This article appraises the role of the Communist Party of India (Marxist) (CPM) in West Bengal, where the CPM-led Left Front formed government uninterruptedly between 1977 and 2011. It identifies four phases of Left politics in West Bengal: the period during which communists built support for a programme of radical transformation; the post-1977 years when the Left Front introduced land reform and effective local government that produced a ‘party society’ in rural areas; a third stage when popular support was subverted through clientelism tinged with coercion and petty corruption; and the 1990s, when growth in agricultural output petered out, the proportion of landless labourers increased and employment in manufacturing stagnated. The Left had also not delivered significant progress in social policy. The CPM turned to corporate investments and special economic zones. This trajectory points to problems of party ideology and the imperative of renewal to devise an anti-capitalist strategy.
BardhanP. (2011). The avoidable tragedy of the Left in India—II. Economic & Political Weekly, 46(24), 10–13.
7.
BasuA. (2004). Parliamentary communism as a historical phenomenon: The CPI(M) in West Bengal. In HasanZ. (Ed.), Parties and party politics in India (pp. 317–350). New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
8.
BasuS. (2010). Transition and development: A case study of West Bengal (Unpublished doctoral thesis). University of Notre Dame.
9.
BasuS. (2011, April13). Tryst with destiny: For better or worse in Bengal. The Statesman, p. 6.
10.
BasuS., & MajumderA. (2013). Dilemmas of parliamentary communism. Critical Asian Studies, 45(2), 167–200.
11.
BhattacharyaA. (2010). Is Lalgarh showing the way?Economic & Political Weekly, 45(2), 17–21.
12.
BhattacharyaD. (2001). ‘Civic community’ and its margins: School teachers in rural West Bengal. Economic & Political Weekly, 36(8), 673–683.
13.
BhattacharyaD. (2009a). Of control and factions: The changing ‘party-society’ in rural West Bengal. Economic & Political Weekly, 44(9), 59–69.
14.
BhattacharyaD. (2009b). West Bengal: Permanent incumbency and political stability. In ShastriS., SuriK.C. & YadavY. (Eds), Electoral politics in Indian states: Lok Sabha elections in 2004 and beyond (pp. 326–345). New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
15.
BhattacharyaD. (2011). Party society, its consolidation and crisis: Understanding political change in West Bengal. In GhoshA., Guha-ThakurtaT., & NairJ. (Eds), Theorizing the present: Essays for Partha Chatterjee (pp. 226–250). New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
16.
BoseP. (2009). Verdict 2009: An appraisal of critiques of the Left. Economic & Political Weekly, 44(40), 32–38.
17.
BoseS. (2013). Transforming India: Challenges to the world’s largest democracy. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
18.
ChakrabartyB. (2011). The 2011 state assembly elections in West Bengal: The Left Front washed-out!Journal of South Asian Development, 6(2), 143–167.
19.
ChatterjeeP. (2009). The coming crisis in West Bengal. Economic & Political Weekly, 44(9), 42–45.
20.
DamodaranK. (1975). Memoirs of an Indian communist. New Left Review, I/93(September–October), 35–59.
21.
Datta GuptaS. (2011). History re-examined: Anti-imperialism, the Communist Party of India and international communism. In HowellD., KirbyD. & MorganK. (Eds), John Saville: Commitment and history: Themes from the life and work of a socialist historian (pp. 113–131). London: Lawrence & Wishart.
22.
DesaiM. (2007). State formation and radical democracy in India, 1860–1990. London: Routledge.
23.
DrezeJ., & SenA. (2013). An uncertain glory: India and its contradictions. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
24.
Government of West Bengal. (1994). Policy statement on industrial development. Retrieved from http://www.wbidc.com/images/pdf/POLICY%20STATEMENT.pdf
25.
GuptaM. (2010). Left Politics in Bengal: Time travels among Bhadralok Marxists. Hyderabad: Orient BlackSwan.
26.
HellerP. (2000). Degrees of democracy: Some comparative lessons from India. World Politics, 52(4), 484–519.
27.
HellerP. (2006, February17–18). Building local democracy: Lessons from Kerala. Paper presented at the Workshop on Poverty and Democracy. Durham, USA: Duke University.
28.
KavirajS. (2009). Marxism in translation: Critical reflections on Indian radical thought. In BourkeR. & GeussR. (Eds), Political judgement: Essays for John Dunn (pp. 172–200). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
29.
KavirajS. (2011). The Enchantment of Democracy and India: Politics and Ideas. Ranikhet: Permanent Black.
30.
KeneallyT. (2010). Three famines. North Sydney, NSW: Knopf.
31.
KohliA. (1997). From breakdown to order: West Bengal. In ChatterjeeP. (Ed.), State and politics in India (pp. 336–366). New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
32.
Koteswara RaoM.V.S. (2003). Communist parties and United Front experience in Kerala and West Bengal. Hyderabad: Prajasakti Book House.
33.
LukacsG. (1977). Lenin: A study on the unity of his thought. London: NLB.
34.
MallickR. (1993). Development policy of a communist government: West Bengal since 1977. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
35.
MukharjiP.B. (2009). ‘Communist’ dispossession meets ‘reactionary’ resistance: The ironies of the parliamentary Left in West-Bengal. Focaal, 54, 89–96.
36.
MukherjeeS. (2007). The use and abuse of democracy in West Bengal. Economic & Political Weekly, 42(44), 101–108.
37.
MukherjeeS. (2008). A glimmer of change in West Bengal. Seminar, 591. Retrieved from http://www.india-seminar.com/2008/591/591_sanjeeb_mukherjee.htm
38.
NandanT. (2012). There is serious problem with CPM’s political direction: Prasenjit Bose. Retrieved from http://www.governancenow.com/news/regular-story/there-serious-problem-cpms-political-direction. Notre Dame, USA.
39.
NandiP. (2005). Communism through the ballot box: Over a quarter century of uninterrupted rule in West Bengal. Sociological Bulletin, 54(2), 171–194.
40.
NielsenK.B. (2010). Contesting India’s development? Industrialisation, land acquisition and protest in West Bengal. Forum for Development Studies, 37, 145–170.
41.
NigamA. (1996). Hegemony and counter-hegemony: Understanding Indian communism. Economic & Political Weekly, 31(14), 901–906.
42.
ÖktemK.G. (2012). A comparative analysis of the performance of the parliamentary Left in the Indian states of Kerala, West Bengal and Tripura. South Asia, 35(2), 306–328.
43.
PatnaikP. (2006). Three decades of Left Front rule in Bengal. Nature, Society and Thought, 19(4), 492–497.
44.
PatnaikP. (2007). Re-envisioning socialism. Economic & Political Weekly, 42(44), 41–48.
45.
PatnaikP. (2009). The crisis of the left. Economic & Political Weekly, 44(44), 27–32.
46.
PatnaikP. (2011). Economic growth and employment. Economic & Political Weekly, 46(26–27), 172–176.
47.
RodriguesV. (2006). The communist parties in India. In DeSouzaP.R. & SridharanE. (Eds), India’s political parties (pp. 199–252). New Delhi: SAGE Publications.
48.
RorrisA. (2013). Greece: SYRIZA shifts from coalition to party at First Congress. Search Newsletter, 20(4), 6–8.
49.
RoyD., & BanerjeeP.S. (2006). Left Front’s electorial victory in West Bengal: An ethnographer’s account. Economic & Political Weekly, 41(40), 4251–4256.
50.
RoyS.N. (1996). West Bengal’s industrial development policy. Economic & Political Weekly, 31(18), 1094–1096.
51.
SaderE. (2008). The weakest link? Neoliberalism in Latin America. New Left Review, II/52(July–August), 5–31.
52.
SamaddarR. (2013). Passive revolution in West Bengal: 1977–2011. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.
53.
SandbookR., EdelmanM., HellerP., & TeichmanJ. (2007). Social democracy in the global periphery. Leiden: Cambridge University Press.
54.
SarkarT., & ChowdhuryS. (2009). The meaning of Nandigram: Corporate land invasion, people’s power and the Left in India. Focaal, 54, 73–88.
55.
SethS. (2002). Interpreting revolutionary excess: The Naxalite movement in India, 1967–1971. In BarlowT.E. (Ed.), New Asian Marxism (pp. 333–357). Durham: Duke University Press.
56.
SuriK.C. (2005). Parties under pressure: Political parties in India since independence. Delhi: Lokniti—Centre for the Study of Developing Societies.
57.
VanaikA. (1986). The Indian Left. New Left Review, I/159(September–October), 49–70.
58.
VergheseA.A. (2007, August31–September2). The role of class politics in India: Why West Bengal and Kerala? Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association, Chicago.
59.
ViolaL., DanilovV.P., IvnitskiiN.A., & KozlovD. (Eds). (2005). The war against the peasantry, 1927–1930: The tragedy of the Soviet countryside. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
