Efficiency of pain inhibition and facilitation of fibromyalgia patients is not different from healthy controls: Relevance of sensitivity-adjusted test stimuli
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online April, 2023
Efficiency of pain inhibition and facilitation of fibromyalgia patients is not different from healthy controls: Relevance of sensitivity-adjusted test stimuli
Pain is a dynamic phenomenon dependent on the balance of endogenous excitatory and inhibitory systems, which can be characterized by quantitative sensory testing. Many previous studies of pain modulatory capacity of patients with fibromyalgia syndrome (FM) have reported decreased pain inhibition or increased pain facilitation. This is the first study to assess pain modulation, including conditioned pain modulation (CPM) and temporal pain summation, in the same healthy control (HC) and FM participants.
Methods
Only sensitivity-adjusted stimuli were utilized for testing of conditioned pain modulation (CPM) and temporal pain summation in 23 FM patients and 28 HC. All subjects received sensitivity-adjusted ramp-hold (sRH) during testing of pain facilitation (temporal summation) and pain inhibition (CPM). CPM efficacy was evaluated with test stimuli applied either concurrently or after application of the conditioning stimulus. Finally, the effects of CPM on pressure pain thresholds were tested.
Results
FM subjects required significantly less intense test and conditioning stimuli than HC participants to achieve standardized pain ratings of 50 ± 10 numerical rating scale (NRS) (p = 0.03). Using such stimuli, FM subjects’ temporal pain summation and CPM efficacy was not significantly different from HC (all p > 0.05), suggesting similar pain facilitation and inhibition. Furthermore, the CPM efficacy of FM and HC participants was similar regardless of whether the test stimuli were applied during or after the conditioning stimulus (p > 0.05).
Conclusion
Similar to previous studies, FM participants demonstrated hyperalgesia to heat, cold, and mechanical stimuli. However, using only sensitivity-adjusted stimuli during CPM and temporal summation testing, FM patients demonstrated similarly effective pain inhibition and facilitation than HC, suggesting that their pain modulation is not abnormal.
WolfeFRossKAndersonJ, et al.The prevalence and characteristics of fibromyalgia in the general population. Arthritis Rheum1995; 38: 19–28.
2.
ClauwDJ. Fibromyalgia and related conditions. Mayo Clin Proc2015; 90: 680–692.
3.
VierckCJCannonRLFryG, et al.Characteristics of temporal summation of second pain sensations elicited by brief contact of glabrous skin by a preheated thermode. J Neurophysiol1997; 78: 992–1002.
4.
StaudRVierckCJCannonRL, et al.Abnormal sensitization and temporal summation of second pain (wind-up) in patients with fibromyalgia syndrome. Pain2001; 91: 165–175.
StaudRGodfreyMMMejiaM, et al.Usefulness of Ramp & Hold Procedures for testing of pain facilitation in human participants: comparisons with temporal summation of second pain. J Pain2020; 21: 390–398.
7.
Tousignant-LaflammeYPageSGoffauxP, et al.An experimental model to measure excitatory and inhibitory pain mechanisms in humans. Brain Res2008; 1230: 73–79.
8.
PriceDDStaudRRobinsonME, et al.Enhanced temporal summation of second pain and its central modulation in fibromyalgia patients. Pain2002; 99: 49–59.
9.
Arendt-NielsenLGraven-NielsenT. Central sensitization in fibromyalgia and other musculoskeletal disorders. Curr Pain Headache Rep2003; 7: 355–361.
10.
Graven-NielsenTSorensonJHenrikssonKG, et al.Central hyperexcitability in fibromyalgia. J Musculoskelet Pain1999; 7: 261–271.
11.
Roldan-JimenezCPerez-CruzadoDNeblettR, et al.Central sensitization in chronic musculoskeletal pain disorders in different populations: a cross-sectional study. Pain Med2020; 21: 2958–2963.
12.
KingCDSibilleKTGoodinBR, et al.Experimental pain sensitivity differs as a function of clinical pain severity in symptomatic knee osteoarthritis. Osteoarthritis Cartilage2013; 21: 1243–1252.
13.
Arendt-NielsenLNieHLaursenMB, et al.Sensitization in patients with painful knee osteoarthritis. Pain2010; 149: 573–581.
14.
FinanPHBuenaverLFBoundsSC, et al.Discordance between pain and radiographic severity in knee osteoarthritis: findings from quantitative sensory testing of central sensitization. Arthritis Rheum2013; 65: 363–372.
15.
BedsonJCroftPR. The discordance between clinical and radiographic knee osteoarthritis: a systematic search and summary of the literature. BMC Musculoskelet Disord2008; 9: 116.
16.
Le BarsD. The whole body receptive field of dorsal horn multireceptive neurones. Brain Res Rev2002; 40: 29–44.
17.
Le BarsDVillanuevaLBouhassiraD, et al.Diffuse noxious inhibitory controls (DNIC) in animals and in man. Patol Fiziol Eksp Ter1992; 4: 55–65.
18.
VillanuevaLLe BarsD. The activation of bulbo-spinal controls by peripheral nociceptive inputs: diffuse noxious inhibitory controls. Biol Res1995; 28: 113–125.
19.
Nahman-AverbuchHNirRRSprecherE, et al.Psychological factors and conditioned pain modulation: a meta-analysis. Clin J Pain2016; 32: 541–554.
20.
FirouzianSOsborneNRChengJC, et al.Individual variability and sex differences in conditioned pain modulation and the impact of resilience, and conditioning stimulus pain unpleasantness and salience. Pain2020; 161: 1847–1860.
21.
PotvinSMarchandS. Pain facilitation and pain inhibition during conditioned pain modulation in fibromyalgia and in healthy controls. Pain2016; 157: 1704–1710.
22.
O’BrienATDeitosATrinanes PegoY, et al.Defective endogenous pain modulation in fibromyalgia: a meta-analysis of temporal summation and conditioned pain modulation paradigms. J Pain2018; 19: 819–836.
23.
AlbusodaAFrissKGysanM, et al.Conditioned pain modulation in functional gastrointestinal disorders: systematic review & meta-analysis. Gut2018; 67: A207–A207.
24.
LewisGNRiceDAMcNairPJ. Conditioned pain modulation in populations with chronic pain: a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Pain2012; 13: 936–944.
25.
MlekuschSNeziriAYLimacherA, et al.Conditioned pain modulation in patients with acute and chronic low back pain. Clin J Pain2016; 32: 116–121.
26.
NuwailatiRCuratoloMLeRescheL, et al.Reliability of the conditioned pain modulation paradigm across three anatomical sites. Scand J Pain2020; 20: 283–296.
27.
TraxlerJMaddenVJMoseleyGL, et al.Modulating pain thresholds through classical conditioning. PeerJ2019; 7: e6486.
28.
OonoYWangKSvenssonP, et al.Conditioned pain modulation evoked by different intensities of mechanical stimuli applied to the craniofacial region in healthy men and women. J Orofac Pain2011; 25: 364–375.
29.
LeoneCTruiniA. The CPM effect: functional assessment of the diffuse noxious inhibitory control in humans. J Clin Neurophysiol2019; 36: 430–436.
30.
Horn-HofmannCKunzMMaddenM, et al.Interactive effects of conditioned pain modulation and temporal summation of pain-the role of stimulus modality. Pain2018; 159: 2641–2648.
31.
KennedyDLKempHIRidoutD, et al.Reliability of conditioned pain modulation: a systematic review. Pain2016; 157: 2410–2419.
32.
YarnitskyDDahanA. Endogenous pain modulation: from humans to animals and back. Anesthesiology2015; 122: 734–735.
33.
WolfeFClauwDJFitzcharlesMA, et al.The provisional diagnostic criteria for fibromyalgia: one step forward, two steps back: comment on the article by Wolfe et al Reply. Arthritis Care Res (Hoboken)2010; 62: 1676–1678.
34.
WolfeFSmytheHAYunusMB, et al.The American college of rheumatology 1990 criteria for the classification of fibromyalgia. report of the multicenter criteria committee. Arthritis Rheum1990; 33: 160–172.
35.
PriceDDBushFMLongS, et al.A comparison of pain measurement characteristics of mechanical visual analogue and simple numerical rating scales. Pain1994; 56: 217–226.
36.
BosmaRLAmeli MojaradELeungL, et al.Neural correlates of temporal summation of second pain in the human brainstem and spinal cord. Hum Brain Mapp2015; 36: 5038–5050.
37.
BosmaRLMojaradEALeungL, et al.FMRI of spinal and supra-spinal correlates of temporal pain summation in fibromyalgia patients. Hum Brain Mapp2016; 37: 1349–1360.
38.
GeisserMERothRSRobinsonME. Assessing depression among persons with chronic pain using the center for epidemiological studies depression scale and the beck depression inventory: acomparative analysis. Clin J Pain1997; 13: 163–170.
39.
RadloffLS. The CES-D scale: a self-report depression scale for research in the general population. Appl Psychol Meas1977; 1: 385–401.
40.
LewinsohnPMSeeleyJRRobertsRE, et al.Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale (CES-D) as a screening instrument for depression among community-residing older adults. Psychol Aging1997; 12: 277–287.
41.
BuysseDJReynoldsCFMonkTH, et al.The Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index: a new instrument for psychiatric practice and research. Psychiatry Res1989; 28: 193–213.
42.
SullivanMJLBishopSRPivikJ. The pain catastrophizing scale: development and validation. Psychol Assess1995; 7: 524–532.
43.
RosenstielAKKeefeFJ. The use of coping strategies in chronic low back pain patients: relationship to patient characteristics and current adjustment. Pain1983; 17: 33–44.
44.
ZhangCZhangHZhaoM, et al.Reliability, validity, and factor structure of pittsburgh sleep quality index in community-based centenarians. Front Psychiatry2020; 11: 573530.
45.
OkifujiATurkDC. Stress and psychophysiological dysregulation in patients with fibromyalgia syndrome. Appl Psychophysiol Biofeedback2002; 27: 129–141.
46.
BrietzkeAPAntunesLCCarvalhoF, et al.Potency of descending pain modulatory system is linked with peripheral sensory dysfunction in fibromyalgia: an exploratory study. Medicine (Baltimore)2019; 98: e13477.
47.
JulienNGoffauxPArsenaultP, et al.Widespread pain in fibromyalgia is related to a deficit of endogenous pain inhibition. Pain2005; 114: 295–302.
48.
SchrepfAHarperDEHarteSE, et al.Endogenous opioidergic dysregulation of pain in fibromyalgia: a PET and fMRI study. Pain2016; 157: 2217–2225.
49.
CarlessoLCLawLFWangN, et al.Association of pain sensitization and conditioned pain modulation to pain patterns in knee osteoarthritis. Arthritis Care Res (Hoboken)2022; 74: 107–112.
50.
CathcartSWinefieldAHRolanP, et al.Reliability of temporal summation and diffuse noxious inhibitory control. Pain Res Manag2009; 14: 433–438.
51.
EdwardsRRNessTJWeigentDA, et al.Individual differences in diffuse noxious inhibitory controls (DNIC): association with clinical variables. Pain2003; 106: 427–437.
52.
FernandesCPidal-MirandaMSamartin-VeigaN, et al.Conditioned pain modulation as a biomarker of chronic pain: a systematic review of its concurrent validity. Pain2019; 160: 2679–2690.
53.
GerhardtAEichWTreedeRD, et al.Conditioned pain modulation in patients with nonspecific chronic back pain with chronic local pain, chronic widespread pain, and fibromyalgia. Pain2017; 158: 430–439.
54.
Nahman-AverbuchHYarnitskyDGranovskyY, et al.The role of stimulation parameters on the conditioned pain modulation response. Scand J Pain2013; 4: 10–14.
55.
YarnitskyD. Conditioned pain modulation (the diffuse noxious inhibitory control-like effect): its relevance for acute and chronic pain states. Curr Opin Anaesthesiol2010; 23: 611–615.
56.
YarnitskyDGranotMNahman-AverbuchH, et al.Conditioned pain modulation predicts duloxetine efficacy in painful diabetic neuropathy. Pain2012; 153: 1193–1198.
57.
TesarzJGerhardtASchommerK, et al.Alterations in endogenous pain modulation in endurance athletes: an experimental study using quantitative sensory testing and the cold-pressor task. Pain2013; 154: 1022–1029.
58.
PriceDDMcHaffieJG. Effects of heterotopic conditioning stimuli on first and second pain: a psychophysical evaluation in humans. Pain1988; 34: 245–252.
59.
WoolfCJSalterMW. Neuronal plasticity: increasing the gain in pain. Science2000; 288: 1765–1769.
60.
MatreD. Conditioned pain modulation (CPM) is not one single phenomenon - Large intra-individual differences depend on test stimulus (TS) and several other independent factors. Scand J Pain2013; 4: 8–9.
61.
GranotMWeissman-FogelICrispelY, et al.Determinants of endogenous analgesia magnitude in a diffuse noxious inhibitory control (DNIC) paradigm: Do conditioning stimulus painfulness, gender and personality variables matter?Pain2008; 136: 142–149.
62.
ValenciaCKindlerLLFillingimRB, et al.Stability of conditioned pain modulation in two musculoskeletal pain models: investigating the influence of shoulder pain intensity and gender. BMC Musculoskelet Disord2013; 14: 182.
63.
PudDGranovskyYYarnitskyD. The methodology of experimentally induced diffuse noxious inhibitory control (DNIC)-like effect in humans. Pain2009; 144: 16–19.
64.
CampbellCMMcCauleyLBoundsSC, et al.Changes in pain catastrophizing predict later changes in fibromyalgia clinical and experimental pain report: cross-lagged panel analyses of dispositional and situational catastrophizing. Arthritis Res Ther2012; 14: R231.
65.
OonoYMatosRLWangK, et al.The inter- and intra-individual variance in descending pain modulation evoked by different conditioning stimuli in healthy men. Scand J Pain2011; 2: 162–169.
MeeusMNijsJ. Central sensitization: a biopsychosocial explanation for chronic widespread pain in patients with fibromyalgia and chronic fatigue syndrome. Clin Rheumatol2007; 26: 465–473.
68.
WongFRodriguesASchmidtS, et al.Extreme thermal sensitivity and pain-induce sensitization in a fibromyalgia patient. Pain Res Ther2010; 2010: 1–6.
69.
McPheeMEVaegterHBGraven-NielsenT. Alterations in pronociceptive and antinociceptive mechanisms in patients with low back pain: a systematic review with meta-analysis. Pain2020; 161: 464–475.
70.
VaegterHBFehrmannEGajsarH, et al.Endogenous modulation of pain: the role of exercise, stress, and cognitions in humans. Clin J Pain2020; 36: 150–161.
71.
McPheeMGraven-NielsenT. Alterations in temporal summation of pain and conditioned pain modulation across an episode of experimental exercise-induced low back pain. J Pain2019; 20: 264–276.
72.
RhudyJLMartinSLTerryEL, et al.Pain catastrophizing is related to temporal summation of pain but not temporal summation of the nociceptive flexion reflex. Pain2011; 152: 794–801.
73.
BjorkedalEFlatenMA. Expectations of increased and decreased pain explain the effect of conditioned pain modulation in females. J Pain Res2012; 5: 289–300.
LariviereMGoffauxPMarchandS, et al.Changes in pain perception and descending inhibitory controls start at middle age in healthy adults. Clin J Pain2007; 23: 506–510.
76.
VaseLNikolajsenLChristensenB, et al.Cognitive-emotional sensitization contributes to wind-up-like pain in phantom limb pain patients. Pain2011; 152: 157–162.
77.
CoghillRCMayerDJPriceDD. Wide dynamic range but not nociceptive-specific neurons encode multidimensional features of prolonged repetitive heat pain. J Neurophysiol1993; 69: 703–716.
78.
StaudRRobinsonMEVierckCJ, et al.Diffuse noxious inhibitory controls (DNIC) attenuate temporal summation of second pain in normal males but not in normal females or fibromyalgia patients. Pain2003; 101: 167–174.
79.
StaudRRobinsonMEPriceDD. Temporal summation of second pain and its maintenance are useful for characterizing widespread central sensitization of fibromyalgia patients. J Pain2007; 8: 893–901.
80.
Le BarsDWillerJC. Diffuse inhibitory noxious controls (DNIC). In: BushnellMCBasbaumAI (eds) Pain. San Diego, CA: Academic Press; 2008.
81.
AlbusodaARuffleJKFriisKA, et al.Systematic review with meta-analysis: conditioned pain modulation in patients with the irritable bowel syndrome. Aliment Pharmacol Ther2018; 48: 797–806.
82.
KingCDWongFCurrieT, et al.Deficiency in endogenous modulation of prolonged heat pain in patients with Irritable Bowel Syndrome and Temporomandibular Disorder. Pain2009; 143: 172–178.
83.
SandriniGRossiPMilanovI, et al.Abnormal modulatory influence of diffuse noxious inhibitory controls in migraine and chronic tension-type headache patients. Cephalalgia2006; 26: 782–789.
84.
CraggsJGStaudRRobinsonME, et al.Effective connectivity among brain regions associated with slow temporal summation of C-fiber-evoked pain in fibromyalgia patients and healthy controls. J Pain2012; 13: 390–400.
85.
StaudRBoissoneaultJLaiS, et al.Spinal cord neural activity of patients with fibromyalgia and healthy controls during temporal summation of pain: an fMRI study. J Neurophysiol2021; 126: 946–956.
86.
JensenKBKosekEPetzkeF, et al.Evidence of dysfunctional pain inhibition in Fibromyalgia reflected in rACC during provoked pain. Pain2009; 144: 95–100.
87.
KosekEHanssonP. Modulatory influence on somatosensory perception from vibration and heterotopic noxious conditioning stimulation (HNCS) in fibromyalgia patients and healthy subjects. Pain1997; 70: 41–51.
88.
LautenbacherSRollmanGB. Possible deficiencies of pain modulation in fibromyalgia. Clin J Pain1997; 13: 189–196.
89.
EdwardsRR. Individual differences in endogenous pain modulation as a risk factor for chronic pain. Neurology2005; 65: 437–443.
90.
CorreaJBCostaLOde OliveiraNT, et al.Central sensitization and changes in conditioned pain modulation in people with chronic nonspecific low back pain: a case-control study. Exp Brain Res2015; 233: 2391–2399.
91.
RabeyMPoonCWrayJ, et al.Pro-nociceptive and anti-nociceptive effects of a conditioned pain modulation protocol in participants with chronic low back pain and healthy control subjects. Man Ther2015; 20: 763–768.
92.
Wilder-SmithOHSchreyerTSchefferGJ, et al.Patients with chronic pain after abdominal surgery show less preoperative endogenous pain inhibition and more postoperative hyperalgesia: a pilot study. J Pain Palliat Care Pharmacother2010; 24: 119–128.
93.
YarnitskyDCrispelYEisenbergE, et al.Prediction of chronic post-operative pain: Pre-operative DNIC testing identifies patients at risk. Pain2008; 138: 22–28.
