Medical doctors enjoy a high degree of professional autonomy because they own and apply professional knowledge in helping patients. Therefore, laymen are unable to evaluate doctors’ clinical practices. For this reason, how to exert effective social control over doctors’ work has been a significant question in the sociology of professions. Based on fieldwork in Beijing, government statistics, and others’ research findings, this paper analyzes the working conditions and clinical practices of Chinese urban doctors. I find that medical professionals are still dependent upon public hospitals that continue dominating the healthcare delivery system, and thus they lack corporate autonomy and are incapable of negotiating working arrangements, payment for their services and their incomes with the state. This condition generates a distortion in doctors’ labor value. However, also because of the domination of the healthcare delivery system, public hospitals and their doctors have gained ‘dual dominance’ over both patients and pharmaceutical enterprises, by which doctors transform their rights of prescription into economic benefits. This informal income, including hongbao (red envelopes containing money) and kickbacks, compensates for doctors’ relatively low formal incomes resulting from the state’s control. However, doctors abuse clinical autonomy constantly and pervasively, by which they transform their monopolies of medical expertise into economic benefits. This also means that the regulation and supervision of health administration is unsuccessful, as is the profession’s self-regulation. Hence, this paper suggests that if the medical profession can effectively participate in health policy-making, medical professionals be given the right of free practice, and non-public medical institutions given the same status and policy treatments as public hospitals, these problems in the current healthcare system will be relieved or solved.
BaoSY (2008) Why are the Expenses for Drugs so High: A Sociological Analysis on the Drugs Circulation of Urban China, Beijing: Social Sciences Academic Press.
2.
BloomGHanLYLiX (2001) How health workers earn a living in China. Human Resources for Health Development Journal5(1–3): 25–38.
3.
BlumenthalDHsiaoW (2015) Lessons from the East – China’s rapidly evolving health care system. New England Journal of Medicine372(14): 1281–1285.
4.
Chan CS-C and Yao Z (2012) A market of distrust and obligation: The micropolitics of unofficial payments for hospital care in China. 2012 Annual Meeting of American Sociological Association, Denver, CO.
5.
CockerhamWC (2000) Medical Sociology, 8th ed. New Jersey: Prentice Hall.
6.
DiaoXHTanXY (2010) The construction succession and system integration of China’s medical security system under the New Medical Organizational Reform background. Finance and Economics3: 77–84. (in Chinese).
7.
DingNNGeYF (2008) Constructing Harmonious Society: Concerning Social Policies of the Past Thirty Years, Beijing: China Development Press.
8.
EgglestonK (2010) ‘Kan bing ban, kan bing gui’: Challenges for China’s healthcare system 30 years into reform. In: OiJCRozelleSZhouXG (eds) Growing Pains: Tensions and Opportunities in China’s Transformation, Stanford, CA: Walter H. Shorenstein Asia Pacific Research Center, pp. 229–272.
9.
ElstonMA (1991) The politics of professional power: Medicine in a changing health service. In: GabeJCalnanMBuryM (eds) The Sociology of the Health Service, London: Routledge, pp. 58–88.
10.
EnsorT (2004) Informal payments for health care in transition economies. Social Science and Medicine58(2): 237–246.
11.
EnsorTSavelyevaL (1998) Informal payments for health care in the former Soviet Union: Some evidence from Kazakhstan. Health Policy and Planning13(1): 41–49.
12.
FengSZ (2011) Formation and variation of China’s state movement: Based on the holistic interpretation of regime. Open Times1: 25–47. (in Chinese).
13.
FieldMG (1988) The position of the Soviet physician: The bureaucratic professional. The Milbank Quarterly66(Supplement 2): 182–201.
14.
FieldMG (1991) The hybrid profession: Soviet medicine. In: AnthonyJ (eds) Professions and the State: Expertise and Autonomy in the Soviet Union and Eastern Europe, Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press, pp. 43–62.
15.
FieldMG (1993) The physician in the commonwealth of independent states: The difficult passage from bureaucrat to professional. In: HaffertyFWMcKinlayJB (eds) The Changing Medical Profession: An International Perspective, New York: Oxford University Press, pp. 162–171.
16.
FreddiG (1989) Problems of organizational rationality in health controls and policy options. In: FreddiGBjorkmanJW (eds) Controlling Medical Professionals: The Comparative Politics of Health Governance, Newbury Park, CA: Sage Publications, pp. 1–27.
17.
FreidsonE (1960) Client control and medical practice. American Journal of Sociology65(4): 374–382.
18.
FreidsonE (1970) Profession of Medicine: A Study of the Sociology of Applied Knowledge, New York: Dodd Mead.
19.
FreidsonE (1980) Doctoring Together: A Study of Professional Social Control, University of Chicago Press.
20.
GeRWBianYSunQet al.(2002) Rationalizing the health care price system: Problems, cause, and adjustment (the second part). Chinese Health Economics6: 44–46. (in Chinese).
21.
GoodeWJ (1957) Community within a community: The professions. American Sociological Review22(2): 194–200.
22.
GuX (2011) Administrative marketization and the reform of China’s public hospitals. Journal of Public Administration3: 15–31. (in Chinese).
23.
HanJH (2011) The 21st century and the coming of medicalized society – A book review on Peter Conrad's The Medicalization of Society. Sociological Studies26(3): 229–242. (in Chinese).
24.
HeitlingerA (1991) Hierarchy of status and prestige. In: AnthonyJ (eds) Professions and the State: Expertise and Autonomy in the Soviet Union and Eastern Europe, Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press, pp. 207–232.
25.
HeitlingerA (1993) The medical profession in Czechoslovakia: Legacies of state socialism, prospects for the capitalist future. In: HaffertyFWMcKinlayJB (eds) The Changing Medical Profession: An International Perspective, New York: Oxford University Press, pp. 172–183.
26.
HeitlingerA (1995) Post-communist reform and health professions: Medicine and nursing in the Czech Republic. In: TerenceJLarkinGSaksM (eds) Health Professions and the State in Europe, London and New York: Routledge, pp. 213–227.
27.
HoffmanLM (1997) Professional autonomy reconsidered: The case of Czech medicine under state socialism. Comparative Studies in Society and History39(2): 346–372.
28.
KornaiJEgglestonK (2001) Welfare, Choice and Solidarity in Transition: Reforming the Health Sector in Eastern Europe, Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press.
29.
LewisM (2007) Informal payments and the financing of health care in developing and transition countries. Health Affairs26(4): 984–987.
30.
LiL (2010) Strengthen the State through Health: On the Reform of the Health Care System, Beijing: Peking University Press.
31.
LimM-KYangHZhangTHet al.(2004) Public perceptions of private health care in socialist China. Health Affairs23(6): 222–234.
32.
LinK-M (1997) The state and medical professional power: A sociological analysis of the Health Insurance Payment System in Taiwan. Taiwanese Sociology1(1): 77–136. (in Chinese).
33.
LiuSD (2011) The Logic of Fragmentation: An Ecological Analysis of the Chinese Legal Services Market, Shanghai: Shanghai SDX Joint Publishing Company.
34.
LiuXZLiuYLChenNS (2000) The Chinese experience of hospital price regulation. Health Policy and Planning15(2): 157–163.
35.
Meng QY, Bian Y, Sun Q, et al. (2002) Rationalizing the health care price system: Problems, cause, and adjustment (the first part). Chinese Health Economics 5: 31–34 (in Chinese).
36.
Ministry of Health (2003) China Health Statistics Yearbook 2003, Beijing: Peking Union Medical College Press.
37.
Ministry of Health (2010) China Health Statistics Yearbook 2010, Beijing: Peking Union Medical College Press.
38.
Ministry of Health (2012) China Health Statistics Yearbook 2012, Beijing: Peking Union Medical College Press.
39.
Ministry of Personnel and Ministry of Finance (2001) Implementing plans for readjusting wage standards of institutional work-unit personnel. State Council Gazette31: 10–19.
40.
National Health and Family Planning Commission (2015) China Health and Family Planning Statistics Yearbook 2015, Beijing: Peking Union Medical College Press.
41.
NongSLiWPNongLG (2014) The condition analysis of social capital investing in the medical industry based on perfect competition market theory. Chinese Health Economics12: 11–13. (in Chinese).
42.
ParsonsT (1951) The Social System, New York: The Free Press.
43.
PotterSJMcKinlayJB (2005) From a relationship to encounter: An examination of the longitudinal and lateral dimensions of the doctor-patient relationship. Social Science and Medicine61(2): 465–479.
44.
QuJD (2014) Professional ethics and civil morals: Durkheim on the relationship between the society and the state. Sociological Studies29(4): 110–131. (In Chinese).
45.
RueschmeyerD (1972) Doctors and lawyers: A comment on the Theory of Professions. In: FreidsonELorberJ (eds) Medical Men and Their Work, Chicago: Aldine, pp. 5–19.
46.
StarrP (1982) The Social Transformation of American Medicine: The Rise of a Sovereign Profession and the Making of a Vast Industry, New York: Basic Books.
47.
StevensR (1971) American Medicine and the Public Interest, New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
48.
StroupeKTMorrisonDAHlatkyMAet al.(2006) Cost-effectiveness of coronary artery bypass grafts versus percutaneous coronary intervention for revascularization of high-risk patients. Circulation114(12): 1251–1257.
49.
Sun H, Zhang H and Ren X (2007) Psychological problems triggered by ownership reform of public hospitals and the countermeasures. In: Beijing Planning Office of Philosophy and Social Sciences (ed.) The Research Report on Health Management and Policy in Capital. Beijing: Tongxin Press, 152–161.
50.
SunQSantoroMAMengQYet al.(2008) Pharmaceutical policy in China. Health Affairs27(4): 1042–1050.
51.
WangKJ (2001) A Chorography of Health in Beijing, Beijing: Beijing Science and Technology Press.
52.
WeiFQYuHCaoJTet al.(2014) Re-exploration on building medical institutions by social capital under the positive policy signal. Chinese Health Economics5: 5–8. (in Chinese).
53.
WuP (2010) Non-public hospitals to be covered by health insurance equally. The Beijing News. December 4th.
54.
Yang JQ (2008) The Power Relationships between Doctors, Patients and the Party-state under the Impact of Red Packets in the Chinese Health-care System. Ph.D. Dissertation, University of New South Wales.
55.
YaoZL (2015) The changing relationship between Chinese urban medical professionals and the state since the republican period: From the perspective of the sociology of professions. Sociological Studies30(3): 46–68. (in Chinese).
56.
ZhangZJ (2009) Contemporary China: Personal Management II, Beijing: Contemporary China Press.
57.
ZhouQR (2008) Essays on Medical Care Reforms in China, Beijing: Peking University Press.
58.
ZhouXR (2008) The Study on Chinese Government’s Control over Medical Price, Beijing: China Social Science Press.
59.
ZhuHP (2007) Abuses in the health care system and distortions in pharmaceutical pricing. Social Sciences in China4: 89–103. (in Chinese).
60.
ZhuHP (2011) The involution of control and its consequences: Taking the price of medicine as an example. The Journal of World Economy7: 64–90. (in Chinese).
