Cheating or Fair Competition? A Structuration Analysis of Social Media Responses to Lia Thomas’ NCAA Swimming Championship

Abstract

In March 2022, Lia Thomas of the University of Pennsylvania became the first openly transgender woman to win an NCAA swimming championship. Using Giddens’ structuration theory as a theoretical lens, this analysis employs Latent Dirichlet Allocation to examine how tweets about Thomas and transgender athletes contain toxic discourses based on established sports structures of fairness and sex separation of sports.

Keywords

social media structuration theory toxicity transgender athletes X

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Almerekhi

Kwak

Jansen

B. J.

Salminen

(2019). Detecting toxicity triggers in online discussions. Proceedings of the 30th ACM conference on hypertext and social media (pp. 291–292). https://doi.org/10.1145/3342220.3344933

Anderson

Travers

(Eds.), (2017). Transgender athletes in competitive sport. Routledge, Taylor & Francis Group.

Avalos

Kibler

Monk-Turner

(2022). Out of the closet and onto the olympic floor: A qualitative look at social media users’ perceptions of transgender olympic athletes. Gender Issues, 39(4), 437–454. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12147-022-09299-6

Baeth

Goorevich

(2022). Mediated moral panics: Trans athlete spectres, the haunting of cisgender girls and politicians as moral entrepreneurs in 2021. In Greey

A. D.

Lenskyj

H. J.

(Eds.), Justice for trans athletes (pp. 137–149). Emerald Publishing Limited. Retrieved from: https://doi.org/10.1108/978-1-80262-985-920221009

Barnes

(2022a). Thomas first transgender athlete to win D-I title. ESPN. Retrieved from: https://www.espn.com/college-sports/story/_/id/33529775/amid-protestspennsylvania-swimmer-lia-thomas-becomes-first-known-transgender-athlete-win-division-national-championship

Barnes

(2022b). Penn’s Lia Thomas ties for fifth in 200-yard freestyle final at NCAA swimming championships. ESPN. Retrieved from: https://www.espn.com/college-sports/story/_/id/33540686/penn-swimmer-lia-thomas-places-fifth-200-yard-freestyle-final

Barnes

(2022c). Lia Thomas finishes 9th in 100-yard freestyle, final race of collegiate swimming career. ESPN. Retrieved from: https://www.espn.com/college-sports/story/_/id/33550045/lia-thomas-finishes-8th-100-yard-freestyle-final-race-collegiate-swimming-career

Bell

R. C.

(2008). A history of women in sport prior to Title IX. The Sport Journal, 10(2), 1–6.

Billings

A. C.

Moscowitz

Jackson

J. R.

Dirks

Tomsett

S. M.

(2024). Trans youth sport bans and the facilitation of moral panic: A cross-platform comparison of 2022 media narratives. Mass Communication & Society, 27(6), 1555–1579. https://doi.org/10.1080/15205436.2024.2313109

10.

Birrell

Cole

C. L.

(1990). Double Fault: Renee Richards and the construction and naturalization of difference. Sociology of Sport Journal, 7(1), 1–21. https://doi.org/10.1123/ssj.7.1.1

11.

Blei

D. M.

A. Y.

Jordan

M. I.

(2003). Latent dirichlet allocation. Journal of Machine Learning Research, 3(1), 993–1022.

12.

Blinder

(2022). Lia Thomas wins an N.C.A.A. swimming title. https://www.nytimes.com/2022/03/17/sports/lia-thomas-swimmer-wins.html

13.

Bouman

W. P.

Claes

Brewin

Crawford

J. R.

Millet

Fernandez-Aranda

Arcelus

(2017). Transgender and anxiety: A comparative study between transgender people and the general population. International Journal of Transgenderism, 18(1), 16–26. https://doi.org/10.1080/15532739.2016.1258352

14.

Brody

(2023). Branding being true: Visibility politics and Nike’s engagement with LGBTQ+ communities. Communication and Critical, 20(4), 416–434. https://doi.org/10.1080/14791420.2023.2272834

15.

Calabrese

Y. J.

(2024). Examining discussions related to transgender athletes on Twitter: The role of negative emotion on message engagement. Communication & Sport. Retrieved from: https://doi.org/10.1177/21674795241265969

16.

Cerit

Dalip

Yildrim

D. S.

(2020). Research in Physical Education, Sport and Health, 9(2), 65–76.

17.

Chen

Peng

Kim

S. H.

Won Choi

(2023). What we can do and cannot do with topic modeling: A systematic review. Communication Methods and Measures, 17(2), 111–130.

18.

Coakley

(2015). Assessing the sociology of sport: On cultural sensibilities and the great sport myth. International Review for the Sociology of Sport, 50(4–5), 402–406. https://doi.org/10.1177/1012690214538864

19.

Coggon

Hammond

Holm

(2008). Transsexuals in sport–fairness and freedom, regulation and law. Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 2(1), 4–17. https://doi.org/10.1080/17511320801896091

20.

Cranmer

G. A.

Brann

Bowman

N. D.

(2014). Male athletes, female aesthetics: The continued ambivalence toward female athletes in ESPN’s the body issue. International Journal of Sport Communication, 7(2), 145–165. https://doi.org/10.1123/IJSC.2014-0021

21.

Dixon

(2011). A ‘third way’ for football fandom research: Anthony Giddens and Structuration Theory. Soccer and Society, 12(2), 279–298. https://doi.org/10.1080/14660970.2011.548363

22.

Durbin

D. T.

(2018). Unwritten rules and press and social conventions. Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 12(4), 416–434.

23.

Edwards

(2024). Who is Blaire fleming? College athlete faces transgender boycott—Newsweek. Newsweek. Retrieved from: https://www.newsweek.com/who-blaire-fleming-transgender-college-athlete-faces-boycott-1993208

24.

Evelyn

Clancy

E. M.

Klettke

Tatnell

(2022). A phenomenological investigation into cyberbullying as experienced by people identifying as transgender or gender diverse. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 19(11), 6560.

25.

Fahey

(2022). World swimming bans transgender athletes from women.

26.

FAQs . (n. d.). Perspective API. Retrieved from: https://support.perspectiveapi.com/s/about-the-api-faqs?language=en_US”\o “https://support.perspectiveapi.com/s/about-the-api-faqs?language=en_US”\h https://support.perspectiveapi.com/s/about-the-api-faqs?language=en_US

27.

Fischer

McClearen

(2020). Transgender athletes and the queer art of athletic failure. Communication & Sport, 8(2), 147–167.

28.

Flores

A. R.

Haider-Markel

D. P.

Lewis

D. C.

Miller

P. R.

Tadlock

B. L.

Taylor

J. K.

(2020). Public attitudes about transgender participation in sports: The roles of gender, gender identity conformity, and sports fandom. Sex Roles, 83(5), 382–398.

29.

Genel

(2017). Transgender athletes: How can they Be accommodated? Current Sports Medicine Reports, 16(1), 12–13. https://doi.org/10.1249/JSR.0000000000000321

30.

Ghorayshi

(2022). Report reveals sharp rise in transgender young people in the U.S.

31.

Giddens

(1984). The constitution of society: Outline of the theory of structuration. University of California Press.

32.

Gleaves

Lehrbach

(2016). Beyond fairness: The ethics of inclusion for transgender and intersex athletes. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport, 43(2), 311–326. https://doi.org/10.1080/00948705.2016.1157485

33.

Glossary of terms . (n. d.). Gay and Lesbian Alliance against discrimination. Retrieved from: https://glaad.org/reference/trans-terms

34.

Goossens

Van Bulck

D. V.

Ley

Dominicy

(2020). Fairness trade-offs in sports timetabling. In Ley

Dominicy

(Eds.), Science Meets Sports: When Stastistics Are More Than Numbers. Cambridge Scholars Publishing.

35.

Griffiths

T. L.

Steyvers

(2004). Finding scientific topics. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 101(suppl_1), 5228–5235.

36.

Halone

K. K.

(2008). The structuration of racialized sport organizing. Journal of Communication Inquiry, 32(1), 22–42. https://doi.org/10.1177/0196859907306832

37.

Henderson

Cole

(2022). Pennsylvania House passes anti-trans sports ban as governor vows to veto bill, CNN Politics. CNN. Retrieved from: https://www.cnn.com/2022/04/12/politics/pennsylvania-transgender-sports-ban/index.htm

38.

Hickey

Schmitz

Fessler

Smaldino

P. E.

Muric

Burghardt

(2023). Auditing Elon Musk’s impact on hate speech and bots. Proceedings of the International AAAI Conference on Web and Social Media, 17(1), 1133–1137. https://doi.org/10.1609/icwsm.v17i1.22222

39.

B. R.

Valenzuela

J. A.

Markes

A. R.

Pandya

N. K.

(2024). Current Reviews in Musculoskeletal Medicine, 17(1), 1–8.

40.

Home

Jary

(2004). Anthony Giddens: Structuration theory, and sport and Leisure. In Giulianotti

(Ed.), Sport and modern social theorists (pp. 129–144). Palgrave Macmillan UK. Retrieved from: https://doi.org/10.1057/9780230523180_9

41.

Ingemi

(2024). Who is Brooke Slusser, SJSU player opposing trans women in sports? The San Francisco Chronicle. Retrieved from: https://www.sfchronicle.com/sports/college/article/brooke-slusser-sjsu-trans-lawsuit-19826534.php

42.

Kim

Author Kim

Jang

(2022). When does it become harassment? An investigation of online criticism and calling out in Twitter. Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction, 6(CSCW2), 1–32. https://doi.org/10.1145/3555575

43.

Kliegman

(2022). 300-Plus collegiate, elite swimmers sign letter to NCAA supporting Lia Thomas. Sports Illustrated. Retrieved from: https://www.si.com/college/2022/02/10/lia-thomas-college-elite-swimmers-letter-to-ncaa-new-policy-transgender-eligibility

44.

Kroshus

Ackerman

Brown

Griffin

Durden

Merrill

Wilson

Hainline

(2023). Improving inclusion and well-being of trans and gender nonconforming collegiate student–athletes foundational concepts from the National Collegiate Athletic Association Summit on Gender Identity and Student–Athlete Participation—564.1.full.pdf. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 50(1), 564–570.

45.

Kuhn

A. W.

Grusky

A. Z.

Cash

C. R.

Churchwell

A. L.

Diamond

A. B.

(2021). Disparities and inequities in youth sports. Current Sports Medicine Reports, 20(9), 494–498.

46.

Lamothe

J. C.

(2022). How to define fair? Examining transgender on the ‘level playing field. In Lamothe

J. C.

Friedman

Perez

(Eds.), Beyond Binaries: Trans identities in contemporary culture (pp. 83–94). Row.

47.

Larsson

A. O.

(2012). Understanding nonuse of interactivity in online newspapers: Insights from structuration theory. The Information Society, 28(1), 253–263.

48.

Levine

(2008, Aug. 3). Out There. New York Times. Retrieved from https://nytimes.com/2008/08/03/sports/playmagazine/803PHELPS-t.html

49.

Lia Thomas’ victory at NCAA swimming finals sparks fierce debate over trans athletes . (2022). The Guardian. Retrieved from: https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2022/mar/21/lia-thomas-victory-at-ncaa-swimming-finals-sparks-fierce-debate-over-trans-athletes

50.

Loland

(2002). Fair play in sport: A moral norm system: Routledge.

51.

Loland

(2020). Caster Semenya, athlete classification, and fair equality of opportunity in sport. Journal of Media Ethics, 46(9), 584–590.

52.

Lucas

C. B.

Newhall

K. E.

(2019). Out of the frame: How sports media shapes trans narratives. In Magrath

(Ed.), LGBT athletes in the sports media (pp. 99–124). Springer International Publishing. Retrieved from: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-00804-8_5

53.

Maier

Waldherr

Miltner

Wiedemann

Niekler

Keinert

Pfetsch

Heyer

Reber

Häussler

Schmidt-Petri

Adam

(2018). Applying LDA Topic Modeling in Communication Research: Toward a valid and reliable methodology. Communication Methods and Measures, 12(2–3), 93–118.

54.

Massanari

(2017). #Gamergate and the Fappening: How Reddit’s algorithm, governance, and culture support toxic technocultures. New Media & Society, 19(3), 329–346. https://doi.org/10.1177/1461444815608807

55.

Masullo Chen

Muddiman

Wilner

Pariser

Stroud

N. J.

(2019). We should not get rid of incivility online. Social Media + Society, 5(3), 205630511986264. https://doi.org/10.1177/2056305119862641

56.

McCann

Brown

(2017). Discrimination and resilience and the needs of people who identify as transgender: A narrative review of quantitative research studies. Journal of Clinical Nursing, 26(23–24), 4080–4093. https://doi.org/10.1111/jocn.13913

57.

McClearen

(2015). The paradox of Fallon’s fight: Interlocking discourses of sexism and cissexism in mixed martial arts fighting. New Formations, 86(1), 74–88.

58.

Minsberg . (2020). Trans athlete Chris mosier on qualifying for the olympic trials. New York Times. Retrieved from: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/28/sports/chris-mosier-trans-athlete-olympic-trials.html

59.

Montilla

(2025). Bills aim to keep transgender women out of women’s sports. 12onyourside. Com. Retrieved from: https://www.12onyourside.com/2025/01/15/bills-aim-keep-transgender-women-out-womens-sports/

60.

Morton

(2022). Trans athletes: In the news and at the vanguard—25 transgender athletes you should know. CBS News. Retrieved from: https://www.cbsnews.com/pictures/25-transgender-athletes-you-should-know/

61.

Muddiman

Stroud

N. J.

(2017). News values, cognitive biases, and partisan incivility in comment sections: Uncivil comments. Journal of Communication, 67(4), 586–609. https://doi.org/10.1111/jcom.12312

62.

NCAA announces transgender student-athlete participation policy change . (2025). NCAA.org. Retrieved from: https://www.ncaa.org/news/2025/2/6/media-center-ncaa-announces-transgender-student-athlete-participation-policy-change.aspx

63.

Nelson

Scovel

Thorpe

(2022). “We’re missing that humanity”: A feminist media analysis of laurel Hubbard and the Tokyo olympic games. In Greey

A. D.

Lenskyj

H. J.

(Eds.), Justice for Trans athletes (pp. 151–163). Emerald Publishing Limited. Retrieved from: https://doi.org/10.1108/978-1-80262-985-920221010

64.

O’Brien

K. S.

Shovelton

Latner

J. D.

(2013). Homophobia in physical education and sport: The role of physical/sporting identity and attributes, authoritarian aggression, and social dominance orientation. International Journal of Psychology, 48(5), 891–899.

65.

O’Carroll

(2024) San Jose State volleyball player on why she outed her transgender teammate | KTVU FOX 2 (2). KTVU FOX. Retrieved from: https://www.ktvu.com/news/why-san-jose-state-volleyball-player-outted-her-transgender-teammate

66.

Ogden

Rose

R. A.

(2005). Using giddens’s structuration theory to examine the waning participation of African Americans in baseball. Journal of Black Studies, 35(4), 225–245. https://doi.org/10.1177/0021934704266091

67.

Papacharissi

(2015). Affective publics: Sentiment, technology and politics. Oxford University Press.

68.

Petit

(2022). “Do female anime fans exist?” The impact of women-exclusionary discourses on rec.arts.anime. Internet Histories, 6(4), 352–368. https://doi.org/10.1080/24701475.2022.2109265

69.

Pieper

L. P.

(2012). Gender regulation: Renée Richards revisited. International Journal of the History of Sport, 29(5), 675–690. https://doi.org/10.1080/09523367.2012.675202

70.

Poole

M. S.

McPhee

R. D.

(2004). Structuration theory. In May

Mumby

D. K.

(Eds.), Engaging organizational communication theory & research: Multiple perspectives (pp. 171–195). Sage.

71.

Przybylski

(2014). Michael Phelps as a model of a champion in swimming. Studia Gdańskie: Wizje i rzeczywistość, 11, 265–275.

72.

Sailors

P. R.

Weaving

(2022). Sex verification and protected categories in sport: Binary or bust? In The routledge handbook of gender politics in sport and physical activity (pp. 29–37). Routledge.

73.

Sanchez

(2024). Livvy Dunne NIL net worth 2024: How much is Olivia Dunne worth? Sports Illustrated. Retrieved from: https://www.si.com/onsi/athlete-lifestyle/news/livvy-dunne-nil-net-worth

74.

Scovel

Nelson

Thorpe

(2023). Media framings of the transgender athlete as “Legitimate controversy”: The case of Laurel Hubbard at the Tokyo Olympics. Communication & Sport, 11(5), 838–853. https://doi.org/10.1177/21674795221116884

75.

Sopelsa

(2021). Transgender olympian Laurel Hubbard fails to win medal in Olympic debut. NBC News. Retrieved from: https://www.nbcnews.com/nbc-out/out-news/transgender-olympian-laurel-hubbard-fails-win-medal-olympic-debut-rcna1568

76.

Stewart

Ashgar

Richards

(2025). House passes bill to ban transgender student-athletes from women’s sports. NBC News. Retrieved from: https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/congress/house-passes-bill-ban-transgender-student-athletes-womens-sports-rcna187703

77.

Tamerler

(2020). 27JeffreySMooradSportsLJ1.pdf. Jeffrey S. Moorad Sports Law Journal, 27(1), 129–179.

78.

Teetzel

(2006). On transgendered athletes, fairness and doping: An international challenge. Sport in Society, 9(2), 22–251.

79.

Thorpe

Nelson

Scovel

Veale

(2023). Journalists on a journey: Towards responsible media on transgender participation in sport. Journalism Studies, 24(9), 1237–1255.

80.

Toomey

R. B.

Syvertsen

A. K.

Shramko

(2018). Transgender Adolescent suicide behavior. Pediatrics, 142(4), e20174218. https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.2017-4218

81.

Torres

C. R.

Frias

F. J.

Patino

M. J.

(2022). Beyond physiology: Embodied experience, embodied advantage, and the inclusion of transgender athletes in competitive sport. Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 16(1), 33–49.

82.

Transgender Student-Athlete Participation Policy . (n. d.). NCAA.Org. Retrieved from: https://www.ncaa.org/sports/2022/1/27/transgender-participation-policy.aspx

83.

Trump

D. J.

(2025). Keeping men out of women’s sports. Executive Order. Retrieved from: https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/02/keeping-men-out-of-womens-sports/

84.

Turbow

Duca

(2011). The baseball codes: Beanballs, sign stealing, and bench-clearing brawls: The unwritten rules of America's pastime. Anchor.

85.

Whipple

K. N.

Graber

S. M.

Peña

(2022). “We F—ing got osuna”: Examining the maintenance of patriarchy and journalistic routines in A major league baseball Clubhouse. Journalism Studies, 23(16), 1–19.

86.

Witz

(2022). Lia Thomas is cleared to swim at N.C.A.A. Championships. New York Times. Retrieved from: https://www.nytimes.com/2022/02/11/sports/lia-thomas-transgender-swimmer.html

87.

Yurcaba

(2022). 16 Penn swimmers issue letter in support of new transgender athlete rules. NBC News. Retrieved from: https://www.nbcnews.com/nbc-out/out-news/16-penn-swimmers-issue-letter-support-new-transgender-athlete-rules-rcna14928

88.

Zeigler

(2024). San Jose state loses match after protests rage over Blaire fleming—outsports. OutSports. Retrieved from: https://www.outsports.com/2024/10/4/24102184/san-jose-state-blaire-fleming-sjsu-women-volleyball-colorado-state/