Social Media Discourse About Division-I Football Players’ Early Exit Announcements: The Role of Expressed Fandom

Abstract

This study sought to understand social media users’ responses to Division-I football players’ early exit announcements as manifestations of BIRGing and CORFing. Researchers analyzed social media users’ replies (N = 2,009) to six collegiate student-athletes’ early exit announcements on Twitter and Instagram during the 2018 National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) football season. Results identified four responses to exit announcements: (a) supporting, (b) noting significance, (c) disagreeing, and (d) capitalizing. These reactions varied as a function of fan identification: (a) those who expressed fandom for exited teams supported student-athletes, (b) those who expressed fandom for other teams capitalized on the announcements, and (c) those who expressed no fandom noted the significance of and disagreed with student-athletes. These findings offer unique insights that reinforce and diverge from assertions about fans’ BIRGing and CORFing behaviors. The results also have consequences for how scholars and practitioners come to view the intersections between team/organizational processes, athlete expression, and athlete–fan interaction.

Keywords

BIRGing CORFing college athletics exit fandom social media

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bauer-Wolf

(2018, July 6). Into the hands of athletes—Kind of. Insidehighered.com. Retrieved from https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2018/07/06/ncaa-institutes-new-transfer-rule

Beasley

T. M.

Schumacker

R. E.

(1995). Multiple regression approach to analyzing contingency tables: Post hoc and planned comparison procedures. The Journal of Experimental Education, 64, 79–93.

Berg

K. A.

Harthcock

(2008). “Let the domination begin”: Sports fans’ construction of identity in online message boards. In Hugenberg

L. W.

Haridakis

P. M.

Earnheardt

A. C.

(Eds.), Sports mania: Essays on fandom and the media in the 21st century (pp. 203–217). Jefferson, NC: McFarland.

Biddy

(2018, September 24). Jonathan Nance to redshirt, to become graduate transfer. Retrieved from https://247sports.com/college/arkansas/Article/Jonathan-Nance-Arkansas-receiver-to-redshirt-graduate-transfer-122437787/

Billings

(2014). Power in the reverberation: Why Twitter matters, but not the way most believe. Communication & Sport, 2, 107–112.

Billings

A. C.

Broussard

R. M.

(2019). Untangling international sport social media use: Contrasting U.S. and Chinese uses and gratifications across four platforms. Communication & Sport, 7(5), 630–652. doi.org/10.1177/2167479518790014

Bizman

Yinon

(2002). Engaging in distancing tactics among sport fans: Effects on self-esteem and emotional responses. The Journal of Social Psychology, 142, 381–392.

Blaszka

Cianfrone

B. A.

Walsh

(2018). An analysis of collegiate athletic departments’ social media practices, strategies, and challenges. Journal of Contemporary Athletics, 12, 271–290.

Bowman

N. D.

Cranmer

G. A.

(2014). SocialMediaSport: Theoretical implications for the reified relationship between spectator and performer. In Billings

A. C.

Hardin

(Eds.), Routledge handbook of sport and new media (pp. 213–224). New York, NY: Routledge.

10.

Brown

C. J.

Webb

T. L.

Robinson

M. A.

Cotgreave

(2018). Athletes’ experiences of social support during their transition out of elite sport: An interpretive, phenomenological analysis. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 36, 71–80.

11.

Brown

N. A.

Billings

A. C.

(2013). Sports fans as crisis communicators on social media websites. Public Relations Review, 39, 74–81.

12.

Brown-Devlin

Devlin

(2020). Winning with personality: Underscoring antecedents for college students’ motives for team identification. Communication & Sport, 8(3), 364–388. doi:10.1177/2167479519832017

13.

Brown-Devlin

Devlin

Vaughan

P. W.

(2018). Why fans act that way: Using individual personality to predict BIRGing and CORFing behaviors. Communication & Sport, 6, 395–417.

14.

Browning

Sanderson

(2012). The positives and negatives of Twitter: Exploring how student-athletes use Twitter and respond to critical tweets. International Journal of Sport Communication, 5, 503–521.

15.

Cialdini

R. B.

Borden

R. J.

Thorne

Walker

M. R.

Freeman

Sloan

L. R.

(1976). Basking in reflected glory: Three (football) field studies. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 34, 366–375.

16.

Clavio

(2008). Demographics and usage profiles of users of college sport message boards. International Journal of Sport Communication, 1, 434–443.

17.

Clavio

(2011). Social media and the college audience. Journal of Issues in Intercollegiate Athletics, 4, 309–325.

18.

Clavio

Walsh

(2014). Dimensions of social media utilization among college sports fans. Communication & Sport, 2, 261–281.

19.

Cleland

(2014). Racism, football fans, and online message boards: How social media has added a new dimension to racist discourse in English football. Journal of Sport and Social Issues, 38, 415–431.

20.

Cox

S. A.

(1999). Group communication and employee turnover: How coworkers encourage peers to voluntarily exit. Southern Journal of Communication, 64, 181–192.

21.

Cranmer

G. A.

Sanderson

(2018). “Rough week for testosterone”: Public commentary around the Ivy League’s decision to restrict tackle football in practice. Western Journal of Communication, 82, 613–647.

22.

Dahlgren

(2005). The internet, public spheres, and political communication: Dispersion and deliberation. Political Communication, 22, 147–162.

23.

Davis

C. W.

Myers

K. K.

(2012). Communication and member disengagement in planned organizational exit. Western Journal of Communication, 76, 194–216.

24.

Diel

(2017). Beyond BIRGing and CORFing: Longitudinal historical performance measures and the impact of fan expectations. In Billings

A. C.

Brown

K. A.

(Eds.), Evolution of the modern sports fan: Communicative approaches (pp. 49–63). Lanham, MD: Lexington.

25.

Dodd

(2018, January 18). 2018 NFL Draft: Record number of early entries a risky proposition for players. CBSsports.com. Retrieved from https://www.cbssports.com/college-football/news/2018-nfl-draft-record-number-of-early-entries-a-risky-proposition-for-players/

26.

Dwyer

Achen

R. M.

Lupinek

J. M.

(2016). Fantasy vs. reality: Exploring the BIRGing and CORFing behaviors of fantasy football participants. Sport Marketing Quarterly, 25, 152–165.

27.

End

C. M.

(2001). An examination of NFL fans’ computer mediated BIRGing. Journal of Sport Behavior, 24, 162–181.

28.

Foote

Butterworth

Sanderson

(2017). Adrian Peterson and the “Wussification of America:” Football and myths of masculinity. Communication Quarterly, 65, 268–284.

29.

Fuller

R. D.

(2014). Transition experiences out of intercollegiate athletics: A meta-synthesis. The Qualitative Report, 19, 1–15.

30.

Gantz

Fingerhut

Nadorff

(2012). The social dimension of sports fanship. In Earnheardt

A. C.

Haridakis

P. M.

Hugenberg

(Eds.), Sports fans, identity, and socialization—Exploring the fandemonium (pp. 65–75). Lanham, MD: Lexington.

31.

Gantz

Wenner

L. A.

(1995). Fanship and the television sports viewing experience. Sociology of Sport Journal, 12, 56–74.

32.

Gerdy

J. R.

(1997). The successful college athletic program: The new standard. Westport, CT: Oryx Press.

33.

Grabowicz

(2014). Tutorial: The transition to digital journalism. Berkeley: Berkeley Advanced Media Institute, University of California. Retrieved from https://www.multimedia.journalism.berkeley.edu/tutorials/digital-transform/

34.

Haugh

B. R.

Watkins

(2016). Tag me, tweet me if you want to reach me: An investigation into how sport fans use social media. International Journal of Sport Communication, 9, 278–293.

35.

Heider

(1946). Attitudes and cognitive organization. Journal of Psychology, 21, 107–112.

36.

Jablin

F. M.

(2001). Organizational entry, assimilation, and disengagement/exit. In Jablin

F. M.

Putnam

L. L.

(Eds.), The new handbook of organizational communication: Advances in theory, research, and methods (pp. 732–818). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

37.

James

(2019, March 19). Reaction: Tate Martell waiver leads to change in transfer rules? 247Sports.com. Retrieved from https://247sports.com/LongFormArticle/Tate-Martell-eligible-Miami-Hurricanes-football-quarterback-Ohio-State-transfer-130281567/

38.

Jensen

J. A.

Ervin

S. M.

Dittmore

S. W.

(2014). Exploring the factors affecting popularity in social media: A case study of football bowl subdivision head coaches. International Journal of Sport Communication, 7, 261–278.

39.

Joinson

A. N.

Harris

P. R.

(1995). Self-enhancement and self protection on the Internet: A study of football fans on the WWW. Paper presented at the BPS Conference, Institute of Education, London, England.

40.

Kassing

J. W.

Sanderson

(2010). Trash talk and beyond: Aggressive communication in the context of sport. In Avtgis

T. A.

Rancer

A. S.

(Eds.), Arguments, aggression, and conflict: New directions in theory and research (pp. 253–266). New York, NY: Routledge.

41.

Katz

Heere

(2016). New team, new fans: A longitudinal examination of team identification as a driver of university identification. Journal of Sport Management, 30, 135–148.

42.

Kavanagh

Jones

Sheppard Marks

(2016). Towards a typologies of virtual maltreatment: Sport, digital cultures, & dark leisure. Leisure Studies, 35, 783–796.

43.

Larkin

B. A.

Fink

J. S.

(2016). Fantasy sport, FOMO, and traditional fandom: How second-screen use of social media allows fans to accommodate multiple identities. Journal of Sport Management, 30, 643–655.

44.

Litchfield

Kavanagh

Osborne J.

Jones

(2018). Social media and the politics of gender, race, and identity: The case of Serena Williams. European Journal for Sport and Society, 15, 154–170.

45.

Love

Gonzalez-Sobrino

Hughey

M. W.

(2017). Excessive celebration: The racialization of recruiting commitments on college football internet message boards. Sociology of Sport Journal, 34, 235–247.

46.

Magnusen

M. J.

Kim

Perrewe

P. L.

Ferris

G. R.

(2014). A critical review and synthesis of student-athlete college choice factors: Recruiting effectiveness in NCAA sports. International Journal of Sports Science & Coaching, 9, 1265–1286.

47.

McCarthy

(2016, August 17). College coaches are using Twitter, other tools more in recruiting. Retrieved from https://www.inquirer.com/college-sports/inq/how-college-sports-recruiting-is-changing-one-tweet-time-20160817.html

48.

McDermott

(2018). Online news comments as a public sphere forum: Deliberation on Canadian children’s physical activity habits. International Review for the Sociology of Sport, 53, 173–196.

49.

Mudrick

Lupinek

(2015). Craving the scoop: An examination of highly identified fans’ utilization of subscription based college-recruiting networks. Journal of Sports Media, 10, 51–77.

50.

Mudrick

Miller

Atkin

(2016). The influence of social media on fan reactionary behaviors. Telematics & Informatics, 33, 896–903.

51.

National Collegiate Athletic Association. (2018). Prevalence of graduate transfer in Division I. ncaa.org. Retrieved from http://www.ncaa.org/about/resources/research/prevalence-graduate-transfer-division-i

52.

Nite

(2017). Message framing as institutional maintenance: The National Collegiate Athletic Association’s institutional work of addressing legitimate threats. Sport Management Review, 20, 338–351.

53.

Niziolek

(2018, October 22). Virginia Tech offensive lineman D’Andre Plantin plans to transfer. Retrieved from https://www.roanoke.com/sports/college/va_tech/virginia-tech-offensive-lineman-d-andre-plantin-plans-to-transfer/article_8a236020-d625-11e8-b6e7-636c3e69a215.html

54.

H. J.

LaRose

(2016). Impression management concerns and support-seeking behaviors on social network sites. Computers in Human Behavior, 57, 38–47.

55.

Pittman

Reich

(2016). Social media and loneliness: Why an Instagram picture may be worth more than a thousand Twitter words. Computers in Human Behavior, 62, 155–167.

56.

Porter

L. V.

Wood

Benigni

V. L.

(2011). From analysis to aggression: The nature of fan emotion, cognition, and behavior in Internet sports community. In Billings

A. C.

(Ed.), Sports media: Transformation, integration, consumption (pp. 128–145). New York, NY: Routledge.

57.

Rowland

(2019, January 18). Attorney: Coaching turnover a factor in former Ohio State QB’s transfer. Retrieved from https://www.toledoblade.com/sports/ohio-state/2019/01/17/college-football-ohio-state-buckeyes-tate-martell-transfer/stories/20190117178

58.

Saldaña

(2013). The coding manual for qualitative researchers (2nd ed.). Los Angeles, CA: Sage.

59.

Sanderson

(2009). “Thanks for fighting the good fight”: Cultivating dissent on Blogmaverick.com. Southern Communication Journal, 74, 390–405.

60.

Sanderson

(2010). Framing Tiger’s troubles: Comparing traditional and social media. International Journal of Sport Communication, 3, 438–453.

61.

Sanderson

(2013). From loving the hero to despising the villain: Exploring sports fans social identity management on Facebook. Mass Communication and Society, 16, 487–509.

62.

Sanderson

(2018). Think twice before you post: Issues student-athletes face on social media. New Directions for Student Services, 163, 81–92.

63.

Sanderson

Browning

Schmittel

(2015). Education on the digital terrain: A case study exploring college athletes’ perceptions of social media education. International Journal of Sport Communication, 8, 103–124.

64.

Sanderson

Frederick

Stocz

(2016). When athlete activism clashes with group values: Social identity threat management via social media. Mass Communication and Society, 19, 301–322.

65.

Sanderson

Truax

(2014). “I hate you man!”: Exploring maladaptive parasocial interaction expressions to college athletes via Twitter. Journal of Issues in Intercollegiate Athletics, 7, 333–351.

66.

Schwarz

Strack

Kommer

Wagner

(1987). Soccer, rooms, and the quality of your life: Mood effects on judgements of satisfaction with life in general and with specific domains. European Journal of Social Psychology, 17, 69–79.

67.

Schweitzer

Zillmann

Weaver

J. B.

Luttrell

E. S.

(1992). Profile: Perception of life threatening events in the emotional aftermath of a televised college football game. Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media, 36, 75–82.

68.

Sherman

(2012, July 26). How early is too early? Retrieved from https://www.espn.com/college-sports/recruiting/football/story/_/id/8201126/junior-high-athletes-being-offered-football-recruiting-starts-earlier-earlier

69.

Slavich

M. A.

O’Hallarn

Morehead

C. A.

(2018). “We smoked a gator!”: An exploration of college football fans’ Instagramming of food. Journal of Intercollegiate Sport, 11, 1–23.

70.

Smith

(2015, February 18). What do Rivals.com’s 6th grade profiles mean for the recruiting industry? Retrieved from https://usatodayhss.com/2015/rivals-com-is-now-officially-tracking-6th-grade-football-prospects

71.

Smith

(2018, October 16). Nick Bosa will not return to Ohio State after injury and instead focus on NFL Draft. Retrieved from https://www.usatoday.com/story/sports/ncaaf/bigten/2018/10/16/nick-bosa-wont-return-ohio-state-focus-nfl-draft-after-surgery/1658347002/

72.

Snyder

C. R.

Higgins

R. L.

Stucky

R. J.

(1983). Excuses: Masquerades in search of grace. New York, NY: Wiley-Interscience.

73.

Snyder

C. R.

Lassegard

M. A.

Ford

C. E.

(1986). Distancing after group success and failure: Basking in reflected glory and cutting off reflected failure. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 51, 382–388.

74.

Solomon

(2014, March 5). Has the college football recruiting media industry hit a bubble with fans? Retrieved from https://www.al.com/sports/2014/02/has_the_college_football_recru.html

75.

Spinda

J. S.

(2011). The development of basking in reflected glory (BIRGing) and cutting off reflected failure (CORFing) measures. Journal of Sport Behavior, 34, 392–420.

76.

Tamanini

(2018, October 17). Ridiculous criticisms arise around Nick Bosa’s departure from Ohio State. Retrieved from https://www.landgrantholyland.com/2018/10/17/17990932/ohio-state-news-nick-bosa-criticism-idiotic

77.

Tang

Cooper

(2018). The most social games: Predictors of social media uses during the 2016 Rio Olympics. Communication & Sport, 6, 308–330.

78.

Wann

D. L.

Branscombe

N. R.

(1990). Die-hard and fair-weather fans: Effects of identification on BIRGing and CORFing tendencies. Journal of Sport and Social issues, 14, 103–117.

79.

Yan

Steller

Watanabe

N. M.

Popp

(2018). What determines user-generated content creation of college football? A big-data analysis of structural influences. International Journal of Sport Communication, 11, 219–240.