Based on an analysis of remarks by top Communist Party of China (CPC) and government leaders and intellectuals on democracy, this study tries to analyze if Chinese-style democracy offers a new model of democracy distinguishable from the liberal Western model. Based on our analysis, the theory of Chinese-style democracy calls for a change in the governance structure, while maintaining the existing model of the people's democracy. It does not present a new model of democracy that is distinguishable from the existing people's democracy or Western liberal representative democracy. This means China intends to achieve political change under CPC leadership, with strong CPC control over the democratization process.
HeywoodAndrewPolitics, (translated in Korean by Cho Hyun Soo), (Seoul: Sungkyunkwan University Press2003)
2.
ZhaoBaohua, “Zhongguode gaige yu minzhuhua quanjiang-jianping haiwai xuezhede Zhongguominzhuguan” [Prospects of China's reform and democratization—with a focus on overseas scholars'evaluations of China's view of democracy], http://www.chinaelections.org/PrintNews.asp?NewsID=130888 accessed August 20, 2008
3.
WangChangjiang, “Buneng ba minzhude shenme dongxi dou kanzuo shi “Xifang'de” [We can't regard everything related to democracy as belonging to the West]People's Tribune(Tianjin, China)No.8 (2007)
4.
ZhuChun-mei, “Mao Zedong, Deng Xiaoping Shehuizhuyi minzhusixiang zhi bijiao” [Democratic Thought Comparison between Mao Zhedong and Deng Xiaoping], Jilinsheng jingjiguali ganbu xueyuan xuebao [Journal of Jilin Province Economic Management Cadre College](Changcun, China), Vol. 21, No.4 (August, 2007)
5.
YangDeshanSuHaizou, Zhongguo gongchandang yu dangdai Zhongguo minzhuzhengzhi jianshe [The CPC and the contemporary China's democratic political construction] (Beijing: Chinese Communist Press, 2008)
6.
XiaopingDeng, Dengxiaoping wenxian (disanjuan) [Collection of Deng Xiaoping's Writings (Vol. 3)], (Beiijng: People's Publishing House, 1994)
7.
XiaopingDeng, Dengxiaoping wenxian (dierjuan) [Collection of Deng Xiaoping's Writings (Vol. 2)], (Beiijng: People's Publishing House, 1994)
8.
ZhaoDie, “Lun yi dangnei minzhu cujin shehuiminzhu” [A study of a view on promoting social democracy based on intra-party democracy], Chongqingkejixueyuanxuebao (Shehuikexueban) [Joumal of Chongqing University of Science and Technology (Social Sciences Edition)](Chongqing, China)No.3 (2008)
YunDonghua, “Rendaminzhu yinggai chengwei Zhongguo zhenggaide huochetou”[Democratization of the NPC should serve as the leading factor for China's political reform], http://www.chinaelections.org, accesssed April 4, 2008
11.
XuDongli, “liening duimakesizhuyi minzhuguande fengfu he fazhan” [Lenin's enrichment and development of the Marxist view of democracy]”, Lilunxuexi [Theories and learning](Beijing)No.8 (2003)
12.
GaoFang, “Jiakuai zhengzhitizhi gaige, wanshan Zhongguominzhumoshi” [Let's complete a Chinese model of democracy by speeding up the reform of the political system], http://www.chinaelections.org/NewsInfo.asp?NewsID=121944, accessed March 13, 2008
ZhuGuangleiYangGuangbin, “Zhongguo chuangzao minzhu xinmoshi shi wanquan kenengde” [It's totally possible for China to build a new model of democracy], People's Tribune(Tianjin, China)No.8 (2007)
16.
XiaoGongqin, “Cong zhengzhifazhan jiaodu kan “Dangneiminzhuhualun” [The theory of intra-party democracy seen from the standpoint of political development], Zhejiangxuekan [Zhejiang Academic Journal](Hangzhou, China), No.2 (2004)
17.
HuJintao, “Zai jinian Mao zedong tanshen 110zhounian jiangzuohuide jianghua” [A speech at a ceremony marking the 110th birthday of Mao Zedong], http://www.xinhuanet.com, accessed December 26, 2003
18.
HuJintao, “Gaoju Zhongguotese shehuizhuyi daqizhi, weiduoqu quanmian jianshe xiaokangshehui xinshengli er duomen: zai Zhongguo gongchandang di shiqici quanguodaibiaodahuishangde baogao” [Let's try to win a new victory for the wholesale construction of a well-off society, upholding the great banner of Chinese-style socialism: A Report to the 17th CPC National Congress] http://www.people.com.cn, accessed October 15, 2007
19.
YanJian (eds.), Minzhu shi ge haodongxi-Yu keping fangtanlu [Democracy is a good thing—an interview with Yu Keping] (Beijing: Social Science Academy Press2006)
20.
LeeJong Suk, Understanding of a New Modern North Korea (Seoul: Yeoksa Bipyeong-sa2000)
21.
YanJirong, “Zhongguode gaige: ling yizhong minzhuhua jingyan” [China's reform: Experience of a new kind of democratization]People's Tribune(Tianjin, China)No.8 (2007)
22.
LeeJung Nam, China's Elections, Political Reform and Political Change (Seoul: Politeia Press2007)
23.
LiJue, “Jiang zemin dui Mao Zedong, Deng Xiaoping shehuizhuyi minzhuzhengzhisixiangde jicheng fazhan fenxi” [Jiang Zemin's analysis of the inheritance and development of socialist democratic political ideologies by Mao Zedong and Deng Xiaoping], Dangde wenxuan [Literature of Chinese Communist Party](Beijing), No.4 (2004)
24.
JiangZemin, Lun dangde jianshe [Jiang on party construction], (Beijing: Central Party Literature Press, 2001)
25.
JiangZemin, Jiang zemin wenxuan (disanjuan) [Collection of Jiang Zemin's Writings (Vol. 3)], (Beijing: Central Party Literature Press, 2006)
26.
JiangZemin, “Jiangzemin zai dangde shiliuda shang suozuode baogao:quanmian jianshe xiaokangshehui, laichuang Zhongguotese shehuizhuyi shiye xin jumian” [Jiang Zemin's report to the 16th CPC National Congress: Let's build a well-off society in a wholesale way and find a new breakthrough in projects for the Chinese-style socialism], http://www.people.com.cn, accessed November 17, 2002
27.
LiuJunning“Dangneiminzhu, huo xuanzhengminzhu” [Intra-party democracy or constitutional democracy], http://www.chinaelections.org, accessed April 3, 2008
28.
WuJianmin“Zhongguo yao shenmeyangde minzhu” [What kind of democracy does China want?], the overseas version of the People's Daily, Feb. 4, 2008
29.
JohnL. Thornton, “Long Time Coming: The Prospect for Democracy in China,”Foreign Affairs, (Jan/Feb, 2008)
YuKeping, “Yukeping tan “Zhongguomoshi” yu “bushijiazhi-fang zhongyang bianyiju fujuzhang Yukeping [An interview with Yu Keping, Chinese Compilation & Translation Bureau, on a Chinese model and universal values], Beijingribao [Beijing Daily] Nov. 18, 2008
32.
LeninLeninguanji[Collection of Lenin's Writings (Vol.3)] (Beijing: People's Publishing House1972)
33.
DiamondLarryRamonH. Myers, Elections and Democracy in Greater China (Oxford University Press, 2004)
34.
PeiMinxin, China's trapped transition: the limits of developmental autocracy (Cambridge, Massachusetts, London, England: Harvard University Press2006)
35.
“QuanguoRendahuiyi kaimu Wenjiabao zuo zhengfu gongzuo baogao (quanmen)”, [Wen Jiabao delivers a government report at the opening session of the National People's Congress (full text)], http://www.people.com.cn, accessed March 5, 2007
36.
WuQijin, “Cong Xinminzhuzhuyilun dao ‘Sangedaibiao’ zhongyaosixiang” [From new-democratic theories to three major ideologies], Jinlingkejixueyuanxuebao (shehuikexueban) [Journal of Jinling Institute of Technology (Social Science)](Nanjing, China)Vol.19, No.2 (2005, June)
ZhaoSuisheng, Debating Political Reform in China: Rule of Law vs. Democratization (Armonk, New York, London, England: M.E. Sharpe2006)
39.
ZhaoShuiSheng (ed) China and Democracy (New York: Routledge2000)
40.
OgdenSuzanne, Inklings of Democracy in China (Cambridge and London: Harvard University Press2002)
41.
SusanL. Shirk, China: fragile superpower (Oxford University Press, 2007)
42.
ZengShiyi, “Fangling fangtan: lang minzhu cong wujiezhong baituo chulai” [Fangning Reportage; It's necessary to rescue democracy from misunderstanding], Xueshutanbang [Academic Exploration] (Kunming, China), No. 5 (2007)
43.
WangTiejun, “Yibaiduonianqian minzhusixiang zai Zhongguode Chuanbo he fazhan” [The introduction of the democratic ideology into China about 100 years ago and its development], http://www.chinaelections.org/NewsInfo.asp?NewsID=124185, accessed April 4, 2008
44.
ZhouTianyongWangChangjiangWangAnlingGongjian: Zhongguo zhengzhitizhigaige yanjiu baogao [A Research Report on Reform of the Political System in China], (Xinjiang, China: Xinjiang Production and Construction Corps Press, 2007)
45.
WenJiabao, “Qingnian yao jisheng Wusi Chuantong: Wenjiabao Wusi qingnianjie kanwang Beishida xuesheng” [The youth should inherit the spirit of the May 4 Movement: Wen Jiabao meets students from Beijing Normal University on May 4 Youth Day], http://www.xinhuanet.com, accessed May 4, 2006
46.
“Wen jiaobao zai tan Xiangzhenzhixuan: Wenjiabao Fang Ouqian jieshou Ouzhoumeiti caifang”[WenJiabao mentions direct elections in Xiangzhen once again: Wen gives an interview to a European media outlet before embarking on a trip to Europe], http://www.chinanews.com.cn, accessed September 6, 2006
47.
“Wenjiaobao tan shehuizhuyi chujijieduande lishi renwu he duiwaizhengce”[Wen Jiabao talks about external policies and the historic duties in the primary stage of socialism], http://www.xinhuanet.com, accessed February 27, 2007
ZhuXueqin, “2007: sixiang zai poju, gaige yao gaifang” [2007: Opening up is also needed in addition to reform, as ideologies are about to collapse], Nanfangdushibao [The Southern Metropolitan Daily](Guangzhou, China), Jan. 1, 2008
53.
DongYunhuLiuMuping, Shijie renquan yuefa zonglan xubian [International Human Rights Law: an overview] (Chengdu: Sichuan People's Publishing House, 1993)
54.
XuYaotong, “Dangquan woguo minzhuzhengzhi jianshede zhuolidian [Important points in the contemporary China's democratic political construction], ZhonghuaYingcai [China Hero](Beijing), No.3 (2008)
55.
ZhengYongnian, “Fansi minzhu shi weile Zhongguo geng kuai, geng haode minzhuhua” [An introspective review of democracy aims to achieve a better model of democracy in a quicker way for China], http://www.dnews.com, accessed February 27, 2008
56.
XiongYuezhi, Zhongguo jindai minzhu sixiangshi [The History of Modern Chinese Democratic Ideology] (Shanghai: Shanghai Social Sciences Publishing House, 2002)
57.
ChoYoung Nam, “China's Political Reform and Chinese-style Democracy,” International Symposium on the “Possibility of Application of a Chinese Model”, Apr. 12, 2008, Sungkyunkwan University Six Centennial Hall(Seoul)
58.
“Zhongyangdangxiao zhuanjia: jiao gao shuiping zhengzhi minzhu xu 60nian”[Expert at the Party School of the Central Committee of the CPC: It will take 60 years to realize political democratization at a relatively high level], http://www.chinaelections.org/NewsInfo.asp?NewsID=125351, accessed May 28, 2008
ChenZhaodeXuTeng, “Yi dangnei minzhu tuijin renminminzhu-Zhongguo zhengzhi fazhande lujing xuanze” [Promotion based on intra-party democracy—ways for China's political development], Gansu Lilun Xuekan [Gansu Theory Research](Lanzhou, China), No.1 (January, 2004)
61.
XuZhongming, “‘Zhongtixuyong’ yu Zhongguo tese”[“Zhongti Xiyong” (to take Chinese learning as the essence and Western learning for its utility) and Chinese characteristics], http://www.chinaelections.org/PrintNews.asp?NewsID=134984, accessed September 24, 2008
62.
MaoZedong, Maozedongxianji (wujuan)[Collection of Mao Zedong's Writings (Vol. 5)] (Beijing: People's Publishing House1977)
63.
WangZongli, “Lun renminminzhude shixian xingshi” [Research on methods of realization of people's democracy], Gansushehuikexue [Gansu Social Science](Lanzhou, China), No.1 (2008)
