Justice scholars have failed to distinguish an accurate historical record of female lynchings in the United States. Most probably, one reason for this lapse in the lynching scholarship is that researchers lack the fact-based information required to document troubling narratives of women irrevocably harmed by mob violence. It is impractical for researchers to bring into sharper focus the fiendish torture women suffered from vigilantism without a reliable historical record of confirmed female lynchings. The present work provides an inventory of 179 confirmed cases of women and young girls murdered at the hands of mostly White terrorists from 1835 to 1965. It is equally important, however, to distinguish 57 cases of unconfirmed and factually inaccurate female lynchings that directly challenge the reliability of existing registries. The present work remedies inaccuracies in these inventories with more historically precise narratives of misidentified cases.
Adams County Free Press [Corning, Iowa]. (1894, July 19). A mob in a courthouse. A negro brute taken from before the judge and strung up, p. 1.
2.
Atlanta Constitution. (1899, March 24). Three lynched in Mississippi. Trio of Negroes quickly disposed of by a mob, p. 1.
3.
Atlanta Constitution. (1901, May 3). Edwards’ murder avenged. Three Negroes are shot to death near Selma, Ala, p. 4.
4.
Atlanta Constitution. (1909, February 9). Young Negro confesses to murder of preacher, danger of mob violence averted by promise of a very speedy trial, p. 5.
5.
Atlantic Daily Telegraph [Atlantic, Iowa]. (1896, October 29). Father arrested for murder, p. 4.
6.
Austin Daily Herald. (1901, March 20). A Negro lynched for usual crime, p. 2.
7.
BaileyA.TolnayS.BeckE.RobertsA.WongN. (2008). Personalizing lynch victims: A new database to support the study of mob violence. Historical Methods, 41, 47–60.
8.
BeckE.ClarkT. (2002). Strangers, community miscreants, or local: Who were the black victims of mob violence?Historical Methods, 25, 77–83.
9.
BergM. (2011). Popular justice: A history of lynching in America. Chicago, IL: Ivan R. Dee.
10.
Boston Sunday Globe. (1901, April 7). White man lynched. Mob takes May Hearn from jail at Osceola, Ark., and hangs him to a tree—He killed Clyde King, p. 4.
11.
BradyS. (2000). [Review of the book Women and the death penalty in the United States, 1900-1998, by Kathleen O’Shea]. National Women's Studies Association Journal, 12, 209–210.
12.
BrundageW. (1993). Lynching in the new south: Georgia and Virginia, 1880-1930. Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press.
13.
BuckelewR. (1999). Racial violence in Arkansas: Lynchings and mob rule, 1860-1930. (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). University of Arkansas. Fayetteville, AR.
14.
CarriganW. (2004). The making of a lynching culture: Violence and vigilantism in central Texas, 1836-1916. Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press.
15.
Cedar Rapids Evening Gazette [Cedar Rapids, Iowa]. (1893, March 20). A Tennessee desperado lynched, p. 1.
ColeJ. (2003). The Forest City lynching of 1900: Populism, racism, and white supremacy in Rutherford County, North Carolina. Jefferson, NC: McFarland.
18.
CookL. (2011). Converging to a national lynching database: Recent developments(Unpublished manuscript). East Lansing, Michigan State University, MI.
19.
Coshocton Daily Age [Coshocton, Ohio]. (1901, October 9). Died of fright, p. 3.
20.
Daily News [Marshall, Michigan]. (1903, June 27). Another Negro lynching, p. 1.
21.
Daily Nevada State Journal [Reno, Nevada]. (1896, December 10), p. 2.
22.
Daily Review [Decatur, Illinois]. (1913, December 15). Feudists burn houses, whip woman. Masked men terrorize Missouri village, p. 1.
23.
DearminK. (2011). Strange Fruit: Tenant Farming as a Contributing Factor to Lynchings in Appalachia. Manuscript presented in May 2011 at the Society of Appalachian Historian Conference.
24.
De LeónA. (1983). They called them greasers, Anglo attitudes toward Mexicans in Texas, 1821-1900. Austin, TX: University of Texas Press.
25.
DeLongoriaM. (2006). Strange fruit: The lynching of black women, the cases of Rosa Jefferson and Marie Scott (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). University of Missouri. Columbia, MO.
26.
Digital Library on American Slavery. Petition Analysis Record [PAR] 11086402. University of North Carolina, Greensboro, NC.
27.
EarlJ.MartinA.McCarthyJ.SouleS. (2004). The use of newspaper data in the study of collective action. Annual Review of Sociology, 30, 65–80.
28.
Eau Claire Sunday Leader [Eau Claire, Wisconsin]. (1903, June 28). Louisiana Negro lynched for assaulting a white man. Riddled with bullets, p. 5.
29.
Eau Claire Leader [Eau Claire, Wisconsin]. (1908, October 7). Kentucky family is slain by nightriders, p. 6.
30.
EckbergD. (2006). Reported victims of lynching, by race: 1882-1964. Table Ec251-253. In CarterS.GartnerS.HainesM.OlmsteadA.SutchR.WrightG. (Eds.), Historical statistics of the united states, earliest times to the present: Millennial edition. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
31.
EspyM.SmyklaJ. (2004). Executions in the United States, 1608-2002: The Espy File[Computer file]. 4th ICPS ed. Compiled by M. Watt Espy and John Ortiz Smykla, University of Alabama. Ann Arbor, MI: Inter-University Consortium for Political and Social Research[Producer and distributor].
Evening Telegram [Elyria, Ohio]. (1909, July 31). Two Negroes shot to death, p. 5.
34.
FeimsterC. (2009). Southern horrors: Women and the politics of rape and lynching. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
35.
FinneganT. (1997). Lynching and political power in Mississippi and South Carolina. In BrundageW. (Ed.), Under sentence of death, lynchings in the south (pp. 189–218). Chapel Hill, NC: The University of North Carolina Press.
36.
Fort Wayne Gazette [Fort Wayne, Indiana] (1895, March 20). Mrs. Holton’s lynchers, p. 1.
37.
Fort Wayne Sentinel [Fort Wayne, Indiana]. (1892, December 21). The Indians way. They hang a man to a tree because he sues for wages due, p. 1.
38.
Fort Wayne Sentinel [Fort Wayne, Indiana]. (1896, November 18). Done by a mob, p. 8.
39.
Fort Wayne Sentinel [Fort Wayne, Indiana]. (1908, October 5). Nightriders wipe out entire family in Kentucky, p. 8.
40.
FranzosiR. (1987). The press as source of socio-historical data: Issues in the methodology of data collection from newspapers. Historical Methods, 20, 5–16.
41.
FrazierH. (2001). Death Sentences in Missouri, 1803-2005. Jefferson, NC: McFarland.
42.
FrazierH. (2009). Lynchings in Missouri, 1803-1981. Jefferson, NC: McFarland.
43.
Freeborn County Standard [Albert Lea, Minnesota]. (1893, July 26). West and south, p. 4.
44.
Galveston Daily News [Galveston, Texas]. (1895, August 31). A backwoods lynching, p. 2.
45.
Gettysburg Times [Gettysburg, Pennsylvania]. (1909, July 3). Two negroes shot to death, p. 1.
46.
Gonzales-DayK. (2006). Lynching in the west: 1850-1935. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
47.
GrimstedD. (1998). American mobbing, 1828-1861, toward the civil war. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
48.
GuinnJ. (1903). History of the state of California. Chicago, IL: Chapman Publishing.
49.
Hamilton Daily Democrat [Hamilton, Ohio]. (1891, August 8). Quadruple lynching, p. 1.
50.
Hamilton Daily Democrat [Hamilton, Ohio]. (1894, July 17). Negro lynched, p. 1.
51.
Hutchinson News [Hutchinson, Kansas]. (1913, December 16). Feudists to fight, p. 1.
52.
Indiana Progress [Indiana, Pennsylvania]. (1909, February 17). Minister’s murderer lynched, p. 7.
53.
Jefferson Souvenir [Jefferson, Iowa] (1895, March 2). Woman lynched in Nebraska, p. 4.
LanierC. (1999). Adding to the story of what we know about capital punishment: A review of women and the death penalty and deathquest. Journal of Criminal Justice and Popular Culture, 7, 30–37.
56.
LaskaL. (2007). Fact-based death penalty research. Tennessee Journal of Law and Policy, 4, 103–112.
57.
LaskaL. (2011). Legal executions in Tennessee: A comprehensive registry, 1782-2009. Jefferson, NC: McFarland.
58.
LeMars Semi-Weekly Sentinel [LeMars, Iowa]. (1894, February 12). Train wreckers arrested, p. 1.
59.
LeonardS. (2002). Lynching in Colorado, 1859-1919. Boulder: University Press of Colorado.
60.
LindersA.Gundy-YoderA. (2008). Gall, gallantry, and the gallows: Capital punishment and the social construction of gender, 1840-1920. Gender and Society, 22, 324–348.
61.
Logansport Daily Reporter [Logansport, Indiana]. (1896, November 18). Lynched. Swift justice overtakes a brutal Negro in Mississippi, p. 1.
62.
Logansport Journal [Logansport, Indiana]. (1895, July 3). Four slain, an ex-convict goes on a manhunt in Kentucky, p. 1.
63.
Logansport Pharos [Logansport, Indiana]. (1901, October 9). Mob is woman’s murderer, p. 6.
64.
Logansport Pharos [Logansport, Indiana]. (1909, February 8). Writing sermon when shot. Clergyman killed while seated under tree—probably a mistake, p. 1.
65.
Logansport Pharos [Logansport, Indiana]. (1909, July 31). Two negroes shot to death, p. 2.
66.
Manitowoc Pilot [Manitowoc, Wisconsin]. (1860, November 16). A young lady murdered by a slave woman—The murderer caught and hung, p. 2.
67.
Marion Daily Star [Marion, Ohio]. (1901, October 8). Died of fright, p. 4.
68.
McLureH. (2011). Book review of Kerry Segrave’s Lynchingsof women in the United States: The recorded cases, 1851-1946. Humanities and Social Sciences, H-Law, H-Net Reviews.
69.
Middletown Daily Herald [Middletown, New York]. (1924, July 20). Negro lynched in Mississippi, p. 3.
70.
MooreJ. (2006). Carnival of blood: Dueling, lynching and murder in South Carolina, 1880-1920. Columbia, SC: University of South Carolina Press.
71.
Morning Review [Decatur, Illinois]. (1891, April 7). A Negro girl’s unnatural crime, p. 1.
72.
Muskogee Times Democrat [Muskogee, Oklahoma]. (1922, February 13). Net nine Negroes in hunt for fiend, p. 3.
73.
MyrdalG. (1944). An American dilemma: The Negro problem and modern democracy. New York, NY: Harper and Row.
74.
NAACP (1919). Thirty years of lynching in the United States, 1889 -1918. New York: NAACP.
75.
Nevada State Journal [Reno, Nevada]. (1914, June 19). Mob shoots woman to enforce eviction, p. 2.
76.
Newark Daily Advocate [Newark, Ohio]. (1895, August 30). Hung by a mob today, p. 1.
77.
Newark Daily Advocate [Newark, Ohio]. (1898, November 12). South Carolina lynchers, p. 1.
78.
NewkirkV. (2009). Lynching in North Carolina: A history, 1865-1941. Jefferson: NC: McFarland.
79.
New York Times. (1898, November 9). Race feud at Phoenix, S.C., p. 1.
80.
New York Times. (1909, February 10). Negro murderer lynched, p. 18.
81.
North Adams Transcript [North Adams, Massachusetts]. (1899, March 24). Taken from constable, p. 4.
82.
Oakland Tribune [Oakland, California]. (1914, June 18). Mob tries to drive out woman; wounds two, p. 3.
83.
Oelwein Daily Register [Oelwein, Iowa] (1913, August 29). Mob lynched wrong Negro. Real murderer of Georgia planter makes full confession of his crime, p. 4.
84.
Ogden Standard [Ogden, Utah]. (1913, December 16). Feudists get ready to fight. Collins family of Old Horton buys arms and barricade homes, p. 6.
85.
Orleans Democrat [New Orleans, Louisiana]. (1892, December 13). Killed her baby and cooked it, p. 2.
86.
O’SheaK. (1999). Women and the death penalty in the United States, 1990-1998. Westport, CT: Praeger Press.
87.
Oxford Mirror [Oxford Junction, Iowa]. (1893, July 20). Epitome of the week. Interesting news compilation from the west and south, p. 2.
88.
PfeiferM. (2004). Rough justice: Lynching and American society, 1874-1947. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
89.
Piqua Daily Call [Piqua, Ohio]. (1894, February 10). Judge lynch at work in Texas, p. 1.
Reno Evening Gazette [Reno, Nevada]. (1914, June 18). Ozark mob makes second attempt to oust woman, p. 1.
92.
Reno Evening Gazette [Reno, Nevada]. (1896, October 27). Horrible murder, p. 1.
93.
Reno Evening Gazette [Reno, Nevada]. (1915, August 19). Judge Lynch busy in Alabama, too, p. 1.
94.
Renwick Times [Renwick, Iowa]. (1898, November 17). Ten slain at the polls, p. 7.
95.
RossJ. (1983). At the bar of Judge Lynch: Lynching and lynch mobs in America(Unpublished doctoral dissertation). Texas Tech University. Dallas, TX.
96.
Salt Lake Daily Tribune [Salt Lake City, Utah]. (1891, September 29). Murder quickly avenged, p. 1.
97.
Salt Lake Daily Tribune [Salt Lake City, Utah]. (1903, June 27). Louisiana lynching. Lamb Whitley, negro on Smith plantation, Concordia Parish, assault white man and is shot, p. 1.
98.
Salt Lake Tribune [Salt Lake City, Utah]. (1896, August 6). Lynched for attempted assassination, p. 1.
99.
San Antonio Daily Light [San Antonio, Texas]. (1895, July 9). No trial needed, p. 1.
100.
Sandusky Daily Register [Sandusky, Ohio]. (1892, October 8). Two women and one man hanged in South Carolina, p. 1.
101.
Sandusky Daily Star [Sandusky, Ohio]. (1901, October 9). Died of fright, p. 2.
102.
SegraveK. (2010). Lynchings of women in the United States, the recorded cases, 1851-1946. Jefferson, NC: McFarland & Company.
103.
Semi-Weekly Landmark [Statesville, North Carolina]. (1900, August 31). A killing and lynching in Rutherford, p. 2.
104.
SteelmanJ. (1928). A study of mob action in the south(Unpublished doctoral dissertation). University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, NC.
105.
Stevens Point Daily Journal [Stevens Point, Wisconsin]. (1896, December 30). Double murder, p. 6.
106.
Stevens Point Daily Journal [Stevens Point, Wisconsin]. (1895, July 13). Four are slain. A bloody quadruple tragedy in Trigg, County, Ky, p. 6.
107.
StreibV.SametzL. (1989). Executing female juveniles. Connecticut Law Review, 22, 3–16.
108.
Sunday Herald [Syracuse, New York]. (1892, July 30). A negro woman hanged, p. 1.
109.
Syracuse Daily Standard [Syracuse, New York]. (1896, December 6). A murder confessed, p. 1.
110.
The Belleville Telescope [Belleville, Kansas]. (1891, August 14). Four lynched at once, p. 2.
111.
The New Era [Humeston, Iowa]. (1891, October 7), Current events, p. 2.
112.
The News [Frederick, Maryland]. (1899, March 24). Three more negroes lynched, p. 1.
113.
The Pointer [Riverdale, Illinois]. (1909, February 12). General news, p. 6.
114.
Titusville Herald [Titusville, Pennsylvania]. (1892, December 13). Too horrible to believe, p. 1.
115.
Titusville Herald [Titusville, Pennsylvania]. (1922, February 14). Nine Negroes held for murder in Texas, p. 1.
116.
Titusville Herald [Titusville, Pennsylvania]. (1895, July 2). A Kentucky tragedy, p. 1.
117.
ThompsonE. (2007). Lynchings in Mississippi: A history, 1865-1965. Jefferson, NC: McFarland.
118.
Tolnays.BeckE. (1995). A festival of violence: An analysis of southern lynchings, 1882-1930. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
119.
TrulsonC.MarquartJ. (2009). First available cell: Desegregation of the Texas prison system. Austin: University of Texas Press.
120.
Van West Daily Bulletin [Van West County, Ohio]. (1909, February 10). Lynching was orderly; Mississippi mob makes quick work of Rob Raskin, p. 1.
121.
Victoria Advocate [Victoria, Texas]. (1922, February 13). Small child only witness to a murder, p. 1.
122.
WilliamsonJ. (1997). Wounds not scars: Lynching, the national conscience, and the American historian. Journal of American History, 83, 1221–1253.
123.
WaldrepC. (1999). Word and deed: The language of lynching, 1820-1953. In BellesilesM. (Ed.), Lethal imagination: Violence and brutality in American history (pp. 229–260). New York: New York University Press.
124.
WaldrepC. (2000). War of words: The controversy over the definition of lynching 1899-1940. Journal of Southern History, 66, 75–100.
125.
WaldrepC. (2002). The many faces of Judge Lynch: Extralegal violence and punishment in America. New York: NY: Palgrave Macmillan.
126.
WaldrepC. (2006). Lynching in America: A history in documents. New York: New York University Press.
