Over the last decade, we have witnessed a resurgence of research on religious cognitions and mental health, including, most notably, perceptions of divine control. Although prior work on divine control tends to assume a loving or benevolent image of God, this is only one potential representation. Using nationwide data from the 2017 Baylor Religion Survey (n = 999), we test whether the mental health benefits of perceived divine control vary according to various images of God (authoritative, benevolent, critical, and distant) and educational attainment. Results suggest that individuals with a college degree tend to report worse mental health if they also exhibit high levels of divine control beliefs and authoritative or critical God images. For those without a college degree, mental health was optimal when perceived divine control beliefs were low and their images of God were either authoritative or critical. For those with a college degree, the best mental health profiles were observed among those who reported high levels of divine control and a benevolent God image. By exploring the intersection of perceived divine control and God imagery, we may gain greater insight into novel processes related to religious cognitions and mental health.
AikenLeona S.WestStephen G.1991. Multiple Regression: Testing and Interpreting Interactions. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
2.
AllottKelly A.Rapado-CastroMartaProffittTina-MarieBendallSarahGarnerBelindaButselaarFelicityMarkulevConniePhassouliotisChristinaMcGorryPatrick D.WoodStephen J.CottonSusan M.PhillipsLisa J.2015. “The Impact of Neuropsychological Functioning and Coping Style on Perceived Stress in Individuals with First-episode Psychosis and Healthy Controls.”Psychiatry Research226:128–35.
3.
AnderssonMatthew A.HitlinSteven. 2023. “Subjective Dignity and Self-reported Health: Results from the United States Before and During the Covid-19 Pandemic.”SSM-Mental Health2:100113.
4.
BanduraAlbert. 2003. “On the Psychosocial Impact and Mechanisms of Spiritual Modeling.”The International Journal for the Psychology of Religion13:167–73.
5.
BeckAaron T.EpsteinNormanBrownGarySteerRobert A.1988. “An Inventory for Measuring Clinical Anxiety: Psychometric Properties.”Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology56:893–97.
6.
BensonPeterSpilkaBernard. 1973. “God Image as a Function of Self-esteem and Locus of Control.”Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion12:297–310.
7.
BonhagRebeccaUpenieksLaura. 2021. “Mattering to God and to the Congregation: Gendered Effects in Mattering as a Mechanism between Religiosity and Mental Health.”Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion60:890–913.
8.
BradshawMattEllisonChristopher G.MarcumJack P.2010. “Attachment to God, Images of God, and Psychological Distress in a Nationwide Sample of Presbyterians.”The International Journal for the Psychology of Religion20:130–47.
9.
BradshawMattKentBlake Victor. 2018. “Prayer, Attachment to God, and Changes in Psychological Well-being in Later Life.”Journal of Aging and Health30:667–91.
10.
DavisEdward B.MoriartyGlendon L.MauchJoseph C.2013. “God Images and God Concepts: Definitions, Development, and Dynamics.”Psychology of Religion and Spirituality5:51–60.
11.
DavisDon E.WorthingtonEverett L.Jr.HookJoshua N.Van TongerenDaryl R.GreenJeffrey D.JenningsDavid J.II. 2009. “Relational Spirituality and the Development of the Similarity of the Offender's Spirituality Scale.”Psychology of Religion and Spirituality1:249–62.
12.
DeAngelisReed T.2018. “Goal-striving Stress and Self-concept: The Moderating Role of Perceived Divine Control.”Society and Mental Health8:141–56.
13.
DeAngelisReed T.BartkowskiJohn P.XuXiaohe. 2019. “Scriptural Coping: An Empirical Test of Hermeneutic Theory.”Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion58:174–91.
14.
DeAngelisReed T.EllisonChristopher G.2017. “Kept in His Care: The Role of Perceived Divine Control in Positive Reappraisal Coping.”Religions8:133.
15.
DeAngelisReed T.EllisonChristopher G.2018. “Aspiration Strain and Mental Health: The Education-contingent Role of Religion.”Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion57:341–64.
16.
DraperScott. “The Preeminent Sacred Symbol: Theorizing Image of God Outcomes.”Sociology Compass11:e12532.
17.
EllisAlbert. 1960. “There is no Place for the Concept of Sin in Psychotherapy.”Journal of Counseling Psychology7:188–92.
18.
EllisonChristopher G.BurdetteAmy M.2012. “Religion and the Sense of Control among US Adults.”Sociology of Religion73:1–22.
19.
EllisonChristopher G.BurdetteAmy M.HillTerrence D.2009. “Blessed Assurance: Religion, Anxiety, and Tranquility among US Adults.”Social Science Research38:656–67.
20.
EllisonChristopher G.LeeJinwoo. 2010. “Spiritual Struggles and Psychological Distress: Is There a Dark Side of Religion?”Social Indicators Research98:501–17.
21.
ExlineJulie J.GrubbsJoshua B.HomolkaSteffany J.2015. “Seeing God as Cruel or Distant: Links with Divine Struggles Involving Anger, Doubt, and Fear of God's Disapproval.”The International Journal for the Psychology of Religion25:29–41.
22.
ExlineJulie J.ParkCrystal L.SmythJoshua M.CareyMichael P.2011. “Anger Toward God: Social-cognitive Predictors, Prevalence, and Links with Adjustment to Bereavement and Cancer.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology100:129–48.
23.
FroesePaulBaderChristopher D.2007. “God in America: Why Theology Is Not Simply the Concern of Philosophers.”Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion46:465–81.
24.
FroesePaulBaderChristopher D.2010. America’s Four Gods: What We Say about God-and What That Says about Us. New York: Oxford University Press.
25.
GreeleyAndrew M.1996. Religion as Poetry. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers.
26.
HayesAndrew F.CaiLi. 2007. “Using Heteroskedasticity-consistent Standard Error Estimators in OLS Regression: An Introduction and Software Implementation.”Behavior Research Methods39:709–22.
27.
JangSung JoonHaysJoshuaJohnsonByron R.HallettMichaelDuweGrant. 2018. “‘Four Gods’ in Maximum Security Prison: Images of God, Religiousness, and Worldviews Among Inmates.”Review of Religious Research60:331–65.
28.
JohnsonKathryn A.OkunMorris A.CohenAdam B.2015. “The Mind of the Lord: Measuring Authoritarian and Benevolent God Representations.”Psychology of Religion and Spirituality7:227–38.
29.
KingstonPaul W.HubbardRyanLappBrentSchroederPaulWilsonJulia. 2003. “Why Education Matters.”Sociology of Education76:53–70.
30.
KirkpatrickLee A.2005. Attachment, Evolution, and the Psychology of Religion. New York: Guilford Press.
31.
KrauseNeal. 2005. “God-mediated Control and Psychological Well-being in Late Life.”Research on Aging27:136–64.
32.
KrauseNeal. 2009. “Religious Involvement, Gratitude, and Change in Depressive Symptoms Over Time.”The International Journal for the Psychology of Religion19:155–72.
33.
KrauseNeal. 2019. “Assessing the Relationships among Stress, God-mediated Control, and Psychological Distress/Well-being: Does the Level of Education Matter?”The Journal of Social Psychology159:2–14.
34.
KrauseNealEmmonsRobert A.IronsonGail. 2015. “Benevolent Images of God, Gratitude, and Physical Health Status.”Journal of Religion and Health54:1503–19.
35.
MarginsonSimon. 2019. “Limitations of Human Capital Theory.”Studies in Higher Education44:287–301.
36.
MarxKarlEngelsFredrick. [1878] 1964. On Religion. New York: Schoken Books.
37.
MaynardElizabethGorsuchRichardBjorckJeff. 2011. “Religious Coping Style, Concept of God, and Personal Religious Variables in Threat, Loss, and Challenge Situations.”Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion40:65–74.
38.
MercierBrettKramerStephanie R.ShariffAzim F.2018. “Belief in God: Why People Believe, and Why They Don't.”Current Directions in Psychological Science27:263–68.
39.
MirowskyJohnRossCatherine E.2003. Education, Social Status, and Health. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers.
40.
MoultonBenjamin E.SherkatDarren E.2012. “Specifying the Effects of Religious Participation and Educational Attainment on Mortality Risk for US Adults.”Sociological Spectrum32:1–19.
41.
PargamentKenneth I.1997. The Psychology of Religion and Coping: Theory, Research, Practice. New York: Guilford Press.
42.
PargamentKenneth I.KennellJosephHathawayWilliamGrevengoedNancyNewmanJonJonesWendy. 1988. “Religion and the Problem-solving Process: Three Styles of Coping.”Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion27:90–104.
43.
PhelanJo C.LinkBruce G.TehranifarParisa. 2010. “Social Conditions as Fundamental Causes of Health Inequalities: Theory, Evidence, and Policy Implications.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior51:28–40.
44.
RadloffLenore Sawyer. 1977. “The CES-D Scale: A Self-report Depression Scale for Research in the General Population.”Applied Psychological Measurement1:385–401.
45.
RossCatherine E.WuChia-ling. 1995. “The Links Between Education and Health.”American Sociological Review60:719–45.
46.
RothmanKenneth J.1990. “No Adjustments Are Needed for Multiple Comparisons.”Epidemiology1:43–46.
47.
Schaap-JonkerHannekeEurelings-BontekoeElisabethVerhagenPiet J.ZockHetty. 2002. “Image of God and Personality Pathology: An Exploratory Study among Psychiatric Patients.”Mental Health, Religion & Culture5:55–71.
48.
SchiemanScott. 2010. “Socioeconomic Status and Beliefs about God's Influence in Everyday Life.”Sociology of Religion71:25–51.
49.
SchiemanScott. 2011. “Education and the Importance of Religion in Decision Making: Do Other Dimensions of Religiousness Matter?”Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion50:570–87.
50.
SchiemanScottBiermanAlex. 2007. “Religious Activities and Changes in the Sense of Divine Control: Dimensions of Social Stratification as Contingencies.”Sociology of Religion68:361–81.
51.
SchiemanScottBiermanAlex. 2011. “The Role of Divine Beliefs in Stress Processes.” Pp. 45–68 in Toward a Sociological Theory of Religion and Health, edited by LeidenA. Blasi, the Netherlands: Brill.
52.
SchiemanScottBiermanAlexEllisonChristopher G.2010. “Religious Involvement, Beliefs about God, and the Sense of Mattering among Older Adults.”Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion49:517–35.
53.
SchiemanScottBiermanAlexEllisonChristopher G.2013. “Religion and Mental Health.” Pp. 457–78 in Handbook of the Sociology of Mental Health, edited by AneshenselCarolPhelanJoBiermanAlex. New York: Springer.
54.
SchiemanScottBiermanAlexUpenieksLaura. 2018. “The Powerful Other: How Divine Control Shapes the Relationship between Personal Control and Psychological Distress.”Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion57:123–38.
55.
SchiemanScottBiermanAlexUpenieksLauraEllisonChristopher G.2017. “Love Thy Self? How Belief in a Supportive God Shapes Self-esteem.”Review of Religious Research59:293–318.
56.
SchiemanScottJungJong Hyun. 2012. “‘Practical Divine Influence’: Socioeconomic Status and Belief in the Prosperity Gospel.”Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion51:738–56.
57.
SchiemanScottNarisadaAtsushi. 2014. “In Control or Fatalistically Ruled? The Sense of Mastery among Working Canadians.”Canadian Review of Sociology51:343–74.
58.
SchiemanScottPudrovskaTetyanaMilkieMelissa A.2005. “The Sense of Divine Control and the Self-concept: A Study of Race Differences in Late Life.”Research on Aging27:165–96.
59.
SchiemanScottPudrovskaTetyanaPearlinLeonard I.EllisonChristopher G.2006. “The Sense of Divine Control and Psychological Distress: Variations across Race and Socioeconomic Status.”Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion45:529–49.
60.
SchreiberJudith A.2011. “Image of God: Effect on Coping and Psychospiritual Outcomes in Early Breast Cancer Survivors.”Oncology Nursing Forum38:293–301.
61.
SchwadelPhilip. 2011. “The Effects of Education on Americans’ Religious Practices, Beliefs, and Affiliations.”Review of Religious Research53:161–82.
62.
SiltonNava R.FlannellyKevin J.GalekKathleenEllisonChristopher G.2014. “Beliefs about God and Mental Health among American Adults.”Journal of Religion and Health53:1285–96.
63.
SteenslandBrianRobinsonLynn D.WilcoxW. BradfordParkJerry Z.RegnerusMark D.WoodberryRobert D.2000. “The Measure of American Religion: Toward Improving the State of the Art.” Social Forces79:291–318.
64.
StroopeSamuelDraperScottWhiteheadAndrew L.2013. “Images of a Loving God and Sense of Meaning in Life.”Social Indicators Research11:125–44.
65.
TungEsther S.RuffingElizabeth G.PaineDavid R.JankowskiPeter J.SandageSteven J.2018. “Attachment to God as Mediator of the Relationship between God Representations and Mental Health.”Journal of Spirituality in Mental Health20:95–113.
66.
UpenieksLaura. 2022. “Do Beliefs in Christian Nationalism Predict Mental Health Problems? The Role of Religious (Non) Involvement.”Socius8:23780231221081641.
67.
UpenieksLauraFord-RobertsonJoanne. 2022. “Give Thanks in All Circumstances? Gratitude Toward God and Health in Later Life after Major Life Stressors.”Research on Aging44:392–404.
68.
UpenieksLauraSchiemanScott. 2021. “The Belief in Divine Control and the Mental Health Effects of Stressful Life Events: A Study of Education-based Contingencies.”Review of Religious Research63:183–215.
69.
UpenieksLauraSchiemanScottBiermanAlex. 2022. “Jitters on the Eve of the Great Recession: Is the Belief in Divine Control a Protective Resource?”Sociology of Religion83:194–221.
70.
UpenieksLauraThomasPatricia A.2021. “Gaining Faith, Losing Faith: How Education Shapes the Relationship between Religious Transitions and Later Depression.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior62:582–98.
71.
WeberMax. [1922] 1963. The Sociology of Religion. Boston, MA: Beacon.
72.
WoodBenjamin T.WorthingtonEverett L.Jr.ExlineJulie JuolaYaliAnn MarieAtenJamie D.McMinnMark R.2010. “Development, Refinement, and Psychometric Properties of the Attitudes Toward God Scale (ATGS-9).”Psychology of Religion and Spirituality2(3):148–67.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
