From online to offline: The formation of collective action and its contributing factors: A case study of a food waste treatment facility location protest

Abstract

This study examines the process from online mobilization to offline action in a case study of a community collective protest against the construction of a food waste treatment facility in a neighborhood. The method of virtual ethnography is employed to study the formation of internet-initiated collective action and its contributing factors. The study finds that online shared views and identity do not necessarily have a definitive influence on the transition from online discussion to offline action. In fact, whether such a transition can be realized depends on the characteristics of the action and the stage of the movement. For initial and insubstantial offline action, online mobilization seems to be effective. However, sustaining the movement requires further mobilization and organization building. The study concludes that all three factors of online mobilization, characteristics of action, and stage of movement play a role in the transition from online discussion to offline actions. Characteristics of action and stage of movement are interrelated, both aiming to accomplish goals, as one is to act and the other is to react to the risks posed by political control. To keep the movement alive is always a challenge for online mobilization. Political risks influence decisions on strategies and tactics of online mobilization, and shape the behavior of netizens, often being described as a special type of ‘slacktivism.’ In conclusion, the Chinese political culture and environment, people’s adaptation to it, and their risk-aversive nature help create the unique type of Chinese online activism that, in turn, determines the effectiveness and outcomes of online mobilization and offline collective action.

Keywords

Online mobilization offline collective action online to offline movement transfers political control

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Boekkooi M (2009) Virtual mobilization and real life participation: How new media change social movements. Available at: http://internet-politics.cies.iscte.pt/IMG/pdf/ECPRPotsdamBoekkooi.pdf (accessed 16 September 2014).

Brunsting

Postmes

(2002) Social movement participation in the digital age: Predicting offline and online collective action. Small Group Research 33(5): 525–554.

(2012) Virtual ethnography: The field, approach and ethics. Sociological Studies 162(6): 217–236.

Cai

(2009) Collective Action Research with the Internet as Media, Nanchang, China: Jiangxi People’s Publishing House.

Castells M (2001) The Rise of the Network Society (trans. Xia Z, et al.). Beijing, China: Social Sciences Academic Press.

Chen

(2012) Disorganize: The strategy of homeowners’ collective activisms – A survey of the Anti-Incinerator Action in Guangzhou. Journal of Public Management 9(2): 67–75.

Chen

(2013) Does internet use encourage non-institutional political participation? An instrumental variable analysis of the data from CGSS2006. Chinese Journal of Sociology (Chinese version) 33(5): 118–143.

Diani

(2000) Social movement networks: Virtual and real. Information, Communication and Society 3(3): 386–401.

Garrett

(2006) Protest in an information society: A review of literature on social movements and new ICTs. Information, Communication and Society 9(2): 202–224.

10.

Granovetter

(1973) The strength of weak ties. American Journal of Sociology 78(6): 1360–1380.

11.

Hampton

(2003) Grieving for a lost network: Collective action in a wired suburb. Information Society 19(5): 417–428.

12.

Huang

(2013) How do people get engaged in civic participation: A case study of the citizen activism in rebuilding Enning Road, Guangzhou. Chinese Journal of Sociology (Chinese version) 33(3): 131–158.

13.

Huang

(2010) The internet and contentious actions: Theoretical models, the China experience, and future research directions. Chinese Journal of Sociology (Chinese version) 30(2): 178–197.

14.

Huang

Gui

(2009) The Internet and homeowners' collective resistance: A qualitative comparative analysis. Sociological Studies 5(1): 29–56.

15.

Kavanaugh

Reese

Carroll

et al. (2005) Weak ties in networked communities. Information Society 21(2): 119–131.

16.

Li D (2011) An analysis of the Internet’s influential mechanism on social movements, taking the Fanyu waste incineration event as an example. Master’s dissertation, China University of Political Science and Law, Beijing, China.

17.

Lou

Liu

(2010) On political mobilization in network: An unbalanced situation. Cass Journal of Political Science 2(1): 74–86.

18.

McAdam

(1986) Recruitment to high-risk activism: The case of freedom summer. American Journal of Sociology 92(1): 64–90.

19.

Morozov

(2011) The Net Delusion: The Dark Side of Internet Freedom, New York, NY: Public Affairs.

20.

Nip

JYM

(2004) The queer sisters and its electronic bulletin board: A study of the Internet for social movement mobilization. Information, Communication and Society 7(1): 23–49.

21.

Oser

Hooghe

Marien

(2013) Is online participation distinct from offline participation? A latent class analysis of participation types and their stratification. Political Research Quarterly 66(1): 91–101.

22.

Postmes

Brunsting

(2002) Collective action in the age of the Internet: Mass communication and online mobilization. Social Science Computer Review 20(3): 290–301.

23.

Putnam R (2011) Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community (Chinese trans. Liu B et al.). Beijing, China: Peking University Press.

24.

Shangapour

Hosseini

Hashemnejad

(2011) Cyber social-networks and social movements case study: Tehran (2009–2010). International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research 11(1): 1–15.

25.

Tarrow

(1998) Power in Movement: Social Movements, Collective Action and Politics, Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.

26.

Van Laer

Van Aelst

(2010) Internet and social movement action repertoires: Opportunities and limitations. Information, Communication and Society 13(8): 1146–1171.

27.

Wang

(2011) The Internet mobilization and collective protesting of OEM factory workers. Open Times 233(11): 114–128.

28.

Wojcieszak

(2009) ‘Carrying online participation offline’: Mobilization by radical online groups and politically dissimilar offline ties. Journal of Communication 59(3): 564–586.

29.

Zeng

Huang

Liu

(2013) Movement entrepreneurs’ virtual organization: A new model of the Internet and social protesting in contemporary China. Open Times 249(3): 169–187.

30.

Zhao

(2006) Social Movements and Revolutions, Beijing, China: Social Sciences Academic Press.

31.

Zhao

Wang

(2004) Thought review on Ecofeminism. Science, Technology and Dialectics 21(5): 35–38.

32.

Zhou

Shen

(2006) Discussions on the Internet’s influence and strategy on citizens’ non-institutional participation. Hubei Social Sciences 229(1): 36–38.