The Influence of Defendant Race/Ethnicity and Police Body-Worn Cameras on Traffic Case Processing

Abstract

The current study evaluates the impact of defendant race/ethnicity and police body-worn cameras (BWCs) on dismissals and guilty pleas in traffic violations. Despite the frequency of traffic violations and the potential for racial/ethnic bias in these incidents, researchers have yet to examine the outcomes of these violations in court. Research is also needed to assess the potential for BWCs to provide evidence and reduce charging disparities and differential pleas for minority defendants. Traffic violations processed in the Tempe, Arizona Municipal Court before and after BWC deployment were examined using logistic regression. Black and Hispanic defendants were less likely to have their violations dismissed than White defendants, regardless of the presence of a BWC. Hispanic defendants were significantly more likely to plead guilty to traffic violations than White defendants, and BWCs did not eliminate this disparity. BWCs did significantly reduce the likelihood of a guilty plea for Black and White defendants, but the finding was not robust to the inclusion of an interaction term between race and BWCs. BWCs did not significantly moderate the impact of defendant race/ethnicity on either dismissals or guilty pleas. Overall, the results suggest that BWCs have little impact on reducing racial/ethnic disparities in traffic violation processing.

Keywords

body-worn cameras dismissals guilty pleas focal concerns traffic race/ethnicity

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adams

Cutshall

C. R.

(1987). Refusing to prosecute minor offenses: The relative influence of legal and extralegal factors. Justice Quarterly, 4(4), 595–609.

Albonetti

C. A.

(1991). An integration of theories to explain judicial discretion. Social Problems, 38(2), 247–266. https://doi.org/10.3868/s050-004-015-0003-8

Anderson

A. L.

Spohn

(2010). Lawlessness in the federal sentencing process: A test for uniformity and consistency in sentence outcomes. Justice Quarterly, 27(3), 362–393. https://doi.org/10.1080/07418820902936683

Berdejó

(2018). Criminalizing race: Racial disparities in plea bargaining. Boston College Law Review, 59(4), 1188–1249.

Brickey

S. L.

Miller

D. E.

(1975). Bureaucratic due process: An ethnography of a traffic court. Social Problems, 22(5), 688–697. https://doi.org/10.3366/ajicl.2011.0005

Davis

Whyde

Langton

(2018). Contacts between police and the public, 2015. https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/cpp15.pdf

Economos

J. P.

(1953). The traffic problem, traffic laws, and traffic courts. The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 287, 13–20. https://doi.org/http://www.jstor.org/stable/1028896

Engel

R. S.

(2010). Introduction. In Rice

S. K.

White

M. D.

(Eds.), Race, ethnicity, and policing: New and essential readings (pp. 1–6). New York University Press.

Engel

R. S.

Calnon

J. M.

(2004). Examining the influence of drivers’ characteristics during traffic stops with police: Results from a national survey. Justice Quarterly, 21(1), 49–90. https://doi.org/10.1080/07418820400095741

10.

Engel

R. S.

Calnon

J. M.

Bernard

T. J.

(2002). Theory and racial profiling: Shortcomings and future directions in research. Justice Quarterly, 19(2), 249–273. https://doi.org/10.1080/07418820200095231

11.

Epp

C. R.

Maynard-Moody

Haider-Markel

(2014). Pulled over: How police stops define race and citizenship. The University of Chicago Press.

12.

Farrell

R. A.

Holmes

M. D.

(1991). The social and cognitive structure of legal decision-making. The Sociological Quarterly, 32(4), 529–542. https://www-jstor-org.ezproxy1.lib.asu.edu/stable/pdf/4120901.pdf?refreqid=excelsior%3Aa04b4e0da25a5a7a4c3208372ce07ead

13.

Federal Bureau of Investigation. (2016). 2016 Crime in the United States, offenses known to law enforcement. https://ucr.fbi.gov/crime-in-the-u.s/2016/crime-in-the-u.s.-2016/tables/table-6/table-6-state-cuts/arizona.xls

14.

Goodall

(2007). Guidance for the police use of body-worn video devices: Police and crime standards directorate. http://www.bwvsg.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/07/Police-BWV-Guidance.pdf

15.

Harris

D. A.

(1999). The stories, the statistics, and the law: Why “driving while Black” matters. Minnesota Law Review, 84(2), 265–326. https://doi.org/10.18574/nyu/9780814776155.003.0003

16.

Harris

D. A.

(2002). Profiles in injustice: Why racial profiling cannot work. New Press.

17.

Hawkins

D. F.

(1981). Causal attribution and punishment for crime. Deviant Behavior, 2(3), 207–230. https://doi.org/10.1080/01639625.1981.9967554

18.

Jamieson

K. M.

Blowers

A. N.

(1993). A structural examination of misdemeanor court disposition patterns. Criminology, 31(2), 243–262. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1745-9125.1993.tb01129.x

19.

Johnson

B. D.

(2006). The multilevel context of criminal sentencing: Integrating judge- and county-level influences. Criminology, 44(2), 259–298. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1745-9125.2006.00049.x

20.

Kalven

Zeisel

(1966). The American jury. Little Brown.

21.

Kim

Spohn

Hedberg

E. C.

(2015). Federal sentencing as a complex collaborative process: Judges, prosecutors, judge-prosecutor dyads, and disparity in sentencing. Criminology, 53(4), 597–623. https://doi.org/10.1111/1745-9125.12090

22.

Kutateladze

B. L.

Lawson

V. Z.

(2018). Is a plea really a bargain? An analysis of plea and trial dispositions in new york city. Crime and Delinquency, 64(7), 856–887. https://doi.org/10.1177/0011128717695224

23.

Lawrence

D. S.

McClure

Malm

Lynch

La Vigne

(2019). Activation of body-worn cameras: Variation by officer, over time, and by policing activity. Criminal Justice Review, 44(3), 339–355. https://doi.org/10.1177/0734016819846228

24.

Leiber

M. J.

Blowers

A. N.

(2003). Race and misdemeanor sentencing. Criminal Justice Policy Review, 14(4), 464–485. https://doi.org/10.1177/0887403403254492

25.

Lum

Stoltz

Koper

C. S.

Scherer

J. A.

(2019). The research on body-worn cameras: What we know, what we need to know. Criminology and Public Policy, 18(1), 93–118. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1461-0248.2011.01634.x

26.

Lundman

R. J.

(2010). Are police-reported driving while Black data a valid indicator of the race and ethnicity of the traffic law violators police stop? A negative answer with minor qualifications. Journal of Criminal Justice, 38(1), 77–87. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcrimjus.2009.11.010

27.

Lundman

R. J.

Kaufman

R. L.

(2003). Driving while Black: Effects of race, ethnicity, and gender on citizen self-reports of traffic stops and police actions. Criminology, 41(1), 195–220.

28.

McCluskey

Smith

Robertson

Uchida

C. D.

Mosler

(2019). The evidentiary value of body-worn camera footage: A survey of prosecutors and public defenders. CAN.

29.

Merola

Lum

Koper

C. S.

Scherer

(2016). Body worn cameras and the courts: A national survey of state prosecutors. George Mason University.

30.

Metcalfe

Chiricos

(2018). Race, plea, and charge reduction: An assessment of racial disparities in the plea process. Justice Quarterly, 35(2), 223–253. https://doi.org/10.1080/07418825.2017.1304564

31.

Miller

(2009). Race, driving, and police organization: Modeling moving and nonmoving traffic stops with citizen self-reports of driving practices. Journal of Criminal Justice, 37(6), 564–575. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcrimjus.2009.09.005

32.

Morrow

W. J.

Katz

C. M.

Choate

D. E.

(2016). Assessing the impact of police body-worn cameras on arresting, prosecuting, and convicting suspects of intimate partner violence. Police Quarterly, 19(3), 303–325. https://doi.org/10.1177/1098611116652850

33.

Natapoff

(2018). Punishment without crime: How our massive misdemeanor system traps the innocent and makes America more unequal. Basic Books.

34.

Owens

Mann

McKenna

(2014). The Essex body worn video trial: The impact of body worn video on criminal justice outcomes of domestic abuse incidents. College of Policing.

35.

Painter-Davis

Ulmer

J. T.

(2020). Discretion and disparity under sentencing guidelines revisited: The interrelationship between structured sentencing alternatives and guideline decision-making. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 57(3), 263–293. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022427819874862

36.

Pierson

Simoiu

Overgoor

Corbett-Davies

Jenson

Shoemaker

Goel

(2019). A large-scale analysis of racial disparities in police stops across the United States. http://arxiv.org/abs/1706.05678

37.

Roberts

(2011). Why misdemeanors matter: Defining effective advocacy in the lower criminal courts. U.C. Davis Law Review, 45, 277–1945.

38.

Rojek

Rosenfeld

Decker

(2004). The influence of driver’s race on traffic stops in Missouri. Police Quarterly, 7(1), 126–147. https://doi.org/10.1177/1098611103260695

39.

Skolnick

J. H.

(1996). A sketch of the police officer’s “working personality.” In Hancock

B. W.

Sharp

P. M.

(Eds.), Criminal justice in America: Theory, practice, and policy (pp. 89–113). Prentice-Hall.

40.

Spohn

Cederblom

(1991). Race and disparities in sentencing: A test of the liberation hypothesis. Justice Quarterly, 8(3), 305–327.

41.

Steffensmeier

Demuth

(2001). Ethnicity and judges’ sentencing decisions: Hispanic-Black-White comparisons. Criminology, 39(1), 145–178. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1745-9125.2001.tb00919.x

42.

Steffensmeier

Kramer

Streifel

(1993). Gender and imprisonment decisions. Criminology, 31(3), 411–446. https://doi.org/10.3868/s050-004-015-0003-8

43.

Steffensmeier

Painter-Davis

Ulmer

(2017). Intersectionality of race, ethnicity, gender, and age on criminal punishment. Sociological Perspectives, 60(4), 810–833. https://doi.org/10.1177/0731121416679371

44.

Steffensmeier

Ulmer

Kramer

(1998). The interaction of race, gender, and age in criminal sentencing: The punishment cost of being young, black, and male. Criminology, 36(4), 763–798. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1745-9125.1998.tb01265.x

45.

Stevenson

Mayson

(2018). The scale of misdemeanor justice. Boston University Law Review, 98(3), 731–777.

46.

Stone

Overton

Mcdade

Smith

Monk-Turner

(2014). Rush-hour traffic: Self-presentation of defendants in speedy traffic court cases. Criminal Justice Studies, 27(4), 439–456. https://doi.org/10.1080/1478601X.2014.904145

47.

Tempe Municipal Court. (2019). https://www.tempe.gov/government/city-court

48.

Todak

Gaub

J. E.

White

M. D.

(2018). The importance of external stakeholders for police body-worn camera diffusion. Policing: An International Journal, 41(4), 448–464. https://doi.org/10.1108/PIJPSM-08-2017-0091

49.

U.S. Census Bureau. (2017). Demographic and housing estimates, 2017 ACS 5-year estimates. https://data.census.gov/cedsci/table?q=tempearizona&g=1600000US0473000&hidePreview=false&tid=ACSDP5Y2017.DP05&vintage=2018&layer=VT_2018_160_00_PY_D1&cid=DP05_0001E

50.

Warren

Tomaskovic-Devey

Smith

Zingraff

Mason

(2006). Driving while Black: Bias processes and racial disparity in police stops. Criminology, 44(3), 709–738.

51.

White

M. D.

Gaub

J. E.

Malm

Padilla

K. E.

(2019). Implicate or exonerate? The impact of police body-worn cameras on the adjudication of drug and alcohol cases. Policing: A Journal of Policy and Practice. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1093/police/paz043

52.

White

M. D.

Malm

(2020). Cops, cameras, and crisis: The potential and the perils of police body-worn cameras. New York University Press.

53.

White

M. D.

Todak

Gaub

J. E.

(2018). Examining body-worn camera integration and acceptance among police officers, citizens, and external stakeholders. Criminology & Public Policy, 17(3), 1–29. https://doi.org/10.1111/1745-9133.12376

54.

Withrow

B. L.

(2004). Race based policing: A descriptive analysis of the Wichita stop study. Police Practice and Research, 5(3), 223–240. https://doi.org/10.1080/156142604200227576