Post-Industrial New York.Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
WaldingerRoger, and LichterMichael I.2003. How the Other Half Works: Immigration and the Social Organization of Labor.Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
WeilDavid2014. The Fissured Workplace: How Work Got So Bad and What Can Be Done to Fix It.Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
66.
WeilDavid, and PylesAmanda2005. “Why Complain? Complaints, Compliance, and the Problem of Enforcement in the U.S. Workplace.”Comparative Labor Law and Policy Journal27(1): 59–92.
67.
WialHoward1999. “Minimum-Wage Enforcement and the Low-Wage Labor Market.” Working Paper for MIT Task Force on Reconstructing America's Labor Market Institutions Conference, Cambridge, MA, August 1.
ZatzNoah D.2008. “Working Beyond the Reach or Grasp of Employment Law.” In The Gloves-Off Economy: Workplace Standards at the Bottom of America's Labor Market, edited by BernhardtAnnetteBousheyHeatherDresserLaura, and TillyChris, 31–64. Champaign, IL: Labor and Employment Relations Association.
