White,Black,and Latina Female Victims in U.S. News: A Multivariate and Intersectional Analysis of Story Differences

Abstract

Prior research suggests the media depict White female victims more sympathetically than their minority counterparts, yet no researcher has yet examined this proposition at the multivariate level. Moreover, prior research on media portrayals generally include White versus non-White or White versus Black comparisons, but no researcher has yet compared media accounts of White, Black, and Latina female victims. Based on critical race feminism, we expected news coverage of White, Black, and Latina victims to vary in key ways. We examined narratives at the bivariate and multivariate levels, and we contextualized findings with story excerpts. Stories about White female victims were more likely to contain sympathetic themes—such as themes of religiosity and reported media attention—and to result in overall sympathetic narratives compared to stories about minority victims, whereas overall narratives about Latina and Black female victims were often unsympathetic. Our findings align with the “ideal victim” stereotype and may help explain the differential treatment of White and minority female victims by the criminal justice system.

Keywords

critical race theory feminist theory stereotypes bias in the criminal justice system race and public opinion treatment by the police African/Black Americans race/ethnicity Latino/Hispanic Americans qualitative document analysis

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alicke

M. D.

(2000). Culpable control and the psychology of blame. Psychological Bulletin, 126(4), 556–574.

Allport

G. W.

(1979). The nature of prejudice. Addison-Wesley.

Altheide

D. L.

(1996). Qualitative media analysis. Sage.

Ammons

L. L.

(1995). Mules, Madonnas, babies, bathwater, racial imagery and stereotypes: The African-American woman and the Battered Woman Syndrome. Wisconsin Law Review, 5, 1003–1080.

Ardovini-Brooker

Caringella-MacDonald

(2002). Media attributions of blame and sympathy in ten rape cases. The Justice Professional, 15(1), 3–18.

Beale

S. S.

(2006). The news media’s influence on criminal justice policy: How market driven news promotes punitiveness. William and Mary Law Review, 48(2), 397–481.

Bjornstrom

E. E. S.

Kaufman

R. L.

Peterson

R. D.

Slater

M. D.

(2010). Race and ethnic representations of lawbreakers and victims in crime news: A national study of television coverage. Social Problems, 57(2), 269–293.

Brooks

D. E.

Hébert

L. P.

(2006). Gender, race, and media representation. In Dow

B. J.

Wood

J. T.

(Eds.), The Sage handbook of gender and communication (pp. 297–317). Sage.

Buckler

Travis

(2005). Assessing the newsworthiness of homicide events: An analysis of coverage in the Houston Chronicle. Journal of Criminal Justice & Popular Culture, 12(1), 1–25.

10.

Bump

(2016, August 24). The numbers behind Trump’s ‘you walk down the street, you get shot’ pitch to Black voters. The Washington Post. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-fix/wp/2016/08/24/the-numbers-behind-trumps-you-walk-down-the-street-you-get-shot-pitch-to-Black-voters/?utm_term=.4e9f44ea9181

11.

Bureau of Justice Statistics. (2009). Female victims of violence (NCJ 228356). https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/fvv.pdf

12.

BurrellesLuce. (2006). Top 100 daily newspapers in the U.S. by circulation: 2006. https://burrelles.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/12/2006_Top_100List.pdf

13.

Catalano

S. M.

(2006). Criminal Victimization, 2005. U.S. Department of Justice.

14.

Catalano

Smith

Snyder

Rand

(2009). Female victims of violence. U.S. Department of Justice.

15.

Cavender

Bond-Maupin

Jurik

N. C.

(1999). The construction of gender in reality crime TV. Gender & Society, 13(5), 643–663.

16.

Christie

(1986). The ideal victim. In Fattah

E. A.

(Ed.), From crime policy to victim policy (pp. 17–30). Palgrave Macmillan UK.

17.

Collins

P. H.

(2000). Black feminist thought: Knowledge, consciousness, & empowerment. Routledge.

18.

Collins

R. E.

(2016). ‘Beauty and bullets’: A content analysis of female offenders and victims in four Canadian newspapers. Journal of Sociology, 52(2), 296–310.

19.

Crenshaw

(1991). Mapping the margins: Intersectionality, identity politics, and violence against women of color. Stanford Law Review, 43(6), 1241–1299.

20.

Daragahi

(2006, March 31). ‘Good day’ in Iraq for freed U.S. journalist. Los Angeles Times, pp. A1, A22.

21.

Davary

(2016). #Black lives matter. Ethnic Studies Review, 37, 11–14.

22.

Davies

Francis

Greer

(2008). Victims, crime and society. Sage.

23.

De Vise

(2011, October 4). What if the rankers ranked newspapers? The Washington Post. https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/college-inc/post/what-if-the-rankers-ranked-newspapers/2011/10/04/gIQAYZl6KL_blog.html?utm_term=.7934658998ca

24.

DiBrito

S. R.

Lopez

C. M.

Jones

Mathur

(2019). Reducing implicit bias: Association of women surgeons #HeForShe task force best practice recommendations. Journal of American College of Surgeons, 228(3), 303–309.

25.

Dixon

T. L.

(2008). Crime news and racialized beliefs: Understanding the relationship between local news viewing and perceptions of African Americans and crime. Journal of Communication, 58(1), 106–125.

26.

Dixon

T. L.

(2017). How the internet and social media accelerate racial stereotyping and social division: The socially mediated stereotyping model. In Lind

R. A.

(Ed.), Race and gender in electronic media: Challenges and opportunities (pp. 161–178). Routledge.

27.

Dixon

T. L.

Azocar

C. L.

(2007). Priming crime and activating Blackness: Understanding the psychological impact of the overrepresentation of Blacks as lawbreakers on television news. Journal of Communication, 57(2), 229–253.

28.

Duggan

Jackman

(2006, May 14). Thousands mourn Fairfax detective, ‘our protector.’ The Washington Post, pp. A1, A12.

29.

Duwe

(2000). Body-count journalism: The presentation of mass murder in the news media. Homicide Studies, 4(4), 364–399.

30.

Edwards

(2017, July 14). How Beyoncé’s Virgin Mary imagery challenges racist, religious, and sexual stereotypes. The Washington Post. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/acts-of-faith/wp/2017/07/14/how-beyonces-virgin-mary-imagery-challenges-racist-religious-and-sexual-stereotypes/?utm_term=.f800e2591fd4

31.

Entman

R. M.

Gross

K. A.

(2008). Race to judgment: Stereotyping media and criminal defendants. Law & Contemporary Problems, 71(4), 93–134.

32.

Epstein

Blake

J. J.

Gonzalez

(2017). Girlhood interrupted: The erasure of Black girls’ childhood. Center on Poverty & Inequality. http://www.law.georgetown.edu/academics/centers-institutes/poverty-inequality/upload/girlhood-interrupted.pdf

33.

Faherty

V. E.

(2008). Compassionate statistics: Applied quantitative analysis for social services (with exercises and instructions in SPSS). Sage.

34.

Fiske

S. T.

(2018). Stereotype content: Warmth and competence endure. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 27(2), 67–73.

35.

ForsterLee

Horowitz

King

(2006). The effects of defendant race, victim race, & juror gender on evidence processing in a murder trial. Behavioral Sciences & the Law, 24(2), 179–198.

36.

Gans

(2005). Race as class. Contexts, 4(4), 17–21.

37.

Garcia-Navarro

(2015, August 27). Hispanic or Latino? A guide for the U.S. presidential campaign. NPR. https://www.npr.org/sections/parallels/2015/08/27/434584260/hispanic-or-latino-a-guide-for-the-u-s-presidential-campaign

38.

Gilchrist

(2010). “Newsworthy” victims? Exploring differences in Canadian local press coverage of missing/murdered Aboriginal and White women. Feminist Media Studies, 10(4), 373–390.

39.

Gladwell

(2005). Blink: The power of thinking without thinking. Little Brown.

40.

Glanz

(2006, May 9). 2 years later, slayings in Iraq and lost cash are mysteries. The New York Times, pp. A1, A12.

41.

Greer

(2007). News media, victims, and crime. In Davies

Francis

Greer

(Eds.), Victims, crime and society (pp. 21–49). Sage.

42.

Greer

Reiner

(2015). Mediated mayhem: Media, crime & criminal justice. In Maguire

Morgan

Reiner

(Eds.), Oxford handbook of criminology (pp. 245–278). Oxford University Press.

43.

Greer

Mensing

(2004). U.S. news web sites better, but small papers still lag. Newspaper Research Journal, 25(2), 98–112.

44.

Grinberg

D. B.

(2018, March 14). Why traditional media still matters in today’s digital age. Medium. https://medium.com/@DBGrinberg/why-traditional-media-still-matters-in-todays-digital-age-f81350674e2f

45.

Gruenewald

Chermak

S. M.

Pizarro

J. M.

(2013). Covering victims in the news: What makes minority homicides newsworthy? Justice Quarterly, 30(5), 755–783.

46.

Gruenewald

Pizarro

Chermak

S. M.

(2009). Race, gender, and the newsworthiness of homicide incidents. Journal of Criminal Justice, 37, 262–272.

47.

Guzman

I. M.

Valdivia

A. N.

(2004). Brain, brow, and booty: Latina iconicity in U.S. popular culture. The Communication Review, 7(2), 205–221.

48.

Hines-Datiri

Carter Andrews

D. J.

(2020). The effects of zero tolerance policies on Black girls: Using critical race feminism and figured worlds to examine school discipline. Urban Education, 55(10), 1419–1440. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0042085917690204

49.

Holland

S. L.

(2006). The dangers of playing dress-up: Popular representations of Jessica Lynch and the controversy surrounding women in combat. Quarterly Journal of Speech, 92(1), 27–50.

50.

Huppke

R. W.

(2006, May 21). Message of peace after death of nun. Chicago Tribune, pp. 1, 16.

51.

Jeanis

M. N.

Powers

R. A.

(2016). Newsworthiness of missing persons cases: An analysis of selection bias, disparities in coverage, & the narrative framework of news reports. Deviant Behavior, 38(6), 1–16.

52.

Jiwani

Young

M. L.

(2006). Missing and murdered women: Reproducing marginality in news discourse. Canadian Journal of Communication, 31(4), 895–917.

53.

Johnstone

J. W. C.

Hawkins

D. F.

Michener

(1994). Homicide reporting in Chicago dailies. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly, 71(4), 860–872.

54.

Jordan

(2008). Perfect victims, perfect policing? Improving rape complainants’ experiences of police investigations. Public Administration, 86(3), 699–719.

55.

Kelley

H. H.

(1973). The processes of causal attribution. American Psychology, 28(2), 107–128.

56.

Kiefer

(2006, July 1). Slaying by serial killer suspected. The Arizona Republic, pp. A1, B1, B2.

57.

Kim

(2017). Statistical notes for clinical researchers: Chi-squared test and Fisher’s exact test. Restorative Dentistry and Endodontics, 42(2), 152–155.

58.

King

P. H.

(2006, June 18). A cold case, a haunting mystery. Los Angeles Times, pp. A1, A20.

59.

Kulig

T. C.

Cullen

F. T.

(2017). Where is Latisha’s Law? Black invisibility in the social construction of victimhood. Justice Quarterly, 34(6), 978–1013.

60.

Kumar

(2004). War propaganda and the (AB)uses of women. Feminist Media Studies, 4(3), 297–313.

61.

Landrine

(1985). Race × class stereotypes of women. Sex Roles, 13(1–2), 65–75.

62.

Lauritsen

J. L.

Heimer

(2009). Gender and violent victimization, 1973-2005 (Report No. 229133). https://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles1/nij/grants/229133.pdf

63.

Leovy

(2006, December 6). She took a stand to testify. Los Angeles Times, pp. A1, A24.

64.

Lobasz

J. K.

(2008). The woman in peril and the ruined woman: Representations of female soldiers in the Iraq War. Journal of Women, Politics, and Policy, 29(3), 305–334.

65.

Lombardo

(2014, March 14). Typical stereotypes of Hispanics. http://nlcatp.org/typical-stereotypes-of-hispanics/

66.

Lupton

(1999). Dangerous places and the unpredictable stranger: Constructions of fear of crime. The Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology, 32(1), 1–15.

67.

Maddox

K. B.

Gray

S. A.

(2002). Cognitive representations of Black Americans: Reexploring the role of skin tone. Personality & Social Psychology Bulletin, 28(2), 250–259.

68.

Mata

A. G.

Jr Herrerías

. (2006). Immigrant bashing and nativist political movements. In Zatz

Mann

C. R.

(Eds.), Images of color, images of crime (pp. 151–167). Roxbury Publishing.

69.

McLemore

D. M.

(2020). Dangerous and disturbed: Media misportrayals of mental illness. In Lippert

L. R.

Hall

R. D.

Miller-Ott

A. E.

Davis

D. C.

(Eds.), Communicating mental health: History, contexts, and perspectives (pp. 309–329). Lexington Books.

70.

Menjívar

(2016). Immigrant criminalization in law and the media: Effects on Latino immigrant workers’ identities in Arizona. American Behavioral Science, 60(5–6), 597–616.

71.

Meyers

(1997). News coverage of violence against women: Engendering blame. Sage.

72.

Moody

Dorries

Blackwell

(2009). How national media framed coverage of missing Black and White women. Media Report to Women, 37(4), 12–18.

73.

Morgan

Shanahan

Signorielli

(2009). Growing up with television: Cultivation processes. In Bryant

Oliver

M. B.

(eds.), Media effects: Advances in theory and research (3rd ed., pp. 34–49). Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.

74.

Morgan

Shanahan

(2010). The state of cultivation. Journal of Broadcasting and Electronic Media, 54(2), 337–355.

75.

Nelson

T. E.

Oxley

Z. M

Clawson

R. A.

(1997). Toward a psychology of framing effects. Political Behavior, 19(3), 221–246.

76.

Nowotny

Graves

(2013). Substance use & intimate partner violence victimization among White, African American, & Latina Women. Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 28(17), 3301–3318.

77.

Office for Victims of Crime. (n.d.). Latinas and sexual violence. https://www.ovc.gov/pubs/existeayuda/tools/pdf/factsheet_eng.pdf

78.

Ortega

(2016). Speaking in resistant tongues: Latina feminism, embodied knowledge, and transformation. Hypatia, 31(2), 313–318.

79.

Parrott

C. T.

(2015). U.S. television’s “mean world” for White women: The portrayal of gender and race on fictional crime drama. Sex Roles, 73(1–2), 70–82.

80.

Patton

L. D.

Ward

(2016). Missing black undergraduate women and the politics of disposability: A critical race feminist perspective. The Journal of Negro Education, 85(3), 330–349.

81.

Paulsen

D. J.

(2003). Murder in Black and White: The newspaper coverage of homicide in Houston. Homicide Studies, 7(3), 289–317.

82.

Pew Research Center. (2014). Racial and ethnic composition: Religious landscape study. http://www.pewforum.org/religious-landscape-study/racial-and-ethnic-composition/

83.

Pew Research Center. (2017). How the U.S. Hispanic population is changing. http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2017/09/18/how-the-u-s-hispanic-population-is-changing/

84.

Pierre

R. E

(2006, November 3). Out of grief, a new search for hope in D.C. The Washington Post, pp. A1, A12.

85.

Pinzur

M. I.

Lebowtiz

(2006, May 27). Another young grad shot dead on street. The Miami Herald, pp. 1A, 24A.

86.

Potter

(2013). Intersectional criminology: Interrogating identity and power in criminology research and theory. Critical Criminology, 21(3), 305–318.

87.

Protess

D. L.

McCombs

M. E.

(1991). Agenda setting: Readings on media, public opinion, and policy making. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.

88.

Quillian

Pager

(2001). Black neighbors, higher crime? The role of racial stereotypes in evaluations of neighborhood crime. American Journal of Sociology, 107(3), 717–767.

89.

Quillian

Pager

(2010). Estimating risk: Stereotype amplification and the perceived risk of criminal victimization. Social Psychology Quarterly, 73(1), 79–104.

90.

Rice

(2006, December 5). Young man’s “obsession” leads to double tragedy. Houston Chronicle, pp. A1, A10.

91.

Rivera

(2014). The brown threat: Post-9/11 conflations of Latina/os and Middle Eastern Muslims in the US American imagination. Latino Studies, 12(1), 44–64. https://doi.org/10.1057/lst.2014.6

92.

Rome

(2004). Black demons: The media’s depiction of the African American male criminal stereotype. Penn State Press.

93.

Rosenstiel

Mitchell

Purcell

Rainie

(2011). How people learn about their community. Pew Research Center. http://www.pewinternet.org/2011/09/26/how-people-learn-about-their-local-community/

94.

Ruiz

Turner

(2006, May 14). Ertman-Pena murders left lasting mark on city. Houston Chronicle, pp. A1, A24.

95.

Rusbridger

(2018). Breaking news: The remaking of journalism and why it matters now. Farrar, Straus and Giroux.

96.

Sacco

V. F.

(1996). Media constructions of crime. Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 539, 141–154.

97.

Semple

Filkins

(2006, March 31). Reporter freed in Iraq, 3 months after abduction. The New York Times, pp. A1, A8.

98.

Slakoff

D. C.

(2020). The representation of women and girls of color in United States crime news. Sociology Compass, 14(1), 1–13. https://doi.org/10.1111/soc4.12741

99.

Slakoff

D. C.

Brennan

P. K.

(2019). The differential representation of Latina and Black female victims in front-page news stories: A qualitative document analysis. Feminist Criminology, 14(4), 488–516.

100.

Smith

M. S.

(2010). Gender, Whiteness, and “other Others.” In Razack

Smith

Thobani

(Eds.), States of race: Critical race feminism for the 21st century. Between the Lines.

101.

Solorzano

D. G.

(1997). Images and words that wound: Critical race theory, racial stereotyping, and understanding in teacher education. Teacher Education Quarterly, 24(3), 5–19.

102.

Sorenson

S. B.

Manz

J. G. P

Berk

R. A.

(1998). News media coverage and the epidemiology of homicide. American Journal of Public Health, 88(10), 1510–1514.

103.

Spohn

Beichner

Davis-Frenzel

(2001). Prosecutorial justifications for sexual assault case rejection: Guarding the “gateway to justice.” Social Problems, 48(2), 206–235.

104.

Stamps

(2019). Is it really representation? A qualitative analysis of Asian and Latino characterizations in broadcast television. American Communication Journal, 21(1), 1–12.

105.

Taylor

C. A.

Sorenson

S. B.

(2002). The nature of newspaper coverage of homicide. Injury Prevention, 8, 121–127.

106.

Thomas

A. J.

Witherspoon

K. M.

Speight

S. L.

(2004). Toward the development of the stereotypic roles for Black women scale. Journal of Black Psychology, 30(3), 426–442.

107.

Tomlinson

(2013). Colonizing intersectionality: Replicating racial hierarchy in feminist academic arguments. Social Identities, 19(2), 254–272.

108.

Tsai

(2006, August 17). Finally, a break in coldest of cases. Houston Chronicle, pp. A1, A6.

109.

Tsui

(2018, April 8). What does it mean to be of mixed race in America? A new book and exhibition aim to answer. Los Angeles Times . http://www.latimes.com/entertainment/arts/la-ca-cm-hapa-kip-fulbeck-20180406-story.html

110.

Tukachinsky

Mastro

Yarchi

(2017). The effect of prime time television ethnic/racial stereotypes on Latino and Black Americans: A longitudinal national level study. Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media, 61(3), 538–556.

111.

Turan

J. M.

Elafros

M. A.

Logie

C. H.

Banik

Turan

Crockett

K. B.

Pescosolido

Murray

S. M.

(2019). Challenges and opportunities in examining and addressing intersectional stigma and health. BMC Medicine, 17(7), 1–15.

112.

Wade

(2011). “Missing White woman syndrome” & fear of crime. Sociological Images. https://thesocietypages.org/socimages/2011/08/23/missing-White-woman-syndrome-and-fear-of-crime/

113.

Walsh

Scarborough

(2006, February 24). All five Mesa deaths called murders. The Arizona Republic, pp. A1, B1, B2.

114.

Wanzo

(2008). The era of lost (White) girls: On body and event. Differences: A Journal of Feminist Cultural Studies, 19(2), 99–126.

115.

Weitzer

Kubrin

C. E.

(2004). Breaking news: How local TV news and real-world conditions affect fear of crime. Justice Quarterly, 21(3), 497–520.

116.

Welch

(2007). Black criminal stereotypes and racial profiling. Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice, 23, 276–288.

117.

Whoriskey

Adcock

(2006, December 23). Prosecutors drop Duke rape counts. The New York Times, pp. A1, A10.

118.

Wilkinson

B. T.

Garand

J. C.

Dunaway

(2015). Skin tone and individuals’ perceptions of commonality and competition with other racial and ethnic groups. Race and Social Problems, 7(3), 181–197.

119.

Willis Esqueda

Harrison

L. A.

(2005). The influence of gender role stereotypes, the woman’s race, and level of provocation and resistance on domestic violence culpability attributions. Sex Roles, 53(11/12), 821–834.

120.

Willis

C. E.

Hallinan

M. N.

Melby

(1996). Effects of sex role stereotyping among European American students on domestic violence culpability attributions. Sex Roles, 34(7/8), 475–491.

121.

Yanez

(2006, September 2). Taking a crack at a Miami cold case. The Miami Herald, pp. 1A, 24A.

122.

Young

V. D.

(1986). Gender expectations and their impact on Black female offenders and victims. Justice Quarterly, 3(3), 305–327.