Russia’s centralized authoritarianism in the disguise of democratic federalism: Evidence from the September 2017 sub-national elections

Abstract

While formally a federation that vests significant powers in the sub-national bodies of government and leaves it for its federal units and municipalities to decide who will govern them by conducting elections, the Russian Federation is effectively a centralized authoritarian state. This paper uses evidence from the September 2017 sub-national elections in Russia to examine the role of formal political institutions in sustaining the country’s political regime. The analysis shows that the political domination of the pro-government party over the regional political assemblies is sustained by a complex combination of party regulations and electoral rules. In particular, gubernatorial elections are organized and conducted in a way that ensures the victories of the incumbent governors who are effectively appointed by the president of Russia.

Keywords

Authoritarianism elections municipal government regional government Russia

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bader

Van Ham

(2015) What explains regional variation in election fraud? Evidence from Russia: a research note. Post-Soviet Affairs 31(6): 514–528.

Bahry

(2005) The new federalism and the paradoxes of regional sovereignty in Russia. Comparative Politics 37(2): 127–146.

Blakkisrud

(2011) Medvedev’s new governors. Europe-Asia Studies 63(3): 367–395.

Blakkisrud

(2015) Governing the governors: legitimacy vs control in the reform of the Russian regional executive. East European Politics 31(1): 104–121.

Bunce

(1998) Subversive institutions: the end of the Soviet state in comparative perspective. Post-Soviet Affairs 14(4): 323–354.

Busygina

Filippov

Taukebaeva

(2018) To decentralize or to continue on the centralization track: The cases of authoritarian regimes in Russia and Kazakhstan. Journal of Eurasian Studies 9(1): 61–71.

Chaisty

(2012) Members and leaders in Russian party organizations. East European Politics 28(3): 283–297.

DeBardeleben

Zherebtsov

(2014) The reinstated gubernatorial elections in Russia: a return to open politics? REGION: Regional Studies of Russia Eastern Europe and Central Asia 3(1): 3–36.

Demchenko

Golosov

(2016) Federalism, gubernatorial power and the incorporation of subnational authoritarianism in Russia: a theory-testing empirical inquiry. Acta Politica 51(1): 61–79.

10.

Dickovick

(2007) Municipalization as central government strategy: central-regional-local politics in Peru, Brazil, and South Africa. Publius: The Journal of Federalism 37(1): 1–25.

11.

Epstein

(2014) Ballot access, vlast’ dominance and pomoshchnik political culture in Russia’s subnational executive elections. REGION: Regional Studies of Russia Eastern Europe and Central Asia 3(1): 83–123.

12.

Filippov

Shvetsova

(1999) Asymmetric bilateral bargaining in the new Russian Federation: a path-dependence explanation. Communist and Post-Communist Studies 32(1): 61–76.

13.

Galimova

Kuznetsova

(2017) V Kremle otkazalis’ sokhranyat’ osobyi dogovor s Tatarstanom. Available at: http://www.rbc.ru/politics/11/07/2017/5963b9d09a7947cc065a5b11 (accessed 23 May 2018).

14.

Gandhi

Lust-Okar

(2009) Elections under authoritarianism. Annual Review of Political Science 12: 403–422.

15.

Gandhi

Przeworski

(2007) Authoritarian institutions and the survival of autocrats. Comparative Political Studies 40(11): 1279–1301.

16.

Gel’man

(2004) The unrule of law in the making: the politics of informal institution building in Russia. Europe-Asia Studies 56(7): 1021–1040.

17.

Gel’man

(2015) Political opposition in Russia: a troubled transformation. Europe-Asia Studies 67(2): 177–191.

18.

Gel’man

Ryzhenkov

Brie

(2003) Making and Breaking Democratic Transitions: The Comparative Politics of Russia’s Regions. Lanham MD: Rowman and Littlefield.

19.

Gel’man

Ross

(eds) (2010) The Politics of Sub-National Authoritarianism in Russia. Burlington: Ashgate.

20.

Golosov

(2006) The structure of party alternatives and voter choice in Russia: evidence from the 2003–2004 regional legislative elections. Party Politics 12(6): 707–725.

21.

Golosov

(2011a) Russia’s regional legislative elections, 2003–2007: authoritarianism incorporated. Europe-Asia Studies 63(3): 397–414.

22.

Golosov

(2011b) The regional roots of electoral authoritarianism in Russia. Europe-Asia Studies 63(4): 93–110.

23.

Golosov

G V

(2012) The 2012 political reform in Russia: the interplay of liberalizing concessions and authoritarian corrections. Problems of Post-Communism 59(6): 3–14.

24.

Golosov

(2013a) Proportional representation and authoritarianism: evidence from Russia’s regional election law reform. Representation 49(1): 83–95.

25.

Golosov

(2013b) Machine politics: the concept and its implications for post-Soviet studies. Demokratizatsiya: The Journal of Post-Soviet Democratization 21(4): 459–480.

26.

Golosov

(2014) The last resort of political regionalism: electoral blocs in Russia’s regional legislative elections, 2003–2005. East European Politics 30(1): 71–85.

27.

Golosov

(2015a) Do spoilers make a difference? Instrumental manipulation of political parties in an electoral authoritarian regime, the case of Russia. East European Politics 31(2): 170–186.

28.

Golosov

(2015b) The idiosyncratic dynamics of party system nationalization in Russia. Post-Soviet Affairs 31(5): 397–419.

29.

Golosov

Gushchina

Kononenko

(2016) Russia’s local government in the process of authoritarian regime transformation: incentives for the survival of local democracy. Local Government Studies 42(4): 507–526.

30.

Goode

(2007) The puzzle of Putin’s gubernatorial appointments. Europe-Asia Studies 59(3): 365–399.

31.

Goode

(2013) The revival of Russia’s gubernatorial elections: liberalization or Potemkin reform? Russian Analytical Digest, no. 139: 9–11.

32.

Gorenburg

(2003) Minority Ethnic Mobilization in the Russian Federation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

33.

Hale

(2003) Explaining machine politics in Russia’s regions: economy, ethnicity and legacy. Post-Soviet Affairs 19(3): 228–263.

34.

Hale

(2004) The origins of United Russia and the Putin presidency: the role of contingency in party-system development. Demokratizatsiiya: The Journal of Post-Soviet Democratization 12(2): 169–194.

35.

Hale

H E

Colton

(2010) Russians and the Putin-Medvedev ’tandemocracy’: a survey-based portrait of the 2007–2008 election season. Problems of Post-Communism 57 (2): 3–20.

36.

Kahn

(2000) The parade of sovereignties: establishing the vocabulary of the new Russian federalism. Post-Soviet Affairs 16(1): 58–89.

37.

Kahn

Trochev

Balayan

(2009) The unification of law in the Russian Federation. Post-Soviet Affairs 25(4): 310–346.

38.

Lyubarev

(2018) Chem obernetsya bor’ba za yavku na vybory. Available at: http://www.rbc.ru/newspaper/2018/03/13/5aa63c9e9a7947eb4a2e54fd (accessed 22 May 2018).

39.

Magaloni

Kricheli

(2010) Political order and one-party rule. Annual Review of Political Science 13: 123–143.

40.

March

(2009) Managing opposition in a hybrid regime: Just Russia and parastatal opposition. Slavic Review 68(3): 504–527.

41.

Matsuzato

(2001) From ethno-Bonapartism to centralized caciquismo: characteristics and origins of the Tatarstan political regime, 1900–2000. Journal of Communist Studies and Transition Politics 17(4): 43–77.

42.

Melikyan

(2017) Optovye otstavki: pochemu Kreml’ provodit zachistki, a gubernatory ‘psikhuyut’. Available at: http://lentaru/articles/2017/10/02/planting_of_greenery/ (accessed 19 January 2017).

43.

Mitin

(2008) From rebellion to submission: the evolution of Russian federalism under Putin. Problems of Post-Communism 55(5): 49–61.

44.

Moraski

Reisinger

(2003) Explaining electoral competition across Russia’s Regions. Slavic Review 62(2): 278–301.

45.

Moraski

Reisinger

(2007) Eroding democracy: federal intervention in Russia’s gubernatorial elections. Democratization 14(4): 603–621.

46.

Myagkov

Ordeshook

(2001) The trail of votes in Russia’s 1999 Duma and 2000 presidential elections. Communist and Post-Communist Studies 34(3): 353–370.

47.

Panov

(2016) How do governors build a power vertical in the context of mayoral elections? Russian Politics 1(3): 252–268.

48.

Panov

Ross

(2013) Sub-national elections in Russia: variations in United Russia’s domination of regional assemblies. Europe-Asia Studies 65(4): 737–752.

49.

Petrov

Lipman

Hale

(2014) Three dilemmas of hybrid regime governance: Russia from Putin to Putin. Post-Soviet Affairs 30(1): 1–26.

50.

Reddaway

Orttung

(eds) (2004) The Dynamics of Russian Politics: Putin’s Reform of Federal-Regional Relations. Lanham MD: Rowman and Littlefield.

51.

Reisinger

Moraski

(2017) The Regional Roots of Russia’s Political Regime. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.

52.

Reuter

(2013) Regional patrons and hegemonic party electoral performance in Russia. Post-Soviet Affairs 29(2): 101–135.

53.

Reuter

Robertson

(2012) Subnational appointments in authoritarian regimes: evidence from Russian gubernatorial Appointments. Journal of Politics 74(4): 1023–1037.

54.

Ross

(2005) Federalism and electoral authoritarianism under Putin. Demokratizatsiya: The Journal of Post-Soviet Democratization 13(3): 347–371.

55.

Ross

(2007) Municipal reform in the Russian Federation and Putin’s ‘electoral vertical’. Demokratizatsiya: The Journal of Post-Soviet Democratization 15(2): 191–208.

56.

Rubin

Rustamova

(2015) Sibir’ za ‘krasnymi’: kak kandidat ot vlasti proigral irkutskie vybory. Available at: http://www.rbc.ru/politics/27/09/2015/56082d319a79472b3f3a4800 (accessed 23 May 2018).

57.

Sharafutdinova

(2010) Subnational governance in Russia: how Putin changed the contract with his agents and the problems it created for Medvedev. Publius: The Journal of Federalism 40(4): 672–696.

58.

Sharafutdinova

(2015) Elite management in electoral authoritarian regimes: a view from Bashkortostan and Tatarstan. Central Asian Affairs 2(2): 117–139.

59.

Smyth

Lowry

Wilkening

(2007) Engineering victory: institutional reform, informal institutions and the formation of a hegemonic party regime in the Russian Federation. Post-Soviet Affairs 23 (2): 118–137.

60.

Solnick

(1998) Gubernatorial elections in Russia, 1996–1997. Post-Soviet Affairs 14(1): 48–80.

61.

Stoner-Weiss

(1997) Local Heroes: The Political Economy of Russian Regional Governance. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

62.

White

(2015) How ethnicity matters in Russian elections: ethnic minorities and support for the United Russia party. Eurasian Geography and Economics 56(5): 524–546.

63.

Wollmann

Gritsenko

(2009) Local self-government in Russia: between de-centralisation and re-centralisation. In: Ross

Campbell

(eds) Federalism and Local Politics in Russia. London and New York: Routledge, pp. 227–248.

64.

Zavadskaya

(2018) The fight for turnout: growing personalism in the Russian presidential elections of 2018. Russian Analytical Digest 217: 2–4.