Quasi-civilian defence minister and civilian authority: The case study of Indonesia's Ministry of Defence during Joko Widodo’s presidency

Abstract

The President of the Republic of Indonesia, Joko Widodo, appointed two former military generals, Ryamizard Ryacudu (2014–2019) and Prabowo Subianto (2019–present), for the first- and second-term defence minister positions consecutively. The appointment of military officers – either retired or active – as defence ministers has been perceived as a recipe for potential democratic setbacks. Current studies on the quasi-civilian defence minister mainly focused on explaining the logic behind such appointments. On the other hand, our study attempts to test the argument about whether the decision to select former military figures to lead the Ministry of Defence undermines civilian control. This article examines: (1) the institutional arrangement of the defence establishment; (2) the composition of the Indonesian Ministry of Defence's leadership structure; and (3) the leadership activities and key initiatives. The findings are that military officers have indeed dominated the ministry's organisational structure. Nevertheless, such domination did not automatically translate into the deterioration of civilian supremacy as the institutional arrangement limits those quasi-civilian defence ministers’ manoeuvres.

Keywords

civil–military relations civilian control democratisation Indonesia Ministry of Defence

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aguero

(1995) Soldiers, Civilians and Democracy: Post-Franco Spain in Comparative Perspective. Baltimore, MD: John Hopkins University Press.

Alagappa

(2001) Coercion and Governance: The Declining Political Role of The Military in Asia. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.

Aljazeera (2022) Indonesia to buy Rafale fighter jets, as US approves F-15 plan. 10 February. Available at: https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2022/2/10/us-approves-major-14-billion-arms-sale-to-indonesia (accessed 14 February 2022).

Anggoro

(2007) The Department of Defence of the Republic of Indonesia: Civil supremacy without effective control. In: Sukadis

(ed) Alamanac on Indonesian Security Sector Reform. Jakarta: LESPERSSI and DCAF, pp. 16–30.

Anggoro

(2009) Otonomi Relatif, Interdependensi, dan Transformasi Departemen Pertahanan. In: Sukadis

(ed) Almanak Reformasi Sektor Keamanan Indonesia. Jakarta: LESPERSSI, pp. 25–36.

Bachelard

(2014) Indonesia: Jokowi’s cabinet of compromises. The Sydney Morning Herald, 27 October. Available at: smh.com.au/world/indonesia-jokowis-cabinet-of-compromises-20141027-11ce1d.html (accessed 2 June 2021).

BBC (2015) Menteri pertahanan buka program Bela Negara. Available at: https://www.bbc.com/indonesia/berita_indonesia/2015/10/151022_indonesia_bela_negara (accessed 10 January 2022).

Betz

(2002) No place for a civilian? Russian defense management from Yeltsin to Putin. Armed Forces & Society 28(3): 481–504.

Brooks

(2019) Integrating the civil–military relations subfield. Annual Review of Political Science 22: 379–398.

10.

Bruneau

Croissant

(2019) Civil–Military Relations: Control and Effectiveness Across Regimes. Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner Publishers.

11.

Bruneau

Goetze Jr

(2006) Ministries of defense and democratic control. In: Bruneau

Tollefson

(eds) Who Guards the Guardians and How: Democratic Civil–Military Relations. Austin, TX: University of Texas Press, pp. 71–98.

12.

CNN Indonesia (2017) Kemhan: Bela Negara hak seluruh WNI, termasuk anggota FPI. 10 January. Available at: https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20170110081919-20-185165/kemhan-bela-negara-hak-seluruh-wni-termasuk-anggota-fpi (accessed 28 March 2022).

13.

Cottey

Forster

(2004) Reshaping Defence Diplomacy: New Roles for Military Cooperation and Assistance. London: Oxford University Press.

14.

Croissant

Kuehn

Chambers

, et al. (2010) Beyond the fallacy of coup-ism: Conceptualizing civilian control of the military in emerging democracies. Democratization 17(5): 950–975.

15.

Detik (2019) Kunjungi mabes TNI, Prabowo janji perkuat kemampuan SDM dan alutsista. 30 October. Available at: https://news.detik.com/berita/d-4765650/kunjungi-mabes-tni-prabowo-janji-perkuat-kemampuan-sdm-dan-alutsista (accessed 16 March 2020).

16.

Detik (2020) Jadi anak buah Prabowo, 2 eks anggota tim mawar naik pangkat jadi mayjen. 21 October. Available at: https://news.detik.com/berita/d-5222448/jadi-anak-buah-prabowo-2-eks-anggota-tim-mawar-naik-pangkat-jadi-mayjen (accessed 14 February 2022).

17.

Diamond

Plattner

(1996) Civil–military Relations and Democracy. Baltimore, MD: John Hopkins University Press.

18.

Diprose

McRae

Hadiz

(2019) Two decades of Reformasi in Indonesia: Its illiberal turn. Journal of Contemporary Asia 49(5): 691–712.

19.

Feaver

(1999) Civil–military relations. Annual Review of Political Science 2: 211–241.

20.

Feaver

(2003) Armed Servants: Agency, Oversight and Civil–Military Relations. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

21.

Febriansyah (2021) Sejarah hari Bela Negara yang diperingati setiap 19 Desember. Tirto, 17 December. Available at: https://tirto.id/sejarah-hari-bela-negara-yang-diperingati-setiap-19-desember-enJ5 (accessed 17 April 2022).

22.

Finer

(1962) The Man on the Horseback: The Role of Military in Politics. London: Pall Mall.

23.

Friend

(2020a) A military litmus test? Evaluating the argument that civilian defense leaders need military experience. Just Security, 19 August. Available at: https://www.justsecurity.org/72084/a-military-litmus-test-evaluating-the-argument-that-civilian-defense-leaders-need-military-experience/ (accessed 28 March 2022).

24.

Friend

(2020b) What makes a civilian? War Room, 9 April. Available at: https://warroom.armywarcollege.edu/articles/what-makes-a-civilian/ (accessed 31 August 2020).

25.

Gunawan

(2017a) Kontrol Sipil atas Militer dan Kebijakan Pertahanan di Indonesia pasca Orde Baru. Jurnal Politik 2(2): 197–230.

26.

Gunawan

(2017b) Civilian control and defence policy in Indonesia’s nascent democracy. In: Croissant

Kuehn

(eds) Reforming Civil Military Relations in New Democracy: Democratic Control and Military Effectiveness in Comparative Perspectives. Cham: Springer, pp. 129–150.

27.

Hadiz

Robison

(2014) President Jokowi vs oligarchy. New Mandala, 10 July. Available at: https://www.newmandala.org/president-jokowi-vs-oligarchy/ (accessed 7 October 2021).

28.

Hamid

(2014) Jokowi’s populism in the 2012: Jakarta gubernatorial election. Journal of Current Southeast Asian Affairs 33(1): 85–109.

29.

Haripin

(2020) Civil–Military Relations in Indonesia: The Politics of Military Operations Other than War. Abingdon, Oxon: Routledge.

30.

Haripin

(2021) Civil–military relations in post-authoritarian Indonesia: A turbulent Odyssey. In: Al-Arian

(ed.) The Quest for Democracy: Examining Civil–Military Relations in Muslim Societies. Istanbul: Center for Islam and Global Affairs, Istanbul Sabahattin Zaim University (CIGA IZU), pp. 291–303.

31.

Haripin

Anindya

Priamarizki

(2020) The politics of counter-terrorism in post-authoritarian states: Indonesia’s experience, 1998–2018. Defense & Security Analysis 36(3): 275–299.

32.

Haripin

Priamarizki

Marzuki

(2021) The Army and Ideology in Indonesia: From Dwifungsi to Bela Negara. Abingdon, Oxon: Routledge.

33.

Honna

(2003) Military Politics and Democratization in Indonesia. Abingdon, Oxon: RoutledgeCurzon.

34.

Huang

(2019) Jokowi-Prabowo political reconciliation as Javanese strategy. New Mandala, 4 September. Available at: https://www.newmandala.org/jokowi-prabowo/ (accessed 7 October 2021).

35.

Huntington

(1957) The Soldier and the State: The Theory of Civil–Military Relations. London: The Belknap Press.

36.

Huntington

(1995) Armed forces and democracy: Reforming civil–military relations. Journal of Democracy 6(4): 9–17.

37.

Janowitz

(1971) The Professional Soldier: A Social and Political Portrait. New York: The Free Press.

38.

Kementerian Pertahanan (2020) Lepas sambut kabalitbang kemhan. Kemhan, 2 October. Available at: https://www.kemhan.go.id/balitbang/2020/10/02/lepas-sambut-kabalitbang-kemhan.html (accessed 10 December 2020).

39.

Kim

K-J

(2014) The soldier and the state in South Korea: Crafting democratic civilian control of the military. Journal of International and Area Studies 21(2): 119–131.

40.

Kompas (2019) Berkunjung ke mabes TNI, Prabowo janji perkuat alutsista. 30 October. Available at: https://nasional.kompas.com/read/2019/10/30/15242311/berkunjung-ke-mabes-tni-prabowo-janji-perkuat-alutsista (accessed 11 January 2020).

41.

Kuehn

Croissant

Kamerling

, et al. (2017) Conditions of civilian control in new democracies: An empirical analysis of 28 ‘third wave’ democracies. European Political Science Review 9(3): 425–447.

42.

Laksmana

(2019a) Civil–military relations under Jokowi: Between military corporate interest and presidential handholding. Asia Policy 14(4): 63–71.

43.

Laksmana

(2019b) Reshuffling the deck? Military corporatism, promotional logjams and post-authoritarian civil–military relations in Indonesia. Journal of Contemporary Asia 49(5): 806–836.

44.

Laksmana

Gindarsah

Maharani

(2020) 75 Tahun TNI: Evolusi Ekonomi Pertahanan, Operasi, dan Organisasi Militer Indonesia. Jakarta: CSIS Indonesia.

45.

Lindsey

(2014) Indonesian president makes shaky start with cabinet of compromises. The Conversation, 29 October. Available at: https://theconversation.com/indonesian-president-makes-shaky-start-with-cabinet-of-compromises-33525 (accessed 20 August 2021).

46.

Mietzner

(2006) The Politics of Military Reform in Post-Suharto Indonesia: Elite Conflict, Nationalism and Institutional Resistance. Washington, DC: East West Center.

47.

Mietzner

(2009) Military Politics, Islam, and the State in Indonesia: From Turbulent Transition to Democratic Consolidation. Singapore: ISEAS.

48.

Mukherjee

(2020) The Absent Dialogue: Politicians, Bureaucrats, and the Military in India. New York: Oxford University Press.

49.

Neto

Accorsi

(2022) Presidents and generals: Systems of government and the selection of defense ministers. Armed Forces & Society 48(1): 136–163.

50.

Priamarizki

(2019) Jokowi’s new cabinet: Guiding two visions of Indonesia to 2024. RSIS, 24 October. Available at: https://www.rsis.edu.sg/rsis-publication/rsis/after-jokowis-first-term-jokowis-new-cabinet-guiding-two-visions-of-indonesia-to-2024/#.YF78C68zYdU (accessed 9 May 2022).

51.

Pion-Berlin

(1997) Through Corridors of Power: Institutions and Civil–Military Relations in Argentina. University Park, PA: Penn State University Press.

52.

Pion-Berlin

(2009) Defense organization and civil–military relations in Latin America. Armed Forces & Society 35(3): 562–586.

53.

Pion-Berlin

(2020) Delegation or dereliction? When governments assign too many defense posts to military officials. Democracy and Security 16(1): 81–96.

54.

Pion-Berlin

Acacio

Ivey

(2019) Democratically consolidated, externally threatened, and NATO aligned: Finding unexpected deficiencies in civilian control. Democratization 26(6): 1070–1087.

55.

Pion-Berlin

Martinez

(2017) Soldiers, Politicians, and Civilians: Reforming Civil–Military Relations in Democratic Latin America. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

56.

Rinakit

(2005) The Indonesian Military after the New Order. Singapore: ISEAS.

57.

Sebastian

Gindarsah

(2013) Assessing military reform in Indonesia. Defense & Security Analysis 29(4): 293–307.

58.

Slater

Simmons

(2013) Coping by colluding: Political uncertainty and promiscuous powersharing in Indonesia and Bolivia. Comparative Political Studies 46(11): 1366–1393.

59.

Stepan

(1988) Rethinking Military Politics: Brazil and the Southern Cone. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

60.

Sukadis

(2016) Reformasi di kementerian pertahanan RI. Jurnal Keamanan Nasional 2(2): 189–204.

61.

Suoneto

Evander

(2021) Assessing Prabowo Subianto’s defense diplomacy. The Diplomat, 18 June. Available at: https://thediplomat.com/2021/06/assessing-prabowo-subiantos-defense-diplomacy/ (accessed 22 November 2021).

62.

Tempo (2018) Menteri pertahanan melantik enam pejabat eselon I. 10 April. Available at: https://nasional.tempo.co/read/1078104/menteri-pertahanan-melantik-enam-pejabat-eselon-i (accessed 19 April 2020).

63.

Trinkunas

(2005) Crafting Civilian Control of the Military in Venezuela: A Comparative Perspective. Chapel Hill, NC: The University of North Carolina Press.

64.

Valenzuela

(1992) Democratic consolidation in post-transitional settings: Notion, process, and facilitating conditions. In: Mainwaring

O’Donnell

(eds) Issues in Democratic Consolidation: The New South American Democracies in Comparative Perspective. Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press, pp. 57–105.

65.

Welch

(1976) Civilian Control of The Military. New York: State University of New York Press.