Although a great deal of research has examined the impact of accountability on a number of different outcomes, particularly achievement, little research to date has assessed the impact of school accountability reform on racial segregation in schools. Using school, district, and state-level data from the Common Core of Data from 1987 to 2010 and data on school accountability from other sources, we examine black-white within-district segregation before and after the passage of the No Child Left Behind Act (NCLB) in 2002. We find that NCLB was associated with significant increases in black-white segregation within school districts, even after controlling for other factors that might have led to increased segregation (e.g., release from court-ordered segregation, recent Supreme Court decisions). This effect was especially pronounced among districts in states that had implemented school accountability policies prior to NCLB. Our results lead us to conclude that policymakers must also consider the negative unintended consequences of education reform policies, even those designed to have an ameliorative impact on inequality.
BifulcoRobertLaddHelen F.2007. “School Choice, Racial Segregation, and Test-score Gaps: Evidence from North Carolina’s Charter School Program.” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management26(1):31–56.
2.
BogerJohn. 2003. “Education’s ‘Perfect Storm?’ Racial Resegregation, High-stakes Testing, and School Resource Inequities: The Case of North Carolina.” North Carolina Law Review81(4):1375–462.
3.
BormanKathrynEitleTamela McNultyMichaelDeannaEitleDavid J.LeeReginaldJohnsonLarryCobb-RobertsDeirdreDornShermanShircliffeBarbara. 2004. “Accountability in a Postdesegregation Era: The Continuing Significance of Racial Segregation in Florida’s Schools.” American Journal of Education41(3):605–31.
4.
BrykAnthony. 2003. “No Child Left Behind, Chicago Style.” Pp. 242–68 in No Child Left Behind: The Politics and Practice of School Accountability, edited by PetersonPaulWestMartin. Washington, DC: Brookings.
5.
CarnoyMartinLoebSusanna. 2002. “Does External Accountability Affect Student Outcomes? A Cross-state Analysis.” Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis24(4):305–31.
6.
ClotfelterCharles. 2001. “Are Whites Still Fleeing? Racial Patterns and Enrollment Shifts in Urban Public Schools, 1987–1996.” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management20(2):199–221.
7.
ClotfelterCharles. 2004. After Brown: The Rise and Retreat of School Desegregation. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
8.
ClotfelterCharlesLaddHelenVigdorJacob. 2004. “Do School Accountability Systems Make It More Difficult for Low-performing Schools to Attract and Retain High-quality Teachers?” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management23(2):251–71.
9.
CohnCarl. 2005. “NCLB Implementation Challenges: The Local Superintendent’s View.” Peabody Journal of Education80(2):156–69.
10.
Darling-HammondLinda. 2004. “Standards, Accountability, and School Reform.” Teachers College Record106(6):1047–85.
11.
DawkinsCasey. 2004. “Recent Evidence on the Continuing Causes of Black-White Residential Segregation.” Journal of Urban Affairs26(3):379–400.
12.
DeeThomasJacobBrian. 2011. “The Impact of No Child Left Behind on Student Achievement.” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management30(3):418–46.
13.
DornSherman. 2007. Accountability Frankenstein: Understanding and Taming the Monster. Charlotte, NC: Information Age.
14.
EitleDavidEitleTamela. 2010. “Public School Segregation and Juvenile Violent Crime Arrests in Metropolitan Areas.” Sociological Quarterly51(3):436–59.
15.
FairlieRobertReschAlexandra. 2002. “Is There ‘White Flight’ into Private Schools? Evidence from the National Educational Longitudinal Survey.” The Review of Economics and Statistics84(1):21–33.
16.
FarleyReynoldsFieldingElaineKrysanMaria. 1997. “The Residential Preferences of Blacks and Whites: A Four-metropolis Analysis.” Housing Policy Debate8(4):763–800.
17.
FiglioDavidGetzlerLawrence. 2006. “Accountability, Ability and Disability: Gaming the System?” Pp. 35–49in Advances in Microeconomics, Vol. 14: Improving School Accountability: Check-ups or Choice? edited by GronbergTimothyJansenDennis. Amsterdam, The Netherlands: Elsevier.
18.
FiglioDavidLucasMaurice. 2004. “What’s in a Grade? School Report Cards and the Housing Market.” American Economic Review94(3):591–604.
19.
FiglioDavidWinickiJohn. 2005. “Food for Thought? The Effects of School Accountability Plans on School Nutrition.” Journal of Public Economics89(2–3):381–94.
20.
FischbachJonathanRheeWillCacaceRobert. 2008. “Race at the Pivot Point: The Future of Race-based Policies to Remedy De Jure Segregation after Parents Involved in Community Schools.” Harvard Civil Rights-Civil Liberties Law Review43:491–538.
21.
FrankenbergErika. 2013. “The Role of Residential Segregation in Contemporary School Segregation.” Education and Urban Society45(5):548–70.
HanushekEricKainJohnRivkinSteven. 2009. “New Evidence about Brown v. Board of Education: The Complex Effects of School Racial Composition on Achievement.” Journal of Labor Economics27(3):349–83.
24.
HanushekEricRaymondMargaret. 2005. “Does School Accountability Lead to Improved Student Performance?” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management24(2):297–327.
25.
HastingsJustineKaneThomasStaigerDouglas. 2005. “Parental Preferences and School Competition: Evidence from a Public School Choice Program.” Working Paper No. 11805, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.
26.
HastingsJustineWeinsteinJeffrey M.2008. “Information, School Choice, and Academic Achievement: Evidence from Two Experiments.” The Quarterly Journal of Economics123(4):1373–1414.
27.
HessFrederickPetrilliMichael. 2006. No Child Left Behind Primer. New York: Peter Lang.
28.
HolmeJennifer.2002. “Buying Homes, Buying Schools: School Choice and the Social Construction of School Quality.” Harvard Educational Review72(2):177–206.
29.
JacobBrianLevittSteven. 2003. “Rotten Apples: An Investigation of the Prevalence and Predictors of Teacher Cheating.” The Quarterly Journal of Economics118(3):843–78.
30.
KaneThomasStaigerDouglas. 2003. “The Unintended Consequences of Racial Subgroup Rules.” Pp. 152–76 in No Child Left Behind: The Politics and Practice of School Accountability, edited by PetersonPaulWestMartin. Washington, DC: Brookings.
31.
KleinAlyson. 2013. “As NCLB Waivers Take Hold, Revision of Law Remains Up in Air.” Education Week32(21):25.
32.
KruseKevin. 2013. White flight: Atlanta and the Making of Modern Conservatism. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
33.
KrysanMaria. 2002. “Whites Who Say They’d Flee: Who Are They, and Why Would They Leave?” Demography39(4):675–96.
34.
KrysanMariaCouperMickFarleyReynoldsFormanTyrone. 2009. “Does Race Matter in Neighborhood Preferences? Results from a Video Experiment.” American Journal of Sociology115(2):527–59.
35.
LaddHelenLauenDouglas. 2010. “Status versus Growth: The Distributional Effects of School Accountability Policies.” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management29(3):426–50.
36.
LareauAnnette. 2014. “Schools, Housing, and the Reproduction of Inequality.” Pp. 169–206 in Choosing Homes, Choosing Schools, edited by LareauAnnetteGoyetteKimberly. New York: Russell Sage.
37.
LauenDouglasGaddisS. Michael. 2012. “Shining a Light or Fumbling in the Dark? The Effects of NCLB’s Subgroup-specific Accountability on Student Achievement.” Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis34(2):185–208.
38.
LechnerMichael. 2011. “The Estimation of Causal Effects by Difference-in-difference Methods.” Foundations and Trends in Econometrics4(3):165–224.
39.
LeeJaekyungWongKenneth. 2004. “The Impact of Accountability on Racial and Socioeconomic Equity: Considering Both School Resources and Achievement Outcomes.” American Educational Research Journal41(4):797–832.
40.
LiebowitzDavidPageLindsay. 2014. “Does School Policy Affect Housing Choices? Evidence from the End of Desegregation in Charlotte-Mecklenburg.” American Educational Research Journal51(4):671–703.
41.
LipmanPaulineHainesNathan. 2007. “From Accountability to Privatization and African American Exclusion: Chicago’s ‘Renaissance 2010.’” Educational Policy21(3):471–502.
42.
LoganJohnOakleyDeirdreStowellJacob. 2008. “School Segregation in Metropolitan Regions, 1970–2000: The Impacts of Policy Choices on Public Education.” American Journal of Sociology113(6):1611–44.
43.
MasseyDouglasDentonNancy. 1988. “The Dimensions of Residential Segregation.” Social Forces67(2):281–315.
44.
MickelsonRoslynSouthworthStephanieSmithStephen. 2009. “Resegregation, Achievement, and the Chimera of Choice in Post-unitary Charlotte-Mecklenburg Schools.” Pp. 129–56 in From the Courtroom to the Classroom: The Shifting Landscape of School Desegregation, edited by SmrekarClaireGoldringEllen. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press.
45.
NicholsSharonBerlinerDavid. 2007. Collateral Damage: How High-stakes Testing Corrupts America’s Schools. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
46.
OakesJeanne. 1995. “Two Cities’ Tracking and Within-school Segregation.” Teachers College Record96(4):681–90.
47.
OrfieldGary. 1996. “Turning Back to Segregation.” Pp. 1–22 in Dismantling Desegregation: The Quiet Reversal of Brown v. Board of Education, edited by OrfieldGaryEatonSusan. New York: The New Press.
48.
OrfieldGaryFrankenbergEricaLeeChungmei. 2003. “The Resurgence of School Segregation.” Educational Leadership60(4):16–20.
49.
PattilloMaryDelale-O’ConnorLoriButtsFelicia. 2014. “High-stakes Choosing.” Pp. 237–67 in Choosing Homes, Choosing Schools, edited by LareauAnnetteGoyetteKimberly. New York: Russell Sage.
50.
QuillianLincoln. 2002. “Why Is Black-White Residential Segregation So Persistent?: Evidence on Three Theories from Migration Data.” Social Science Research31:197–229.
51.
RavitchDiane. 2010. The Death and Life of the Great American School System: How Testing and Choice are Undermining Education. New York: Basic Books.
52.
ReardonSeanGrewalElenaKalogridesDemetraGreenbergErica. 2012. “Brown Fades: The End of Court-ordered School Desegregation and the Resegregation of American Public Schools.” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management31(4):876–904.
53.
ReardonSeanO’SullivanDavid. 2004. “Measures of Spatial Segregation.” Sociological Methodology34(1):121–62.
54.
ReardonSeanYunJohnEitleTamela. 2000. “The Changing Structure of School Segregation: Measurement and Evidence of Multiracial Metropolitan-area School Segregation, 1989–1995.” Demography37(3):351–64.
55.
ReardonSeanYunJohn. 2001. “Suburban Racial Change and Suburban School Segregation, 1987–95.” Sociology of Education74(2):79–101.
56.
RenzulliLindaEvansLorraine. 2005. “School Choice, Charter Schools, and White Flight.” Social Problems52(3):398–418.
57.
RenzulliLindaRoscignoVincent. 2007. “Charter Schools and the Public Good.” Contexts6 (1):31–36.
58.
RossellChristine. 1990. “The Carrot or the Stick for School Desegregation Policy?” Urban Affairs Review25(3):474–99.
59.
SaporitoSalvatore. 2003. “Private Choices, Public Consequences: Magnet School Choice and Segregation by Race and Poverty.” Social Problems50(2):181–203.
60.
SchillerKathrynMullerChandra. 2003. “Raising the Bar and Equity? The Effects of State High School Graduation Requirements and Accountability Policies on Students’ Mathematics Course Taking.” Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis25(3):299–318.
61.
SchneiderMarkBuckleyJack. 2002. “What Do Parents Want from Schools? Evidence from the Internet.” Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis24(2):133–44.
62.
SmithStephenMickelsonRoslyn. 2000. “All That Glitters is Not Gold: School Reform in Charlotte-Mecklenburg.” Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis22(2):101–21.
63.
SuperfineMichael. 2005. “The Politics of Accountability: The Rise and Fall of Goals 2000.” American Journal of Education112(1):10–43.
64.
SwartzRobertRobinsonMarian. 2000. “Goals 2000 and the Standards Movement.” Brookings Papers on Education Policy1:173–206.
WarrenJohnJenkinsKristaKulikRachel. 2002. “High School Exit Examinations and State-level Completion and GED Rates, 1975 through 2002.” Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis28(2):131–52.
68.
WeiningerElliot. 2014. “School Choice in an Urban Setting.” Pp. 268–294 in Choosing Homes, Choosing Schools, edited by LareauAnnetteGoyetteKimberly. New York: Russell Sage.
69.
WellsAmy StuartHolmeJennifer. 2005. “No Accountability for Diversity: Standardized Tests and the Demise of Racially Mixed Schools.” Pp. 187–211 in School Resegregation: Must the South Turn Back? edited by CharlesJohnOrfieldGary. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.
70.
WellsAmy StuartHolmeJenniferRevillaAnitaAtandaAwo. 2009. Both Sides Now: The Story of School Desegregation’s Graduates. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
