Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2020-5
Effort,Avolition,and Motivational Experience in Schizophrenia: Analysis of Behavioral and Neuroimaging Data With Relationships to Daily Motivational Experience
Recent research suggests that schizophrenia is associated with reduced effort allocation. We examined the willingness to expend effort, neural correlates of effort allocation, and the relationship of effort to daily motivational experience in individuals with schizophrenia. We recruited 28 individuals with schizophrenia and 30 control participants to perform an effort task during functional MRI. Individuals with schizophrenia also completed a protocol involving ecological momentary assessment (EMA). Individuals with schizophrenia with severe negative symptoms were less willing to expend effort for rewards. Daily EMAs of motivation were positively associated with effort allocation on a trend level. Individuals with schizophrenia and control participants displayed similar increases in blood-oxygen-level-dependent (BOLD) activation in frontal, cingulate, parietal, and insular regions during effort-based decision making. However, negative symptoms were associated with reduced BOLD activation in the bilateral ventral striatum. These results replicate previous reports of reduced effort allocation in patients with severe negative symptoms and provide evidence for the role of the ventral striatum in effort impairments.
American Psychiatric Association. (1994). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (4th ed.). Washington, DC: Author.
2.
BarchD. M.DowdE. C. (2010). Goal representations and motivational drive in schizophrenia: The role of prefrontal–striatal interactions. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 36, 919–934.
3.
BarchD. M.TreadwayM. T.SchoenN. (2014). Effort, anhedonia, and function in schizophrenia: Reduced effort allocation predicts amotivation and functional impairment. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 123, 387–397.
4.
BenjaminiY.HochbergY. (2000). On the adaptive control of the false discovery rate in multiple testing with independent statistics. Journal of Educational and Behavioral Statistics, 25, 60–83.
Cléry-MelinM.-L.SchmidtL.LafargueG.BaupN.FossatiP.PessiglioneM. (2011). Why don’t you try harder? An investigation of effort production in major depression. PLOS ONE, 6(8), Article e23178. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0023178
7.
CoxR. W.ChenG.GlenD. R.ReynoldsR. C.TaylorP. A. (2017). FMRI clustering in AFNI: False-positive rates redux. Brain Connectivity, 7, 152–171.
8.
CroxsonP. L.WaltonM. E.O’ReillyJ. X.BehrensT. E.RushworthM. F. (2009). Effort-based cost–benefit valuation and the human brain. The Journal of Neuroscience, 29, 4531–4541.
9.
CulbrethA.MoranE.BarchD. (2018). Effort-cost decision-making in psychosis and depression: Could a similar behavioral deficit arise from disparate psychological and neural mechanisms?Psychological Medicine, 48, 889–904.
10.
CulbrethA.WestbrookA.BarchD. (2016). Negative symptoms are associated with an increased subjective cost of cognitive effort. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 125, 528–536.
11.
DocxL.de la AsuncionJ.SabbeB.HosteL.BaetenR.WarnaertsN.MorrensM. (2015). Effort discounting and its association with negative symptoms in schizophrenia. Cognitive Neuropsychiatry, 20, 172–185.
12.
FervahaG.DuncanM.FoussiasG.AgidO.FaulknerG. E.RemingtonG. (2015). Effort-based decision making as an objective paradigm for the assessment of motivational deficits in schizophrenia. Schizophrenia Research, 168, 483–490.
13.
FervahaG.Graff-GuerreroA.ZakzanisK. K.FoussiasG.AgidO.RemingtonG. (2013). Incentive motivation deficits in schizophrenia reflect effort computation impairments during cost-benefit decision-making. Journal of Psychiatric Research, 47, 1590–1596.
14.
FirstM. B.SpitzerR. L.GibbonM.WilliamsJ. B. (2002). Structured clinical interview for DSM-IV-TR axis I disorders—patient edition (SCID-I/P). New York, NY: New York State Psychiatric Institute.
FlorescoS. B.OngeJ. R. S.Ghods-SharifiS.WinstanleyC. A. (2008). Cortico-limbic-striatal circuits subserving different forms of cost-benefit decision making. Cognitive, Affective, & Behavioral Neuroscience, 8, 375–389.
17.
GlasserM. F.SotiropoulosS. N.WilsonJ. A.CoalsonT. S.FischlB.AnderssonJ. L.. . .PolimeniJ. R. (2013). The minimal preprocessing pipelines for the Human Connectome Project. NeuroImage, 80, 105–124.
18.
GoldJ. M.KoolW.BotvinickM. M.HubzinL.AugustS.WaltzJ. A. (2014). Cognitive effort avoidance and detection in people with schizophrenia. Cognitive, Affective, & Behavioral Neuroscience, 15, 145–154.
19.
GoldJ. M.StraussG. P.WaltzJ. A.RobinsonB. M.BrownJ. K.FrankM. J. (2013). Negative symptoms of schizophrenia are associated with abnormal effort-cost computations. Biological Psychiatry, 74, 130–136.
20.
GoldJ. M.WaltzJ. A.FrankM. J. (2015a). Effort cost computation in schizophrenia: A commentary on the recent literature. Biological Psychiatry, 78, 747–753.
21.
GoldJ. M.WaltzJ. A.PrenticeK. J.MorrisS. E.HeereyE. A. (2008). Reward processing in schizophrenia: A deficit in the representation of value. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 34, 835–847.
22.
GrantP. M.BeckA. T. (2008). Defeatist beliefs as a mediator of cognitive impairment, negative symptoms, and functioning in schizophrenia. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 35, 798–806.
23.
GreenM. F.HoranW. P.BarchD. M.GoldJ. M. (2015). Effort-based decision making: A novel approach for assessing motivation in schizophrenia. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 41, 1035–1044. doi:10.1093/schbul/sbv071
24.
HartmannM. N.HagerO. M.ReimannA. V.ChumbleyJ. R.KirschnerM.SeifritzE.. . .KaiserS. (2015). Apathy but not diminished expression in schizophrenia is associated with discounting of monetary rewards by physical effort. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 41, 503–512.
25.
HershenbergR.SatterthwaiteT. D.DaldalA.KatchmarN.MooreT. M.KableJ. W.WolfD. H. (2016). Diminished effort on a progressive ratio task in both unipolar and bipolar depression. Journal of Affective Disorders, 196, 97–100.
26.
HoranW. P.KringA. M.GurR. E.ReiseS. P.BlanchardJ. J. (2011). Development and psychometric validation of the Clinical Assessment Interview for Negative Symptoms (CAINS). Schizophrenia Research, 132, 140–145.
27.
HoranW. P.ReddyL. F.BarchD. M.BuchananR. W.DunayevichE.GoldJ. M.. . .GreenM. F. (2015). Effort-based decision-making paradigms for clinical trials in schizophrenia: Part 2—external validity and correlates. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 41, 1055–1065. doi:10.1093/schbul/sbv090
28.
HoskingJ. G.CockerP. J.WinstanleyC. A. (2014). Dissociable contributions of anterior cingulate cortex and basolateral amygdala on a rodent cost/benefit decision-making task of cognitive effort. Neuropsychopharmacology, 39, 1558–1567.
29.
HuangJ.YangX. H.LanY.ZhuC. Y.LiuX. Q.WangY. F.. . .ChanR. C. (2016). Neural substrates of the impaired effort expenditure decision making in schizophrenia. Neuropsychology, 30, 685–696.
30.
KringA. M.GurR. E.BlanchardJ. J.HoranW. P.ReiseS. P. (2013). The clinical assessment interview for negative symptoms (CAINS): Final development and validation. American Journal of Psychiatry, 170, 165–172.
31.
KringA. M.MoranE. K. (2008). Emotional response deficits in schizophrenia: Insights from affective science. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 34, 819–834.
32.
KurniawanI. T.Guitart-MasipM.DayanP.DolanR. J. (2013). Effort and valuation in the brain: The effects of anticipation and execution. Journal of Neuroscience, 33, 6160–6169.
33.
KurniawanI. T.SeymourB.TalmiD.YoshidaW.ChaterN.DolanR. J. (2010). Choosing to make an effort: The role of striatum in signaling physical effort of a chosen action. Journal of Neurophysiology, 104, 313–321.
34.
LeottiL. A.DelgadoM. R. (2011). The inherent reward of choice. Psychological Science, 10, 1310–1318.
35.
McCarthyJ. M.TreadwayM. T.BennettM. E.BlanchardJ. J. (2016). Inefficient effort allocation and negative symptoms in individuals with schizophrenia. Schizophrenia Research, 170, 278–284.
36.
MilevP.HoB.-C.ArndtS.AndreasenN. C. (2005). Predictive values of neurocognition and negative symptoms on functional outcome in schizophrenia: A longitudinal first-episode study with 7-year follow-up. American Journal of Psychiatry, 162, 495–506.
37.
MoranE. K.CulbrethA. J.BarchD. M. (2017). Ecological momentary assessment of negative symptoms in schizophrenia: Relationships to effort-based decision making and reinforcement learning. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 126, 96–105.
38.
ParkI. H.LeeB. C.KimJ.-J.KimJ. I.KooM.-S. (2017). Effort-based reinforcement processing and functional connectivity underlying amotivation in medicated patients with depression and schizophrenia. Journal of Neuroscience, 37, 4370–4380.
39.
ReddyL. F.HoranW. P.BarchD. M.BuchananR. W.DunayevichE.GoldJ. M.. . .WynnJ. K. (2015). Effort-based decision-making paradigms for clinical trials in schizophrenia: Part 1—psychometric characteristics of 5 paradigms. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 41, 1045–1054. doi:10.1093/schbul/sbv089
40.
ReddyL. F.HoranW. P.BarchD. M.BuchananR. W.GoldJ. M.MarderS. R.. . .GreenM. F. (2018). Understanding the association between negative symptoms and performance on effort-based decision-making tasks: The importance of defeatist performance beliefs. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 44, 1217–1226.
41.
SalamoneJ. D.KoychevI.CorreaM.McGuireP. (2015). Neurobiological basis of motivational deficits in psychopathology. European Neuropsychopharmacology, 25, 1225–1238.
42.
SalamoneJ. D.WisnieckiA.CarlsonB.CorreaM. (2001). Nucleus accumbens dopamine depletions make animals highly sensitive to high fixed ratio requirements but do not impair primary food reinforcement. Neuroscience, 105, 863–870.
43.
SchlagenhaufF.HuysQ. J.DesernoL.RappM. A.BeckA.HeinzeH.-J.. . .HeinzA. (2014). Striatal dysfunction during reversal learning in unmedicated schizophrenia patients. NeuroImage, 89, 171–180.
44.
SchmidtL.LebretonM.Cléry-MelinM.-L.DaunizeauJ.PessiglioneM. (2012). Neural mechanisms underlying motivation of mental versus physical effort. PLOS Biology, 10, Article e1001266. doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.1001266
45.
SerperM.PayneE.DillC.PortilloC.TaliercioJ. (2017). Allocating effort in schizophrenia: Relation to negative symptoms, working memory, reward anticipation and real world functioning. European Psychiatry, 46, 57–64.
46.
SherdellL.WaughC. E.GotlibI. H. (2012). Anticipatory pleasure predicts motivation for reward in major depression. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 121, 51–60.
47.
SimonJ. J.BillerA.WaltherS.Roesch-ElyD.StippichC.WeisbrodM.KaiserS. (2010). Neural correlates of reward processing in schizophrenia—relationship to apathy and depression. Schizophrenia Research, 118, 154–161.
48.
SnowJ. (2012). Qualtrics survey software: Handbook for research professionals. Provo, UT: Qualtrics Labs.
49.
StraussG. P.AhmedA. O.YoungJ. W.KirkpatrickB. (2018). Reconsidering the latent structure of negative symptoms in schizophrenia: A review of evidence supporting the 5 consensus domains. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 45, 725–729.
50.
StraussG. P.WheartyK. M.MorraL. F.SullivanS. K.OssenfortK. L.FrostK. H. (2016). Avolition in schizophrenia is associated with reduced willingness to expend effort for reward on a Progressive Ratio task. Schizophrenia Research, 170, 198–204.
51.
TreadwayM. T.BossallerN. A.SheltonR. C.ZaldD. H. (2012). Effort-based decision-making in major depressive disorder: A translational model of motivational anhedonia. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 121, 553–558.
52.
TreadwayM. T.BuckholtzJ. W.CowanR. L.WoodwardN. D.LiR.AnsariM. S.. . .ZaldD. H. (2012). Dopaminergic mechanisms of individual differences in human effort-based decision-making. The Journal of Neuroscience, 32, 6170–6176.
53.
TreadwayM. T.PetermanJ. S.ZaldD. H.ParkS. (2015). Impaired effort allocation in patients with schizophrenia. Schizophrenia Research, 161, 382–385.
54.
WaltzJ. A.KasanovaZ.RossT. J.SalmeronB. J.McMahonR. P.GoldJ. M.SteinE. A. (2013). The roles of reward, default, and executive control networks in set-shifting impairments in schizophrenia. PLOS ONE, 8(2), Article e57257. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0057257
55.
WaltzJ. A.SchweitzerJ. B.RossT. J.KurupP. K.SalmeronB. J.RoseE. J.. . .SteinE. A. (2010). Abnormal responses to monetary outcomes in cortex, but not in the basal ganglia, in schizophrenia. Neuropsychopharmacology, 35, 2427–2439.
56.
WangJ.HuangJ.YangX.-h.LuiS. S.CheungE. F.ChanR. C. (2015). Anhedonia in schizophrenia: Deficits in both motivation and hedonic capacity. Schizophrenia Research, 168, 465–474.
57.
WechslerD. (2001). Wechsler Test of Adult Reading: WTAR. San Antonio, TX: Psychological Corporation.
58.
WestbrookA.KesterD.BraverT. S. (2013). What is the subjective cost of cognitive effort? Load, trait, and aging effects revealed by economic preference. PLOS ONE, 8(7), Article e68210. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0068210
59.
WestbrookA.LamichhaneB.BraverT. (2019). The subjective value of cognitive effort is encoded by a domain-general valuation network. Journal of Neuroscience, 39, 3934–3947. doi:10.1101/391805
60.
WolfD. H.SatterthwaiteT. D.KantrowitzJ. J.KatchmarN.VandekarL.ElliottM. A.RuparelK. (2014). Amotivation in schizophrenia: Integrated assessment with behavioral, clinical, and imaging measures. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 40, 1328–1337.
61.
YangX. H.HuangJ.LanY.ZhuC. Y.LiuX. Q.WangY. F.. . .ChanR. C. (2016). Diminished caudate and superior temporal gyrus responses to effort-based decision making in patients with first-episode major depressive disorder. Progress in Neuropsychopharmacology and Biological Psychiatry, 64, 52–59.
62.
YangX. H.HuangJ.ZhuC. Y.WangY. F.CheungE. F.ChanR. C.XieG. R. (2014). Motivational deficits in effort-based decision making in individuals with subsyndromal depression, first-episode and remitted depression patients. Psychiatry Research, 220, 874–882.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
