To compare immediate interlocking nailing with external fixation followed by delayed interlocking nailing, for Gustilo type IIIB open tibial fractures.
Methods.
23 patients with Gustilo IIIB open tibial fractures were treated with either immediate unreamed interlocking nailing (n=9) or external fixation followed by delayed unreamed interlocking nailing (n=14). Patient age, sex ratio, fracture site, fracture type, and severity were similar in both groups. The time to union, deep infection rate, and nonunion rate in the 2 groups were compared.
Results.
In the immediate and delayed nailing groups, respective mean times to union were 21 (standard deviation [SD], 14) months and 14 (SD, 8) months; nonunion rates were 44% (4/9) and 36% (5/14), and deep infection rates were 22% (2/9) and 7% (1/14). All corresponding differences were not statistically significant.
Conclusion.
Prospective, randomised, multicentre studies are needed to assess whether there are significant differences between the 2 treatment methods.
GustiloRBMendozaRMWilliamsDN. Problems in the management of type III (severe) open fractures: A new classification of type III open fractures. J Trauma1984;24:742–6.
2.
GodinaM. Early microsurgical reconstruction of complex trauma of the extremities. Plast Reconstr Surg1986;78:285–92.
3.
YaremchukMJBrumbackRJMansonPNBurgessARPokaAWeilandAJ. Acute and definitive management of traumatic osteocutaneous defects of the lower extremity. Plast Reconstr Surg1987;80:1–14.
4.
TrabulsyPPKerleySMHoffmanWY. A prospective study of early soft tissue coverage of grade IIIB tibial fractures. J Trauma1994;36:661–8.
5.
AhoAJNieminenSJNylamoEI. External fixation by Hoffmann-Vidal-Adrey osteotaxis for severe tibial fractures. Treatment scheme and technical criticism. Clin Orthop Relat Res1983;181:154–64.
6.
EdwardsCC. Staged reconstruction of complex open tibial fractures using Hoffmann external fixation. Clinical decisions and dilemmas. Clin Orthop Relat Res1983;178:130–61.
7.
TornettaP3rdBergmanMWatnikNBerkowitzGSteuerJ. Treatment of grade-IIIb open tibial fractures. A prospective randomised comparison of external fixation and non-reamed locked nailing. J Bone Joint Surg Br1994;76:13–9.
8.
TuYKLinCHSuJIHsuDTChenRJ. Unreamed interlocking nail versus external fixator for open type III tibia fractures. J Trauma1995;39:361–7.
9.
BlickSSBrumbackRJLakatosRPokaABurgessAR. Early prophylactic bone grafting of high-energy tibial fractures. Clin Orthop Relat Res1989;240:21–41.
10.
DervinGF. Skeletal fixation of grade IIIB tibial fractures. The potential of metaanalysis. Clin Orthop Relat Res1996;332:10–5.
11.
HenleyMBChapmanJRAgelJHarveyEJWhortonAMSwiontkowskiMF. Treatment of type II, IIIA, and IIIB open fractures of the tibial shaft: A prospective comparison of unreamed interlocking intramedullary nails and half-pin external fixators. J Orthop Trauma1998;12:1–7.
12.
MaurerDJMerkowRLGustiloRB. Infection after intramedullary nailing of severe open tibial fractures initially treated with external fixation. J Bone Joint Surg Am1989;71:835–8.
13.
McGrawJMLimEV. Treatment of open tibial-shaft fractures. External fixation and secondary intramedullary nailing. J Bone Joint Surg Am1988;70:900–11.
14.
KrettekCSeekampAKontoppHTscherneH. Hannover Fracture Scale '98—re-evaluation and new perspectives of an established extremity salvage score. Injury2001;32:317–28.
15.
BakerSPO'NeillBHaddonWJrLongWB. The injury severity score: A method for describing patients with multiple injuries and evaluating emergency care. J Trauma1974;14:187–96.
16.
MuellerME. The comprehensive classification of fractures of long bones. In: MuellerMEAllogowerMSchneiderRWillenggerH, editors. Manual of internal fixation. 3rd ed.Berlin: Springer-Verlag; 1991:118–50.
17.
YokoyamaKItomanMNakamuraKUchinoMTsukamotoTSuzukiT. Primary shortening with secondary limb lengthening for Gustilo IIIB open tibial fractures: A report of six cases. J Trauma2006;61:172–80.
18.
KempfIGrosseABeckG. Closed locked intramedullary nailing. Its application to comminuted fractures of the femur. J Bone Joint Surg Am1985;67:709–20.
19.
DellingerEPMillerSDWertzMJGrypmaMDroppertBAndersonPA. Risk of infection after open fracture of the arm or leg. Arch Surg1988;123:1320–7.
20.
ChanKMLeungYKChengJCLeungPC. The management of type III open tibial fractures. Injury1984;16:157–65.
21.
YokoyamaKItomanMTanakaKKaiHShindoMUiK. Secondary unreamed intramedullary nailing following external fixation and acute flap coverage for type IIIB open tibia fractures: A report of three successful cases. J Orthop Surg (Hong Kong)1998;6:71–7.
22.
UenoMYokoyamaKNakamuraKUchinoMSuzukiTItomanM. Early unreamed intramedullary nailing without a safety interval and simultaneous flap coverage following external fixation in type IIIB open tibial fractures: A report of four successful cases. Injury2006;37:289–94.
23.
YokoyamaKShindoMItomanMYamamotoMSasamotoN. Immediate internal fixation for open fractures of the long bones of the upper and lower extremities. J Trauma1994;37:230–6.
24.
BokuTYokoyamaKNakamuraKUchinoMSuzukiTOhtsukaH. Functional outcome and quality of life of Gustilo IIIB open tibial fractures requiring free tissue transfers: A report of eight cases. Microsurgery2005;25:532–7.
25.
YokoyamaKItomanMNakamuraKTsukamotoTSaitaYAokiS. Free vascularized fibular graft vs. Ilizarov method for post-traumatic tibial bone defect. J Reconstr Microsurg2001;17:17–25.
26.
MineharaHYokoyamaKSekiguchiMNakamuraTShindoMItomanM. Bone transport combined with free flap reconstruction and antibiotic bead spacers for a type IIIB open tibial fracture: Case report. J Trauma1998;44:1103–7.
27.
YagiKYokoyamaKNakamuraTTsukamotoTItomanMTanakaK. Primary shortening with secondary limb lengthening for type IIIB tibial fracture: A case report on refracture at the docking site. J Orthop Surg (Hong Kong)1998;6:101–5.
28.
ScaleaTMBoswellSAScottJDMitchellKAKramerMEPollakAN. External fixation as a bridge to intramedullary nailing for patients with multiple injuries and with femur fractures: Damage control orthopedics. J Trauma2000;48:613–23.
29.
PapeHCHildebrandFPertschySZelleBGarapatiRGrimmeK. Changes in the management of femoral shaft fractures in polytrauma patients: From early total care to damage control orthopedic surgery. J Trauma2002;53:452–62.
30.
MarshallPDSalehMDouglasDL. Risk of deep infection with intramedullary nailing following the use of external fixators. J R Coll Surg Edinb1991;36:268–71.
31.
Antich-AdroverPMarí-GarinDMurias-AlvarezJPuente-AlonsoC. External fixation and secondary intramedullary nailing of open tibial fractures. A randomised, prospective trial. J Bone Joint Surg Br1997;79:433–7.
32.
BlachutPAMeekRNO'BrienPJ. External fixation and delayed intramedullary nailing of open fractures of the tibial shaft. A sequential protocol. J Bone Joint Surg Am1990;72:729–35.
33.
RiemerBLButterfieldSL. Comparison of reamed and nonreamed solid core nailing of the tibial diaphysis after external fixation: A preliminary report. J Orthop Trauma1993;7:279–85.
34.
SiebenrockKAGerichTJakobRP. Sequential intramedullary nailing of open tibial shaft fractures after external fixation. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg1997;116:32–6.
35.
WheelwrightEFCourt-BrownCM. Primary external fixation and secondary intramedullary nailing in the treatment of tibial fractures. Injury1992;23:373–6.
36.
WuCCShihCH. Complicated open fractures of the distal tibia treated by secondary interlocking nailing. J Trauma1993;34:792–6.
37.
YokoyamaKUchinoMNakamuraKOhtsukaHSuzukiTBokuT. Risk factors for deep infection in secondary intramedullary nailing after external fixation for open tibial fractures. Injury2006;37:554–60.
38.
BhandariMZlowodzkiMTornettaP3rdSchmidtATemplemanDC. Intramedullary nailing following external fixation in femoral and tibial shaft fractures. J Orthop Trauma2005;19:140–4.
39.
GopalSMajumderSBatchelorAGKnightSLDe BoerPSmithRM. Fix and flap: The radical orthopaedic and plastic treatment of severe open fractures of the tibia. J Bone Joint Surg Br2000;82:959–66.
40.
GopalSGiannoudisPVMurrayAMatthewsSJSmithRM. The functional outcome of severe, open tibial fractures managed with early fixation and flap coverage. J Bone Joint Surg Br2004;86:861–7.
