Over the past two decades, researchers have worked to make sense of the fact that black Americans tend to exhibit similar or better mental health profiles relative to their white counterparts. In this study, we extend previous research by proposing and testing a new potential explanation of the black-white mental health paradox: the dark side of religion or religious/spiritual (R/S) struggles. We also consider whether the association between R/S struggles and mental health is moderated by race. Our mediation analysis of data collected from a 2021 nationally representative sample of American adults (n = 1,381) indicates that black respondents tend to exhibit lower levels of non-specific psychological distress than white respondents partly because black respondents also tend to report lower levels of R/S struggles. Our moderation analysis demonstrates that the positive association between R/S struggles and psychological distress is more pronounced for white respondents than for black respondents.
Abu-RaiyaHishamPargamentKenneth I.KrauseNeal. 2016. “Religion as Problem Religion as Solution: Religious Buffers of the Links between Religious/Spiritual Struggles and Well-being/Mental Health.” Quality of Life Research25:1265–74.
2.
AlangSirry M.2014. “Racial Variations in the Effects of Structural and Psychological Factors on Depressive Symptoms: A Structural Equation Modeling Approach.” Mental Health & Prevention2:2–10.
3.
AllenRebecca S.PhillipsLaura LeeRoffLucinda LeeCavanaughRonaldDayLaura. 2008. “Religiousness/Spirituality and Mental Health among Older Male Inmates.” The Gerontologist48:692–97.
4.
AssariShervinLankaraniMaryam Moghani. 2018. “Secular and Religious Social Support Better Protect Blacks than Whites against Depressive Symptoms.” Behavioral Sciences8:46.
5.
BarnaGeorge. 2002. The State of the Church 2002. Ventura, CA: Issachar Resources.
6.
BarnesDavid M.BatesLisa M.2017. “Do Racial Patterns in Psychological Distress shed Light on the Black–White Depression Paradox? A Systematic Review.” Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology5:913–28.
7.
BarnesDavid M.BatesLisa M.2019. “Testing a Somatization Hypothesis to Explain the Black–White Depression Paradox.” Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology54:1255–63.
8.
BaronReuben M.KennyDavid A.1986. “The Moderator–Mediator Variable Distinction in Social Psychological Research: Conceptual, Strategic, and Statistical Considerations.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology51:1173–82.
9.
BeeversChristopher G.MullarkeyMichael C.Dainer-BestJustinStewartRochelle A.LabradaJocelynAllenJohn J. B.McGearyJohn E.ShumakeJason. 2019. “Association between Negative Cognitive Bias and Depression: A Symptom-level Approach.” Journal of Abnormal Psychology128:212–27.
10.
BreslauJoshuaAguilar-GaxiolaSergioKendlerKenneth S.SuMaxwellWilliamsDavidKesslerRonald C.2006. “Specifying Race-ethnic Differences in Risk for Psychiatric Disorder in a USA National Sample.” Psychological Medicine36:57–68.
11.
BreslauJoshuaKendlerKenneth S.SuMaxwellGaxiola-AguilarSergioKesslerRonald C.2005. “Lifetime Risk and Persistence of Psychiatric Disorders across Ethnic Groups in the United States.” Psychological Medicine35:317–27.
12.
Calhoun-BrownAllison. 1999. “The Image of God: Black Theology and Racial Empowerment in the African American Community.” Review of Religious Research40:197–212.
13.
ClayLauren A.RogusStephanie. 2021. “Primary and Secondary Health Impacts of COVID-19 among Minority Individuals in New York State.” International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health18:683. doi:10.3390/ijerph18020683.
14.
CooperLisa A.WilliamsDavid R.2020. “Excess Deaths from COVID-19, Community Bereavement, and Restorative Justice for Communities of Color.” JAMA324:1491–92.
15.
EllisonChristopher G.GeorgeLinda K.1994. “Religious Involvement, Social Ties, and Social Support in a Southeastern Community.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion33:46–61.
16.
EllisonChristopher G.LeeJinwoo. 2010. “Spiritual Struggles and Psychological Distress: Is There a Dark Side of Religion?”Social Indicators Research98:501–17.
17.
EllisonChristopher G.LevinJeffrey S.1998. “The Religion-health Connection: Evidence, Theory, and Future Directions.” Health Education & Behavior25:700–20.
18.
EllisonChristopher G.MusickMarc A.HendersonAndrea K.2008. “Balm in Gilead: Racism, Religious Involvement, and Psychological Distress among African–American Adults.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion47:291–309.
19.
ExlineJulie J.KaplanKalman J.GrubbsJoshua B.2012. “Anger, Exit, and Assertion: Do People see Protest Toward God as Morally Acceptable?”Psychology of Religion and Spirituality4:264–77.
20.
ExlineJulie J.PargamentKenneth I.GrubbsJoshua B.YaliAnn Marie. 2014. “The Religious and Spiritual Struggles Scale: Development and Initial Validation.” Psychology of Religion and Spirituality6:208–22.
21.
ExlineJulie J.ParkCrystal L.SmythJoshua M.CareyMichael P.2011. “Anger toward God: Social-cognitive Predictors, Prevalence, and Links with Adjustment to Bereavement and Cancer.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology100:129–48.
22.
ExlineJulie Juola. 2002. “Stumbling Blocks on the Religious Road: Fractured Relationships, Nagging Vices, and the Inner Struggle to Believe.” Psychological Inquiry13:182–89.
23.
FigueroaJose F.WadheraRishi K.LeeDennisYehRobert W.SommersBenjamin D.2020. “Community-level Factors Associated with Racial snd Ethnic Disparities in COVID-19 Rates in Massachusetts.” Health Affairs39:1984–92.
24.
FroesePaulBaderChristopher. 2010. America’s Four Gods: What We Say about God—And What That Says about Us. New York: Oxford University Press.
25.
GlaudeEddie S.2018. An Uncommon Faith: A Pragmatic Approach to the Study of African American Religion. Athens, GA: University of Georgia Press.
26.
GoldmannEmilyHagenDanielEl KhouryEstelleOwensMarkMisraSupriyaThrulJohannes. 2021. “An Examination of Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Mental Health During the Covid-19 Pandemic in the US South.” Journal of Affective Disorders295:471–78.
27.
GouldEliseWilsonValerie. 2020. Black Workers Face Two of the Most Lethal Pre-existing Conditions for Coronavirus-racism and Economic Inequality. June1. Economic Policy Institute. https://www.epi.org/publication/black-workers-covid/.
28.
HillTerrence D.BurdetteAmy M.EllisonChristopher G.MusickMarc A.2006. “Religious Attendance and the Health Behaviors of Texas Adults.” Preventive Medicine42:309–12.
29.
HillTerrence D.Christie-MizellC. AndréVaghelaPreetiMossakowskiKrysia N.JohnsonRobert J.2017. “Do Religious Struggles Mediate the Association between Day-to-day Discrimination and Depressive Symptoms?”Religions8:134.
30.
HillTerrence D.CobbRyon J.2011. “Religious Involvement and Religious Struggles.” Pp. 239–60 in Toward a Sociological Theory of Religion and Health, edited by BlasiA.Boston, MA: Brill.
31.
HillTerrence D.RoteSunshine M.EllisonChristopher G.2017. “Religious Participation and Biological Functioning in Mexico.” Journal of Aging and Health29:951–72.
32.
HillTerrence D.ZengLiwenRambottiSimoneMossakowskiKrysia N.JohnsonRobert J.2021. “Sad Eyes, Crooked Crosses: Religious Struggles, Psychological Distress and the Mediating Role of Psychosocial Resources.” Journal of Religion and Health60:2573–91.
33.
HoggMichael A.TerryDeborah J.WhiteKatherine M.1995. “A Tale of Two Theories: A Critical Comparison of Identity Theory with Social Identity Theory.” Social Psychology Quarterly58:255–69.
34.
IdlerEllen L.MusickMarc A.EllisonChristopher G.GeorgeLinda K.KrauseNealOryMarcia G.PargamentKenneth I.PowellLynda H.UnderwoodLynn G.WilliamsDavid R.2003. “Measuring Multiple Dimensions of Religion and Spirituality for Health Research: Conceptual Background and Findings from the 1998 General Social Survey.” Research on Aging25:327–65.
35.
JacksonJames S.KnightKatherine M.2006. “Race and Self-regulatory Health Behaviors: The Role of the Stress Response and the HPA Axis in Physical and Mental Health Disparities.” Pp. 189–207 in Social Structures, Aging, and Self-regulation in the Elderly, edited by SchaieK. W.CartensenL.New York: Springer.
36.
JacksonJames S.KnightKatherine M.RaffertyJane A.2010. “Race and Unhealthy Behaviors: Chronic Stress, the HPA Axis, and Physical and Mental Health Disparities over the Life-course.” American Journal of Public Health100:933–39.
37.
KesslerRonald C.AndrewsGavinColpeLisa J.HiripiEvaMroczekDaniel K.NormandS.-L. T.WaltersEllen E.ZaslavskyAlan M.2002. “Short Screening Scales to Monitor Population Prevalences and Trends in Non-specific Psychological Distress.” Psychological Medicine32:959–76.
38.
KeyesCorey L. M.2007. “Promoting and Protecting Mental Health as Flourishing: A Complementary Strategy for Improving National Mental Health.” American Psychologist62:95–108.
39.
KoenigHaroldKoenigHarold GeorgeKingDanaCarsonVerna B.2012. Handbook of Religion and Health. New York: Oxford University Press.
40.
KrauseNeal. 2002. “Church-based Social Support and Health in Old Age: Exploring Variations by Race.” The Journals of Gerontology Series B: Psychological Sciences and Social Sciences57:S332–47.
41.
KrauseNeal. 2012. “Religious Doubt, Financial Strain, and Depressive Symptoms among Older Mexican Americans.” Mental Health, Religion & Culture15(4):335–48
42.
KrauseNealBastidaElena. 2011. “Social Relationships in the Church during Late Life: Assessing differences between African Americans, Whites, and Mexican Americans.” Review of Religious Research53:41–63.
43.
KrauseNeal R.HaywardDavid. 2012. “Negative Interaction with Fellow Church Members and Depressive Symptoms among Older Mexican Americans.” Archive for the Psychology of Religion34:149–71.
44.
KrauseNealPargamentKenneth I.HillPeter C.IronsonGail. 2018. “Assessing the Role of Race/Ethnicity in the Relationships among Spiritual Struggles, Health, and Well-being.” American Journal of Orthopsychiatry88:132–41.
45.
LincolnC. EricMamiyaLawrence H.1990. The Black Church in the African American Experience. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
46.
LouiePatriciaUpenieksLauraErvingChristy L.Thomas TobinCourtney S.2022. “Do Racial Differences in Coping Resources Explain the Black–White Paradox in Mental Health? A Test of Multiple Mechanisms.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior63:55–70. doi:10.1177/00221465211041031.
47.
LouiePatriciaWheatonBlair. 2019. “The Black-White Paradox Revisited: Understanding the Role of Counterbalancing Mechanisms during Adolescence.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior60:169–87.
48.
MannheimerAndrew H.HillTerrence D.2015. “Deviating from Religious Norms and the Mental Health of Conservative Protestants.” Journal of Religion and Health54:1826–38.
49.
MezukBrianaAbdouCleopatra M.HudsonDarrellKershawKiarri N.RaffertyJane A.LeeHedwigJacksonJames S.2013. ““White Box” Epidemiology and the Social Neuroscience of Health Behaviors: The Environmental Affordances Model.” Society and Mental Health3:79–95.
50.
MouzonDawne M.2013. “Can Family Relationships Explain the Race Paradox in Mental Health?”Journal of Marriage and Family75:470–85.
51.
MouzonDawne M. 2014. “Relationships of Choice: Can Friendships or Fictive Kinships Explain the Race Paradox in Mental Health?” Social Science Research44:32–43.
52.
MouzonDawne M.2017. “Religious Involvement and the Black–White Paradox in Mental Health.” Race and Social Problems9:63–78.
53.
NguyenAnn W.2020. “Religion and Mental Health in Racial and Ethnic Minority Populations: A Review of the Literature.” Innovation in Aging4:igaa035.
54.
NieFanhaoOlsonDaniel V. A.2016. “Demonic Influence: The Negative Mental Health Effects of Belief in Demons.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion55:498–515.
55.
PageRobin L.PeltzerJill N.BurdetteAmy M.HillTerrence D.2020. “Religiosity and Health: A Holistic Biopsychosocial Perspective.” Journal of Holistic Nursing38:89–101.
56.
PamplinJohn R.IIBatesLisa M.2021. “Evaluating Hypothesized Explanations for the Black-White Depression Paradox: A Critical Review of the Extant Evidence.” Social Science & Medicine281:114085.
57.
PargamentKenneth I.1997. The Psychology of Religion and Coping: Theory, Research and Practice. London, England: Guilford Press.
58.
PargamentKenneth I.KoenigHarold G.PerezLisa M.2000. “The Many Methods of Religious Coping: Development and Initial Validation of the RCOPE.” Journal of Clinical Psychology56:519–43.
PearlinLeonard I.BiermanAlex. 2013. “Current Issues and Future Directions in Research into the Stress Process.” Pp. 325–40 in Handbook of the Sociology of Mental Health, edited by AneshenselC. S.PhelanJ. C.Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Springer.
61.
RosenfieldSarah. 2012. “Triple Jeopardy? Mental Health at the Intersection of Gender, Race, and Class.” Social Science & Medicine74:1791–1801.
62.
SchiemanScottPudrovskaTetyanaPearlinLeonard I.EllisonChristopher G.2006. “The Sense of Divine Control and Psychological Distress: Variations across Race and Socioeconomic Status.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion45(4):529–49.
63.
SchiemanScottBiermanAlexEllisonChristopher G.2013. “Religion and Mental Health..” Pp. 457–78 in Handbook of the Sociology of Mental Health, edited by AneshenselC. S.PhelanJ. C.BiermanA.Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Springer.
64.
ScottLionel D.Jr.2003. “The Relation of Racial Identity and Racial Socialization to Coping with Discrimination among African American Adolescents.” Journal of Black Studies33:520–38.
65.
SprecherSusanBrooksJames E.AvogoWinfred. 2013. “Self-esteem among Young Adults: Differences and Similarities Based on Gender, Race, and Cohort (1990–2012).” Sex Roles69:264–75.
66.
StaunerNickExlineJulie J.GrubbsJoshua B.PargamentKenneth I.BradleyDavid F.UzdavinesAlex. 2016. “Bifactor Models of Religious and Spiritual Struggles: Distinct from Religiousness and Distress.” Religions7:68.
67.
SteenslandBrianRobinsonLynn D.WilcoxW. BradfordParkJerry Z.RegnerusMark D.WoodberryRobert D.2000. “The Measure of American Religion: Toward Improving the State of the Art.” Social Forces79:291–318.
68.
TaylorRobert JosephChattersLinda M.2010. “Importance of Religion and Spirituality in the Lives of African Americans, Caribbean Blacks and Non-Hispanic Whites.” The Journal of Negro Education79:280–94.
69.
TaylorRobert JosephChattersLinda M.LevinJeff. 2004. Religion in the Lives of African Americans: Social, Psychological, and Health Perspectives. New York: Sage.
70.
TwengeJean M.CrockerJennifer. 2002. “Race and Self-esteem: Meta-analyses Comparing Whites, Blacks, Hispanics, Asians, and American Indians and Comment on Gray-Little and Hafdahl.” Psychological Bulletin128:371–408.
71.
UpenieksLaura. 2021a. “Changes in Religious Doubt and Physical and Mental Health in Emerging Adulthood.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion60:332–61.
72.
UpenieksLaura. 2021b. “‘The Assurance of Things Hoped For, The Conviction of Things not Seen’: Racial Differences in the Effects of Changes in Religiosity and Hope in Later Life.” Journal of Religion, Spirituality & Aging. Published electronically October31. doi:10.1080/15528030.2021.1998817.
73.
UpenieksLaura. 2022. “Religious/Spiritual Struggles and Well-being during the COVID-19 Pandemic: Does “Talking Religion” Help or Hurt?”Review of Religious Research64:249–78. doi:10.1007/s13644-022-00487-0.
74.
ValeriLindaVanderWeeleTyler J.2013. “Mediation Analysis Allowing for Exposure–Mediator Interactions and Causal Interpretation: Theoretical Assumptions and Implementation with SAS and SPSS Macros.” Psychological Methods18:137–50.
75.
Van TongerenDaryl RSandersMarkEdwardsMeganDavisEdward B.AtenJamie D.RanterJennifer M.TsarouhisAngelaShortAmandaCuthbertAndrewHookJoshua N.DavisDon E.2019. “Religious and Spiritual Struggles Alter God Representations.” Psychology of Religion and Spirituality11:225–32.
76.
Von HippelPaul T. 2007. “Regression with Missing Ys: An Improved Strategy for Analyzing Multiply Imputed Data.” Sociological Methodology37(1):83–117.
77.
WilliamsDavid R.GonzalezHector M.NeighborsHaroldNesseRandolphAbelsonJamie M.SweetmanJulieJacksonJames S.2007. “Prevalence and Distribution of Major Depressive Disorder in African Americans, Caribbean Blacks, and Non-Hispanic Whites: Results from the National Survey of American Life.” Archives of General Psychiatry64:305–15.
78.
WillisKelcie D.NelsonTamaraMorenoOswaldo. 2019. “Death Anxiety, Religious Doubt, and Depressive Symptoms across Race in Older Adults.” International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health16:3645.
79.
WiltJoshua A.ExlineJulie J.JeongPeterYunDorothyTakahashiJoyce T.PargamentKenneth I.2022. “Imagined Conversations with God during Divine Struggles: Relationships with Global Views of God and Struggle-specific Interactions.” Journal of Spirituality in Mental Health. Published electronically April25. doi:10.1080/19349637.2022.2065944.
80.
ZarzyckaBeata. 2016. “Prevalence and Social-cognitive Predictors of Anger toward God in a Polish Sample.” The International Journal for the Psychology of Religion26:225–39.
81.
ZhangHansongHookJoshua N.HodgeAdam S.CoomesSteven P.DavisCameron W.Van TongerenDaryl R.DavisDon E.AtenJamie D.2021. “Religious and Spiritual Struggles and Coping Amidst the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Qualitative Study.” Spirituality in Clinical Practice8:245–61.
