Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2019-7
Sustainable Intensification in a Forest-agriculture Frontier Landscape: Analysis of C Capture and Sequestration Potential Under Two Different Scenarios in Binga District,Zimbabwe
Zimbabwe has been experiencing widespread land degradation, soil erosion, increasing aridity and temperatures that, coupled with population growth, pose a menace to agricultural production and prospective food security. As a win-win strategy, conservation agriculture (CA) is being promoted across the country with the objective to restore damaged ecosystems, curb and revert environmental depletion and guarantee food security. Binga district, where smallholders’ cropland expansion has been identified as the main driver of deforestation, has been one of the first recipient of CA-supporting projects and is the current beneficiary of a newly implemented Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Degradation (REDD)+ project. In light of the controversial forest-sparing/forest-clearing effect of sustainable intensification, the present study tried to assess how the adoption of CA may influence deforestation rates in the area and related C stocks under two hypothetical future scenarios. A pool of experts was consulted with the objective to quantify land cover changes in 2040 and the model InVEST was used to compute the district C stocks under the two considered scenarios. Findings show that the rate of CA adoption in Binga is very limited, partly failing to address the problem of agriculture-driven deforestation and widespread farmland degradation. Consequently, both scenarios portray a district doomed to a poverty-environmental degradation vicious cycle that, according to experts, requires a holistic approach to be eased.
ACB (African Centre for Biodiversity). (2016). Zimbabwean smallholder support at the crossroads: Diminishing returns from green revolution seed and fertiliser subsidies and the agro-ecological alternative. Johannesburg: Author.
2.
AngelsenA. (1999). Agricultural expansion and deforestation: Modelling the impact of population, market forces and property rights. Journal of Development Economics, 58, 185–218.
3.
AngelsenA.KaimowitzD. (2001). Agricultural technologies and tropical deforestation. New York City, NY: CABI.
4.
BarbierE. B. (2005). Explaining agricultural land expansion and deforestation in developing countries. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 86, 1347–1353.
5.
BarrosV. R.FieldC. B.DokkenD. J.MastrandreaM. D.MachK. J.BilirT. E.. (2014). Climate change 2014: Impacts, adaptation, and vulnerability: Part B: Regional aspects. Contribution of Working Group II to the Fifth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
6.
BatanaiS.TavengwaC.BrendaM. T.BlessingN.ButeteC. J. (2015). Challenges and constraints to agricultural mechanization in Zimbabwe: A dealers’ and manufacturers’ perspective. International Journal, Agriculture, Innovations, Research, 4, 2–5.
7.
BergC.RogersS.MineauM. (2016). Building scenarios for ecosystem services tools: Developing a methodology for efficient engagement with expert stakeholders. Futures, 81, 68–80.
8.
BesleyT. (1995). Property rights and investment incentives: Theory and evidence from Ghana. The Journal of Political Economy, 103, 903–937.
9.
BiggsR.SimonsH.BakkenesM.ScholesR. J.EickhoutB.van VuurenD.. (2008). Scenarios of biodiversity loss in southern Africa in the 21st century. Global Environmental Change, 18, 296–309.
10.
BorlaugN. (2007). Feeding a Hungry world. Science, 318, 359.
11.
BrymanA. (2012). Social research method. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
12.
ChakravartyS.GhoshS. K.SureshC. P.DeyA. N.ShuklaG. (2012). Deforestation: Causes, effects and control strategies. In AkaisO. C. (Ed.), Global perspectives on sustainable forest managements (pp. 3–28). Rijeka: InTech.
13.
ChimhowuA.WoodhouseP. (2008). Communal tenure and rural poverty: Land transactions in Svosve Communal Area, Zimbabwe. Development and Change, 39, 285–308.
14.
ChipikaJ. T.KoweroG. (2000). Deforestation of woodlands in communal areas of Zimbabwe: Is it due to agricultural policies?Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 79, 175–185.
15.
CliffeL.AlexanderJ.CousinsB.GaidzanwaR. (2017). Outcomes of post-2000 fast track land reform in Zimbabwe. London: Routledge.
16.
ConyersD. (2002). Whose elephants are they? Decentralization of control over wildlife management through the CAMPFIRE program in Binga district, Zimbabwe (Environmental governance in Africa, Working Paper No. 4). Washington, DC: World Resources Institute.
17.
COSV (Cooperazione per lo sviluppo). (2014). Livelihood diversification program in Hwange and Binga districts: Final evaluation. Milan: Author.
18.
DouglasG.BillyM.RonaldM. (2015). Conservation agriculture and food security: An analysis of action contra La Faim’s (ACF) interventions in Chipinge district, Zimbabwe. Journal Science Technology, 10, 201–213.
19.
EstesL. D.SearchingerT.SpiegelM.TianD.SichingaS.MwaleM.. (2016). Reconciling agriculture, carbon and biodiversity in a savannah transformation frontier. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 371, 1–10. pii: 20150316.
20.
EstradaM. (2011). Standards and methods available for estimating project-level REDD+carbon benefits: Reference guide for project developers (CIFOR Working paper No. 52). Bogor: CIFOR.
21.
Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO). (2006). Fertilizer use by crop in Zimbabwe Fertilizer use by crop in Zimbabwe. Rome: Author.
22.
Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO). (2009). Declaration of the world summit on food security. Rome: FAO, World Food Summit.
23.
Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO). (2010). The status of conservation agriculture in Southern Africa: Challenges and opportunities for expansion. Rome: Author.
24.
Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO). (2011). Socio-economic analysis of conservation agriculture in Southern Africa. Rome: Author.
25.
Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO). (2015). Climate change and food security: Risks and responses. Rome: Author.
26.
FenskeJ. (2011). Land tenure and investment incentives: Evidence from West Africa. Journal of Development Economics, 95, 137.
27.
GamaM.ThierfelderC. (2011, February8–10). Improved food security and livelihoods for resource poor smallholder farmers through conservation agriculture in Balaka district, Malawi. Conservation Agriculture Regional Symposium for Southern Africa, Johannesburg, South Africa.
28.
GillerK. E.WitterE.CorbeelsM.TittonellP. (2009). Conservation agriculture and smallholder farming in Africa: The heretics’ view. Field Crops Research, 114, 23–34.
29.
GodfrayH.BeddingtonJ.CruteI.HaddadL.LawrenceD.MuirJ.. (2010). Food security: The challenge of feeding 9 billion people. Science, 327, 812–818.
GoveraI. (2009). Policy perspectives on the role of government in the distribution of agricultural inputs to farmers: Lessons from Zimbabwe. International NGO Journal, 4, 470–479.
33.
HallT. J.DennisJ. H.LopezR. G.MarshallM. I. (2009). Factors affecting growers’ willingness to adopt sustainable floriculture practices. HortScience, 44, 1346–1351.
34.
HamrickK. (2017). Unlocking potential state of the voluntary carbon markets 2017 supporter sponsors initiative for sustainable forest landscapes. Washington, DC: Ecosystem Marketplace.
35.
HicksC.WoronieckiS.FancourtM.BieriM.Garcia RoblesH.TrumperK.. (2014). The relationship between biodiversity, carbon storage and the provision of other ecosystem services: Critical review for the forestry component of the international climate fund. Nairobi: UNEP.
36.
IIED (International Institute for Environment and Development). (2013). ‘Land grabbing’: Is conservation part of the problem or the solution?London: Author.
JohansenC.HaqueM. E.BellR. W.ThierfelderC.EsdaileR. J. (2012). Conservation agriculture for small holder rainfed farming: Opportunities and constraints of new mechanized seeding systems. Field Crops Research,132, 18–32.
39.
KassamA.FriedrichT.ShaxtonF.BartzH.MelloI.KienzleJ.. (2014). The spread of Conservation Agriculture: Policy and institutional support for adoption and uptake. Field Actions Science Reports, 7, 1–18.
40.
KillJ. (2015). REDD: A collection of conflicts, contradictions and lies. Montevideo: World Rainforest Movement.
41.
KnowlerD.BradshawB. (2007). Farmers’ adoption of conservation agriculture: A review and synthesis of recent research. Food Policy, 32, 25–48.
42.
KnoxJ.HessT.DaccacheA.WheelerT. (2012). Climate change impacts on crop productivity in Africa and South Asia. Environmental Research Letters, 7, 034032.
43.
KundhlandeG.AdamowiczW. L.MapaureI. (2000). Special section: Land use options in dry tropical woodland ecosystems in Zimbabwe—Valuing ecological services in a savanna ecosystem: A case study from Zimbabwe. Ecological Economics, 33, 401–412.
44.
LalR. (2007). Constraints to adopting no-till farming in developing countries. Soil & Tillage Research, 94, 1–3.
45.
LauranceW. F.SayerJ.CassmanK. G. (2014). Agricultural expansion and its impacts on tropical nature. Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 29, 107–116.
46.
LinB. B.MacfadyenS.RenwickA. R.CunninghamS. A.SchellhornN. A. (2013). Maximizing the environmental benefits of carbon farming through ecosystem service delivery. Bioscience, 63, 793–803.
47.
LinW. C.LinY. P.LienW. Y.WangY. C.LinC. T.ChiouC. R.. (2014). Expansion of protected areas under climate change: An example of mountainous tree species in Taiwan. Forests, 5, 2882–2904.
48.
MakwaraE. C.GamiraD. (2012). Zimbabwe: Rewards of unsustainable land use. European Journal of Sustainable Development, 1, 457–476.
49.
MangoN.SizibaS.MakateC. (2017). The impact of adoption of conservation agriculture on smallholder farmers’ food security in semi-arid zones of southern Africa. Agriculture and Food Security, 6, 6–32.
50.
MarcariniA. A.ReimerF. (2017). Kariba REDD+ Project monitoring and implementation report 2014–2016. Zurich: South Pole Carbon.
51.
MarongweL. S.KwaziraK.JenrichM.ThierfelderC.KassamA.FriedrichT. (2011). An African success: The case of conservation agriculture in Zimbabwe. International Journal of Agricultural Sustainability, 9, 153–161.
52.
MatavireM. M.SibandaM.DubeT. (2015). Assessing the aftermath of the fast track land reform programme in Zimbabwe on land-use and land-cover changes. Transactions of the Royal Society of South Africa, 70, 181–186.
53.
MazvimaviK.NdlovuP. V.NyathiP.MindeI. J. (2010). Conservation agriculture practices and adoption by smallholder farmers in Zimbabwe. In Proceedings from the Joint 3rd African Association of Agricultural Economists and 48th Agricultural Economists of South Africa. Cape Town.
54.
MazvimaviK.TwomlowS. (2009). Socioeconomic and institutional factors influencing adoption of conservation farming by vulnerable households in Zimbabwe. Agricultural Systems, 101, 20–29.
55.
MckenzieE.RosenthalA.BernhardtJ.GirvetzE.KovacsK.OlweroN. (2012). Developing scenarios to assess ecosystem service Tradeoffs: Guidance and case studies for InVEST users. Washington, DC: WWF.
56.
Ministry of Agriculture, Mechanization and Irrigation Development (MoAMID). (2010). Conservation agriculture upscaling framework for Zimbabwe. Harare: Author.
57.
Ministry of Agriculture, Mechanization and Irrigation Development (MoAMID). (2013). Zimbabwe Agriculture Investment Plan (Zaip) 2013–2018. Harare: Author.
58.
Ministry of Environment, Water and Climate (MoEWC). (2015). Zimbabwe’s national climate change response strategy (NCCRS). Harare: Author.
MoyoM.MvumiB.KunzekwegutaM.MazvimaviK.CraufurdP.DorwardP. (2012). Farmer perception of climate change and variability in the semi-arid Zimbabwe in relation to climatology evidence. African Crop Science Journal, 20, 317–335.
61.
MoyoS. (2005). Land policy, poverty reduction and public action in Zimbabwe Sam MoyoSeptember2005. (ISS/UNDP Land, Poverty and Public Action Policy Paper No. 11.) The Hague: Institute of Social Studies.
MundawararaM. I. A. (2012, September6). The contribution of conservation agriculture to sustainable development in Zimbabwe: A review. Paper Presented at the Research and Intellectual Expo 2012 Held at the University of Zimbabwe, Harare, Zimbabwe.
64.
MurungweniC. (2011). Vulnerability and resilience of competing land-based livelihoods in south eastern Zimbabwe. The Netherlands: Wageningen University.
65.
NCP. (2016). InVEST user’s manual. Stanford: Natural Capital Project.
66.
NelsonG. C.RosegrantM. W.PalazzoA.GrayI.IngersollC.RobertsonR.. (2010). Food security, farming, and climate change to 2050: Scenarios, results, policy options (Research reports IFPRI). Washington, DC: IPFRI. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.2499/9780896291867
67.
NgomaH.AngelsenA. (2017). Can conservation agriculture save tropical forests? The case of minimum tillage in Zambia (Working Paper No. 2/2017). Ås: Norwegian University of Life Sciences.
68.
NordhausW. D.HammittJ. K.McgartlandA.YoheG. W. (2016). Revisiting the social cost of carbon. PNAS,114, 1518–1523.
69.
NyamangaraJ.MasvayaE. N.TirivaviR.NyengeraiK. (2013). Effect of hand-hoe based conservation agriculture on soil fertility and maize yield in selected smallholder areas in Zimbabwe. Soil Tillage Research, 126, 19–25.
70.
PedzisaT.RugubeL.Winter-NelsonA.BaylisK.MazvimaviK. (2015). The intensity of adoption of conservation agriculture by smallholder farmers in Zimbabwe. Agre, 54, 1–22.
71.
PetersonG. D.CummingG. S.CarpenterS. R. (2003). Scenario planning: A tool for conservation in an uncertain world. Conservation and Biology, 17, 358–366.
72.
PowlsonD. S.StirlingC. M.ThierfelderC.WhiteR. P.JatM. L. (2016). Does conservation agriculture deliver climate change mitigation through soil carbon sequestration in tropical agro-ecosystems?Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 220, 164–174.
73.
PrettyJ.BharuchaZ. P. (2014). Sustainable intensification in agricultural systems. Annals of Botany, 114, 1571–1596.
74.
PrettyJ.ToulminC.WilliamsS. (2011). Sustainable intensification in African agriculture the production challenge for Africa. International Journal of Agricultural Sustainability, 9, 5–24.
75.
RudelT. K. (2013). The national determinants of deforestation in sub-Saharan Africa. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 368, 20120405.
76.
Save the Children. (2003). Household economy asssessment: Binga & Nyaminyami (Kariba Rural) Districts, Matabeleland North & Mashonaland West Provinces, Zimbabwe. London: Author.
77.
SchmidhuberJ.TubielloF. N. (2007). Global food security under climate change. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 104, 19703–19708.
78.
ScoonesI. (2001). Dynamics & diversity: Soil fertility management and farming livelihoods in Africa: Case studies from Ethiopia, Mali and Zimbabwe. London: Earthscan.
79.
SilberT. (2012). Kariba REDD+ Project CCBS project design document (PDD) version 6. Zurich: South Pole Carbon.
80.
SilberT. (2013). Kariba REDD+ Project monitoring report 2011–2012. Zurich: South Pole Carbon.
81.
StockmannU.AdamsM. A.CrawfordJ. W.FieldD. J.HenakaarchchiN.JenkinsM.. (2013). The knowns, known unknowns and unknowns of sequestration of soil organic carbon. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 164, 80–99.
82.
SUSTAINET EA. (2010). Technical manual for farmers and field extension service providers: Conservation agriculture. Nairobi: Sustainable Agriculture Information Initiative.
83.
SwetnamR. D.FisherB.MbilinyiB. P.MunishiP. K. T.WillcockS.RickettsT.. (2011). Mapping socio-economic scenarios of land cover change: A GIS method to enable ecosystem service modelling. Journal of Environmental Management, 92, 563–574.
84.
ThierfelderC.CheesmanS.RusinamhodziL. (2012). A comparative analysis of conservation agriculture systems: Benefits and challenges of rotations and intercropping in Zimbabwe. Field Crops Research, 137, 237–250.
85.
ThierfelderC.WallP. C. (2012). Effects of conservation agriculture on soil quality and productivity in contrasting agro-ecological environments of Zimbabwe. Soil Use and Management, 28, 209–220.
86.
Transparency International. (2016). REDD+ and corruption risks for Africa’s forests. Bonn: Author.
87.
TwomlowS.UrolovJ.JenrichM.OldrieveB. (2008). Lessons from the field: Zimbabwe’s conservation agriculture task force. Journal of SAT Agriculture Research, 6, 1–11.
88.
UNICEF Zimbabwe. (2015). The Zimbabwe poverty atlas. Harare: Author.
89.
United States Agency for International Development (USAID). (2012). Zimbabwe USAID: BEST analysis. Washington, DC: Author.
90.
VagenT. G.LalR.SinghB. R. (2005). Soil carbon sequestration in sub-Saharan Africa: A review. Land Degradation & Development, 16, 53–71.
91.
WaggonerP. E.AusubelJ. H. (2001). How much will feeding more and wealthier people encroach on forests?Population and Development Review, 27, 239–257.
WhitlowJ. R. (1980). Deforestation in Zimbabwe: Some problems and prospects. Harare: Government Press.
94.
ZhengC.JiangY.ChenC.SunY.FengJ.DengA.. (2014). The impacts of conservation agriculture on crop yield in China depend on specific practices, crops and cropping regions. The Crop Journal, 2, 289–296.
95.
ZikhaliP. (2010). Fast track land reform and agricultural productivity in Zimbabwe (Working Paper in economics No. 322). Gothenburg, Sweden: School of Business, Economics and Law, Univeristy of Gotherburg.
96.
ZimStat. (2012). Zimbabwe population census 2012. Provincial report Matabelel and North. Harare: Author.
