Evolution of Credit Risk Management Capability Maturity: Lessons from the Indian Banking Sector

Abstract

A wide array of credit risk management (CRM) practices have been followed by commercial banks since their inception. These practices have evolved over the years; new practices/strategies have been formulated, old practices have been updated/revised, traditional operations are being replaced by new sophisticated procedures. With such continuous evolution of CRM practices, CRM capability maturity of banks has also improved over time. Further, the role/importance and effectiveness of each CRM practice in determining the maturity of CRM capability is an important issue that needs to be addressed. A number of capability maturity models have been suggested in general for a business organisation. However, these studies focus on the assessment of overall business risk management maturity and do not offer any model to trace the path of evolution towards maturity in CRM capability in commercial banks. This article attempts to fill this gap by investigating into how commercial banks mature in their ability to manage credit risk in their advances portfolio. The objective of this study is to go beyond descriptive in terms of specifying practices, challenges and issues in each stage of CRM capability maturity and also be prescriptive in terms of recommended strategies and actions to move on to the next higher level of CRM capability maturity. The path of evolution of credit risk management capability maturity is illustrated on the basis of primary data collected from 35 Indian commercial banks (representing 70 per cent of the population) through a structured questionnaire in year 2007–2008. A comprehensive list of questions relating to major elements of CRM namely, (a) CRM organisation, (b) CRM policy and strategy; and (c) CRM operations and systems at the transaction level; and (d) CRM operations and systems at the portfolio level were included in questionnaire. The CRM index tool is employed to benchmark a given commercial bank’s approach to CRM against four standard levels of maturity. The statistical analysis of scores in four major elements of the CRM index for banks lying in different stages of maturity clearly brings out whether or not credit risk processes/techniques/tools/procedures are adequate, identifies realistic targets for improvement and shall enable bank management to frame concrete plans for evolving towards a higher CRM capability maturity level. This study, by drawing conclusions from empirical data, is unique and contributes to additional insights into the risk management literature in emerging economies.

Keywords

Commercial banks credit risk management capability maturity credit risk management operations and systems Indian banking sector

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Arora

Anju

. (2010). Credit risk management practices: Indian banking experience. Prajann, Journal of Social and Management Sciences, XXXIX (Oct–Dec), 197–198.

Arora

Anju

. (2011). Benchmarking credit risk management operations and systems at transaction level: An evaluation of Indian commercial banks. Prajann, Journal of Social and Management Sciences, XL(2).

Association of Supervisors of Banks of the Americas. (2008). Working group report on ‘Sound management and supervision practices for credit risk in the Americas’.

Crawford

J. K.

(2002). PM solutions project management maturity model: Providing a proven path to project management excellence. New York: Marcel Dekker, Inc.

Hillson

D. A.

(1997). Towards a risk maturity model. The International Journal of Project and Business Risk Management, 1(1), 35–45.

Ibbs

C. W.

Kwak

Y. H.

(2000). Assessing project management maturity. Project Management Journal, 31(1), 32–43.

KPMG International. (2011). Corporate Sustainability: A progress report. Retrieved 10 September 2014, from http://www.kpmg.com/Global/en/IssuesAndInsights/ArticlesPublications/Documents/corporate-sustainability-v2.pdf

Kumar

Arora

Lihelle

J. P.

(2011). Construct of credit risk management index for commercial banks. Bank & Bank Systems, 6(1), 16–25.

Loosemore

Raftery

Reilly

Higgon

(2006). Risk management in projects (Second Edition). New York: Taylor and Francis.

10.

Orisni

Basil

. (2002). Mature risk management. The Internal Auditor, August 2002. Retrieved from www.theiia.org

11.

Ren

Y. T.

Yeo

K. T.

(2004). Risk management capability maturity model for complex product systems projects. Artcile presented at International Engineering Management Conference, Singapore.

12.

Reserve Bank of India. (2002). Reserve Bank of India guidance note on CRM. Retrieved 21 October 2014, from rbidocs.rbi.org.in/rdocs/notification/PDFs/23401.pdf

13.

Reserve Bank of India. (2010). Annual Report.

14.

Risk Management Research and Development Program. (2002). Formal Collaboration: INCOSE Risk Management Working Group, Project Management Institute Risk Management Specific Interest Group, UK Association for Project Management. Retrieved 14 May 2007, from http://www.pmiswitzerland.ch/fall05/riskmm.pdf

15.

Spencer

Pickett, K. H.

(2005). Auditing the risk management process. USA: John Wiley and Sons.

16.

Scott

Roman

(2003). Credit risk management for emerging markets. In Gordon

Gaeta,

(ed.), Frontiers in credit risk (pp. 420–435). United States: Wiley Finance.