Nonverbal Synchrony and the Alliance in Psychotherapy for Major Depression: Disentangling State-Like and Trait-Like Effects

Abstract

Given the importance of the alliance in psychotherapy, nonverbal synchrony has been suggested as a promising automatic objective marker of its levels and development. Accumulating research presents mixed results regarding the association between alliance and nonverbal synchrony. In the current study, we propose that one of the reasons for the inconsistencies is that previous studies did not disentangle trait-like characteristics from state-like changes occurring throughout treatment. To test this, we had 86 patients enrolled in an ongoing randomized controlled trial, along with their therapists, report their alliance levels after every session. Nonverbal movement synchrony was quantified by motion energy analysis for each of the 16 sessions of treatment. Findings suggest a significant association between nonverbal synchrony and the state-like effect of patient-reported alliance (p < .0001) but not for the trait-like effect. The results confirm the importance of disentangling the state-like and trait-like components because they may have distinct effects.

Keywords

nonverbal synchrony movement coordination alliance congruence trait-like and state-like components psychotherapy process

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Altmann

Schoenherr

Paulick

Deisenhofer

A. K.

Schwartz

Rubel

J. A.

Strauss

(2020). Associations between movement synchrony and outcome in patients with social anxiety disorder: Evidence for treatment specific effects. Psychotherapy Research, 30(5), 574–590.

Altmann

Schwartz

Schoenherr

Rubel

Stangier

Lutz

Strauss

(2020). Therapeuteneffekte bei der ambulanten Behandlung sozialer Ängste [Therapist effects in outpatient treatment of social anxiety disorder]. Psychotherapeut, 65, 444–455. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00278-020-00453-7

American Psychiatric Association. (2013). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (5th ed.).

Arueti

Perach-Barzilay

Tsoory

M. M.

Berger

Getter

Shamay Tsoory

S. G.

(2013). When two become one: The role of oxytocin in interpersonal coordination and cooperation. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience, 25(9), 1418–1427.

Asher

Kauffmann

Aderka

I. M.

(2020). Out of sync: Nonverbal synchrony in social anxiety disorder. Clinical Psychological Science, 8(2), 280–294.

Bachelor

Salamé

(2000). Participants’ perceptions of dimensions of the therapeutic alliance over the course of therapy. The Journal of Psychotherapy Practice and Research, 9(1), 39–53.

Barber

J. P.

Zilcha-Mano

Gallop

Barrett

McCarthy

K. S.

Dinger

(2014). The associations among improvement and alliance expectations, alliance during treatment, and treatment outcome for major depressive disorder. Psychotherapy Research, 24(3), 257–268.

Bolger

Laurenceau

J. P.

(2013). Intensive longitudinal methods: An introduction to diary and experience sampling research. Guilford Press.

Bordin

E. S.

(1979). The generalizability of the psychoanalytic concept of the working alliance. Psychotherapy: Theory, Research & Practice, 16(3), 252–260.

10.

Condon

W. S.

Ogston

W. D.

(1966). Sound film analysis of normal and pathological behavior patterns. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 143(4), 338–347

11.

Delgadillo

Overend

Lucock

Groom

Kirby

McMillan

Gilbody

Lutz

Rubel

J. A.

de Jong

(2017). Improving the efficiency of psychological treatment using outcome feedback technology. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 99, 89–97.

12.

Edwards

J. R.

(2001). Ten difference score myths. Organizational Research Methods, 4(3), 265–287.

13.

Edwards

J. R.

(2002). Alternatives to difference scores: Polynomial regression and response surface methodology. In Drasgow

Schmitt

(Eds.), The Jossey-Bass business & management series. Measuring and analyzing behavior in organizations: Advances in measurement and data analysis (pp. 350–400). Jossey-Bass.

14.

Edwards

J. R.

(2011). The fallacy of formative measurement. Organizational Research Methods, 14(2), 370–388.

15.

Edwards

J. R.

Parry

M. E.

(1993). On the use of polynomial regression equations as an alternative to difference scores in organizational research. Academy of Management Journal, 36(6), 1577–1613.

16.

Eubanks

C. F.

Lubitz

Muran

J. C.

Safran

J. D.

(2019). Rupture resolution rating system (3RS): Development and validation. Psychotherapy Research, 29(3), 306–319.

17.

Eubanks

C. F.

Muran

J. C.

Safran

J. D.

(2018). Alliance rupture repair: A meta-analysis. Psychotherapy, 55(4), 508–519.

18.

Flückiger

Del Re

A. C.

Wampold

B. E.

Horvath

A. O.

(2018). The alliance in adult psychotherapy: A meta-analytic synthesis. Psychotherapy, 55(4), 316–340.

19.

Gehricke

J. G.

Shapiro

(2000). Reduced facial expression and social context in major depression: Discrepancies between facial muscle activity and self-reported emotion. Psychiatry Research, 95(2), 157–167.

20.

Gülüm

İ. V.

Soygüt

Safran

J. D.

(2018). A comparison of pre-dropout and temporary rupture sessions in psychotherapy. Psychotherapy Research, 28(5), 685–707.

21.

Hall

J. A.

Harrigan

J. A.

Rosenthal

(1995). Nonverbal behavior in clinician—patient interaction. Applied and Preventive Psychology, 4(1), 21–37.

22.

Hamilton

M. A. X.

(1967). Development of a rating scale for primary depressive illness. British Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology, 6(4), 278–296.

23.

Horvath

A. O.

Del Re

A. C.

Flückiger

Symonds

(2011). Alliance in individual psychotherapy. Psychotherapy, 48(1), 9–16.

24.

Horvath

A. O.

Greenberg

L. S.

(1989). Development and validation of the Working Alliance Inventory. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 36(2), 223–233.

25.

Imel

Z. E.

Barco

J. S.

Brown

H. J.

Baucom

B. R.

Baer

J. S.

Kircher

J. C.

Atkins

D. C.

(2014). The association of therapist empathy and synchrony in vocally encoded arousal. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 61(1), 146–153.

26.

Kleinbub

J. R.

(2017). State of the art of interpersonal physiology in psychotherapy: A systematic review. Frontiers in Psychology, 8, Article 2053. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2017.02053

27.

Kleinbub

J. R.

Ramseyer

F. T.

(2021). rMEA: An R package to assess nonverbal synchronization in motion energy analysis time-series. Psychotherapy Research, 31(6), 817–830. https://doi.org/10.1080/10503307.2020.1844334

28.

Koole

S. L.

Tschacher

(2016). Synchrony in psychotherapy: A review and an integrative framework for the therapeutic alliance. Frontiers in Psychology, 7, Article 862. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2016.00862

29.

Laws

H. B.

Constantino

M. J.

Sayer

A. G.

Klein

D. N.

Kocsis

J. H.

Manber

Markowitz

J. C.

Rothbaum

B. O.

Steidtmann

Thase

M. E.

Arnow

B. A.

(2017). Convergence in patient–therapist therapeutic alliance ratings and its relation to outcome in chronic depression treatment. Psychotherapy Research, 27(4), 410–424.

30.

Leibovich

Nof

Auerbach-Barber

Zilcha-Mano

(2018). A practical clinical suggestion for strengthening the alliance based on a supportive–expressive framework. Psychotherapy, 55(3), 231–240.

31.

Littell

R. C.

Milliken

G. A.

Stroup

W. W.

Wolfinger

R. D.

Oliver

(2006). SAS for mixed models. SAS Publishing.

32.

Luborsky

(1984). Principles of psychoanalytic psychotherapy: A manual for supportive expressive treatment (No. 616.8917 L8). Basic Books.

33.

Luborsky

Mark

Hole

A. V.

Popp

Goldsmith

Cacciola

(1995). Supportive expressive dynamic psychotherapy of depression: A time-limited version. In Barber

J. P.

Crits-Christoph

(Eds.), Dynamic therapies for psychiatric disorders (Axis I) (pp. 13–42). Basic Books.

34.

Marmarosh

C. L.

Kivlighan

D. M.

Jr. (2012). Relationships among client and counselor agreement about the working alliance, session evaluations, and change in client symptoms using response surface analysis. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 59(3), 352–367.

35.

McCarthy

K. S.

Barber

J. P.

(2009). The multitheoretical list of therapeutic interventions (MULTI): Initial report. Psychotherapy Research, 19(1), 96–113.

36.

Paulick

Deisenhofer

A. K.

Ramseyer

Tschacher

Boyle

Rubel

Lutz

(2018). Nonverbal synchrony: A new approach to better understand psychotherapeutic processes and drop-out. Journal of Psychotherapy Integration, 28(3), 367–384.

37.

Paulick

Rubel

J. A.

Deisenhofer

A. K.

Schwartz

Thielemann

Altmann

Boyle

Strauß

Lutz

(2018). Diagnostic features of nonverbal synchrony in psychotherapy: Comparing depression and anxiety. Cognitive Therapy and Research, 42(5), 539–551.

38.

Philippot

Feldman

R. S.

Coats

E. J.

(Eds.). (2003). Nonverbal behavior in clinical settings. Oxford University Press.

39.

Prinz

J. N.

Boyle

Ramseyer

F. T.

Kabus

Bar-Kalifa

Lutz

(2021). Within and between associations of nonverbal synchrony in relation to Grawe’s general mechanisms of change. Clinical Psychology & Psychotherapy, 28(1), 159–168. https://doi.org/10.1002/cpp.2498

40.

Ramseyer

F. T.

(2020a). Exploring the evolution of nonverbal synchrony in psychotherapy: The idiographic perspective provides a different picture. Psychotherapy Research, 30(5), 622–634.

41.

Ramseyer

F. T.

(2020b). Motion energy analysis (MEA): A primer on the assessment of motion from video. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 67(4), 536–549.

42.

Ramseyer

F. T.

Tschacher

(2010). Nonverbal synchrony or random coincidence? How to tell the difference. In Esposito

Campbell

Vogel

Hussain

Nijholt

(Eds.), Development of multimodal interfaces: Active listening and synchrony (pp. 182–196). Springer.

43.

Ramseyer

F. T.

Tschacher

(2011). Nonverbal synchrony in psychotherapy: Coordinated body movement reflects relationship quality and outcome. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 79(3), 284–295.

44.

Ramseyer

F. T.

Tschacher

(2014). Nonverbal synchrony of head-and body-movement in psychotherapy: Different signals have different associations with outcome. Frontiers in Psychology, 5, Article 979. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2014.00979

45.

Raudenbush

S. W.

Bryk

A. S.

(2002). Hierarchical linear models: Applications and data analysis methods (Vol. 1). SAGE.

46.

R Core Team. (2020). R: A language and environment for statistical computing (Version 4.0.2) [Computer software]. R Foundation for Statistical Computing.

47.

Repp

B. H.

Y. H.

(2013). Sensorimotor synchronization: A review of recent research (2006–2012). Psychonomic Bulletin & Review, 20(3), 403–452.

48.

Rubel

J. A.

Bar-Kalifa

Atzil-Slonim

Schmidt

Lutz

(2018). Congruence of therapeutic bond perceptions and its relation to treatment outcome: Within-and between-dyad effects. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 86(4), 341–353.

49.

SAS Institute. (2015). Base SAS 9.4 procedures guide.

50.

Shanock

L. R.

Baran

B. E.

Gentry

W. A.

Pattison

S. C.

Heggestad

E. D.

(2010). Polynomial regression with response surface analysis: A powerful approach for examining moderation and overcoming limitations of difference scores. Journal of Business and Psychology, 25(4), 543–554.

51.

Sheehan

D. V.

Lecrubier

Sheehan

K. H.

Amorim

Janavs

Weiller

Dunbar

G. C.

(1998). The Mini-International Neuropsychiatric Interview (MINI): The development and validation of a structured diagnostic psychiatric interview for DSM-IV and ICD-10. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry, 59, 22–33.

52.

Shick Tryon

Collins Blackwell

Felleman Hammel

(2007). A meta-analytic examination of client–therapist perspectives of the working alliance. Psychotherapy Research, 17(6), 629–642.

53.

Solomonov

McCarthy

K. S.

Gorman

B. S.

Barber

J. P.

(2019). The multitheoretical list of therapeutic interventions–30 items (MULTI-30). Psychotherapy Research, 29(5), 565–580.

54.

Wang

L. P.

Maxwell

S. E.

(2015). On disaggregating between-person and within-person effects with longitudinal data using multilevel models. Psychological Methods, 20, 63–83.

55.

Wheatley

Kang

Parkinson

Looser

C. E.

(2012). From mind perception to mental connection: Synchrony as a mechanism for social understanding. Social and Personality Psychology Compass, 6(8), 589–606.

56.

Wiltshire

T. J.

Philipsen

J. S.

Trasmundi

S. B.

Jensen

T. W.

Steffensen

S. V.

(2020). Interpersonal coordination dynamics in psychotherapy: A systematic review. Cognitive Therapy and Research, 44, 752–773. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10608-020-10106-3

57.

Yokotani

Takagi

Wakashima

(2020). Nonverbal synchrony of facial movements and expressions predict therapeutic alliance during a structured psychotherapeutic interview. Journal of Nonverbal Behavior, 44(1), 85–116.

58.

Zilcha-Mano

(2017). Is the alliance really therapeutic? Revisiting this question in light of recent methodological advances. American Psychologist, 72(4), 311–325.

59.

Zilcha-Mano

(2021). Toward personalized psychotherapy: The importance of the trait-like/state-like distinction for understanding therapeutic change. American Psychologist, 76(3), 516–528. https://doi.org/10.1037/amp0000629

60.

Zilcha-Mano

Brown

P. J.

Roose

S. P.

Cappetta

Rutherford

B. R.

(2019). Optimizing patient expectancy in the pharmacologic treatment of major depressive disorder. Psychological Medicine, 49(14), 2414–2420.

61.

Zilcha-Mano

Dinger

McCarthy

K. S.

Barber

J. P.

(2014). Does alliance predict symptoms throughout treatment, or is it the other way around? Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 82(6), 931–935.

62.

Zilcha-Mano

Dolev

Leibovich

Barber

J. P.

(2018). Identifying the most suitable treatment for depression based on patients’ attachment: Study protocol for a randomized controlled trial of supportive-expressive vs. supportive treatments. BMC Psychiatry, 18(1), Article 362. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12888-018-1934-1

63.

Zilcha-Mano

Porat

Dolev

Shamay-Tsoory

(2018). Oxytocin as a neurobiological marker of ruptures in the working alliance. Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics, 87(2), 126–128.

64.

Zilcha-Mano

Snyder

Silberschatz

(2017). The effect of congruence in patient and therapist alliance on patient’s symptomatic levels. Psychotherapy Research, 27(3), 371–380.

Supplementary Material

Please find the following supplemental material available below.

For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.

For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.

0.00 MB

0.15 MB