Reasons for elective orthopedic operations cancellation in an educational hospital

Abstract

Background

Cancellation during elective surgeries on the day of surgery is one of the many challenges that cause operational disruptions, resource waste, low patient satisfaction, and adverse influences on medical outcomes. Therefore, this study was conducted to determine the frequency of cancellation of elective orthopedic operations performed on the day of surgery.

Methods

This retrospective study was conducted to evaluate same-day cancellations of elective orthopedic surgeries over a one-year period from March 2022 to February 2023. Data were collected via hospital records, focusing on demographic information, type of operation, and causes of cancellation.

Results

Among 4954 intended elective orthopedic surgeries, 299 were cancelled on the day of surgery. Cancellations occurred mostly because of administrative (29.8%), surgeon-related (28.4%), and medical and anesthesiology factors (27.1%). Other factors included the administration of preoperative preparations (8.4%) and patient-related factors (6.4%). Fracture surgeries have the highest cancellation rates owing to administrative and anesthesia-related causes.

Conclusions

Cancellations of elective orthopedic surgery were due mainly to administrative, surgeon-related, and anesthesia-related factors. Improvements in theater resources, perioperative optimization, and good communication between surgeons and patients could effectively reduce such cancellation rates.

Keywords

Cancellations elective operations orthopedic operations

Introduction

The cancellation of elective surgeries is a global problem, with severe consequences for healthcare systems and patients.¹ These cancellations often lead to a waste of time, resources, and workforce, negatively affecting patients’ medical conditions and psychological well-being.^2,3 A previous study reported that with each surgery cancellation, patients and their families are forced to miss an average of five days from work, which has a tremendous impact on the entire country's economic system.⁴ Cancellation rates for elective procedures ranged between 1.96%⁵ and 49%,⁶ increasing the costs by up to 21.2%.⁷ Studies have shown that cardiovascular and orthopedic cases are the most frequently canceled elective surgeries.^8,9 The rate of surgical cancellations in orthopedics is estimated to be 20–45%.^10–12 Understanding the reasons for these cancellations can help minimize losses and improve patient care.¹³ This study evaluated the causes of same-day cancellations for elective orthopedic surgeries in an educational hospital and explored potential strategies to address them.

Methods

This retrospective study was conducted to evaluate same-day cancellations of elective orthopedic surgeries over a one-year period from March 2022 to February 2023 at Poursina Educational and Medical Hospital, a referral center located in Guilan Province, Iran. More than 12,000 surgical procedures and complicated orthopedic operations, such as trauma, joint replacement, and pediatric orthopedic procedures, are performed annually at our hospital. It consists of six specialized wards, two main surgical theaters with nine rooms, and a 23-bed intensive care unit (ICU).

All patients who were scheduled for elective orthopedic surgery and whose surgeries were canceled on the day of the procedure were included in this study. Excluded cases were cancellations that did not fall into any of the predefined categories.

Data were collected from patients in the orthopedic department of Poursina Educational and Medical Hospital during the study period. The study included surgeries that were canceled on the day of the procedure. The reasons for cancellation were extracted retrospectively from patient records. Hospital records were reviewed by a general physician to document relevant details, including the patient's age, sex, month of canceled surgery, type of operation, and reasons for cancellation. The study was approved by the Guilan University Medical Sciences Ethics Committee (IR.GUMS.REC.1402.161). Informed consent was obtained from all patients involved in the study, and all data collection adhered to the Declaration of Helsinki. Statistical analysis was performed using SPSS (version 28), and categorical variables are expressed as frequencies and percentages. Descriptive statistics were used to summarize the data. Inferential statistics, such as chi-square tests, were applied to identify significant predictors of cancellations.

Results

Over the study period, 12,294 surgeries were performed at Poursina Hospital, of which 4954 (40.3%) were elective orthopedic surgeries. Among these, 6% (299 cases) were canceled on the same day as scheduled. The majority of cancellations involved male patients, accounting for 72.2% (216 cases) of the cancellations, with a male-to-female ratio of 2.6:1. The mean age of the patients was 50.28 ± 21.66 years. The most common cause of cancellation was administrative factors, accounting for 29.8% of the cases. These include a shortage of intensive care beds and deficiencies in surgical equipment. Surgeon-related issues were the second most common cause, accounting for 28.4% of cancellations, and included the unavailability of surgeons and emergency priorities. Anesthetic and medical reasons contributed to 27.1% of the cancellations, including patients who were unfit for anesthesia or had abnormal laboratory results (Figure 1).

Figure 1.

Reasons for same-day cancellations of elective orthopedic surgeries.

Patient-related factors such as failure to follow preoperative instructions accounted for 6.4% of cancellations, whereas inadequate preoperative preparation contributed to 8.4% of cancellations. Fracture surgery had the highest cancellation rate, accounting for 76.6% (229 patients) of all canceled procedures. Other canceled procedures included laceration and repair surgeries (14%), implant removal (5.3%), joint arthroplasty (2.7%), and dislocation surgeries (1.3%) (Table 1).

Table 1.

Orthopedic surgery cancellations according to the type of scheduled procedures.

Type of surgery	Cancellation no. (%)
Fracture	229 (11%)
Laceration and repair	42 (1.9%)
Implant removal	16 (6.9%)
Joint arthroplasty and reconstruction	8 (2.8%)
Dislocation	4 (4.3%)

The fracture surgery group had the highest frequency of cancellations, with administrative and anesthesia-related factors being the primary reasons (72 (31.4%) and 65 (28.4%) cases, respectively) (Figure 2).

Figure 2.

The frequency of reasons for cancellations in different types of orthopedic surgeries.

Most cancellations occurred in November and December, predominantly because of administrative factors, whereas surgeon-related issues were the leading cause in May (Figure 3).

Figure 3.

The frequency distributions of orthopedic operation cancellations in different months.

The majority of surgical cancellations occurred in November and December due to administration-related factors, with 17 (47.2%) cases, and 10 (33.3%) cases occurred in May due to surgeon-related factors (Figure 3).

Discussion

Cancellation during elective orthopedic surgery is a major problem in the healthcare system, potentially resulting in various adverse consequences. These factors may include inefficient allocation of hospital resources, negative impacts on patients’ health status, and an increase in the financial burden on both healthcare facilities and individuals seeking treatment. This study aimed to evaluate the frequency and underlying reasons for same-day cancellations of elective orthopedic surgeries at the Educational and Medical Hospital of Poursina over one year.

The magnitude of orthopedic cancellations in this study was 6%, which aligns with similar investigations where cancellation rates ranged significantly from 1.96% to 49%.^3,6 This wide range may be attributed to differences in sociodemographic characteristics, study areas, sample sizes, healthcare systems, and methodological approaches. According to an authoritative meta-analysis conducted by Abate et al., the global cancellation rate of elective surgeries on the day of the procedure is 18% (95% CI, 16–20).¹⁴ In contrast, according to Wong et al.'s prospective observational cohort study, 13.9% of the cases scheduled by the National Health Service were canceled on the day of the operation.¹⁵ Cancellation rates are significantly lower in high-income countries, such as <2% in the US,⁵ 14.3% in Australia,¹⁶ and 4.7% in Finland,¹⁷ whereas developing countries generally report higher rates of cancellation, such as 49% in Nigeria.⁶ Variations in the data perfectly demonstrate the influence of national healthcare systems and operational resources on surgical outcomes.

The primary reason for the cancellation of orthopedic surgeries in our survey was administration-related factors, which accounted for 29.8% of all cases (Table 2). This is consistent with the findings of Tayeb et al., who demonstrated that a shortage of ICU beds and other administrative factors are the most common reasons for delays in elective surgeries that require intensive postoperative care.¹³ Moreover, a meta-analysis of 33 studies by Abate et al. revealed that the primary reasons for cancellation of orthopedic surgeries are administration-related factors, specifically ICU and ward bed shortages (22%).¹⁴ According to other correlative investigations, insufficient numbers of ICU beds (0.1%–20.7%), high volumes of emergency surgeries (5.2%–21%), and equipment malfunctions in operating rooms (1.2%–11.5%) are also determining factors that contribute to operation rescheduling.¹⁸

Table 2.

Reasons for same-day cancellation of elective orthopedic operation.

Reasons		No	Total no (%)
administrative-related	ICU and ward bed shortages Lack of oxygen in the operating room C-arm failure Unavailability of ORs Inadequate number of antiviral gloves Lack of electricity in the operating room	66 9 8 3 2 1	89 (29.8%)
Surgeon-related	Surgeon unavailability Incorrect timing/scheduling error Unforeseen complications	70 9 6	85 (28.4%)
Anesthesia-related	Patient unfit for anesthesia Abnormal laboratory results Cardiac problems High blood pressure	32 21 15 13	81 (27.1%)
Inadequate preoperative assessment	Inadequacy in surgical equipment Failure to preserve packed red blood cells	22 3	25 (8.4%)
Patient-related	Not fasting Canceled by patients Medication use	9 9 1	19 (6.4%)
Total		299

The second most frequent cause of cancellation in this study was surgeon-related factors (28.4%), including surgeon unavailability and scheduling errors. This agrees with the study by Desta et al., in which surgeon-related factors due to other emergency operations or unexpected complications were the most common reasons for canceling elective cases (35.8%).¹⁹ According to previous studies, the main reasons for the lack of surgical time are related to the late start of surgery, the time required for cleaning and preparing the operating room between surgeries, and delays in transferring patients to and from the operating room. Preventing the late start of surgery can be performed with better cooperation between anesthesia and surgical teams.^20,21 Garg et al. reported that 59.7% of operations were canceled because of the unavailability of operating rooms.²² This highlights the importance of organizing a flexible and effective scheduling system for surgeons and surgical teams to manage these challenges.

According to our findings, anesthesia-related factors, accounting for 27.1% of the total cases, also play crucial roles in cancellations, mainly due to abnormal laboratory results, patient unfitness for anesthesia, and medical comorbidities such as diabetes and cardiovascular diseases.²³ These outcomes are consistent with those of previous studies, highlighting the role of preoperative evaluation in anesthesia-related cancellation. Therefore, it is recommended that surgeons evaluate patients for anesthesia issues before they are admitted or placed them on the surgery list and that evaluating patients for anesthesia-related issues not only significantly reduces the rate of surgery cancellations.²² Knox et al. reported that a complete physical examination of patients and an evaluation of their medical history enabled the detection of potential anesthetic risks and increased their preparedness for surgery, which could decrease the cancellation rate by up to 30%.²⁴

Patient-related variables accounted for 6.4% of the cancellations in this study. A recent study revealed that these factors, specifically failure to follow preoperative instructions and fasting requirements, are leading causes of surgical delays. These statistics can be decreased by improving effective communication between patients and health care professionals. This can lead to better preoperative follow-up, such as following fasting requirements and subtle medication management of patients, including precise observation of the discontinuation of anticoagulants and similar drugs.²⁵ Previous research has shown that conducting preoperative phone conversations two days before the operation and regularly reviewing the surgical schedule can significantly decrease the occurrence of cancellations on the day of surgery. Many disorganizations can be prevented if patients are informed of the preparation required for surgery.²⁶ Our research revealed that the majority of cancellations occurred on the day of the operation while the patients were at the hospital, which resulted in unnecessary fasting and emotional stress. These findings emphasize the importance of associations between physicians, including surgeons and residents, and patients and their families.

One significant conclusion of our study was that fracture surgery, with 76.6% of cancellations, had the highest cancellation frequency. The close association of trauma-related situations, which often require urgent clinical examination and treatment, with fracture surgeries makes patients extremely vulnerable to unscheduled cancellations.²⁷ According to a survey conducted by Soleymanha et al., the rate of disorganization is higher in fracture procedures because of the competition between emergency and elective surgeries for healthcare resources.²⁸ University hospitals at the regional level often experience higher referral rates, leading to reduced operating periods, insufficient equipment and beds, surgeon unavailability, and a lack of cross-matched blood, which leads to the cancellation of planned procedures. This challenge can be worse because emergency cases often take precedence over elective cases.²⁹ Improving the issue of cancellation is a complicated and multifactorial obstacle that can be diminished by sharing experiences and strategies for quality improvement and granting valuable insights to healthcare systems for better adaptation to local needs.

Limitations

Notably, this study has several limitations, including the fact that the long-term consequences of cancellations were not explored because the data were collected from a single hospital over a one-year period. Hence, it may be difficult to extend these results to other orthopedic clinics with various qualities, such as the services provided, size, and case differences. However, the clinical outcomes of delays and cancellations in inpatient rehabilitation operations were not investigated in this study.

Conclusion

According to our study, the overall rate of same-day cancellation for elective orthopedic operations was 6% at our orthopedic research center, with administration-related factors followed by surgeons and anesthesia-related factors as the leading reasons. Fracture surgeries had the highest cancellation rate, primarily due to a shortage of facilities and preoperative preparations for patient anesthesia. The article emphasizes the need to enhance operating room capacity, preoperative assessments, and patient-provider communication to reduce cancellations. Effective communication between physicians and patients regarding unscheduled delays can also play a significant role in the efficient emotional pacification of patients and their clinical management. Additional investigations are needed to explore long-term consequences and enhance the healthcare system to diminish unplanned cancellations.

Supplemental Material

sj-xlsx-1-otr-10.1177_22104917261428696 - Supplemental material for Reasons for elective orthopedic operations cancellation in an educational hospital

Supplemental material, sj-xlsx-1-otr-10.1177_22104917261428696 for Reasons for elective orthopedic operations cancellation in an educational hospital by Mehran Soleymanha, Nima Azadeh, Sara Zamani, Pariya Nazarinezhad Giashi, Arash Aris and Maryam Mousavi in Journal of Orthopaedics, Trauma and Rehabilitation

Footnotes

Acknowledgments

The researchers are thankful to the Orthopedic Research Center of the Poursina Medical and Educational Hospital.

ORCID iDs

Mehran Soleymanha

Nima Azadeh

Sara Zamani

Pariya Nazarinezhad Giashi

Ethics approval and consent to participate

This study was approved by the Ethics Committee of Guilan University of Medical Sciences, Rasht, Iran, before beginning the research (research ethics certification code: IR.GUMS.REC.1402.161), and all participants provided written informed consent prior to participation.

Authors’ contributions

Development of the original idea and protocol: Mehran Soleymanha. Data collection: Nima Azadeh, Pariya Nazarinezhad Giashi, Sara Zamani. Draft: Sara Zamani, Pariya Nazarinezhad Giashi, Arash Aris. Data analysis: Maryam Mousavi, Pariya Nazarinezhad Giashi, Sara Zamani. Manuscript preparation and revision: All authors. Nima Azadeh, Pariya Nazarinezhad Giashi, and Sara Zamani contributed equally to this work and are listed as second authors.

Funding

The authors received no financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.

Declaration of conflicting interests

The authors declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.

Availability of data and materials

The datasets used and analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.

Supplemental material

Supplemental material for this article is available online.

References

Chua

Duff

Munday

. Elective day of surgery cancellations: a retrospective observational study. Collegian 2023; 30: 721–726.

Altun

Özer

Aksoku

, et al. Evaluation of the reasons for the cancellation of elective procedures at level 3 university hospital on the day of surgery. J Perianesth Nurs 2020; 35: 514–517.

Kaddoum

Fadlallah

Hitti

, et al. Causes of cancellations on the day of surgery at a tertiary teaching hospital. BMC Health Serv Res. 2016;16:1–8.

Herrod

PJJ

Adiamah

Boyd-Carson

, et al. Winter cancellations of elective surgical procedures in the UK: a questionnaire survey of patients on the economic and psychological impact. BMJ open 2019; 9: e028753.

Trentman

Mueller

Fassett

, et al. Day of surgery cancellations in a tertiary care hospital: a one year review. J Anesthesia Clin Res 2010; 1: 2–2.

Gajida

Takai

Nuhu

. Cancellations of elective surgical procedures performed at a teaching hospital in north‒west Nigeria. J Med Trop 2016; 18: 108–112.

Maimaiti

Rahimi

Aghaie

. Economic impact of surgery cancellation in a general hospital, Iran. Ethiopian J Health Dev 2016; 30: 94–98.

Askari

Nunn

Hajuthman

, et al. Reasons for same-day cancellation in a dedicated day surgery hospital. Ambul Surg 2020; 26: 30–34.

Okeke

Obi

Tijani

, et al. Cancellation of elective surgical cases in a Nigerian teaching hospital: frequency and reasons. Niger J Clin Pract 2020; 23: 965–969.

10.

Ayele

Menchamo

Efa

. Magnitude and reasons of surgical case cancellation at a specialized hospital in Ethiopia. J Anesth Clin Res 2020; 10: 12.

11.

Ogwal

Oyania

Nkonge

, et al. Prevalence and predictors of cancellation of elective surgical procedures at a tertiary hospital in Uganda: a cross-sectional study. Surg Res Pract 2020; 2020: 1464098.

12.

Shaheen

Abbass

Elkheir

, et al. Cancellation of elective surgical operations in a teaching hospital at Khartoum Bahri, Sudan. Sudan Med Monitor 2016; 11: 45.

13.

Tayeb

. An audit on surgery cancellation in a teaching hospital. Saudi J Anaesth 2024; 18: 40–47.

14.

Abate

Chekole

Minaye

, et al. Global prevalence and reasons for case cancellation on the intended day of surgery: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Int J Surg Open 2020; 26: 55–63.

15.

Wong

DJN

Harris

Moonesinghe

et al, Health Services Research Centre NIoAA, Study Steering G , et al. Cancelled operations: a 7-day cohort study of planned adult inpatient surgery in 245 UK National Health Service hospitals. Br J Anaesth. 2018; 121: 730–738.

16.

Keller

Ashrafi

Ali

. Causes of elective surgery cancellation and theatre throughput efficiency in an Australian urology unit. F1000Res 2014; 3: 197.

17.

Turunen

Miettinen

Setälä

, et al. Financial cost of elective day of surgery cancellations. 2018.

18.

Özkan

Ünver

Diğin

et al. Evaluation of the reasons for cancellations of surgical among orthopedic patients. Balkan Sağlık Bilimleri Dergisi 2022; 1: 1–10.

19.

Desta

Manaye

Tefera

, et al. Incidence and causes of cancellations of elective operation on the intended day of surgery at a tertiary referral academic medical center in Ethiopia. Patient Saf Surg 2018; 12: 1–6.

20.

Abiyu

Aderaw

Yismaw

, et al. Time to elective surgery and its predictors after first cancellation at debremarkos comprehensive specialized hospital, northwest Ethiopia. PLoS Global Public Health 2024; 4: e0002183.

21.

Engidayehu

Ayalew

Gela

, et al. Cancellation of elective surgery and its associated factors in public teaching hospitals of Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, 2021. 2024;14:21582440241300519.

22.

Garg

Bhalotra

Bhadoria

, et al. Reasons for cancellation of cases on the day of surgery-a prospective study. Indian J Anesthesia 2009; 53: 35–39.

23.

Okuda

Inoue

Kawaguchi

. Anesthesia-related care dissatisfaction: a cohort historical study to reveal related risks. Braz J Anesthesiol 2021: 71.

24.

Knox

Myers

Wilson

, et al. The impact of preoperative assessment clinics on elective surgical case cancellations. Surgeon 2009; 7: 76–78.

25.

Al Talalwah

McIltrot

Al Ghamdi

. Elective surgical cancellations in a tertiary hospital in the Middle East: quality improvement process. J Perianesth Nurs 2019; 34: 310–321.

26.

Lee

Rodgers

, et al. Reducing surgery cancellations at a pediatric ambulatory surgery center. AORN J 2017; 105: 384–391.

27.

Denis

Montreuil

Harvey

, et al. Cancellations and delays of emergent orthopedic operations at a Canadian level 1 trauma center. Can J Surg 2022; 65: E382–E3e7.

28.

Soleymanha

Mobayen

Asadi

, et al. Survey of 2582 cases of acute orthopedic trauma. Trauma Mon 2014; 19: e16215.

29.

Caesar

Karlsson

Hansson

. Incidence and root causes of delays in emergency orthopedic procedures: a single-center experience of 36,017 consecutive cases over seven years. Patient Saf Surg 2018; 12: 2.

Supplementary Material

Please find the following supplemental material available below.

For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.

For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.

0.02 MB

0.00 MB